Four intelligence agencies produced multiple reports on the future of Afghanistan, but none forecast the lightning march of the Taliban or predicted Kabul's swift collapse, says new review

Asia's Tech News Daily

Summaries of multiple intelligence reports on Afghanistan show how agencies failed to forecast the rapid collapse of KabulThe Wall Street Journal obtained assessments dating back to April 2020They offer an insight into the advice given to Presidents Biden and Trump as they weighed bringing home U.S. troops from the 20-year conflictThey said the Kabul government was unlikely to survive without foreign troopsBut none said the Taliban would take Kabul by the middle of August 

Extensive reports on Afghanistan produced by four U.S. intelligence agencies in the run-up to the withdrawal of foreign troops all failed to predict the speed at which the Taliban would capture Kabul, according to a review published on Thursday.

Instead they offered ‘scattershot assessments’ of the staying power of the Afghan military and government, reported the Wall Street Journal.

They extrapolated from Taliban advances from spring 2020 until July, and forecast that the government in Kabul was unlikely to survive once U.S. troops left. 

They differed in how long that would take – and none predicted that the Taliban would race into the capital by Aug. 15 while American forces were still on the ground.

The chaotic scenes at Kabul airport, and the deaths of 13 U.S. personnel in a suicide attack, have left lingering questions about why no one forecast the collapse and whether President Biden should have dropped his Aug. 31 deadline for leaving the country.

In May, a month after President Biden announced his decision to withdraw, the Central Intelligence Agency produced a report entitled ‘Government at Risk of Collapse Following U.S. Withdrawal.’

President Joe Biden ordered troops out of Afghanistan by the end August, but the operation ended in chaos as the Taliban stormed into the capital Kabul before U.S. soldiers had left

President Joe Biden ordered troops out of Afghanistan by the end August, but the operation ended in chaos as the Taliban stormed into the capital Kabul before U.S. soldiers had left

Taliban gunmen are now a common sight in Kabul, replacing troops of the government of Ashraf Ghani, who fled the country in the middle of August

Taliban gunmen are now a common sight in Kabul, replacing troops of the government of Ashraf Ghani, who fled the country in the middle of August

Its estimate was that President Ashraf Ghani’s administration would fall by the end of the year, the newspaper reported.

Another forecast came a month later from the agency, called ‘Afghanistan: Assessing Prospects for a Complete Taliban Takeover Within Two Years.’ 

A June 4 Defense Intelligence Agency report forecast that the Taliban would continues its strategy of isolating rural areas from Kabul for another 12 months, according to a summary. 

The summaries, offer an insight into the advice being given to Biden and his predecessor Donald Trump as they weighed how to safely bring troops home from a two-decade conflict.

The result has been something of a blame game as politicians and military officers said they were never warned such a rapid collapse could happen.

For example Joint Chiefs of Staff Chair Gen. Mark Milley said days after the collapse of Kabul that he had not been warned the Afghan army would simply melt away in the face of Taliban advances.

‘There was nothing that I or anyone else saw that indicated a collapse of this army and this government in 11 days,’ he said during a Pentagon briefing.

Intelligence chiefs have defended their work, saying that they offered a range of eventualities.  

The rapid takeover by the Taliban took policymakers by surprise leaving U.S. intelligence agencies to explain why they didn't see it coming

The rapid takeover by the Taliban took policymakers by surprise leaving U.S. intelligence agencies to explain why they didn’t see it coming

CIA Director William Burns, among others, has defended the the agencies’ performance but admitted things moved faster than expected.

‘There’s a very sobering picture that we painted of some very troubling trend lines,’ he said at a Stanford University appearance last week, according to the Wall Street Journal. 

‘So does that mean that we, with mathematical precision, can say that, you know, former President Ghani in Afghanistan is going to flee his office and not tell his senior-most aides on the 15th of August? No.’

National security adviser Jake Sullivan has promised a ‘hotwash’ of the withdrawal in order to identify failings. 

Representatives of the CIA, the DIA, the State Department and the Office of Director of National Intelligence all declined comment to the newspaper. 

But there were Afghan watchers who saw the rapid collapse coming. 

Bill Roggio, a senior fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, who repeatedly warned that the Taliban was advancing fast, said intelligence agencies and policy makers should take responsibility for being blindsided. 

‘The intelligence community needs to take a long, hard look at how it provides assessments to senior leadership,’ he said.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


From a three-hour yacht cruise to a helicopter ride over Sydney harbour and an overnight stay at the zoo: The top adventure-filled gifts to purchase for loved ones this Christmas

RedBalloon has a range of experiences Australians can take advantage ofIf your friend or loved one isn't the present type why not opt for an experienceIn NSW you can go hot air ballooning or stay overnight at a zoo in VictoriaTry tandem skydiving in Queensland or a glamping setup on Rottnest Island  Read more »

Covid vaccine protests in Melbourne as Kerry Chant warns of ‘uptick' in Sydney Omicron cases

Photograph: Joel Carrett/AAP The Australian government says Covid vaccines could soon be rolled out for children as young as five as Victoria reported nine deaths and the NSW chief health ... Read more »

Video: Ryan Seacrest, 46, and girlfriend Aubrey Paige, 24, make rare appearance together at iHeartRadio's Jingle Ball event in LA

Read more »

Dolph Lundgren Reveals The A+ Prank Sylvester Stallone Played On Him While Making The First Expendables Film

The Expendables 4 has officially wrapped production, which means fans of the franchise are closer to get another installment in the action franchise. So far, we know a few things ... Read more »

Lib Dem candidate sorry after comparing migrants to Jewish prisoners

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A candidate in the forthcoming North Shropshire by-election has apologised after The Mail on Sunday uncovered social media posts appearing to liken the ... Read more »

Heart attack patients are dying because medics can't put on full PPE

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Heart attack victims have lost their lives because doctors are still obliged to put on full Covid-protection equipment before resuscitating them in hospitals, ... Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: Britney Spears cuddles up under towels at the beach with fiancé Sam Asghari as she continues her 40th birthday celebration in Cabo San Lucas... before the lovebirds take a romantic sunset cruise on a yacht

She jetted down to Mexico to celebrate her 40th birthday with her fiancé on Wednesday. And Britney Spears and Sam Asghari seemed to be enjoying some time to relax and ... Read more »

Whingeing English sooks will stop play during the Ashes if sledging gets too intense - which is a joke when you read the sickening abuse they encouraged their fans to hit the Aussies with, writes MIKE COLMAN

England captain Joe Root will tell team to stop playing if sledging crosses lineIt's two-faced coming from side that encouraged fans to sledge the AussiesDavid Warner and Mitchell Johnson copped vile abuse on other Ashes toursBarmy Army fans are famous for targeting vulnerable players with chants  Read more »

Rishi Sunak draws up plans for a 2p income tax cut before next General Election - and tells officials he also wants to slash VAT and inheritance tax

Rishi Sunak, 41, is attempting to reposition himself as a tax-cutting ChancellorHe has told officials to draw up plans to cut income tax and slash VAT rates  Chancellor could cut the basic rate of income tax by 1p in 2023 and 2024 Read more »

COVID-19: NHS planning to roll out 'game-changing' coronavirus pill - and it could happen 'before Christmas'

The health service will reportedly deliver courses of molnupiravir, sometimes referred to as Lagevrio, to clinically vulnerable and and immunosuppressant patients within as little as 48 hours of them testing positive for COVID-19. Read more »

Cricket-Patel spurred to 10-wicket haul by Jurgensen's motivational video

(Reuters) – Ajaz Patel credited New Zealand bowling coach Shane Jurgensen for his record-equalling display against India on Saturday, after the spinner became the third player in history to claim ... Read more »

Jack Grealish's woes in front of goal shouldn't mask key Man City role at Watford

There are obviously huge perks for England manager Gareth Southgate when it comes to so many of his first-choice stars residing in the Manchester City squad. The Three Lions’ finest ... Read more »

GEOFFREY ROBERTSON gives a warning after Meghan's attack on Press

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo This win is precedent setting,’ proclaimed Meghan Markle, immediately after last week’s Court of Appeal decision against The Mail on Sunday – even ... Read more »

Video: Caught in the act! Dan Walker and his Strictly partner are spotted doing cheeky jig to 'sway favour' with viewers 

Read more »

What the papers say – December 5

The front pages focus on Covid-19 treatment, a royal’s relationship with his late mother and the legacy of Arthur Labinjo-Hughes. The Sunday Telegraph reports a pill to fight Covid-19 could ... Read more »

Prince Charles is willing to speak to police over evidence that his aide 'fixed an honour for Saudi billionaire'

Michael Fawcett resigned as foundation's chief executive after string of claimsHe allegedly promised to help get a knighthood and UK citizenship for donor Prince Charles is said to be willing to speak to detectives over the allegationsClarence House said Charles had 'no knowledge' of cash for honours scandalDonor Mahfouz Marei Mubarak bin Mahfouz was awarded CBE back in 2016 Read more »

Ranked: The 50 most beautiful places in the world in 2021 – according to Instagram

This year, Big 7 Travel created its list of the 50 most beautiful places in the world according to Instagram hashtags for destinations around the world. It also asked the ... Read more »

Video: Prince William cringes over how Taylor Swift led him on stage 'like a puppy' for surprise Livin' on a Prayer performance with US singer and Jon Bon Jovi 

Read more »

Dami Im is pregnant! X Factor winner announces she's expecting her first child with husband Noah Kim - as she shares her sonogram online

Singer Dami Im has announced she’s expecting her first chid with husband Noah Kim.  The former X Factor winner, 33, shared the exciting news on Sunday, uploading a photo of ... Read more »

Video: DR ELLIE CANNON: Why do I always feel such nausea when I wake up?

Read more »

No 10 braced for political row over amnesty for Irish terrorists under plans to draw a line under Troubles prosecutions

Number 10 is braced for political row over amnesty for Irish Troubles terroristsLegislation is expected to be introduced by Christmas for a statute of limitationsProposals would also mean a ban on prosecutions for British soldiers charged over shootings at the time Read more »

Pensions crisis is looming as nearly one million women retire early due to menopause symptoms, warns government adviser

Andy Briggs said one million women left employment because of the menopauseMr Briggs is also the Government’s Business Champion for Older WorkersRecommendations include more clinical support for women with symptoms Read more »

David Beckham faces more pressure over his multi-million pound deal to promote the 2022 World Cup as Qatar pundit launches on-air rant about gay rights

David Beckham is under yet more pressure over his multi-million pound deal to promote the 2022 World Cup It is after homosexuality was described as being ‘against human nature’ on a Qatari TV channel run by a close friendFootball pundit Mohamed Aboutrika, a former Egypt international, launched the offensive tirade on beIN Sports  Read more »

Oliver Reed's friends slam 'crazy' decision not to erect a blue plaque in his honour - after English Heritage decided his legacy as an actor was not 'sufficiently strong'

Film legend Oliver Reed has been snubbed for a commemorative blue plaque after English Heritage decided his legacy as an actor was not ‘sufficiently strong’. A committee at the charity ... Read more »

Covid antiviral pill could be offered to vulnerable patients before Christmas in first at-home treatment for the virus

First at-home Covid treatment could reportedly be rolled out before ChristmasSajid Javid, 52, is said to be set to launch a national pilot of the Molnupiravir pillThe move is a bid to protect vulnerable people from the Omicron Covid variantLast month, the UK became the first country in the world to license tablet's use Read more »

Labour suspends Angela Rayner's aide amid 'rising hostilities between the deputy leader and Keir Starmer'

Jack McKenna is under investigation on suspicion of a 'personal data breach' Claims he briefed press about potential sacking of another party staff memberMr McKenna, who is head of Ms Rayner's communications, denies the allegation  Read more »

Royal Mail boss issues urgent call for HUNDREDS more vans to deliver Christmas presents as postmen are left short at the busiest time of the year

Simon Thompson, Royal Mail boss, has told managers to get more vehiclesHe admitted head office bosses had left posties short at busiest time of year  The decision will leave staff hunting for extra vans with little notice to get vast quantities of mail delivered on time Read more »

Thousands of Britons face a postcode lottery to get Covid jabs as figures show some are travelling more than 50 miles for a booster shot

Health Secretary Sajid Javid has said it's 'absolutely crucial' to have a top up jabFears over the Omicron variant have seen an increase in the roll out of boostersMany people are now complaining they are finding it hard to get an appointment  Read more »

BBC bosses are split over dumping temporary Strictly judge Anton Du Beke as Bruno Tonioli bids to waltz back to panel after standing down due to Covid restrictions

BBC bosses are split over whether to dump Anton Du Beke and bring Bruno Tonioli back to the Strictly panel. Du Beke was brought in as a judge on a ... Read more »

Biden, Putin to talk next week amid military buildup in Ukraine

President Biden and Russian President Putin shake hands in Geneva The White House announced on Saturday that President Biden and Russian President Vladimir Putin will talk next week amid a ... Read more »

Police confirm two teenagers dead and two other children, including nine-month-old, injured in shooting at gas station on Elvis Presley Boulevard in Memphis

Two victims, aged 15 and 16, succumbed to their injuries, while another 16-year-old female and a nine-month-old baby boy are recovering in the hospital The Memphis Police Department responded to the shooting at a Marathon gas station on 3885 Elvis Presley Blvd. around 9.35pm on Friday The four victims were reportedly parked inside a red Infiniti vehicle at a gas pump when shots were fired in their direction by suspects inside a dark Nissan After the shooting, the suspects fled the scene in their Nissan, which was later recovered by police. No arrests have been made Read more »

The Covid Christmas Habits We'd Quite Like To Keep, Actually

(Photo: Kemal Yildirim via Getty Images) For many of us, Christmas 2020 was pretty challenging. Just days before Christmas (and despite government assurances to the contrary),fresh Covid-19 restrictions were enforced, ... Read more »

Martha Stewart reveals she's currently dating someone... but won't unveil her suitor's identity: 'I'm not going to tell you'

Martha Stewart has officially revealed that she is currently dating someone. The 80-year-old entrepreneur made the big news known to the public during Thursday’s episode of Watch What Happens Live! ... Read more »

GOP lawmaker slammed for posting insensitive family Christmas photo with ASSAULT RIFLES just DAYS after deadly Michigan high school shooting massacre

A Kentucky congressman caused outrage after the Republican posted a Christmas photo that showed him and his family brandishing large assault riflesThe photo comes just days after a deadly high school shooting massacre in Michigan that left four students deadCritics on social media slammed the photo of Thomas Massie and his family, who were fully armed and in front of a Christmas tree, which he tweeted on Saturday Massie's photo, which accrued 31.4K likes, 4,826 retweets and 17.7K quote tweets within five hours of being posted, was criticized as being tone deaf  Read more »

Australia live news update: Albanese speaks at campaign rally; Victoria and NSW won't close border over Omicron Covid variant

LIVE – Updated at 01:53 Follow live updates.   01:53 The Bureau of Meteorology plan to provide an update later this afternoon on the eruption of Mount Semeru in Indonesia, ... Read more »

'I tried the best pizza in the country and it was better than what I had during 3 weeks in Italy'

It was a typical Thursday at work for me, I was tired and drained from a busy week and needed a pick-me-up to get me through to the weekend. Coffee ... Read more »

Amy Day and AJ Bunker celebrate their birthdays in matching style

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo They were catapulted into the world of reality TV during their Love Island appearance this summer. And Love Island contestants Amy Day and ... Read more »

Aston Villa vs Leicester: Best bets for all Sunday's Premier League games

Bet it’s level headed as Steven Gerrard takes on his former headshrinker. Leicester’s trip to Aston Villa (4.30pm) will be the first time he and Brendan Rodgers have clashed as ... Read more »

Amadou Haidara to become Ralf Rangnick's first Man Utd signing in January on one condition

© Provided by Metro Amadou Haidara could move to Manchester United in January (Picture: Getty) Amadou Haidara is likely to become Ralf Rangick’s first signing as Manchester United manager in ... Read more »

Cold Chisel rock legend Ian Moss is 'caught using a cheat sheet to help him remember the lyrics' of the Australian anthem at Bathurst 1000

Rock legend Ian Moss slammed for using a 'cheat sheet' for national anthemCold Chisel icon was busted singing from piece of paper at Bathurst 1000 Motorsport fans labelled the 66-year-old old a 'disgrace' and 'unAustralian'  Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic