Forget levelling up: Rishi Sunak is deliberately increasing tax injustice

Forget levelling up: Rishi Sunak is deliberately increasing tax injustice
© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Stefan Rousseau/PA

A wise tax plan silently vanished last week. The chancellor was due to narrow a notorious tax loophole for the wealthy by raising capital gains tax. Now, in a quiet reverse ferret, he won’t. You might think any chancellor in these harsh times would collect what they could, and that this policy would be voter friendly, raising large sums from a few of the richest. But it would no doubt displease Tory donors and the influencers who will choose their next leader.

Besieged by urgent spending pleas, Rishi Sunak can’t pretend he doesn’t see the arid social landscape after a decade of depredation. One fragile sector after another teeters towards public scandal. Will a report on the murder of six-year-old Arthur Labinjo-Hughes expose the brutal cuts in child protection? An ambitious man eager to move next door to No 10 must surely fear the NHS buckling under current strains. But no, it seems not. Other political calculations come first.

The chancellor is abandoning the chance to raise as much as £14bn a year by reforming capital gains tax, according to his own Office for Tax Simplification, the outfit set up by George Osborne to iron out anomalies and inefficiencies. Sunak asked the OTS to report on raising the tax from its current 20% to 25%. That would catch some of the sleight of hand that allows high earners with personal service companies or private equity magnates to disguise their annual income as a capital gain to avoid far steeper income tax rates. They usually do that by taking pay in company stock, not cash, which cuts their tax rate from 45% to 20%. That’s how a hedge fund manager once notoriously boasted in 2007 that he paid less tax than his cleaner.

The OTS duly reported the facts, and its top estimate found the Treasury would gain a significant £14bn from raising capital gains tax. But last month the chancellor slipped out a response that stamped on the whole idea. Undertaxed, unearned wealth is soaring, but Sunak’s preferred choice is to raise National Insurance from everyone else. Capital gains trebled to £63bn in the eight years before the pandemic: Arun Advani of Warwick University reports the rise of “super gainers” who declare more than £1m a year of their income as a capital gain. Now consider this: last week the ONS reported the assets of the rich skyrocketed even faster during the pandemic. The Resolution Foundation warns that the pandemic has widened wealth gaps “with profound consequences for social mobility and future income inequality”. Those already on high salaries saw the value of their property, pensions and bank deposits soar.

Forget levelling up: Rishi Sunak is deliberately increasing tax injustice
© Photograph: Stefan Rousseau/PA ‘Rishi Sunak should be copying the one good reform Nigel Lawson enforced, when he equalised tax rates on all types of income.’

Sunak should be copying the one good reform that Nigel Lawson enforced as chancellor in 1988, when he equalised tax rates on all types of income, rightly declaring in the Commons: “There is little economic difference between income and capital gains.” Taxing all income at the same rate removed any incentive to disguise earnings as profits.

Forget levelling up under a chancellor who is deliberately increasing tax injustice. Last week Sunak let the Times know he would be cutting taxes, not raising them. His “retail” offer ahead of the next election will be a 2p cut to income tax, but as ever, those in higher bands benefit most. The cut would cost the Treasury an estimated £12bn. Meanwhile he is piling on extra bonanzas, with plans to scrap the top 45% rate altogether and cut inheritance tax. Not surprisingly, the Institute for Fiscal Studies has responded brusquely: the income tax cut would be “indefensible”, said its director, Paul Johnson, as it “discriminates in favour of the wealthy”.

These are monstrous sums for the state to forgo while failing to keep basic services afloat in the NHS, social care, schools, skills and transport, let alone progressing to net zero emissions. Will he say where his axe will fall to pay for these tax cuts? Michael Gove’s white paper on levelling up has been postponed until the new year, amid a reported dispute over the chancellor’s decision to allocate only a paltry £4.8bn over three years for all levelling-up projects. Many have compared that with the £2tn it cost to level up East and West Germany – which only took them 85% of the way.

Labour’s shadow chancellor, Rachel Reeves, did say she would tax wealth more fairly, but without revealing a plan or responding to Sunak’s capital gains retreat. She mentioned a windfall on Covid profiteers, so she could adopt the proposals in Tax Justice UK’s report about the six companies that made £16bn in excess pandemic profits. Some easy wins might include scrapping business asset disposal relief and reforming council tax and inheritance tax, according to Helen Miller, the deputy director of the IFS. Another move could be removing the VAT zero rate on food, which is an additional bonus for high spenders. This may sound regressive, but Miller says it would yield so much that it would be easy to compensate all lower earners and make them better off. A small fortune could be saved from the gigantic hidden welfare state that the well-off benefit from, such as pension tax relief, ISAs, charitable relief for private health and education and a host of other perks. These are waiting to be stripped away by any Labour chancellor brave enough to do so.

Sunak may have only one thought: how to prove himself a small-state anti-taxer to win the backing of the hardline Tory party selectorate. Maybe he’s right that cash in the pocket buys most votes. But he risks a pyrrhic victory if the price of seducing a small and unrepresentative rightwing clique is to lose the next election due to public repugnance at levelling down everything, everywhere.

  • Polly Toynbee is a Guardian columnist

News Related


Budget session to commence with strict Covid protocol, different timings for Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha

© Provided by DNA Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha will have staggered timing during the budget session of parliament beginning March 31 as part of measures against COVID-19 amid a ... Read more »

Flying of Parachute Regiment flags ahead of Bloody Sunday anniversary condemned

Unionist politicians have criticised the flying of Parachute Regiment flags in Londonderry and called for their removal, ahead of the 50th anniversary of Bloody Sunday. As parts of Derry city ... Read more »

Aldi is selling a heated dressing gown to help beat the cold - and we need one

We all have that one trusty dressing gown which gets us through the cold winters, but do you have one with a built-in heater? We take that as a no. ... Read more »

Inside Dele Alli's Tottenham fall and Daniel Levy's plans for midfielder reboot

Back in the summer of 2018, Dele Alli went to the World Cup as one of England’s biggest stars. Four years on ahead of the next World Cup, Alli is ... Read more »

'Sheena Bora is alive,' says Indrani Mukerjea in plea before Mumbai court

© Provided by Zee News Former media baron Indrani Mukerjea on Monday submitted a hand-written application before a special court here claiming her daughter Sheena Bora, whom she is accused ... Read more »

Join Squidge and The42 Rugby Weekly crew for our members' Six Nations preview

RESTRICTIONS HAVE BEEN kicked to touch, stadiums can be filled to the brim once more and the four provinces have reached the knockout stages of the Champions Cup. Who could ... Read more »

Chelsea are forced to increase the size of the away dressing room

Chelsea have been ordered to increase the size of the away dressing room at Stamford Bridge after complaints from visiting teams including Liverpool and Brighton. Liverpool made their point to ... Read more »

Benedict Cumberbatch 'loved' being in lockdown with his family

© Bang Showbiz Benedict Cumberbatch says lockdown was an enjoyable period of his life Benedict Cumberbatch “loved” being in lockdown. The 45-year-old actor – who has children Christopher, six, Hal, ... Read more »

ITV The Chase: Bradley Walsh secret method to stop himself laughing at questions

Bradley Walsh is known for his laughing fits while presenting ITV’s daytime quiz show The Chase. Who can forget the moment the Fanny Chmelar question came up and Bradley struggled ... Read more »

Punjab police arrest man for sacrilege bid at Patiala temple; attempt to disrupt peace, says CM Channi

Punjab sacrilege attempt Police in Punjab have arrested a man for allegedly attempting sacrilege at the Kali Devi temple in Patiala. The incident was captured on CCTV and a video ... Read more »

Novelis to raise $300-350 mn from Axis Bank in GIFT City

MUMBAI: Novelis, the overseas subsidiary of Hindalco , is raising about $300-350 million in offshore loans from Axis Bank, seeking to trim multiple credit lines through part repayment of earlier ... Read more »

Boris Johnson 'reconsidering' VAT cut on energy bills for every household

Boris Johnson is understood to be reconsidering a VAT cut on gas and electricity – cutting every household energy bill by 5% as prices surge to record levels. Though no ... Read more »

Palin COVID-19 tests delay libel trial against NY Times

NEW YORK (AP) — An unvaccinated Sarah Palin tested positive for COVID-19 Monday, forcing a postponement of the start of a trial in her libel lawsuit against The New York ... Read more »

I'm a self-confessed catfish – people say I'm the reason men have trust issues but at least I've already got a husband

A WOMAN got a strong reaction from followers after showing herself on camera without any make-up and then sharing a glammed up “catfish” snap. Viewers of the dramatic transformation couldn't ... Read more »

Consumer Reports: Testing Tesla & Ford Driver Monitoring Systems

© InsideEVs wmTuamHeedA Only two automakers passed Consumer Reports’ driver monitoring tests: Ford and GM. According to Consumer Reports, Tesla’s camera-based driving monitoring system doesn’t work to keep a driver’s ... Read more »

Sweden's RGNT Motorcycles Will Sell Its Electric Bikes In The U.S.

© Copyright RGNT No. 1 – Scrambler – Left Side Beauty in all its nuts and volts. Back in 2019, Swedish electric motorcycle startup RGNT released its extremely striking ... Read more »

Diego Carlos: Newcastle will have to stump up at least £37.9m to sign Sevilla defender

Diego Carlos has attracted £30m offers from Newcastle and a London Premier League club; Sevilla want £37.9m (€45m) if they are to part company with the defender; Newcastle still pushing for Jesse Lingard with talks over loan move from Manchester United on going Read more »

Desi, healthy winter desserts to keep you warm this January

© Provided by The Indian Express Festival time in India is synonymous with good food, and desserts top the list of most-favourite foods. As we celebrate one festival after another, ... Read more »

Fed to signal rate hike as it launches risky inflation fight

On Location: January 24, 2022 Catch up on the developing stories making headlines.The Associated Press WASHINGTON — With inflation punishing consumers and threatening the economy, the Federal Reserve this week ... Read more »

Israel's top Arab police officer takes leave pending probe

JERUSALEM — The highest-ranking Arab Muslim in Israel’s police force has taken leave, the police said Monday, after video emerged showing him tripping over a stabbing victim as he left ... Read more »

Apex's third anniversary will give players Packs for Octane, Wattson, and Valkyrie just for logging in

© Provided by Dot Esports To celebrate its third anniversary, Apex Legends is giving players three thematic Apex Packs for three different legends and a special Legendary Pack at the ... Read more »

FDA approves 2 self-test antigen kits

FDA Deputy Dir. Gen. Oscar Gutierrez at Jan. 24, 2022 briefing The Philippine Food and Drug Administration has approved two self-administered COVID-19 antigen test kits, officer-in-charge Oscar Gutierrez said Monday. ... Read more »

Delhi to have only three ‘dry days' in 2022

Delhi to have only three ‘dry days’ in 2022 The Delhi government, in an official notification on Monday, stated that the union territory will have only three ‘dry days’ this ... Read more »

SolChicks guide: How to make money in the play-to-earn crypto game

SOLCHICKS is gaining popularity as one of the leading fantasy play-to-earn gaming ecosystems on the Solana blockchain. The game features adorable “battle chicken” characters, which players can acquire to win ... Read more »

When is ranked play coming to Call of Duty: Vanguard?

© Provided by Dot Esports After months of anticipation, ranked play is finally on the way to Call of Duty: Vanguard. A ranked ladder was confirmed back in October by ... Read more »

Your own CIA jail? Lithuania to sell secret U.S. 'rendition' site

© Reuters/JANIS LAIZANS A building used by CIA to house Iraq and Afghanistan extraordinary rendition prisoners, in Vilnius By Andrius Sytas ANTAVILIAI, Lithuania (Reuters) – A huge steel barn outside ... Read more »

Kabore, Burkina's consensus-builder and onetime beacon of hope

© JULIEN DE ROSA Kabore, seen during 75th anniversary celebrations of UNESCO in Paris in November, vowed to stem jihadist violence but his failure to do so has hit his ... Read more »

Kate packt das Baby-Fieber – kommt nun das vierte Kind?

Bei einem Besuch in Lancashire mutierte Herzogin Kate kurzerhand zum Kindermädchen für das Baby einer Besucherin. Dabei zeigte sie sich so entzückt von dem kleinen Geschöpf, dass selbst William ins ... Read more »

Call of Duty: Warzone and Vanguard Season 2 Operators reportedly leak

© Provided by GamePur Call of Duty: Warzone Pacific and Vanguard have had their second seasons delayed due to ongoing bugs and weapon balancing issues, but that doesn’t necessarily mean ... Read more »

Apex Legends Season 12 is called Defiance, stars Mad Maggie as new Legend

© Provided by GamePur The new season of Apex Legends has been coming for a while now, but players have been speculating about who the new character would end up ... Read more »

Respawn Entertainment Reveals Newest Legend Mad Maggie and Apex Legends Season 12

Respawn Entertainment revealed the latest Stories from the Outlands, highlighting the next Legend to join the fray. Players should be well aware of who Mad Maggie is since Fuse was ... Read more »

Aaron Rodgers is open about life because he doesn't ‘give a f–k'

Aaron Rodgers is living up to his promise to be unapologetically himself. When asked why he has been so “willing” to speak his mind this season, the Packers quarterback said ... Read more »

COVID-19 in India: Karnataka logs over 40K new cases with 32.95 pc positivity rate; Delhi, Maharashtra, Kerala see decline in infections

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran News Desk: India’s Covid-19 positivity rate saw a rise while the nation saw a dip in Covid cases in the last ... Read more »

Spotify takes Meghan Markle and Prince Harry's podcast ‘into its own hands' after couple produce NO content for a YEAR

SPOTIFY is taking Harry and Meghan's £18million podcast project “into their own hands” by hiring a host of in-house producers to finally help deliver content. The streaming giant has been ... Read more »

Allow kin of Covid victims to claim ex-gratia physically: HC

© Provided by Hindustan Times Advocate Kejali Mastakar for the BMC informed the HC that it had received nearly 34,159 applications for ex-gratia compensation from kin of Covid victims (HT ... Read more »

Maharashtra ACB sees notable dip in corruption cases amid Covid-19 pandemic

© Provided by Hindustan Times ACB officials attributed the dip in fresh cases to Covid-19 pandemic-triggered lockdowns and closures of non-essential establishments. (Bachchan Kumar/ HT PHOTO) Mumbai Maharashtra has seen ... Read more »

Teen arrested for 89-year-old's murder in Rawsonville

© CAPE TOWN – A 15-year-old boy has been arrested for the murder of an 89-year-old woman in Rawsonville, in the Western Cape. Police say the teen suspect arrived ... Read more »

Claudio Ranieri: Watford sack head coach after just three months in charge amid relegation battle

Claudio Ranieri was appointed Watford head coach in October but has failed to turn around the team's fortunes, with the Hornets dropping into the relegation zone for the first time this season after Friday's loss to Norwich; Watford lost seven of eight league matches under Ranieri Read more »

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai, 24 January 2022, Written Update: Akshara and Abhimanyu are missing

© Provided by Pinkvilla In today’s episode, Goenkas criticises the Birla family and say Abhimanyu has gone astray. Akhilesh yells that Birlas can not be trusted. Aarohi runs outside her ... Read more »

Late singer Meat Loaf's wife Deborah Aday opens up about experiencing 'gut wrenching' grief: He was my world

© Provided by Pinkvilla   Deborah Aday, Meat Loaf’s widow, has expressed gratitude to fans for their well wishes, admitting that she is going through ‘gut-wrenching’ sadness in the aftermath ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic