FNV vice-chairman: ‘We should not try to maintain all jobs'

FNV vice-chairman: ‘We should not try to maintain all jobs’

Increasing waiting lists in healthcare, factories that have to refuse orders, restaurants that shorten their opening hours. For employers, the staff shortages are starting to hurt. But ask Zakaria Boufangacha, vice-chairman of the trade union FNV about the shortage on the labor market and he starts to put things into perspective.

“I also hear a lot of cry-cry stories from employers,” he says. He points to the catering industry, the shopping street and Schiphol Airport. “I see low wages, poor quality of work and flex workers that companies said goodbye to en masse at the start of the corona crisis, even though wage subsidies were available to them. It is obvious to me that employers have caused this problem themselves.”

This Friday, the FNV will present a new report on the labor shortage in which the union mainly describes what should not be done. The FNV does not want the Dutch to work more hours to combat the shortage.

Also read: The staff shortages are back, so how do you bring in people?

That is what economists and employers regularly advocate. The Netherlands is known as the European champion of part-time work. In no other EU country is the average working week so short: 30.6 hours. According to the FNV, that is not a problem. That short working week is more than made up for by the fact that so many Dutch people have a job in the first place: few people choose to stay at home. The Dutch also retire relatively late.

In addition, the FNV report puts the blame for the staff shortages mainly on employers themselves. The hospitality industry and commerce (including the shopping street) have made themselves unattractive due to an increase in flexiwork and lower wages. ‘Real wages’ – adjusted for inflation – have fallen by around 5 percent in ten years, FNV economists have calculated.

Boufangacha has little compassion for employers in shortage sectors, he says in the library of a chic hotel in The Hague near Noordeinde Palace. “It is their own fault that they have not invested in quality work. And that flex workers they sent out last year are not coming back. Own fault.”

You now refer to the hospitality industry and trade, but the entire labor market is tight. There is a record number of vacancies. Shouldn’t that be resolved?

Not all vacancies have to be filled. Look at shortage sectors such as trade, hospitality and aviation. Should Schiphol be a hub for the world if necessary? With eight companies for baggage handling? If only those were high-quality jobs… But experience has shown that there are a lot of pulp jobs there. Just like in the catering industry and trade.”

Some jobs have to disappear?

“Exactly. If we see low-quality jobs that offer little added value, then we should choose to reduce that a bit.”

How do you determine which jobs are not useful? That’s a harsh judgment.

“It is a harsh judgement. But maybe the market will find its own solutions. In any case, we should not try to maintain all jobs, but take a good look at which sectors we think are really important for our society, such as care and education. We have to invest in that.”

What should be done with non-useful jobs?

“The government must ensure that employers can no longer so easily opt for endless flexible work: disposable jobs. They have to start giving permanent jobs again. Companies that say: I cannot afford higher wages or permanent jobs, you can ask yourself: do they still have a right to exist?

And crucial sectors? How should they combat the shortage?

“In healthcare, education and technology, it also starts with sustainable employment relationships and good pay. And improving the quality of work. Make the sector more attractive to work in.”

Is the problem in the terms of employment? There are already many permanent jobs and high wages in technology?

“There are also many temporary workers there: in the process industry and the chemical industry we still see a flexible workforce of 20, 30 percent. And look at the metal sector. After years of fighting, we finally succeeded this year in making that sector attractive by abolishing the lower wage scales for young people. Even there, in a sector with large shortages, that did not happen automatically and we had to go on strike.”

Many healthcare and education employers are trying to get their staff, especially women, to work longer hours. Does the FNV oppose this?

“I am firmly convinced that part-time work is often born of necessity. My son’s teacher recently said: a part-time contract is actually a full-time job, if you see what it takes. So when you say let them work as much as possible, you’re doing phantom control. You have to start with the cause: how do you tackle the workload?”

We are also willing to discuss what kind of employment we want in the Netherlands and how we can focus on automation

Can it be both? Reduce the workload and encourage more hours?

“I think one thing flows from the other. You do have to start with the real problems: the workload, the increasing number of tasks. First, the quality of work must improve. Let’s not drive each other crazy by wanting to work more and more.”

One in three women is not economically independent. Isn’t that a reason to encourage them to work more hours?

“Yes, we support that. But not as a solution to the shortage, but from an emancipation issue. You can do this by making partner leave and parental leave more attractive: it is often a financial choice that the man continues to work. In this way we want to increase the labor participation of women. But on the other hand, men are allowed to be at home much more.”

The CNV union advocates the opposite: a full-time working week of 30 hours. What does the FNV think about this?

“We have long believed that the 32-hour working week should be the norm. But our difference with CNV is that we do not put this firmly on the agenda in collective bargaining everywhere. In many sectors, employers say: we don’t start with that, we just need extra hands. And we don’t think this is the most urgent topic everywhere.”

FNV vice-chairman: ‘We should not try to maintain all jobs’

Also read: Work four days and get paid for five. Does that work?

According to forecasts, the shortage will become even more acute due to an aging population. Should the government focus on destroying jobs in the Netherlands, for example by stimulating robotisation? Then more people will become available for other vacancies.

“That would go a long way. But I do think that in recent years, perhaps decades, the Netherlands has failed to develop a good vision on this: what kind of work do we want in the Netherlands? Indeed, government could promote such innovation. But the most important thing is that low-quality forms of employment – ​​cheap flex contracts – are made less attractive.”

Does the FNV support companies that want to automate? Even if that leads to job loss?

“Of course.”

The union usually opposes job loss, isn’t it?

“The most important thing is that a company does this in consultation with trade unions and employees: how do we deal with the consequences of automation and robotisation? And how can employees also benefit from this? If we can enter into that conversation, then we will stand side by side with the employer.”

Suppose a company says to the FNV: we have a fantastic plan for robotisation. Half of the jobs will disappear. What is your reaction?

“Very good. That leads to more labor productivity.”

That’s not your first reaction, is it?

“Okay, we have to be critical of ourselves. Of course, your first reflex is that it’s no fun when jobs disappear. But it is then up to the employer to make agreements with us. To keep as many jobs as possible, to allow people who are close to retirement to retire earlier, or to shorten the full-time working week while retaining salary – that would be very appropriate here.”

FNV vice-chairman: ‘We should not try to maintain all jobs’

Also read: In ten years half of the Netherlands will no longer be suitable for his work

Such agreements actually mean that these people do not enter the labor market. That’s not how you fight the shortages, is it?

“That’s true. But then my question is: are these people still capable of doing something completely new? Some have already burned out. And sometimes it is difficult to retrain people.”

You point a lot to the responsibility of government and employers. What can unions do themselves?

“Maybe it’s a clincher, but we feel empowered in our agenda of more permanent jobs, higher wages and better quality work. But we are also prepared to discuss what kind of employment we want in the Netherlands and how we can focus on automation. I don’t think it’s a bad development that you can now place an order in the catering industry itself with such a QR code. If you therefore need fewer people in the hospitality industry, more people can work in care.”

A version of this article also appeared in NRC in the morning of September 17, 2021

FNV vice-chairman: ‘We should not try to maintain all jobs’
Source link FNV vice-chairman: ‘We should not try to maintain all jobs’

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Search continues for missing NQ fisherman

A search is continuing near Cairns for a missing spear fisherman who was separated from his fishing companion late on Saturday. Police on Sunday upped their search efforts to locate ... Read more »

BREAKING NEWS: Up to 17 American missionaries and their families are kidnapped from bus by gang members as they leave an orphanage in Haiti

As many as 17 Christian Missionaries from the United States have been kidnapped by a gang on Saturday in Port-au-PrinceHaitian security officials say the group, including children, were kidnapped as they were leaving an orphanageOfficials say the missionaries were abducted from a bus headed to the airport  Read more »

Ardern seeks Maori mandate for COVID plan

Jacinda Ardern's government has quietly staged a series of meetings this weekend with Maori groups as it seeks buy-in for New Zealand's fight against COVID-19. Many Maori leaders have felt ... Read more »

Eyes on jobs market as restrictions ease

The focus will remain on the state of Australia's labour force market in a quieter week for economic data and after figures last week showed another steep drop in employment ... Read more »

Needle phobia device a design winner

COVID or otherwise, who even knew trypanophobia was a thing, right? For most people, the unnerving sight of something so sharp aimed straight at them as they wait to be ... Read more »

WA search continues for missing 4yo girl

A desperate search has continued through the night for a four-year-old girl who went missing more than 24 hours ago from a campsite in rural Western Australia. Cleo Smith was ... Read more »

AFL/AFLW players take climate change stand

Hundreds of professional men's and women's Australian rules football players have banded together to give climate change the boot. The newly formed AFL Players for Climate Action has attracted more ... Read more »

COVID puppy fears over Vic training delays

Not only are the social skills of Melburnians suffering in lockdown, but so too their four-legged friends. The Lost Dogs' Home has revealed its number of puppy training classes, which ... Read more »

Girl, 4, goes missing at WA campsite

A desperate search is under way for a four-year-old girl who has gone missing a campsite in rural Western Australia. Cleo Smith was last seen about 1.30am on Saturday at ... Read more »

Opposition to NSW kangaroo cull grows

Former Test cricketer Jason Gillespie says he is shocked by evidence to a NSW parliamentary inquiry which has raised questions about the state's kangaroo harvest. A report on the health ... Read more »

Victorian health agencies to share $200m

More than two dozen Victorian health services and organisations will share in $200 million worth of infrastructure funding. Almost 50 separate projects will receive money under the first round of ... Read more »

Melbourne heroin haul worth $140 million

An estimated $140 million worth of heroin hidden inside a shipping container sent to Melbourne from Malaysia has been intercepted by Australian authorities. The 450 kilogram haul is the largest ... Read more »

Cash for canegrowers in reef credit market

Queensland canegrower Peter Anderson has been taking steps to reduce run-off from his 650 hectare farm at Tully for about 10 years. “We would encourage everyone to have a look ... Read more »

Man bitten by shark in Qld's Whitsundays

A 34-year-old man is recovering after being bitten by a shark in Queensland's Whitsundays. He was reportedly climbing into the back of a vessel when the shark latched on to ... Read more »

Pandemic inspires fitness ... and injury

While lockdown has inspired some Australians to get more active, the extra physical activity during the pandemic has come at an unexpected cost. We've also become more prone to injury. ... Read more »

BREAKING NEWS: Ethics watchdog files a complaint against Jen Psaki because she 'violated the Hatch Act by endorsing' Democrat Terry McAuliffe for Virginia Gov. at the White House

Citizens for Responsible Ethics in Washington filed the complaintIt says she 'appears to have violated the Hatch Act by endorsing Terry McAuliffe’s gubernatorial campaign'Psaki said 'we're going to do everything we can to help former Governor McAuliffe, and we believe in the agenda he's representing'Hatch Act limits politicking on White House groundsEthics group says she appears to have given an 'endorsement' from the podium Filed complaint to Office of Special Counsel  Read more »

Another sleeper train from the Netherlands, and more are coming

Yet it is financially a more complicated story around the sleeper trains. Because the wagons have to pass through several countries, with a relatively large number of personnel on board, ... Read more »

Flexibility key to worker happiness: study

Flexible workers are happier workers it seems. New research shows they feel better rested, more engaged and have a higher sense of wellbeing than those confined to the office. A ... Read more »

Hillary Clinton visits husband Bill, 75, in the ICU as he battles sepsis caused by urinary tract infection: Former president is 'on the mend' and responding well to antibiotics after two days of treatment in California

Hillary Clinton was pictured visiting her husband, Bill Clinton, in a California ICU unit as the former President battles sepsis caused by a urinary tract infection. The 75-year-old, who had ... Read more »

Tasmania faces 'greatest virus risk'

Southern Tasmania has begun a snap lockdown after an infected NSW traveller sneaked out of hotel quarantine, as the state faces its greater risk of COVID-19 transmission this year. The ... Read more »

Kyrsten Sinema says she opposes ANY tax increase on Americans or corporations in Biden's mulit-trillion dollar spending plan while bulk of Democrats want negotiations to wrap up now

Sen. Kyrsten Sinema is opposing any tax increases for individuals and large corporations to pay for President Joe Biden’s reconciliation bill that’s being negotiated between the White House and Capitol ... Read more »

Bill Clinton's sepsis was caused by E.Coli and he was taken to hospital after vomiting and feeling faint at a fundraiser, his lead doctor says: Ex-president, 75, set to be released at the weekend

Bill Clinton has a blood infection caused by E.Coli, his doctors have said in a Friday morning updateThe told a cable morning show that he could be released to a regiment of oral medicine at home this weekend  Clinton was admitted to a California hospital on Tuesday, his spokesperson said on Thursday eveningHe is 'on the mend', Angel Urena added, explaining the former president was admitted for non-COVID reasonHis doctors confirmed his admission was not connected to his heart trouble, which has sparked past concernHillary Clinton was pictured entering and leaving the hospital Thursday night flanked by a security detail In 2004 he had a quadruple heart bypass, with arteries almost entirely blocked, and a stent inserted in 2010  That same year the former junk food lover became vegan and lost a significant amount of weight The Democratic commander-in-chief turned 75 years old this past August and was said to be in good spirits Read more »

BREAKING NEWS: Finally! Biden will lift travel restrictions for ALL vaccinated foreign visitors on November 8 - 18 months after they were put in place

The White House will announce on Friday it will lift travel restrictions for fully vaccinated foreign nationals effective Nov. 8, at land borders and for air travel, a White House ... Read more »

BREAKING: Southend Tory MP David Amess 'stabbed multiple times' as he holds constituency surgery in Methodist church

MP Sir David Amess has been stabbed in major incident at his constituency surgery in Leigh. The Tory MP for Southend West was holding a surgery at the Belfairs Methodist ... Read more »

Nearly one in five Dutch young people has a mental illness

“There are no precise figures for the Netherlands, which means that young people in our country do not always receive the help they need,” says the organization, which made an ... Read more »

Death of Adelaide woman deemed suspicious

The death of a 63-year-old woman at a home in Gawler South in Adelaide's north is being treated as suspicious, with another woman arrested. Police and paramedics were called to ... Read more »

Man, 70, drowns after boat capsizes off WA

A man aged in his 70s has drowned after the boat he was on capsized off Western Australia's Mid West coast. Police say the incident happened on Friday morning about ... Read more »

Construction of temporary school Waddinxveen is already causing many problems

Five contractors have been asked, but they do not want to make an offer. “The main reason is that construction costs have risen enormously in the past year and that ... Read more »

‘Time-Out' launched to focus on child abuse and domestic violence

State Secretary Paul Blokhuis (VWS): “It is unacceptable that one in five young people in our country has to deal with domestic violence. Home should be safe for everyone who ... Read more »

Queen Máxima visits a performance about the impact of corona among students

Her Majesty Queen Máxima paid a visit to the Time Out Café in Delft on Thursday evening 14 October. Time Out is an interactive performance for and by students about ... Read more »

The autumn holidays are starting in the north and middle regions

These regions include the provinces of Groningen, Friesland, Drenthe, Flevoland, North Holland, Overijssel, part of Gelderland, Utrecht and South Holland. The other provinces have off from October 23 to October ... Read more »

Adele releases long-awaited new single

Adele divorced her husband Simon Konecki in April 2019. The new album, the release date of which is not yet known, is very personal, partly because in the songs she ... Read more »

Drama series De Zomer van Zoë wins Televizier-Ster Jeugd

The Summer of Zoë is about horse girl Zoë (played by Gioia Parijs) who wants to win an important show jumping competition with her grooming pony in order to win ... Read more »

Qld cannabis farm had crop worth $25m

Police have seized a huge cannabis crop with a street value of $25 million west of Brisbane. Detectives found more than 10,000 plants, grow houses and hydroponic systems when they ... Read more »

Koalas join queue for chlamydia jabs

Researchers hope a new vaccine to protect koalas against the ravages of chlamydia could boost long-term survival prospects for the species. The vaccine, which has been years in the making, ... Read more »

Roberts-Smith lawsuit delayed until 2022

The resumption of Ben Roberts-Smith's defamation trial has been put off until at least the middle of January but no date has been set due to COVID-19 disruption. The Victoria ... Read more »

Students rally for climate change action

Thousands of students, parents and their supporters have taken part in a day of national action on climate change, calling on the federal government to stop funding gas and coal ... Read more »

Second man fined for Roxy Jacenko graffiti

A second man has been fined over obscene graffiti about Roxy Jacenko scrawled on the Sydney publicist's office. The seven-metre phrase “Roxy is a c***” was sprayed outside Ms Jacenko's ... Read more »

Victorian budget deficit revised to $14.6b

Victoria's 2020/21 deficit has been revised downwards after the state's economy performed better than expected between lockdowns. The government 2020/21 financial report, tabled in parliament on Friday, shows the state ... Read more »

Australia's most powerful music boss is stripped of the country's top music award after ABC exposé

Ex-staff have spoken out about former Sony Music chairman Denis HandlinThey allege a culture of abuse and intimidation existed while he was in chargeMr Handlin left the company in June with announcement it was a 'new direction'He was one of the most powerful and influential men in the music industryKIIS 1065 host Kyle Sandilands said those complaining should 'get over it'  Read more »