FM Sitharaman pitches for ‘genuine debate’ on freebies

fm sitharaman pitches for ‘genuine debate’ on freebies

In recent years, the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP), has especially been accused by its opponents of promising freebies to draw votes, a charge that the party denies. On Thursday, Delhi chief minister and AAP chief Arvind Kejriwal wondered as to why the Centre was opposed to free education, healthcare, medicine, etc. to the poor.

Finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Thursday called for a ‘genuine debate’ on the raging issue of ‘freebies’ being resorted to by political parties and governments.

The contentious issue gathered traction after Prime Minister Narendra Modi last month cautioned people against the ‘revari culture’ under which votes are sought by pledging freebies. This was followed by the Supreme Court expressing concerns over the ‘the culture of freebies ahead of elections’.

In recent years, the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP), has especially been accused by its opponents of promising freebies to draw votes, a charge that the party denies. On Thursday, Delhi chief minister and AAP chief Arvind Kejriwal wondered as to why the Centre was opposed to free education, healthcare, medicine, etc. to the poor.

Also Read| What inflation? India to be fastest growing economy this year, says top govt source

Rejecting his claims, Sitharaman said: “No Indian government has ever called (spending on) health and education ‘freebies’.”

“So by classifying (spending on) education and health as freebies, Kejriwal has given a perverse twist to the debate on freebies,” the finance minister said speaking to a group of journalists.

On August 3, the apex court had advised the Union government to form a composite expert committee to examine the pros and cons of freebies given out by governments and ways to curb irrational electoral promises that cost the exchequer dear. The committee may deliberate on the issue and come out with a report, it said. The panel may include Niti Aayog, RBI, EC, Finance Commission, ruling and opposition parties and other stakeholders, the SC had said.

However, the Election Commission of India has expressed its inability to be part of any such committee, saying it would not be ‘appropriate’ for the constitutional authority to be part of the panel as it will ‘disturb the level-playing field’.

In a recent article in The Indian Express, NK Singh, who chaired the 15th Finance Commission wrote: “The political dialogue built around freebies is fraught with danger.” Stating that there was a need to distinguish between the concept of merit goods and public goods on which expenditure outlays have overall benefits, he said expenditure on strengthening and deepening of the public distribution system, employment guarantee schemes, support to education and enhanced outlays for health etc. could be considered desirable.

“Therefore, it’s not about how cheap the freebies are but how expensive they are for the economy, life quality and social cohesion in the long run. We must dread the thought of replicating the culture of competitive freebie politics,” he wrote.

The AAP-ruled Punjab government has announced freebies including free electricity to each household, which might cost around `17,000 crore/annum or 3% of the state’s GDP. This is despite the fact that Punjab’s debt-to-GDP ratio is among the highest in the country and a sizeable chunk of its revenues goes towards interest payments.

Separately, a finance ministry source said, “There is no justification for political parties offering freebies that the government’s exchequer cannot afford and will eventually lead to bankruptcy of the state.”

The ministry’s opposition to the freebie culture stems from the fact that when parties promise free electricity, water or other freebies, they are merely borrowing from future generations to reward present ones, said the source. Moreover, when the Centre is raising the quality of spending by resorting to higher capital expenditure (which has a high multiplier-effect) by keeping a lid on revenue expenditure, some states are doing the opposite.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Looking to get better at...: Indian batting coach Vikram Rathour reveals biggest headache for Rohit Sharma's men

Looking to get better at…: Indian batting coach Vikram Rathour reveals biggest headache for Rohit Sharma’s men Indian batting coach Vikram Rathour has said the team is looking to improve ... Read more »

Rajasthan political crisis: Congress MLAs take U-TURN, those who resigned say 'we are with high command'

Rajasthan political crisis: Congress MLAs take U-TURN, those who resigned say ‘we are with high command’ Two days after their open “revolt” created a crisis for the Congress in Rajasthan, ... Read more »

After NIA mega-raids, Centre bans Popular Front of India for 5 years - Details inside

After NIA mega-raids, Centre bans Popular Front of India for 5 years – Details inside New Delhi: The Popular Front of India (PFI) and its associates or affiliates or fronts have ... Read more »

Thalapathy 67: Will Netflix Acquire Digital Rights?

Thalapathy Vijay and Lokesh Kanagaraj are all set to work together in the highly anticipated Tamil film, tentatively titled Thalapathy 67. The movie has been in the news ever since ... Read more »

Rajasthan political crisis: Congress gives clean chit to Gehlot, issues show cause notices to 3 MLAs

Rajasthan political crisis: Congress gives clean chit to Gehlot, issues show cause notices to 3 MLAs New Delhi: The Congress on Tuesday night issued show cause notices to two Rajasthan ... Read more »

Top court goes live in push for transparency

New Delhi, September 27: Scenes from a court inside the Supreme Court, where Constitution Bench hearings are now being live streamed, in New Delhi, on Tuesday, September 27, 2022. (HT Photo) ... Read more »

For ₹500/night, Uttarakhand offers real 'jail experience'

For ₹500/night, Uttarakhand offers real ‘jail experience’ DEHRADUN: If your astrologer predicts that planetary positions in your horoscope are not good (bandhan yog) and you are likely to go to ... Read more »

Day after mega crackdown, Centre bans radical outfit Popular Front of India

Day after mega crackdown, Centre bans radical outfit Popular Front of India Following multiple raids across the country and arrests by the probe agencies, radical outfit, Popular Front of India ... Read more »

Hindutva is a way of life, why is it related to extremism, asks actor Aashiesh Sharma

Hindutva is a way of life, why is it related to extremism, asks actor Aashiesh Sharma Actor Aashiesh Sharma on Tuesday said that “Hindutva” is a way of life and ... Read more »

'Greatest campaign slogan ever': Dr. Oz gives Fetterman a perfect opportunity for trolling after insult backfires

By Meaghan Ellis Dr. Mehmet Oz in 2008, Wikimedia Commons Republican Senate candidate Mehmet Oz appears to have given Democratic opponent John Fetterman an opportunity to troll him mercilessly after ... Read more »

Delhi Liquor Scam: CBI makes first arrest, nabs businessman Vijay Nair

Delhi Liquor Scam: CBI makes first arrest, nabs businessman Vijay Nair In a latest development in the alleged excise policy scam in Delhi, the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) made ... Read more »

Watch: Wife sings to husband of 70 years in this heart-touching video

Watch: Wife sings to husband of 70 years in this heart-touching video It is widely believed soulful music can have a healing effect and a video, which is now going ... Read more »

Barcelona's fitness woes continue! Club confirm Bellerin set to undergo tests on leg injury

Hector Bellerin Barcelona 2022-23 Bellerin to undergo tests on Wednesday Experiencing pain in left leg Joins long list of Barca injury concerns WHAT HAPPENED? According to the club, Bellerin “reported ... Read more »

'I guess I'll just..': Charlie Dean breaks silence on Deepti Sharma's controversial run-out saga

'I guess I'll just..': Charlie Dean breaks silence on Deepti Sharma's controversial run-out saga Days after Deepti Sharma cleverly dismissed Charlie Dean via run-out in the third ODI between India ... Read more »

Watch: This Pup's Friendship With Ducklings is the Cutest Thing on Internet Today

Watch: This Pup’s Friendship With Ducklings is the Cutest Thing on Internet Today Friendship is not based on any rationale. It occurs naturally and seamlessly. Imagine walking to your school ... Read more »

Chup box office collection Day 3: Dulquer Salmaan-Sunny Deol thriller gains momentum, here’s how much it minted

Chup box office collection Day 3: Dulquer Salmaan-Sunny Deol thriller gains momentum, here’s how much it minted Dulquer Salmaan and Sunny Deol’s thriller Chup: Revenge of the Artist has been ... Read more »

China’s focus to develop domestic medical device industry may discourage MNCs: GlobalData

GlobalData also claimed that the government wants foreign medical device manufacturers to transfer technologies and their assembly processes to China. (File) GlobalData said on Tuesday that China’s increasing focus to ... Read more »

Draft telecom bill proposes suspension of internet services in public interest

The Supreme Court expressed displeasure over such shutdowns in January 2020. (Getty Images/iStockphoto) The draft Indian Telecommunication Bill, which was released on Wednesday last, proposes time-bound limited suspension of internet ... Read more »

Was it illegal for Himanta and Sadhguru to enter Kaziranga at night? Strictly speaking, no

Facing flak for driving inside Kaziranga National Park with Sadhguru Jaggi Vasudev after sunset, Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma on Monday said that night safari in wildlife sanctuaries was ... Read more »

ECB offers to host Test series between India and Pakistan

Bilateral cricket between India and Pakistan has dried up due to political tensions between the two countries © AFP/Getty Images The ECB has offered to host men’s Test cricket between ... Read more »

G-Sec listing overseas: No plan for tax relief yet

Even as it’s keen on listing certain government securities on overseas bond indices, India is hesitant to extend capital gains tax waivers to foreign investors or freeze the rate at ... Read more »

Watch: Boy's Violent Act Sends Teacher To Hospital Bed

Watch: Boy’s Violent Act Sends Teacher To Hospital Bed During the COVID-19 lockdown, a lot of videos showing students taking advantage of virtual lectures surfaced on social media. Now, a ... Read more »

'My dad will be king': Prince George's cheeky reply to friends at school

‘My dad will be king’: Prince George’s cheeky reply to friends at school Prince George, the nine-year-old son of Prince William and Kate Middleton, reportedly told his classmates to “better ... Read more »

Enhance coverage of SCs in schemes: FM to PSU banks

Enhance coverage of SCs in schemes: FM to PSU banks NEW DELHI: As part of a focus on scheduled caste community, finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Tuesday asked state-run banks ... Read more »

WATCH: Virat Kohli and his ENERGETIC run after receiving THIS special prize in Hyderabad

WATCH: Virat Kohli and his ENERGETIC run after receiving THIS special prize in Hyderabad Former India captain Virat Kohli came back into form in the third and final T20I against ... Read more »

'We had warned her' - Deepti Sharma on the Charlie Dean dismissal

Was Deepti Sharma running Charlie Dean out at the non-striker’s end at Lord’s on Saturday a plan India had worked out in advance? Or was it an instinctive decision? According ... Read more »

'Don't Cross The Line!' Indian Fans Hit Back As England Captain Calls Team India 'Liar'

‘Don’t Cross The Line!’ Indian Fans Hit Back As England Captain Calls Team India ‘Liar’ Deepti Sharma, on Monday, made a revelation that the Indian team repeatedly warned Charlotte Dean ... Read more »

Well into offline schooling, students still in lockdown feels?

Students attending offline school (Representational Image) Even after 6 long months of offline schooling, many students are finding it difficult to shirk off the lockdown lethargy. Being shut behind doors ... Read more »

Do a Google Search for NASA DART and the results will surprise you

Do a Google Search for NASA DART and the results will surprise you NASA’s DART spacecraft successfully completed its planned collision with the asteroid Dimorphos at 4.44 AM IST on ... Read more »

'If Bhuvneshwar Kumar is listening...' - India's T20 WC medallist shares his two cents for out-of-form pacer

'If Bhuvneshwar Kumar is listening…' – India's T20 WC medallist shares his two cents for out-of-form pacer Since the Super Four round in the Asia Cup, India pacer Bhuvneshwar Kumar’s ... Read more »

Iran: 'Ex-president Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani's daughter arrested,' says report

iran: ‘ex-president akbar hashemi rafsanjani’s daughter arrested,’ says report Tehran: Iran on Tuesday arrested the daughter of ex-president Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani for inciting protests, the Tasnim news agency said, amid ... Read more »

'Truly, a historic day': More than 8 lakh viewers watched SC's first live streamed proceedings

‘truly, a historic day’: more than 8 lakh viewers watched sc’s first live streamed proceedings New Delhi: On the day the Supreme Court live streamed its proceedings for the first ... Read more »

Thane: 5, including 4 children injured after wall falls during demolition drive by BNMC

The demolition drive by Bhiwandi-Nizampura Municipal Corporation (BNMC) on a social organisation Hazrat Khwaja Garib Nawaz at Chauhan Colony on Tuesday turned out to be an unfortunate incident for four ... Read more »

‘Honest’ party worker, didn’t sign letter in favour of Tharoor: BJP MP

‘Honest’ party worker, didn’t sign letter in favour of Tharoor: BJP MP Stating that he is an “honest and loyal” worker of the party, BJP MP Dr Anil Agrawal has ... Read more »

PM to launch 3rd Vande Bharat train in Gandhinagar on Friday

PM to launch 3rd Vande Bharat train in Gandhinagar on Friday Prime Minister Narendra Modi will take a ride on the third Vande Bharat train which he will flag off ... Read more »

Fact Check: This photo of naked people demonstrating on road has nothing to do with Karnataka

New Delhi (Vishvas News). Days after a Dalit boy was allegedly thrashed for touching the idol at a religious procession in Karnataka’s Kolar district, on September 8, and his family ... Read more »

‘Injury Or Boosting Mumbai Lobby?’ Angry Fans Slam Rohit After Hooda’s Sudden Exclusion

‘Injury Or Boosting Mumbai Lobby?’ Angry Fans Slam Rohit After Hooda’s Sudden Exclusion It’s a known fact that Team India barely gets to rest and that their schedule has always ... Read more »

OnePlus Nord Watch specification officially revealed ahead of launch

OnePlus has officially revealed the specifications of the upcoming OnePlus Nord Watch ahead of launch. As revealed so far, the Nord Watch will boast a 1.78-inch AMOLED screen, with 500 ... Read more »

Adipurush: Here’s when the teaser of Prabhas and Kriti Sanon’s epic drama will be released

Kriti Sanon, Prabhas and Saif Ali Khan-starrer epic drama Adipurush’s teaser and poster of the movie will be unveiled on October 2. The poster and teaser will be launched on ... Read more »

Witnesses changed statement within months: Sanjay Raut

Witnesses changed statement within months: Sanjay Raut Mumbai: Pointing out the difference in statements of witnesses against Shiv Sena leader Sanjay Raut in the Patra Chawl redevelopment case, his advocate ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network