Florida Court Says Teen Not 'Mature' Enough For Abortion, So Must Bear Child

A Florida appeals court decided Monday to uphold a lower court’s ruling that a pregnant 16-year-old had not shown she was “mature” enough to terminate her unwanted pregnancy, and must therefore give birth.

The teen, described as “parentless” in court documents, has been petitioning the state court system to let her get an abortion without the written consent of a parent or guardian, which is required for minors under a law signed by Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) two years ago.

She argued before Escambia County Circuit Court Judge Jennifer Frydrychowicz that she was not ready to be a parent and did not have a job. She was living with a relative while she worked toward earning her GED.

But Frydrychowicz found that the teen did not establish “by clear and convincing evidence that she was sufficiently mature to decide whether to terminate her pregnancy,” court documents say. Florida’s First District Court of Appeals upheld the decision, with two judges on the panel concurring and one issuing a separate opinion concurring in part and dissenting in part.

In Florida, abortion is only permitted until the 15-week mark. (The American Civil Liberties Union is challenging the law, but at the moment it remains in effect.) The teen was 10 weeks pregnant when she first came before the court with her case worker and a guardian ad litem.

The teen explained to Frydrychowicz how she had researched abortion procedures, saying that she understood her medical options and had weighed the pros and cons of having an abortion.

Judge Scott Makar, the appellate court panelist who dissented in part, wrote that he believed Frydrychowicz did not think the teen had put enough consideration into the matter, because she was under heightened stress due to the recent death of a friend.

His dissent stemmed from his opinion that the case should have been sent back to the trial judge to sort out some loose ends, and he appeared to encourage the teen to go back and make her case again.

But she may be able to get an abortion another way. As Makar noted, the teen initially told the court that her legal guardian “was fine” with the decision to terminate her pregnancy. Under Florida law, Makar pointed out, she does not need to go through the judicial bypass process at all if her guardian fills out a form affirming their consent to the abortion.

Oddly, the issue of the teen’s guardian was “raised indirectly” but “not addressed” by the court, Makar said.

He also noted that the teen “inexplicably checked the box indicating that she did not request an attorney, which is available by law for free under the statute,” suggesting the process might have gone differently from the start if not for a check mark on a form.

This article originally appeared on HuffPost and has been updated.

florida court says teen not 'mature' enough for abortion, so must bear child

gold-trimmed wooden judicial gavel ~ shot with canon eos rp

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Commentary: I’ve seen how reading banned books can enrich kids’ education

My kids and I began reading banned books together when they were just learning sight words. Snuggled with my kids on the couch, I’d read aloud from a slim paperback ... Read more »

NFLPA fires independent doctor involved in clearing Tua Tagovailoa

NFLPA fires independent doctor involved in clearing Tua Tagovailoa The NFL Players Association has exercised its right to remove the independent neurological expert who was involved in the decision to ... Read more »

‘Blacklisted’ Afghan interpreters were disqualified from U.S. visas. Now they’re in hiding

WASHINGTON —  As an expert in explosive device removal, H.S.spent nearly three decades carefully cleaning up land mines and disabling unexploded bombs planted by insurgent groups in Afghanistan. During the last ... Read more »

Lincoln Riley delivers halftime magic: Takeaways from USC’s win over Arizona State

Caleb Williams punctuated his postgame press conference with a final reminder. The quarterback likes to get in the last word. “5-0,” he said, rising from the table and pumping his ... Read more »

174 dead as tear gas triggers stampede to exit soccer match in Indonesia

At least 174 people have died in a stampede after tear gas fired by police sparked panic among fans rioting after a soccer match in Indonesia, in one of the ... Read more »

Company responsible for O.C. oil spill gets permission to repair pipeline

The Houston-based company operating the oil pipeline that ruptured off Huntington Beach last fall announced Saturday that the government has green-lighted its plans to repair the pipeline, raising the possibility ... Read more »

2 San Francisco restaurants rank among Tripadvisor's best places to eat in US

Two San Francisco restaurants ranked high on Tripadvisor’s Best of the Best Restaurants for 2022 list, released Sept. 27, alongside some of the best places to eat in the world. ... Read more »

Graham Potter Gives Honest Reaction To Thiago Silva Red Card Decision

Crystal Palace were left fuming after the Brazilian was only shown yellow. View the original article to see embedded media. The new Chelsea boss Graham Potter secured his Premier League ... Read more »

Investigation underway after 2 separate stabbings in NW DC within 12 hours

Investigation underway after 2 separate stabbings in NW DC within 12 hours The Metropolitan Police Department is investigating two separate stabbings that happened in Northwest D.C. within less than 12 ... Read more »

Marjorie Taylor Greene deceptively tells Trump rally that Democrat 'killings' of Republicans have already started

Majorie Taylor Greene waves to the crowd before she makes speaks during a Save America rally on October 1, 2022 in Warren, Michigan Emily Elconin/Getty Images Marjorie Taylor Greene spoke ... Read more »

3 Industrial Dividend Stocks Smart Investors Are Buying in the Bear Market

3 Industrial Dividend Stocks Smart Investors Are Buying in the Bear Market Most industrial dividend stocks are easily impacted by economic cycles, making the industrial sector a hard play today. ... Read more »

Brazzo was happy to mobilize quickly and bring Matthijs de Ligt to Bayern Munich during the summer

Brazzo was happy to mobilize quickly and bring Matthijs de Ligt to Bayern Munich during the summer Bayern Munich sporting director Hasan “Brazzo” Salihamidžić is happy to have brought in ... Read more »

3 Recession-Resistant Agriculture Dividend Stocks That Can Steer Your Portfolio Toward Greener Pastures

Fluctuating commodity prices and varying demand for new equipment and machinery add cyclicality to the agriculture industry. However, the industry also has a great deal of recession resistance. The agriculture ... Read more »

Sadio Mane admits adapting to Bayern Munich 'is not easy at all'

Mane has made a mixed start to life in Munich | Alexander Hassenstein/GettyImages Sadio Mane has admitted adapting to Bayern Munich after joining from Liverpool hasn’t been “easy at all.” ... Read more »

Hold fire: Re-enactors fear being targeted by NY gun law

ALBANY, N.Y. – Some historical battle re-enactors in New York are holding their musket fire because of worries over the state’s new gun rules — an unplanned side effect of ... Read more »

The Qualities Women Find Irresistibly Attractive in Men (How to Get the Girl)

Dating is a complicated game, especially if you’re a man—women have been found to be the pickier gender until the age of forty, which essentially means men have to try ... Read more »

Man Killed Outside Philly Home in Ambush Shooting: Police

Man Killed Outside Philly Home in Ambush Shooting: Police A man was fatally shot outside his Philadelphia home shortly before midnight Saturday night, authorities said. At around 11:55 p.m., A ... Read more »

Forget avocado toast — why sweet potato toast is the best fall breakfast

For those of us who are good little millennials, avocado toast is a sacred part of our morning routine. Something about our day just feels amiss if it’s not started ... Read more »

Shootings in Chicago: 7 shot, 1 fatally in weekend violence across city, police say

Seven people have been shot, including one fatally since Friday across Chicago, police said. A 3-year-old boy who was shot while in a car with his mother Friday night on ... Read more »

Commentary: College football review: From Lincoln Riley to Brent Venables, grading new coaches

Just how bad was the Oklahoma Sooners’ defense on Saturday during their 55-24 humiliation at the hands of Texas Christian? The numbers spell it out clearly: 27 first quarter points. ... Read more »

Pope Francis appeals to Russian President Vladimir Putin to end 'spiral of violence and death,' decries nuclear war risk

Pope Francis appeals to Russian President Vladimir Putin to end 'spiral of violence and death,' decries nuclear war risk Pope Francis appeals to Russian President Vladimir Putin to end 'spiral ... Read more »

Former Mayor To Be Released From Prison | Metra Fatality | Paw Patrol

Southland Week In Review Miss a day, miss a lot. Let’s get caught up with the Southland Week In Review. Former Crestwood Mayor Lou Presta To Be Released From Federal ... Read more »

Column: USC star Caleb Williams rebounded against Arizona State. Is he ready for bigger tests?

Caleb Williams is the kind of player who can make an entire stadium “ohhhh” multiple times a game. By spinning out of a certain sack. With a jump pass to ... Read more »

Report: Fabrizio Romano Gives Update On Christopher Nkunku To Chelsea

Fabrizio Romano has given an update on the news linking RB Leipzig’s Christopher Nkunku to Chelsea. View the original article to see embedded media. The Christopher Nkunku to Chelsea rumours ... Read more »

Death toll rises amid struggle to recover from Ian

As of Saturday night, nearly 1 million homes and businesses were still without electricity in Florida. Read more »

Victim’s son and friend charged in Seekonk murder after 15-month investigation

DIGHTON, MA. – MAY 10: Bristol County District Attorney Thomas Quinn holds a press conference on May 10, 2019 in Dighton, Massachusetts, with Dighton Police Chief Chief Robert Macdonald and ... Read more »

Hurricane Ian: 'Some people have been trapped for days' says Sky presenter in Florida

Although the hurricane itself is over, the operation to rescue people and property continues. Read more »

Polls open in Brazil for election that could return a leftist president after four years of far-right politics

Polls open in Brazil for election that could return a leftist president after four years of far-right politics Polls open in Brazil for election that could return a leftist president ... Read more »

Did an Apex, NC, startup outmaneuver the sharks on ABC’s ‘Shark Tank’?

A North Carolina couple had little trouble getting an offer on “Shark Tank.” The drama lay in which offer they would take. On the latest episode of the popular ABC ... Read more »

3 reasons IU football lost to Nebraska: Defeat in Lincoln complicates bowl picture

A scoreless second half consigned Indiana to a 35-21 loss Saturday night at Nebraska. Here are three reasons why: Oct 1, 2022; Lincoln, Nebraska, USA; Nebraska Cornhuskers wide receiver Alante ... Read more »

Caruso cuts into Bass’ lead, poll finds, as L.A. mayoral race heads into final weeks

Rick Caruso has made significant progress in the race for mayor, closing a large part of the gap with Rep. Karen Bass since August, but the billionaire businessman still trails ... Read more »

Jacob Steichen was ‘gravely disabled’ 3 days before fatal stabbing, clinician said

Editor’s note: This is the second story in a series on the failure of local agencies to protect the Steichen family from a preventable tragedy. After weeks of the family ... Read more »

3 Ultra-High-Yield Dividend Stocks to Buy in October

3 Ultra-High-Yield Dividend Stocks to Buy in October There’s usually a bright side to any bad story. We’re definitely seeing a bad story unfold this year with the major stock ... Read more »

Flight Review: KLM Boeing 737-800 Intra-Europe Economy Class

Flight Review: KLM Boeing 737-800 Intra-Europe Economy Class KLM IATA/ICAO Code: KL/KLM Airline Type: Full Service Carrier Hub(s): Amsterdam Schiphol Airport Year Founded: 1919 Alliance: SkyTeam Airline Group: Air France-KLM ... Read more »

West Virginia Dominated in Texas

Texas’ big first half stuns Mountaineers as Longhorns cruise to a 38-20 victory Austin, TX – The Texas Longhorns (3-2, 1-1) strung together four consecutive touchdown drives behind 267 yards ... Read more »

The Pagan roots of Democrats’ abortion extremism

The Pagan roots of Democrats’ abortion extremism Arizona’s recent ruling on abortion will set women “back more than a century,” White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre claimed last week. But ... Read more »

Hurricane Orlene strengthens into Category 3 storm as it heads toward western Mexico

Rapidly intensifying Category 3 Hurricane Orlene is approaching western Mexico, where it’s expected to cause life-threatening flooding, according to the National Hurricane Center. The hurricane, packing maximum sustained winds of ... Read more »

Review: For a young Chinese American, our hearts are missing in action

Review: For a young Chinese American, our hearts are missing in action Some books are great because there is a plot twist down the road and that road is a ... Read more »

A huge chance for Chelsea

Roseann Bongiovanni of GreenRoots prepared to give a tour of the site Friday. CHELSEA — At a contaminated, overgrown industrial site where the Mill and Chelsea creeks meet, something is ... Read more »

KPRC 2 Investigates: Judge reprimands body shop owner for failing to pay back victims

HOUSTON – When the law finally catches up to criminals, they may be sentenced to jail or probation. Sometimes they’re ordered to pay what’s called restitution to reimburse their victims ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network