Finding the Missing Pieces of Urban Planning Puzzle in India

Asia's Tech News Daily

Finding the Missing Pieces of Urban Planning Puzzle in India
© Provided by News18 Finding the Missing Pieces of Urban Planning Puzzle in India

Planned urban development in a nation depends on its capacities and systems. This article unbundles the complexities of the present capacities in India for city planning and management.

The urban maze in which one-third of India lives has been enduring multiple transitions—technological, digital, lifestyle and demographic. It is estimated that by 2050 India might become a half-urban country; presently, one-third population lives in urban centres. The Union and state governments have been investing heavily in the urban sector since 2014. However, deficiencies in urban planning capacities at all levels emerge as a deep-seated legacy issue.

Often, the inefficiencies in the cities are attributed to the way cities are planned in India and the level of skills of urban planners. Most commonly, such notions lead to fragmented capacity building events for a handful of urban planning workforce. Though relevant, these approaches alone have not yielded sweeping transformations at the size and scale the country needs.

NITI Aayog constituted a high-level inter-ministerial advisory committee chaired by Dr Rajiv Kumar, Vice Chairperson, NITI Aayog, on ‘Reforms in Urban Planning Capacity in India’ in October 2020. It comprised 14 members including CEO of NITI Aayog, President of CEPT University, Ahmedabad and Director of School of Planning and Architecture, Delhi. The committee did not choose the path of prescribing an ideal city or a ‘one-size-fits-all’ framework for all Indian cities—given the diversity in the country it would not have been useful. In fact, the committee focused on mechanisms to create capacities that could propel India to become ‘Aatma Nirbhar’ in the domain of urban planning and management.

Beginning October 2020, a series of intensive consultations and workshops were conducted by NITI Aayog. The inter-ministerial deliberations with ministries of housing and urban affairs, education, panchayati raj and rural development depicted the constraints in planning of rural-urban continuum. Eminent planners, think tanks, professionals and civil society organisations were consulted. Each consultation unveiled critical bottlenecks at multiple levels.

Simply put, urban planning capacity of India has three pillars—education and research sector, public and private sector. Robust capacity of each individual pillar and its seamless functioning with the other two is essentially a desired scenario, which needs to be created.

A snapshot of the present situation highlights ironies and a compelling need to bring reforms. Of the 7,933 towns counted as ‘urban’ in the Census of India (2011), almost half are called ‘census towns’, meaning they are administratively ‘rural’. Master plans are statutory tools to guide urban growth. However, almost 65 per cent of 7,933 urban centres in India continue to grow without them.

The urban planning system is the foundation to achieve integrated development and socio-economic growth. This cannot be created without investing in ‘soft capital’ of qualified urban planners in urban local bodies, state town and country planning departments and domestic private sector companies. The number of sanctioned positions of town planners in the state town and country planning departments are 3,945—which is just one-third of what is needed (estimated based on the population and workload). Of this, more than 40 per cent posts are lying vacant.

To get a better perspective of the magnitude of shortage, presently there is not even one town planner per urban centre in the state town and country planning departments. Ironically, the skilled planning graduates struggle to prove their eligibility for town planners’ jobs while cities face unplanned growth. Cities like Singapore were not built without robust organisations with skilled workforce.

Who is an urban planner is a widely contested question. Let us break it down to understand better. Cities are not just a set of buildings. They are living entities where society, economy and environment must co-exist. Imbalance in this equation can cause an unreasonable consequence on the other—which is what has been happening if one looks at cities only through a lens of spatial design.

Urban planning involves complex decision-making and moderation among various competing land uses, societal considerations, economic policies and environmental constraints. Therefore, it needs a multi-disciplinary skillset and dedicated training. Age-old beliefs that any professional who knows spatial design can suit the role of a planner are thus fallacious.

Also, there is an urgent need to understand that city planning deals with land. Be it creation of houses, roads, railways, ports, industrial areas or riverfronts—every activity is inter-related and interdependent in terms of functionality. The present approach of urban governance does not ensure such integration. It needs to be horizontally and vertically integrated to bring efficiencies.

The tools that are used by state governments for planning and managing the cities—town and country planning legislations for creating a base for statutory plan preparation and implementation, recruitment of the town planners, and so on have become dated. In many cities, development control regulations were formulated long back and are updated without sufficient empirical evidence of their impacts.

The public sector organisations are statutorily responsible for planning of cities and their management. However, they face technical, systemic and human resource limitations to engage private sector companies. Resultingly, the private sector ecosystem in this sector has also remained underdeveloped in the country.

With about 50 institutions offering degree courses in urban planning, the education sector in this domain is wide but qualitatively not strong enough, except for few front-running institutions. The institutions also face faculty shortage. The degrees awarded to the urban planning graduates vary to the tune of 25 nomenclatures, creating confusion in market. There is no statutory body to represent and regulate the profession of urban planning due to which any untrained professional is allowed to undertake the planning job—posing great risks to work quality.

In a nutshell, the current urban planning capacities in India are extremely skeletal. This structure has to be nourished with systemic reforms and change of mindsets. The final report of the advisory committee of NITI Aayog elaborates on the present capacities and puts forward a set of recommendations that can bring a sea change. On the demand side, it has proposals for a central sector scheme to create 500 healthy cities, creation of posts for lateral entrants, upgradation of rules, etc. On the supply side, it bats for normalising the degree nomenclature and creating national council for town and country planners and national digital platforms of town and country planners. The report has also suggested systemic reforms like research-backed upgradation of bylaws, town and country planning legislation, urban governance frameworks—to create an enabling environment.

Albert Einstein once said that we can’t solve problems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created them. Changes from a ‘business as usual’ approach might be difficult to implement and all the stakeholders—Union ministries, state urban development departments, academicians, and urban planners need to work together in a systematic manner.

Dr K Rajeswara Rao, IAS, is Special Secretary, NITI Aayog and Anshika Gupta is Senior Associate, NITI Aayog. The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not represent the stand of this publication.

Read all the Latest News, Breaking News and Coronavirus News here. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Telegram.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Live like the McCallisters at Airbnb's real ‘Home Alone' house this holiday season

© Provided by Lifestyle Asia This holiday season, Airbnb x Home Alone wants to help you eat all the junk food and watch all the rubbish you want with nobody ... Read more »

Threatened with insolvency, Green Party considers closing its head office

© Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press Green Party interim leader Amita Kuttner listens to a question during a news conference in Ottawa on Wednesday, Dec. 1, 2021. As it looks for ... Read more »

Asha Bhosle calls 'India's Best Dancer 2' contestant 'Choti Helen'

© IANS Asha Bhosle Mumbai, Dec 3 (IANS) Asha Bhosle, who will be seen as a special guest on ‘India’s Best Dancer 2’, has praised the show’s contestant Saumya and ... Read more »

Antonio Conte reveals where Tottenham can still improve after encouraging win over Brentford

© Getty Images antoniocontetottenham03122021A.jpg Antonio Conte says Tottenham still need to learn to break down tight defences, despite being encouraged by their forward play in Thursday night’s 2-0 win over ... Read more »

New retrospective explores the 50-year career of First Nations artist Robert Houle

TORONTO — The half-century long career of renowned Saulteaux and Anishinaabe artist Robert Houle is the focus of a new major retrospective at the Art Gallery of Ontario titled “Red ... Read more »

India vs New Zealand 2021, Tea Report: Mayank Agarwal Stars With the Bat After Virat Kohli Dismissal Hogs Limelight

© Provided by News18 India vs New Zealand 2021, Tea Report: Mayank Agarwal Stars With the Bat After Virat Kohli Dismissal Hogs Limelight Mayank Agarwal made up for his poor ... Read more »

Six wild elephants trapped in muddy pond in Assam's Goalpara, rescued by forest officials

Six wild elephants trapped in muddy pond in Assam’s Goalpara, rescued by forest officials After five wild elephants were rescued from a muddy pond in Assam’s Goalpara district on Thursday ... Read more »

Booster vaccines ‘likely to offer good protection against Omicron'

© Provided by Booster vaccines may well offer good protection in the face of the Omicron variant, experts behind a major new study have suggested. A team studying the ... Read more »

Vicky-Katrina Wedding or 'Mission Impossible'? NDAs, Codes at Ceremony Baffle Desis

© Provided by News18 Vicky-Katrina Wedding or ‘Mission Impossible’? NDAs, Codes at Ceremony Baffle Desis Secret codes, non-disclosure agreements (NDAs), 100 bouncers and no contact with the outside world: while ... Read more »

Only Punjab reported 4 suspected deaths due to lack of oxygen: Mansukh Mandaviya

Of the 19 states that responded to the Centre’s query on the data on deaths due to oxygen shortage, only Punjab reported four suspected deaths, the Centre said on Friday, ... Read more »

Omicron scare: 10 foreigners from African countries go untraceable in Bengaluru

At least 10 international travellers who arrived in Bengaluru from African countries have gone untraceable, the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP) said on Friday. This comes as Karnataka has reported ... Read more »

Did Krushna Abhishek just confirm Vicky Kaushal-Katrina Kaif's rumoured wedding? Watch video

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran Entertainment Desk: Katrina Kaif and Vicky Kaushal’s wedding rumour has made its place firm at the top, every now and then, ... Read more »

Star Health cuts IPO size after tepid subscription

© Provided by Business Today Star Health cuts IPO size after tepid subscription Star Health will cut the offer for sale portion of its IPO after the offering received a ... Read more »

Big Bollywood Premieres Back with Salman Khan, Leander Paes, Disha Patani Attending Tadap Screening

© Provided by News18 Star studded Bollywood movie premieres were a regular phenomena in the pre-pandemic times. After a lull of almost two years, Wednesday night saw the biggest of ... Read more »

Petition filed against Kangana in UP's Agra over 'bheekh' remark, petitioner receives flak for naming PM in it

A petition was filed against Bollywood actor Kangana Ranaut in Uttar Pradesh’s Agra over ‘bheekh’ remark. (File photo) An Agra-based lawyer has filed a petition in the court of chief ... Read more »

Photos of 1970s Dubai show the birth of the modern city

Dubai’s skyline is adorned with record-breaking buildings. From the world’s tallest building — the 828-meter-tall (2,716-foot) Burj Khakifa — to the world’s tallest hotel — the 356-meter-tall (1,168-foot) Gevora Hotel ... Read more »

Disaster expert urges those affected by B.C. flooding to take care of mental health

An expert on the psychological and social impacts of disasters on families is encouraging people affected by devastating floods in British Columbia to take care of their mental health while ... Read more »

Delay to rules on Covid-19 testing for travellers into Ireland

© Brian Lawless A man wearing a protective face mask in the departures area of terminal one at Dublin airport (Brian Lawless/PA) The introduction of new testing rules for arrivals ... Read more »

BGC Dawson's frozen meal program tackles food insecurity and waste in Verdun

© Chloe Ranaldi/CBC Marc Mckeown, BGC Dawson head chef, responsible for all food preparation. During the month of December, CBC will be working with BGC Dawson to showcase stories of ... Read more »

Five members of a family killed in road accident in Assam's Goalpara

Five members of a family killed in road accident in Assam’s Goalpara Five members of a family including two children were killed and three others injured in a road accident ... Read more »

'Actively' Follow Up: Health Secy Writes to States as 30 Nations, Including India, Confirm Omicron Cases

© Provided by News18 ‘Actively’ Follow Up: Health Secy Writes to States as 30 Nations, Including India, Confirm Omicron Cases Union Health Secretary, Rajesh Bhushan reiterates measures that Indian states ... Read more »

Viral alert: THIS doctor wife dancing with hubby on Manike Mage Hithe sets stage on fire- Watch trending video

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: We have seen multiple renditions of the Sri Lankan viral song Manike Mage Hithe so far. Joining the bandwagon is this couple, who ... Read more »

The Matrix Resurrections: Warner Bros Korea confirms return of original trilogy character

© Warner Bros Pictures Matrix-Resurrections.png The Matrix Resurrections has a lot of surprises in store for fans – but one has now been revealed weeks before it’s released. A theory has ... Read more »

Noida: Covid hospital reserves 30 beds for international travellers amid Omicron scare

The district health department on Thursday reserved 30 beds in two wards of Noida Covid hospital located in Sector 39 for all international travellers who test positive for Covid-19. Reportedly, ... Read more »

Gujarat Man Gets Unique Card For Son's Wedding, It Turns Into Bird's Nest

© Provided by News18 Gujarat Man Gets Unique Card For Son’s Wedding, It Turns Into Bird’s Nest The wedding day is special not just for the bride and groom but ... Read more »

Omicron: India's Genome Scientists, Part of Centre's Team, Recommend Booster Shot for Those Above 40

© Provided by News18 Omicron: India’s Genome Scientists, Part of Centre’s Team, Recommend Booster Shot for Those Above 40 Top Indian genome scientists have recommended a booster dose of COVID-19 ... Read more »

WhatsApp Tips: Here's how to hide online status and send a text message

WhatsApp may be your favourite app since it allows you to stay in touch with your friends, family, and coworkers without difficulties. © Provided by Zee News Furthermore, it is ... Read more »

Inside Edge Season 3 review: ‘90s nostalgia, thrilling onscreen India-Pakistan cricket rivalry make it sneaky-good fun

© Provided by Firstpost Inside Edge Season 3 review: ‘90s nostalgia, thrilling onscreen India-Pakistan cricket rivalry make it sneaky-good fun The first season of Inside Edge had me hooked. The second season ... Read more »

Musk humiliated after choosing Germany over UK as Britain a 'lucrative market after all'

© PA Elon Musk The Tesla CEO continues to face delays in opening a Gigafactory in Berlin over red tape. As well as being held up by challenges from environmental ... Read more »

'Needlessly provocative': Shashi Tharoor on BJP's protest in Parliament

© Provided by Hindustan Times Congress MP Shashi Tharoor speaks in the Lok Sabha during ongoing Winter Session of Parliament, in New Delhi. (PTI) Members of Parliament from the Bharatiya ... Read more »

India vs New Zealand: Miffed Virat Kohli sets unwanted record after 4-ball duck on return in Mumbai Test

Virat Kohli India captain Virat Kohli set an unwanted record on Friday as he got out for a duck on his return to competitive cricket on Day 1 of the ... Read more »

‘It was my princess moment': Manushi Chhillar reveals her ‘most favourite thing'

© Provided by The Indian Express From memories to souvenirs, one’s home is a treasure trove of all things personal. As such, taking her fans on a tour of her ... Read more »

Tory chairman says Brits can kiss at parties as long as they wear masks on the bus home

People are free to snog at Christmas parties – as long as they wear masks on the bus home, a top Tory has said. Conservative Party chairman Oliver Dowden said ... Read more »

Govt may not ban cryptocurrencies, regulation likely: Reports

Cryptocurrencies may not be completely banned in India and the government may create a framework to regulate highly risky virtual assets, as per multiple reports. The development comes at a ... Read more »

IND vs NZ 2021, 2nd Test, Day 1 Live Score: India Post 111/3 At Tea After Mayank Agarwal's Fighting Fifty

© Provided by News18 IND vs NZ 2021, 2nd Test, Day 1 Live Score: India Post 111/3 At Tea After Mayank Agarwal’s Fighting Fifty IND vs NZ 2021, 2nd Test, ... Read more »

Storm Arwen: Military dispatched to North East as desperate residents prepare for second week without power

The military is to dispatch 100 soldiers to the north east to help residents still struggling without power seven days after Storm Arwen knocked out supplies. © Getty Images Marines ... Read more »

Bella Hadid explains why she chose to return to working with Victoria's Secret

© Getty Images GettyImages-1328179947.jpg Bella Hadid has returned to working with Victoria’s Secret. The 25-year-old model, who has walked in three fashion shows for the lingerie brand, stopped working with ... Read more »

Petition begging journalists to stop interviewing Will and Jada Smith now has 15,000 signatures

Will and Jada Pinkett Smith’s relationship has been making headlines recently – but thousands of people are calling for this to stop. © Getty Images GettyImages-1353322911.jpg Taking matters into their ... Read more »

Canada should focus on vaccine equity — not travel bans — human rights advocate, doctors say

© Michael Probst/Associated Press Canadian experts say the country needs to do better to address vaccine equity by providing more vaccines and supporting vaccine production. Health and infectious disease specialists ... Read more »

Woman With Spina Bifida Wins Case Against Mother's Doctor For Negligent Pregnancy Advice

A young woman with spina bifida has successfully sued the doctor that gave her mother negligent pre-pregnancy advice. © d76 masahiro ikeda – Getty Images A woman with spina bifida ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic