'Financial equivalent of the Death Star': These US lawmakers are sounding the alarm over talks of a central bank digital currency — here's why one calls it an 'Orwellian-style' system

'financial equivalent of the death star': these us lawmakers are sounding the alarm over talks of a central bank digital currency — here's why one calls it an 'orwellian-style' system

US lawmaker blasts the Fed over CBDC

Last week, Rep. Tom Emmer (R-MN) re-introduced a bill that would block efforts from the Fed and Biden administration to develop and institute a central bank digital currency (CBDC) that he believes would be used to “undermine the American way of life.”

“The administration has made it clear: President Biden is willing to compromise the American people’s right to financial privacy for a surveillance-style CBDC,” Emmer said during a Sept. 13 press conference.

Don’t miss

  • Commercial real estate has outperformed the S&P 500 over 25 years. Here’s how to diversify your portfolio without the headache of being a landlord
  • Rich young Americans have lost confidence in the stock market — and are betting on these 3 assets instead. Get in now for strong long-term tailwinds
  • Worried about the economy? Here are the best shock-proof assets for your portfolio. (They’re all outside of the stock market.)

“If not designed to be open, permissionless, and private – emulating cash – a government-issued CBDC is nothing more than a CCP-style surveillance tool that would be used to undermine the American way of life,” he said.

Emmer’s move comes after a fellow Republican lawmaker accused the Federal Reserve of quietly working on a CBDC — which he has likened to “building the financial equivalent of the Death Star.” For the uninitiated, the Death Star is a moon-shaped space station and superweapon featured in the Star Wars franchise.

In a July outburst on X (formerly Twitter), Rep. Warren Davidson (R-OH) called on Congress to “swiftly ban, then criminalize any effort to design, build, develop, test or establish a CBDC.”

“Money should not be programmable by a central authority,” Davidson wrote. “Money should be a stable store of value and an efficient means of exchange, not a tool for surveillance, coercion, and control. Sound money facilitates permissionless, peer-to-peer transactions.”

A digital dollar

A CBDC would essentially be a government-issued and -backed “digital dollar” that would be widely available to the general public.

Interest in CBDCs has grown alongside a wave of technological advances in private-sector financial products, including digital wallets, mobile payment apps, and new digital assets such as cryptocurrencies and stablecoins.

The Fed believes a CBDC could have many potential benefits, including: giving U.S. citizens a convenient, electronic form of central bank money, while also supporting faster, cheaper payments and expanding consumer access to the financial system.

But along with those benefits, others argue a CBDC poses issues of autonomy and control. It could essentially create a direct line from the central bank to individual people, meaning that the federal government could have the ability to track every transaction going into and coming out of people’s accounts. A CBDC could also be programmable with built-in rules, meaning that the government could impose restrictions on the use of the money.

That being said, the Fed does address those privacy concerns on its site, stating that “any CBDC would need to strike an appropriate balance between safeguarding the privacy rights of consumers and affording the transparency necessary to deter criminal activity.” And the central bank indicated that any potential CBDC should be intermediated, meaning that accounts or digital wallets would be offered and managed through the private sector using their existing privacy and identity-management frameworks.

That the Fed is seriously considering the pros and cons of issuing digital cash to U.S. citizens should come as no surprise, as the move was encouraged by President Joe Biden back in March 2022 in an executive order.

What’s got Davidson riled up

The Fed says it “has made no decision on issuing a central bank digital currency and would only proceed with issuing a CBDC with an authorizing law.”

However, it appears the bank is moving ahead with some planning as Davidson’s social media tirade included a preview of a job posting on Indeed for a “Senior Crypto Architect – CBDC” position with the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco.

The job description said the Fed “seeks a technologist to perform central bank digital currency research and development” and to “ensure the Federal Reserve is well-positioned to design, develop and implement technology to support a CBDC as may be required by the Board of Governors.”

But Davidson believes this level of investment — and the Fed’s quest to build a “team on the leading edge of technology research into central bank digital currency,” as stated in the job posting — is a sign of what’s to come and he’s adamant that a CBDC wouldn’t be in the best interests of U.S. citizens.

A crusade against CBDCs

Many critics of CBDCs share the same concerns about privacy, a lack of anonymity, increased surveillance, patchy monetary policies and the potential elimination of cash.

Speaking at a recent World Economic Forum event held in China, economist Eswar Prasad discussed the “programmability” of CBDCs.

“You could have […] a potentially better — or some people might say a darker world — where the government decides that units of central bank money can be used to purchase some things, but not other things that it deems less desirable like, say, ammunition or drugs or pornography,” he said. “And that is very powerful in terms of the use of a CBDC, and I think also extremely dangerous to central banks.”

Davidson described CBDCs on X as “an Orwellian-style payment system that has no place in our government” — and he’s not the only dissenting voice in Congress.

In March, Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas introduced a bil that would prohibit the Fed from developing a direct-to-consumer CBDC and ensure that “big government doesn’t attempt to centralize or control cryptocurrency.”

Bill co-sponsor Sen. Chuck Grassley of Iowa said: “The American people ought to be able to spend their money how they choose without the possibility that every transaction could be tracked by the government. Policy this impactful should be made by Congress, not government bureaucrats, and our bill would ensure that no one is snooping on the finances of hardworking Americans.”

Several states, such as Florida and North Carolina, have already passed anti-CBDC laws to restrict their use.

What to read next

  • The US dollar has lost 98% of its purchasing power since 1971 — invest in this stable asset before you lose your retirement fund
  • How can I stop the pain and make money in this nightmarish market? Here’s 1 simple way you can protect your nest egg
  • Jeff Bezos and Oprah Winfrey invest in this asset to keep their wealth safe — you may want to do the same in 2023

This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.

News Related


Pope Francis appoints 21 new cardinals as he moves to cement his legacy and reform the church

Among the new cardinals is the new head of the Vatican’s doctrine office, Victor Manuel Fernandez, and Robert Prevost, a Chicago-born missionary now responsible for vetting bishop candidates around the globe Read more »

Texas: Couple arrested under Big Cat Act on suspicion of selling margay and attempting to sell jaguar cub

Rafael Gutierrez-Galvan, 29, and his wife Deyanira Garza, 28, could face up to five years in federal prison and a possible $20,000 fine if they are found guilty of trying to sell the exotic animals. Read more »

Las Vegas Sheriff emotionally announces Tupac arrest

He praised the work of their homicide section and appeared to become emotional when he talked about how long the rapper’s family had waited for answers. Read more »

Rockets, Astros acquire regional network from Warner Bros. Discovery

Houston Astros Houston has a new regional sports network… sort of. The NBA’s Rockets and the defending World Series champion Astros officially acquired the assets of AT&T SportsNet Southwest from ... Read more »

Gold and silver prices on September 30: Check latest rates in your city

Today Gold Price, Silver Price: The price of gold registered a drop on Saturday. The rate for 22-carat gold stood firm at ₹5,853 per gram, easing ₹27. The larger quantities, ... Read more »

83% of Warren Buffett's $347 Billion Portfolio Is Invested in Only 8 Stocks

When it comes to making money on Wall Street, Berkshire Hathaway (NYSE: BRK.A)(NYSE: BRK.B) CEO Warren Buffett is, arguably, in a class of his own. In the 58 years that ... Read more »

Jose Urquidy Dominant in Spot Start, Astros' 2-1 Win Over Diamondbacks

Jose Urquidy had not made a start in over a month, but his number was called upon Friday night. With his team’s playoff hopes on the line, Urquidy led the ... Read more »

UAW expands strike against Ford, General Motors

UAW expands strike against Ford, General Motors The United Auto Workers union is widening its historic strike against Ford and General Motors, UAW president Shawn Fain announced Friday. Driving the ... Read more »

When will we know if the government is shutting down?

When will we know if the government is shutting down? (NEXSTAR) – Lawmakers still have time – but not much – to avoid a government shutdown. The deadline is fast ... Read more »

World Of Warcraft: Best Transmog Sets For Mages

World Of Warcraft: Best Transmog Sets For Mages The transmog system in World of Warcraft allows players to customize their Mage’s appearance with a wide variety of armor sets, offering ... Read more »

Air India Express Receives First Boeing 737 MAX 8s

Air India Express Receives First Boeing 737 MAX 8s Air India Express receives its first two Boeing 737 MAX 8 aircraft, marking the beginning of deliveries from a massive order ... Read more »

Romania suspects violation of its airspace during Russian attack on Ukraine

©GALATI IN ROMANIA. PHOTO: GOOGLE MAPS Romania is investigating possible violations of its airspace during Russia’s attack on Ukraine’s Danube ports on the night of 29-30 September. Source: European Pravda, ... Read more »

Employee Feels Passed Over and Stuck in a Rut at Work

Jeanne Phillips, Dear Abby DEAR ABBY: I applied to be a supervisor at the company where I work. Unfortunately, I didn’t get the job. One of my co-workers, who held ... Read more »

Climate extremists are afraid to debate. Maybe they should be

For billions of human beings on the planet earth, the “Just Stop Oil” and “Just Stop Fossil Fuels” movements really do equate to: just stop life. No matter what the ... Read more »

Yes, student loan payments will continue during a government shutdown

Yes, student loan payments will continue during a government shutdown A federal government shutdown will interrupt an array of services, but not the collection of student loans, the Education Department ... Read more »

Will Social Security Checks Be Held if the Federal Government Shuts Down? What to Know

James Martin/CNET A government shutdown could happen this week unless lawmakers can come to an agreement by Sept. 30 — that’s when the federal fiscal year ends and funding runs out. With ... Read more »

Student Loan Payments Have Begun Again and There Are Some Big Changes

Women looking at paper work We have all spent the last couple of years riding waves of hope and disappointment as the saga of student debt cancellation unfolded. Last summer, ... Read more »

No. 10 Utah struggles on offense again in 21-7 loss to No. 19 Oregon State

No. 19 Oregon State rebounded from a loss to Washington State with a convincing win over Utah on Friday night. (AP Photo/Amanda Loman) No. 10 Utah’s offense had another dreadful ... Read more »

Ukraine-Russia war latest: Ukraine closes in on Donetsk airport

Ukrainian military chaplain Ivan prays with infantry soldiers on the frontline near Donetsk on September 9, 2023 – Pierre Crom/Getty Images Europe Ukraine has come within a couple of miles ... Read more »

50 Parting Thoughts From the U.S. Open 2023

Nature abhors a vacuum. So does tennis. This marked the first U.S. Open without Roger Federer and Serena Williams and, great as they were, the sport persisted just fine. Coco ... Read more »

Joakim Noah officiated Derrick Rose’s wedding in touching moment

Call it a Chicago reunion. Joakim Noah and Derrick Rose reunited Thursday for Rose’s wedding, and just like during their respective NBA careers, Noah played an important supporting role — ... Read more »

Elon Musk has his demons. Walter Isaacson does his best to dissect them.

Elon Musk has his demons. Walter Isaacson does his best to dissect them. If you were trying to reverse-engineer from Elon Musk’s life a blueprint for creating the sort of ... Read more »

How to donate to earthquake survivors in Morocco

How to donate to earthquake survivors in Morocco More than 2,100 people have been killed and more than 2,400 injured in the earthquake that struck Morocco on Friday evening. As ... Read more »

Ukraine live briefing: Two foreign aid volunteers dead in Donetsk; German official arrives in Kyiv

The volunteer aid workers killed in Ukraine’s Donetsk region have been identified as 32-year-old Spanish national Emma Igual and Canadian national Anthony “Tonko” Ihnat, according to the Spanish government and ... Read more »

The Promotion Paradox: Are Americans Climbing off the Corporate Ladder?

The Promotion Paradox: Are Americans Climbing off the Corporate Ladder? Promotion Paradox Employers typically issue promotions as a way to recognize employees on consistent hard work and encourage them to ... Read more »

The frontrunners for the 2024 Republican nomination

The frontrunners for the 2024 Republican nomination Former President Donald Trump announced in November that he was seeking the Republican nomination for the presidential elections in 2024. Trump served one ... Read more »

Rugby World Cup 2023: Results, fixtures, schedule in full, how to watch, kick-off times, venues and odds

walesrugbyworldcup11092023a.jpg The Rugby World Cup is in full swing with England making an impressive start to life in Pool D over the weekend. Steve Borthwick’s side looked on course for ... Read more »

Luis Rubiales resigns as Spanish soccer president following unwanted kiss with World Cup winner Jennifer Hermoso

Luis Rubiales on Sunday resigned from his position as president of the Spanish soccer federation following weeks of fierce criticism over his unwanted kiss with Women’s World Cup winner Jennifer ... Read more »

11 Things That The US Should Seriously Adopt From Other Countries, According To A World Traveler

I love the US, but after living abroad in four different countries and traveling to more than 50, I have to say there are certain areas where this great country ... Read more »

U.S. News Releases ‘Best Countries’ Rankings — See What Tops The List

Oleksiy Mark / Shutterstock.com When you’re planning a trip, it helps to know what you can expect when visiting your destination. Finding that in-depth information, however, can be challenging. Fortunately, ... Read more »
Top List in the World