Filibuster meaning: What Biden's new stance could mean for how US democracy works

Asia's Tech News Daily

Filibuster meaning: What Biden’s new stance could mean for how US democracy works
© Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved


– Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved

For the first time since he became president with a 50-50 Democratic majority in the Senate, President Joe Biden is expressing a willingness to support altering a centuries-old Senate rule that Republicans have been using to stymie his legislative programme.

Mr Biden was speaking at a CNN town hall in Baltimore, Maryland when moderator Anderson Cooper asked him why he opposed changes to Senate rules governing the filibuster — a parliamentary practice which, in theory, allows for unlimited debate on legislation.

Because 60 senators’ votes are needed to end debate and allow a vote on a given bill, Republicans have in recent years weaponised the practice to prevent nearly all legislation supported by Democrats from being put to an up-or-down vote on the Senate floor.

The president, who represented Delaware in the upper chamber for more than three decades, initially told Cooper that he would support a return to the rules as they existed before 1970, which required all Senate business to stop while a filibustering senator held the floor and spoke for as long as he or she – or their colleagues – could stand. He also suggested that senators carve out an exception to prevent filibusters from blocking specific types of legislation, such as bills to increase the federal debt ceiling.

What would a return to the ‘talking filibuster’ mean?

Under the pre-1970 rules, a filibustering senator could block a bill from passing by prolonging debate endlessly. This mean that as long as the senator or their colleagues could stand and speak, they could gum up the works of legislation by talking, and talking, and talking.

It’s a tactic that was immortalised in Frank Capra’s 1939 film Mr Smith Goes to Washington when the title character played by Jimmy Stewart speaks for 25 hours to defend himself against false allegations of graft.

But while Mr Stewart’s fictional senator Jefferson Smith used the filibuster for good, perhaps its most infamous use was in service of the de jure system of racial segregation that permeated the American south for most of the 20th century, when South Carolina Senator Strom Thurmond held the Senate floor from 8.54pm on 28 August 1957 to 9.12pm the next day to block passage of the 1957 Civil Rights Act.

Mr Thurmond, who ultimately failed to block the bill, also joined with his southern colleagues to attempt to stop passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. Together, they held the floor for 60 days until then-President Lyndon Johnson (a sponsor of the 1957 Act) marshalled enough support to end debate and pass the bill.

If the Senate were to return to the old “talking filibuster” rules, a Republican senator who wants to stop a Biden-backed piece of legislation (such as the Freedom to Vote Act that Republicans blocked earlier this week) could no longer stop the Senate from debating or voting on a bill by raising an objection to it. They would have to speak in opposition to the bill continuously if they want to stop the senate from considering it.

But the 60-vote threshold to end debate means GOP leader Mitch McConnell and his 49 colleagues could keep gumming up the works as long as they could keep 10 of their colleagues from defecting.

Some experts, including former senator Al Franken and scholar Norm Ornstein, have pushed for Democrats to change rules to set a 40-vote threshold to continue debate rather than 60 votes to end it. This would keep the onus on the minority to actively work to stop the Senate from voting.

What about a ‘carve-out’ to the filibuster?

But returning to the old ways of senators past might not cut it in the modern age.

Mr Biden alluded to this on Thursday when he said he thinks “we’re going to have to move to the point where we fundamentally alter the filibuster”.

“The idea that, for example, my Republican friends say that we’re going to default on the national debt because they’re going to filibuster that and we need 10 Republicans to support us is the most bizarre thing I ever heard,” he said.

Earlier this month, Senate Republicans used the tactic to block legislation suspending the nation’s statutory debt ceiling, risking a national debt default that experts say could spiral into a global economic catastrophe.

Although the GOP eventually allowed for a temporary increase to be signed into law, Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell has vowed to block any attempt to fix the problem that does not require Democrats to use a different — and equally arcane — parliamentary manoeuvre known as “reconciliation” to pass it.

Mr Biden said he thinks his allies in the Senate will reach a breaking point with the filibuster if Mr McConnell follows through on his threat.

“I think you’re going to see … if they — gets pulled again, I think you’ll see an awful lot of Democrats being ready to say, ‘Not me.  I’m not doing that again.  We’re going to end the filibuster’,” he said.

In such a case, the process would be simple, and would follow the so-called “nuclear option” previously used to reduce the number of senators needed to end debate on judicial and executive branch nominees to 51.

First, a senator — most likely Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer — would raise a parliamentary point of order that the threshold to end debate on a debt ceiling bill is by majority vote. Vice President Kamala Harris or the senator then presiding would, under current rules, not sustain the point of order.

Mr Schumer would then appeal the ruling, which would bring about a vote. If 51 senators vote to not uphold the ruling, the threshold for ending debate on a debt ceiling bill would then be a majority, rather than the current 60 votes.

What would this mean for Biden’s agenda — and democracy?

If Democrats go “nuclear” for debt ceiling bills, they could just as easily add other carve-outs for different kinds of legislation.

In theory, this would let them pass voting rights and so-called “democracy protection” legislation with just 51 votes, so long as they hold at least 50 seats under a Democratic vice president.

That’s why many House progressives who’ve been frustrated by the continuation of Mr McConnell’s “legislative graveyard” under a Democratic majority have pushed for Mr Schumer to invoke the “nuclear option” and end the filibuster.

And with Republican state legislatures advancing more and more restrictive voting and election laws, democracy advocates such as Mr Ornstein say that killing the filibuster is a must if Mr Biden wants to ensure that his legacy is strengthening democracy, not presiding over a slow march to authoritarianism under a second Trump administration.

Speaking to The Independent this past February, Mr Ornstein put it bluntly: “The single most significant element of keeping from having voter suppression become the norm is to get reforms for federal elections that guarantee the right to vote”.

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


What a former CDC director says about Omicron

With at least 16 states now reporting cases of the Omicron variant have been detected, there’s still much more we don’t know about the spread of the latest COVID-19 strain.  ... Read more »

Biden lanza nuevo plan anticorrupción con impacto a nivel mundial

© Anna Moneymaker El presidente Joe Biden refuerza sus acciones contra la corrupción. El presidente Joe Biden lanza este lunes una nueva estrategia contra la corrupción en los Estados Unidos, ... Read more »

Jewish couple kicked off American Airlines flight for refusing to put prayer shawl on floor

A Jewish couple who were kicked off an American Airlines flight for refusing to store their sacred prayer shawl on the floor have filed a lawsuit against the airline. © ... Read more »

Next season starts now for the Giants and the Jets

Photos: Getty Images (3); AP Getty Images (3); AP Sign up here to get Beyond the Back Page delivered to your inbox each morning. It ended appropriately, with more urgency ... Read more »

I'm remortgaging but might move, should I fix for two years or five?

© Provided by This Is Money MailOnline logo My mortgage fixed term is coming to an end, and I am looking to remortgage.  Given the low rates currently available, fixing ... Read more »

China Evergrande shares hit record low as it edges closer to default

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Aly Song/Reuters Shares in the struggling Chinese property developer Evergrande hit a record low on Monday after strong indications that it is on the ... Read more »

Putin heads to India with eye on military, energy ties

© – Russian President Vladimir Putin’s visit to India will be only his second trip abroad since the coronavirus pandemic began Russian President Vladimir Putin arrived in India on Monday ... Read more »

Three charged after £500,000 drugs seized in raid

© PA Archive Mock-up picture of cocaine. – PA Archive Police have seized cocaine and heroin with an estimated street value of £500,000. Officers with a warrant raided a property ... Read more »

Billionaire investor Ray Dalio says his comments on China's disappearances were misunderstood – after he said Beijing was being a 'strict parent'

© Eoin Noonan/Web Summit via Getty Images Ray Dalio has raised $1.3 billion for a private fund in China, according to Bloomberg. Eoin Noonan/Web Summit via Getty Images Ray Dalio ... Read more »

EV maker Lucid gets SEC subpoena on $24-billion blank-check deal

© Reuters/ANDREW KELLY Lucid Motors (Nasdaq: LCID) begins trading today on the Nasdaq stock exchange in New York City (Reuters) -The U.S. securities regulator has asked Lucid Group Inc for ... Read more »

I'm A Celeb's Arlene Phillips reveals details of castle evacuation when she had roots done

What happened to the I’m A Celebrity… Get Me Out Of Here! campmates during the ITV show’s three-day cancellation due to the havoc caused by Storm Arwen has mostly remained ... Read more »

EU and Nato ‘believe Russia is preparing to invade Ukraine'

© Sat Img ©2021 Maxar via REUTERS A satellite image of Russian military deployments in Crimea, close to the border with Ukraine – Sat Img ©2021 Maxar via REUTERS Intelligence ... Read more »

Don't look at my teeth! Pregnant Jennifer Lawrence's dental challenge on movie set

© Getty Images Netflix’s “Don’t Look Up” World Premiere 06122021 Jennifer Lawrence says she had to film most of her latest movie toothless after losing a veneer during filming. The ... Read more »

Adam Driver's 'exhausting' Burberry Hero shoot

© Provided by BANG Showbiz Adam Driver’s ‘exhausting’ Burberry hero shoot Adam Driver found it “exhausting” trying to “mirror” a horse’s “physicality” for the Burberry Hero campaign. The ‘House of ... Read more »

A Shake Shack manager who makes over $100,000 a year describes her daily schedule and says supply issues are her biggest challenge

© Provided by Business Insider Angela Campbell/Shake Shack Angela Campbell is a General Manager at a Las Vegas Shake Shack. She is responsible for keeping her store staffed and ready ... Read more »

Omicron: Curve of COVID cases driven by new variant 'much steeper' than previous waves, professor warns

South Africa is preparing its hospitals for more admissions as the Omicron variant pushes the country into its fourth COVID-19 wave, with the strain now accounting for the majority of new infections, President Cyril Ramaphosa said. Read more »

World's oldest giraffe dies aged 31 after having 14 babies at Aussie zoo

THE world's oldest giraffe has died at an Australian zoo aged 31. Taronga Western Plains Zoo in New South Wales announced the devastating news on Friday just weeks after Mutangi ... Read more »

Woman shares simple item she found in her boyfriend's car which has her convinced he's cheating

NOTHING'S as heartbreaking as finding out your loved one, the one you thought would stay loyal, turns out to be something you never thought he would. Unfortunately, some cheaters are ... Read more »

Warning for millions of Apple fans NOT to buy new iPhone model

A TIKTOKER has highlighted why shoppers should think twice before buying the latest iPhone this Christmas. In a recent video, Kevin Hirschberg explained why he thinks splashing out on an ... Read more »

Probe opened into fights at French election campaign rally

The Associated PressFrench far right presidential candidate Eric Zemmour delivers his speech during his first rally, Sunday, Dec. 5, 2021 in Villepinte, north of Paris. Far-right former French TV pundit ... Read more »

Japan has 3rd omicron case as Kishida vows strict response

TOKYO — Japan confirmed on Monday its third case of the new omicron variant — a traveler entering from Italy — as Prime Minister Fumio Kishida vowed to take strict ... Read more »

Nepal starts census of endangered Royal Bengal tigers

© Prakash MATHEMA A Royal Bengal tiger walks in its enclosure at a zoo in Lalitpur, on the outskirts of Kathmandu Nepal started counting endangered Royal Bengal tigers in its ... Read more »

Olympics-Swedish goaltender Lehner to skip Beijing Games due to mental health issues

(Reuters) – Swedish goaltender Robin Lehner will skip next year’s Winter Olympics in Beijing after the 30-year-old said on Monday that his participation would not be ideal for his mental ... Read more »

'Dominant', 'Would be ideal...' - Luke Hatfield drops key Wolves January transfer verdict

Wolves need to bring in both a centre-back and a midfielder in the January transfer window, according to journalist Luke Hatfield. © Provided by Transfer Tavern Bruno Lage Wolves The ... Read more »

Transgender swimmer smashes women's records while competing for University of Pennsylvania

Transgender swimmer Lia Thomas smashed a number of women’s records for the University of Pennsylvania last month. © GiveMeSport Transgender swimmer Lia Thomas smashed a number of women’s records for ... Read more » CEO fires 900 employees on Zoom call, accuses them of ‘stealing' CEO Vishal Garg reportedly fired the 900 people during a zoom call. The chief executive of New York-based online mortgage lender laid off some 900 employees during a ... Read more »

Elly Mattiuzzo dead at 18: Tributes paid to figure skating star after dying in horror car crash alongside boyfriend

FIGURE SKATER Elly Mattiuzzo has tragically died aged 18 following a horror car crash with her boyfriend. According to Gazzetta dello Sport the couple were driving a Fiat 500 on ... Read more »

Gender pay gap has barely changed if gains in women's educational attainments are excluded, IFS says

The pay gap between men and women has barely changed in 25 years if the gains in women’s educational attainments are excluded, according to the IFS – PA The gender ... Read more »

MPPSC exam calendar 2021-22: Tentative schedule out for recruitment exams at

© Provided by Firstpost MPPSC exam calendar 2021-22: Tentative schedule out for recruitment exams at The examination calendar for recruitment to various posts for the year 2021-2022 has been ... Read more »

‘It takes great courage to write that way': David Eldridge on Robert Holman

Photograph: Sarah Lee/The Guardian In Robert Holman’s play Jonah and Otto, Otto says: “I think we learn to love, by loving, by listening to another person. Love is paying attention.” ... Read more »

Indian math genius Nikhil Srivastava just solved a 62-year-old problem and won a top US prize

Say you have been facing a maths problem for a very long time and neither you nor your colleagues have been able to solve it so far. Many years after the problem, a computer ... Read more »

'Unang Hirit' hosts share their motivation to wake up early for the past 22 years

Photos: Unang Hirit/IG “Unang Hirit” hosts shared what has been motivating them to wake up early in the morning to serve the people for the past 22 years as they ... Read more »

Rabiya Mateo retraces the biggest lesson from her "emotionally devastating" Miss Universe loss

© Provided by “I used to be a people pleaser talaga. That was my downfall when I was competing for Miss Universe.”  Ito ang pag-amin ni Rabiya Mateo tungkol ... Read more »

Cyclone Jawad-triggered heavy rainfall leads to waterlogged streets in Kolkata

© Provided by Zee News Kolkata: Normal life was partially disrupted in parts of Bengal on Monday as heavy rain triggered by Cyclone ‘Jawad’ left several areas waterlogged in the ... Read more »

Become a PayMaya Verified Seller now and let your customers know you're legit!

Online shopping has definitely become more popular in the Philippines, but online scams – from fake sellers to bogus buyers – are ruining the experience for many Filipinos. © Provided ... Read more »

PM Modi lauds Jai Ram govt for 100 per cent Covid vaccination

© Provided by The Statesman PM Modi lauds Jai Ram govt for 100 per cent Covid vaccination Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Monday lauded Chief Minister Jai Ram Thakur led ... Read more »

Monday Musings: The many challenges facing Pune city's Metro project

© Provided by Hindustan Times There have been inordinate delays in bringing the Metro project to Pune. While the major share of the blame does go to the Congress-NCP for ... Read more »

CII, HP edu regulatory body inks pact for industry-academia collaboration

© Provided by The Statesman CII, HP edu regulatory body inks pact for industry-academia collaboration The Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) and Himachal Pradesh Private Educational Institution Regulatory Commission (HP-PERC) ... Read more »

Big-Bobber von Meister Takamine - Indian Chief von Brat Style

Go Takamine hat als Customizer seinen eigenen, weltbekannten Stil geprägt: Brat Style. Für Indian eine Super Chief zum Minimal-Bobber um. © Indian Motorcycles Der Kotflügel hinten stammt von einem 1937er-Ford. ... Read more »

Covid: People with cold-like symptoms should WFH and avoid Christmas parties, says expert

© REUTERS People walk past a Selfridge’s store on Oxford Street, amid the COVID-19 outbreak in London People with cold-like symptoms should work from home and avoid Christmas parties to ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic