Fikile Mbalula demands R2-million from GroundUp reporters over luxury home story

The minister accuses us of defamation but neglects to point out any factual errors in our article.

Fikile Mbalula demands R2-million from GroundUp reporters over luxury home story
© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved

Minister of Transport Fikile Mbalula is demanding an apology and R2-million from GroundUp’s reporters Raymond Joseph and Masego Mafata and from Daily Maverick. This follows the publication last Monday of our article The minister, the Lottery boss and the luxury R5.6-million home by Daily Maverick.

The letter of demand from Mbalula’s lawyers, BBMLaw, claims that allegations in our article are wrongful and defamatory. Yet it does not point out any factual errors in the article.

The article describes the strange circumstances in which a house in Bryanston, Johannesburg, was purchased.

The letter claims that Daily Maverick readers will understand the article to mean that (1) Mbalula was associated with Solly Siweya (a businessman) and Phillemon Letwaba (the suspended National Lotteries Commission chief operating officer), (2) he had financial interests with them in relation to the house that is the subject of the story, and (3) he was the “benefactor or influenced questionable lottery grants”.

In fact, the article states: “We have seen no evidence of wrongdoing by the minister. But the circumstances of his involvement and the conduct of his associates do raise troubling questions.”

The letter states that if the demands are not met within five days, “we are instructed to institute the necessary legal proceedings to enforce our client’s rights”.

GroundUp’s lawyer has responded stating that the article was based on documents we obtained, matters of public record such as a Public Protector report, interviews with witnesses and responses provided by people who agreed to provide answers, including Mbalula, whose response was published in full.

“The curious involvement of [Mbalula and his wife’s] offer and sudden disappearance from the scene, are matters of the public interest, and relevant in the context of an article that dealt with Upbrand’s acquisition of the property shortly after [Mbalula’s] offer,” our lawyer’s letter states.

It also states that the facts that a company closely related to Letwaba and a charity that received lottery funding were involved in the sale process are matters of public interest.

“The article does not make any allegation that your client is in any other way associated with persons who are mentioned in the article, other than as referred to in the article. The article specifically does not allege that your client … was in any way involved in the business ventures of Messrs Letwaba and Siweya; was in any way financially associated with Messrs Letwaba and Siweya; or benefitted from or influenced questionable lottery grants.”

GroundUp stands by the article. We will not be apologising to Minister Mbalula, or paying him anything. We will defend any legal action taken against our journalists or us. Daily Maverick editors have informed us they will take the same position. 

DM

First published by GroundUp.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

2 busted in fatal shooting of Staten Island man during home invasion: cops

The fatal incident occurred at Shaarawy’s Arden Heights home, above, on Dec. 16. white Two people have been busted in connection to the shooting death of a Staten Island man ... Read more »

West African regional bloc suspends Burkina Faso's membership over coup

© Olympia de Maismont, AFP West Africa’s main regional bloc on Friday suspended Burkina Faso from its governing bodies in response to this week’s military coup and decided to send ... Read more »

Legal status for British Sign Language a step closer after Commons backing

A proposal to give British Sign Language (BSL) legal recognition and enhance its use in public services has been backed in the Commons The measures are included in a Private ... Read more »

'Also...' - Reliable reporter reveals Liverpool now chasing 'fantastic' star as well as Diaz

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Fabio Carvalho vs Millwall Liverpool could still sign Fulham youngster Fabio Carvalho in January after they bring in Luis Diaz, according to journalist Graeme Bailey. ... Read more »

Shamima Begum could return to the UK after court victory

© ITV ShamimaBegum150921 A landmark court ruling may clear the way for Shamima Begum to return to the UK. The 22-year-old’s chances of returning home have improved by the court ... Read more »

More people trust Labour than Tories on tax level in Britain

© PA Wire G20 summit Labour has opened up a 10-point lead over the Conservatives on setting the right level of taxation ahead of April’s National Insurance hike, a new ... Read more »

Kate found 'her calling' ahead of next major step in royal life

Kate‘s journey within the Royal Family is still evolving, as she is destined to take on two crucial roles, of Princess of Wales first and Queen Consort later, in the ... Read more »

Rare portrait of Diana, Princess of Wales, sells for more than $200,000

Late artist Nelson Shanks’ portrait of Princess Diana sold for 10 times its high estimate, according to auction house Sotheby's. Read more »

Blocking the Sun's rays too risky to consider as climate change solution

Scientists from around the world are calling for global leaders to ban the development of technologies that would cool Earth’s climate by dimming the Sun’s rays. Such programs, they say, ... Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: What's in store for newlyweds Mouni Roy, Suraj Nambiar? Celebrity astrologer & face reader REVEALS

© Provided by Pinkvilla Mouni Roy and Suraj Nambiar made things official as they got married yesterday on the 27th of January in Goa. From the photos and videos that ... Read more »

WATCH: Shehnaaz Gill's heartwarming tribute for late actor Sidharth Shukla at Bigg Boss 15 Grand Finale

© Provided by Pinkvilla Bigg Boss 15 is coming to an end. The show has kept its audience entertained throughout the season. However, to make the show more interesting the ... Read more »

Pelajar UniSZA kumpul sampah 1 tan di pantai Seberang Takir

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Menurut Anuar, mereka terlibat dalam program ini terdiri 37 pelajar antarabangsa dari pelbagai negara seperti Syria, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Nigeria dan Indonesia. PETALING JAYA: Sebanyak ... Read more »

MUDA sah bertanding PRN Johor

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today PETALING JAYA: MUDA secara rasminya akan bertanding pada pilihan raya negeri (PRN) Johor akan datang. Parti itu dalam kenyataan di Twitter memaklumkan, PRN Johor ... Read more »

Krystle D'souza's home: Inside the lavish and elegant abode of the actress

© Provided by Pinkvilla The popular television and movies actress Krystle D’souza enjoys a massive fan following on social media. She came to the limelight with her show Ek Hazaaron ... Read more »

Nakuul Mehta's wife Jankee shares a video as they complete 10 years of wedding; Calls it 'A decade of love'

© Provided by Pinkvilla Nakuul Mehta and Jankee Parekh are among the most adorable couples in the television industry. They were blessed with a baby boy last year, whom they ... Read more »

Sara Ali Khan takes over Kashmir with brother Ibrahim; Here's how they had fun in winter wonderland; PICS

© Provided by Pinkvilla After wrapping up her recent film with Vicky Kaushal in Indore, Sara Ali Khan has now joined her brother Ibrahim Ali Khan in the beautiful and ... Read more »

Automaker Stellantis to suspend COVID-19 vaccine mandate for U.S. staff

© Reuters/PASCAL ROSSIGNOL FILE PHOTO: FILE PHOTO: The logo of Stellantis is seen in this image provided on November 9, 2020. (Reuters) – Automaker Stellantis NV said it would suspend ... Read more »

Ananya Panday says she wants a lover like Shah Rukh Khan

© Provided by Pinkvilla Ananya Panday these days has been grabbing all the limelight and making it to the headlines ever since her film ‘Gehraiyaan’s’ first look has released. After ... Read more »

Liverpool man jailed for posting heroin to island

© BBC Matthew Henwood was arrested as part of a joint operation between Manx and UK authorities A Liverpool man who tried to “infiltrate” the Isle of Man with “vast ... Read more »

Apple rallies 3% after smashing revenue forecasts and teasing metaverse plans

© Karl Mondon/Digital First Media/The Mercury News via Getty Images Tim Cook has been CEO of Apple since 2011. Karl Mondon/Digital First Media/The Mercury News via Getty Images Apple’s stock ... Read more »

Ukraine-Russia tensions: 'Fully-fledged' Russian invasion could include cyber attacks and a coup, NATO warns

The Kremlin is thought to be mobilising infantry and artillery units in southwestern Russia, alongside war planes in Kaliningrad on the Baltic Sea and warships in the Black Sea and Arctic. Read more »

One year after the GameStop frenzy, Robinhood hits a new low because people just aren't trading stocks as much anymore

© Brendan McDermid/Reuters Robinhood CEO Vlad Tenev at Nasdaq for the company’s stock trading debut. Brendan McDermid/Reuters Robinhood shares sank 15% on Friday following the release of Q4 financial results.  ... Read more »

Chelsea system change brought out best in Hakim Ziyech - so will Thomas Tuchel stick with it?

Will Hakim Ziyech’s wonder goal against Tottenham be enough to convince Thomas Tuchel to fully unleash the Chelsea winger? Watching his picture-perfect strike to set up Sunday’s 2-0 win, it ... Read more »

Arsenal face 'last resort' in striker transfer search after Dusan Vlahovic 'smokescreen'

Arsenal are struggling to sign a striker before the transfer deadline on January 31. The Gunners are on the hunt for a new talisman after Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang was stripped of ... Read more »

Max Eberls emotionaler Rücktritt

© KEYSTONE/DPA/UWE ANSPACH Max Eberl (48) hört beim kriselnden Bundesligisten Borussia Mönchengladbach aus gesundheitlichen Gründen als Sportdirektor auf. Das teilten der Verein und der 48-jährige Eberle, der den Posten seit ... Read more »

Putin fordert im Gespräch mit Macron Sicherheitsgarantien für Moskau

© Keystone/Pool Sputnik Kremlin/AP/Alexei Nikolsky Der russische Präsident Wladimir Putin hat im Gespräch mit seinem französischen Kollegen Emmanuel Macron Moskaus Forderungen nach verbindlichen Garantien für die Sicherheit in Europa bekräftigt. ... Read more »

Unglück in US-Stadt Pittsburgh: Schneebedeckte Brücke bricht zusammen

Vor dem Besuch von US-Präsident Joe Biden (79) in Pittsburgh ist in der US-Metropole am Freitagmorgen eine schneebedeckte Brücke mit einer wichtigen Verkehrsverbindung eingestürzt. Es könnte einige verletzte Personen geben. ... Read more »

Haben ihm Verletzungen und Corona so zugesetzt?: Schmächtiger Gareth Bale schockt Real-Fans

© Bereitgestellt von Blick Schmächtiger Gareth Bale schockt Real-Fans Im Training von Real Madrid zieht Gareth Bale derzeit viele Blicke auf sich. Allerdings nicht so, wie sich das der 32-jährige ... Read more »

Corona-Impfungen in Apotheken in Deutschland ab 8. Februar

© Keystone/dpa/David Inderlied In Deutschland können Apotheken vom 8. Februar an landesweit Corona-Impfungen anbieten. Damit soll das Impfangebot vereinfacht und verbreitert werden. Die Voraussetzungen dafür seien jetzt geschaffen, sagte Gabriele ... Read more »

Coimbatore: Man arrested for stealing jewellery; police recover gold ornaments

Coimbatore: Man arrested for stealing jewellery; police recover stolen gold ornaments A 27-year-old man was arrested for reportedly stealing 20 sovereigns of jewellery from the house of an engineer in ... Read more »

Son, 32, and dad, 59, murdered businessman after running him over in row over £40,000 at Iceland car park

A DAD and son mowed down and killed a businessman in an Iceland car park in a row over £40,000. John Avers, 47, was heard screaming as Bobby Ternent, 32, ... Read more »

Coronavirus cases top 74,000 in a day but true figure is still unclear

Positive coronavirus test. Photo: DutchNews.nl A total of 74,085 new positive coronavirus tests were reported to public health institute RIVM in the 24 hours to Friday morning, but the true ... Read more »

Putin says West ignoring Russia's security concerns

© – Ukraine has been test-firing anti-tank missiles delivered by the British amid tensions with Moscow President Vladimir Putin told French counterpart Emmanuel Macron on Friday that the West was ... Read more »

Google to invest $1 billion in Bharti Airtel; partners to accelerate growth of India's digital ecosystem

© Provided by Zee Business Bharti Airtel, India’s communications solutions providers, and Google on Friday announced that they will partner on a long-term, multi-year agreement to accelerate the growth of ... Read more »

What the Post Wanted team has been loving this January

New York Post Composite Listen up, Post Wanted readers. It’s time for our editors’ picks — the good, the great and the otherwise outstanding products we need to share. We ... Read more »

Mumbai: Death Toll in Tardeo's Kamala Building Fire Rises to Nine, Five Critical

© Provided by News18 Mumbai: Death Toll in Tardeo’s Kamala Building Fire Rises to Nine, Five Critical The death toll due to a massive fire on the 18th floor of ... Read more »

Budget 2022: Lawyers seek tax benefits, push for legal reforms

© Moneycontrol Budget 2022: Lawyers seek tax benefits, push for legal reforms There’s been a paradigm shift in the way lawyers and the justice delivery system have functioned over the ... Read more »

After Amit Shah's meet in Delhi, BJP takes khap route to win over Jats

© Provided by The Times of India LUCKNOW: Even as Union home minister and BJP’s chief strategist Amit Shah hit the alleyways of communally restive Kairana and then Hindutva nerve ... Read more »

NBA bettors must act early in day to maximize value

Periodically in Bet Smart, Action Network’s NBA expert will explain some of his favorite betting strategies. Today, the need to act early. One of the best ways to gain an ... Read more »

Delhi Metro to operate as per usual routine; entry/exit restricted on THESE station due to Beating Retreat

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran News Desk: Delhi Metro will resume its services on weekends as per usual routine starting Saturday, January 29, 2022. The development ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic