FEC says Twitter acted legally in blocking Hunter Biden laptop stories, pointing to claim of intel warnings about hacking

The Federal Elections Commission said on Wednesday its members unanimously rejected complaints from the Republican National Committee and others that Twitter’s decision to block the sharing of links to articles from the New York Post related to Hunter Biden’s laptop constituted an illegal contribution to now-President Joe Biden’s candidacy.

© Provided by Washington Examiner

In announcing the decision, the FEC pointed to Twitter’s assertion that part of the reason it stopped the spread of the New York Post articles in October was over concerns that foreign actors obtained the salacious materials through hacking. The social media giant claimed the U.S. Intelligence Community was warning about such an effort in the lead-up to the 2020 election. No evidence has emerged that the Hunter Biden laptop story stemmed from a foreign hacking operation.

The FEC said there was a 6-0 vote in finding “no reason to believe” that Twitter violated the law “by making corporate in-kind contributions” and “no reason to believe” that Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey or Brandon Borrman, who was Twitter vice president of global communications, broke the law.

In response to reporting on the decision published on Monday, RNC spokeswoman Emma Vaughn said the group was “weighing its options for appealing this disappointing decision from the FEC.”

An October complaint from the RNC alleged: “Through its ad hoc, partisan oppression of media critical of Biden, [Twitter] is making illegal, corporate in-kind contributions as it provides unheard-of media services for Joe Biden’s campaign.” The RNC argued at the time that Twitter was “doing so for the clear purpose of supporting the Biden campaign.”

Robert Kelner, a lawyer who had represented retired Lt. Gen. Mike Flynn before Sidney Powell took over his representation, helped represent Twitter in the FEC complaint, writing in December that “Twitter undertook, for bona fide commercial reasons” actions to block potentially hacked content.

A lengthy statement from Yoel Roth, head of site integrity for Twitter, was included in Kelner’s response.

“Since 2018, I have had regular meetings with the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, the Department of Homeland Security, the FBI, and industry peers regarding election security,” Roth said. “During these weekly meetings, the federal law enforcement agencies communicated that they expected ‘hack-and-leak operations’ by state actors might occur in the period shortly before the 2020 presidential election, likely in October. I was told in these meetings that the intelligence community expected that individuals associated with political campaigns would be subject to hacking attacks and that material obtained through those hacking attacks would likely be disseminated over social media platforms, including Twitter… I also learned in these meetings that there were rumors that a hack-and-leak operation would involve Hunter Biden.”


Roth added: “The Site Integrity Team preliminarily determined that the information in the articles could have been obtained through hacking, based on, among other things, the type of material, the sourcing described in the articles, and the information security community’s initial reactions.”

The laptop was given to a computer shop in Delaware for repair in April 2019, according to John Paul Mac Isaac, the computer store’s legally blind owner, who said the hardware was never retrieved by the owner. The laptop and hard drive were reportedly seized by the FBI through a grand jury subpoena in December 2019. One copy of the hardware’s contents was obtained by Rudy Giuliani, then a personal lawyer to former President Donald Trump, and the data were shared with various media outlets.

Hunter Biden has never denied the authenticity of the computer materials that have since been published.

The New York Post reported emails showed evidence of a possible meeting between Hunter Biden , his father, who was the vice president at the time,  and Burisma Holdings adviser Vadym Pozharskyi, which the elder Biden denies took place as described in the reporting.

The newspaper also detailed Hunter Biden’s financial dealings with shady Chinese businessmen . Hunter Biden held a position on the board of Burisma, a Ukrainian gas company, from 2014 to 2019.

When the New York Post attempted to post the articles on its Twitter  account, the social media company claimed it violated its rule against sharing “hacked” materials. In fact, Twitter and Facebook limited users from sharing it for a time.

Pozharskyi sent Hunter Biden an email on April 17, 2015, saying, “Dear Hunter, thank you for inviting me to DC and giving an opportunity to meet your father and spent [sic] some time together.”

Biden’s presidential campaign denied the meeting took place based on “Biden’s official schedules from the time.”

Roth has a number of anti-Trump tweets from before he took his position with Twitter.

He tweeted in September 2016, “I’ve never donated to a presidential campaign before, but I just gave $100 to Hillary for America. We can’t f-ck around anymore.” He said in November that year that “we fly over those states that voted for a racist tangerine for a reason.” In January 2017, he said Trump won partly because of “racism.” That month he also claimed that there were “ACTUAL NAZIS IN THE WHITE HOUSE.”

The Trump War Room tweeted in 2020 that Roth “has a history of tweeting terrible and vile things that show he has a very bad case of Trump Derangement Syndrome (TDS)!”

Borrman’s LinkedIn states that he left Twitter in June to become an adviser for the Franklin Project, and offshoot of the anti-Trump Lincoln Project.

The FEC signaled that it believed Roth’s explanation with its “factual and legal analysis” in August claiming that Twitter “has credibly explained that it acted with a commercial motivation in response to the New York Post articles rather than with an electoral purpose.” The commission said “the actions taken by Twitter in response to the October 2020 New York Post articles, i.e., blocking users from tweeting hacked or personal information … appear to reflect bona fide commercial considerations rather than an effort to influence a federal election.”

The FEC wrote “federal law enforcement agencies apparently communicated to Twitter that they expected hack-and-leak operations by state actors might occur in the period shortly before the 2020 presidential election and warned that such a hack-and-leak operation might involve Hunter Biden” and “these circumstances appear to reflect a commercial, not electoral, basis for Twitter to have blocked users from sharing this information on its platform.”

Despite offering no proof, Joe Biden’s 2020 campaign and many in the media dismissed the October laptop story as part of a Russian disinformation operation. However, then-Director of National Intelligence John Ratcliffe “there is no intelligence” indicating the laptop was part of a Russian disinformation effort. A senior intelligence official told the Washington Examiner that “the IC and DOJ are in lock-step on this: there is absolutely zero evidence or intel that the laptop or the information contained therein is a Russian op.”

Concerns about Hunter Biden gained broader attention in late 2020 after confirming he was under federal investigation. Multiple outlets reported he is being federally investigated in connection with his taxes and potentially related to his overseas business with China and other countries.

Joe Biden’s son went on a media blitz this year to promote his memoir , Beautiful Things, during which he admitted the laptop could be his. However, he said he doesn’t remember and that it could have been stolen, he could have been hacked, or Russian intelligence could have been involved, without providing any evidence. A forensic analysis of the laptop’s emails reportedly concluded that “no evidence was found to suggest that the timestamps or data were altered or manufactured.”

The day after Twitter blocked the New York Post’s mid-October stories on Hunter Biden, Dorsey tweeted, “Straight blocking of URLs was wrong, and we updated our policy and enforcement to fix.”

Dorsey testified  about the controversy before the Senate Judiciary Committee in November after Biden defeated Trump.

“We made a quick interpretation, using no other evidence, that the materials in the article were obtained through hacking, and, according to our policy, we blocked them from being spread,” Dorsey said. “Upon further consideration, we admitted this action was wrong and corrected it within 24 hours.”


The 50 former intelligence officials who signed a letter suggesting Russia was involved with the Hunter Biden laptop matter are now largely silent about why they weighed in on the story weeks before the 2020 presidential election. During a presidential debate, Joe Biden dismissed the laptop emails as part of a “Russian plan” and cited the letter.

Hunter Biden also falsely claimed the intelligence community publicly concluded that stories involving his laptop is “Russian disinformation.”

FEC Commissioner Sean Cooksey released remarks dated September, saying he had joined the unanimous vote but disagreed with the reasoning of his colleagues.

“I’m not so sure” that “none of the behavior at issue was for the purpose of influencing the 2020 presidential election,” Cooksey said. He called this “irrelevant,” however, arguing that “Twitter is a publisher with a First Amendment right to control the content on its platform and to favor or disfavor certain speech and speakers.”


Washington Examiner Videos

Tags: News, Hunter Biden, Twitter

Original Author: Jerry Dunleavy

Original Location: FEC says Twitter acted legally in blocking Hunter Biden laptop stories, pointing to claim of intel warnings about hacking

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


United Nations withdraws Matt Hancock job offer

Photograph: John Walton/PA Matt Hancock, the former UK health secretary, will no longer become a special envoy for the United Nations after the job offer was withdrawn. Hancock had said ... Read more »

Man dies after house collapses in suspected gas explosion

The house collapsed on Kirkby Avenue in Clayton-le-Woods, Chorley – Google A man has died after a house collapsed in a suspected gas explosion on Friday. Emergency services were called ... Read more »

Walthamstow murder: Drug addict killed man while on court bail for ‘vicious' axe attack

( Met Police) A drug addict has been found guilty of murdering a man while on court bail for a “vicious” axe attack. Richard Hand stabbed Yassar Moussa, 37, in ... Read more »

Roma plotting January move for Barcelona's Riqui Puig

Roma boss Jose Mourinho is hoping to take advantage of Barcelona’s poor start to the season with a January move for midfielder Riqui Puig. © Provided by 90min Puig has ... Read more »

Eidgenössisches Schützenfest: Hier setzt Viola Amherd den Sch(l)usspunkt

Rund tausend Schiesssportbegeisterte haben am Samstag in Luzern den Abschluss des 58. Eidgenössischen Schützenfests gefeiert. Bundesrätin Viola Amherd stellte dabei ihre Schiesskünste unter Beweis und wies auf die militärische Bedeutung ... Read more »

With Pixel 6 coming soon, is it still worth buying a Pixel 3, 4 or 5?

Recently, I faced a dilemma: My Google Pixel 3 XL was on its last legs. Its battery was a pale shadow of its former self. Its USB-C port failed to carry ... Read more »

Paris Mayor Hidalgo clinches Socialist Party ticket to run for president

Paris Mayor Anne Hidalgo has been named the presidential candidate of France's Socialist Party following a vote – coming from behind to clinch the party's ticket. The 62-year-old, who announced ... Read more »

Kyle Rittenhouse victim sues city, county

A man who survived being shot by Kyle Rittenhouse during a protest last year against police brutality in Kenosha has filed a federal lawsuit alleging police enabled the violence by ... Read more »

‘The heaven of film-making': how a Dalit orphan got to tell her own story

Belmaya Nepali’s life changed for ever when, at 14, she was given a camera. The British film-maker Sue Carpenter had come to Pokhara, a tourist city in central Nepal, to ... Read more »

Here comes the anti-vaccine requirement solidarity movement

Workers of the world! Listen up. © Cecilia Fabiano/LaPresse/AP People hold a banner reading No Green Pass during a protest in Rome, Friday, Oct. 15, 2021. Half of Chicago’s rank-and-file ... Read more »

The Kids Who Have Lost a Parent to the Pandemic

Throughout the pandemic, media outlets and online dashboards have provided constant updates on the number of people who have died from COVID-19. Far less prominent—but just as striking—are the tallies ... Read more »

Assistant House sergeant-at-arms arrested on child pornography charges

© Getty Images Assistant House sergeant-at-arms arrested on child pornography charges A man who serves as an assistant to the House of Representatives sergeant-at-arms was arrested this week and charged ... Read more »

50 years of sweet sounds: Naples Concert Band marks half century with own music, Artis—Naples date

The Naples Concert Band decided to pull out the stops and commission a musical work for its 50th anniversary concert later this season. But this is a band that knows how ... Read more »

Zara McDermott looks stunning as she strips down to gem bra and knickers

ZARA McDermott looked incredible as she stripped down to a gem bra and knickers for a recent photoshoot. The Love Island star, 24, shared the snap with her 1.5m followers ... Read more »

THPD finally gets new home

Oct. 16—The new headquarters for the Terre Haute Police Department is full of history. The last 150 years of public safety in the city are documented in the historic photos ... Read more »

Chef, 32, charged with kidnap after ‘posing as a cop' and ‘searching' girl, 14, as she walked to school

A CHEF has been charged with kidnap with intent to sexually assault a 14-year-old girl after allegedly posing as a cop and searching her as she walked to school. David ... Read more »

Deliveryman fatally stabbed over e-bike outside lower Manhattan park: officials

A deliveryman was knifed to death early Saturday by a mugger who robbed him of his e-bike outside a lower Manhattan park, officials said. Cops responding to a report of ... Read more »

Inside James Harden's emergence as the leader the Nets need right now

Charles Wenzelberg/New York Post With Kyrie Irving gone indefinitely, Brooklyn’s Big 3 is down to two. The simple math says James Harden and Kevin Durant will have to do more ... Read more »

How I made money out of mysteries

Otto Penzler, owner of The Mysterious Bookshop Stephen Yang When Otto Penzler was preparing to open The Mysterious Bookshop in 1979, he enthusiastically planned an opening day bash. Everything was ... Read more »

Lawsuit over Kenosha shootings: Police enabled armed militia

Police Shooting Wisconsin Kenosha (Copyright 2020 Associated Press) A man who was shot in the arm by Kyle Rittenhouse during a protest last year against police brutality in Wisconsin has ... Read more »

Austrian chancellor says government coalition can still work together

© Reuters/POOL FILE PHOTO: Austria’s Chancellor Alexander Schallenberg speaks during a media statement with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen at EU headquarters in Brussels ZURICH (Reuters) – Newly ... Read more »

Lebanon's judicial council will meet with Beirut blast probe judge on Tuesday - LBCI TV on Twitter

© Reuters/MOHAMED AZAKIR A view shows the grain silo that was damaged during last year’s Beirut port blast, in Beirut CAIRO (Reuters) – Lebanon’s higher judicial council will meet with ... Read more »

Iran ex-central bank governor gets 10-year jail term

© ATTA KENARE Photo taken on January 17, 2016, shows then head of the Central Bank of Iran, Valiollah Seif (R) A former governor of Iran’s central bank was sentenced ... Read more »

How Long Island became a hotbed of espionage during the Cold War

Tensions were high when Nikita Khrushchev came to stay at the Killenworth estate in Glen Cove — where it was speculated the Soviets kept high-tech surveillance equipment, a new book ... Read more »

School slammed after pupils claim short skirts ‘blamed for upskirting and unwanted sexual attention' in assembly

A SCHOOL has been slammed after pupils claimed short skirts were being blamed for upskirting and unwanted sexual attention. Students at The Elton High School in Bury, Greater Manchester, took ... Read more »

How Bob Mackie rose to create iconic dresses for Cher and other stars

Cher made a splash in 1974 with fashion designer Bob Mackie on her arm — and Mackie’s feathers on her arms — at the Met Gala. He went on to ... Read more »

FDA panel votes to authorize J&J booster shot

An independent advisory panel voted Friday to move forward with Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccine booster, which can be administered two months after a person’s first shot. Read more »

PDRM buka kertas siasatan kes Pandora Papers

© Provided by Sinar Harian KUALA LUMPUR – Polis Diraja Malaysia (PDRM) mengesahkan telah menerima empat laporan berhubung pendedahan Pandora Papers mengenai dakwaan pengaliran wang negara ini ke luar negara ... Read more »

‘Hanya fikir nyawa', wira cilik selamatkan moyang dalam tragedi Gunung Jerai terima anugerah

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Muhammad Hadif Syazwan Anas, 11, menerima Pingat Hang Tuah sempena sambutan Hari Kanak-Kanak Kebangsaan. (Gambar Bernama) PETALING JAYA: Keberanian dan kepantasan bertindak menyelamatkan moyang ... Read more »

French pool-owners beware: Government allies with Google to spot undeclared pools and verandahs via satellite

Luxury Villas with swimming pools top down aerial view in Southern France – Rudmer Zwerver/Alamy Stock Photo Owners of swimming pools in France beware, the artificially intelligent taxman cometh. When ... Read more »

FDA panel endorses Moderna booster for some groups, Butterball's turkey recall, Ex-Boeing pilot indicted on fraud

Yahoo Finance’s Julie Hyman breaks down Friday’s business headlines. Read more »

Scotland skipper Kyle Coetzer excited by strength of T20 World Cup squad

Kyle Coetzer believes Scotland possess the strongest squad that the country has ever assembled at a Twenty20 World Cup. © PA Images Scotland v England – One Day International – ... Read more »

Everton ambition clear for Benitez despite key injury miss

Everton boss Rafa Benitez has been happy with his squad’s performances so far and is ambitious for the season, despite missing key players. © Getty Images Rafa Benitez, former Liverpool ... Read more »

The lessons of Egypt's perplexing whiskey tariff

© Getty Images The lessons of Egypt’s perplexing whiskey tariff There are tariffs, there are prohibitive tariffs and then there’s Egypt tariff on whiskey. It is, without a doubt, the ... Read more »

I'm in prison and I just had my first contact visit in 500 days. To reduce recidivism, prisons need to prioritize human contact.

© Getty A visitation requests box in a max-security prison in Louisiana. Getty I’m incarcerated in Washington, and I just had my first contact visit in over 500 days. Studies ... Read more »

Vet's heartbreaking final words to five healthy dogs when she puts them down in one day as she reveals she's ‘haunted'

A DEVASTATED vet has revealed the final words she told five dogs she had to put down in one day. Dr Amy Jackson-Moss penned the message on Facebook, which she ... Read more »

Watford vs Liverpool LIVE: Stream FREE, TV channel Firmino doubles Reds' lead before break after Mane's opener

GOALS from Sadio Mane and Roberto Firmino have given Liverpool comfort at Vicarage Road going into half time. Mane latched on to Mo Salah's sublime outside-of-the-foot pass with a cool ... Read more »

QSB eyeing for innovative investment in promoting circular economy

© Provided by New Straits Times JOHOR BARU: Qhazanah Sabah Berhad (QSB) is eyeing for a strategic investment expansion with Malaysia’s waste-reduce online to offline (O2O) building materials marketplace, HOMA2u, ... Read more »

7,509 new Covid-19 cases yesterday

© Provided by New Straits Times KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia recorded 7,509 new Covid-19 infections, a slight increase from the 7,420 cases reported on Friday. Health director-general Tan Sri Dr Noor ... Read more »

Removing the %&*@ from Maine's vanity plates will take time

Associated Press (AP) — Removing the flipping obscenities from license plates on Maine's roads and highways isn't going to happen overnight, even though a law banning such profanities in a ... Read more »