FDA panel recommends limiting Pfizer booster shots to Americans 65 and older, and those at high risk of severe COVID-19

No third dose for now. AP Photo/Robert F. Bukaty

The key scientific advisory council of the Food and Drug Administration has voted to deny authorization of a “booster” shot of Pfizer’s mRNA vaccine to the general public – a move that will likely disappoint some public health experts pushing for a third dose to help slow the spread of COVID-19.

In a 16-2 vote on Sept. 17, 2021, an independent committee of physicians, scientists and public health experts recommended against full approval of the third dose of the vaccine, which now goes by the brand name “Comirnaty.” However, the panel did recommend the shot for Americans age 65 and older or those at high risk for severe COVID-19. In recommending against the shot for the general public, the committee cited reasons such as lack of sufficient safety data in younger age groups as well as indications that the initial doses still seem to be providing robust protection against severe illness leading to hospitalization and death. The panel also agreed in a poll – but not a formal vote – that boosters would be beneficial for certain populations, such as health care workers and others at high risk for occupational exposure.

Although the vote is not binding, it is likely that it will form the basis of a formal FDA recommendation.

As an immunologist who studies COVID-19 and immune responses to vaccination, I saw the push for a booster as predictable, although the outcome of the vote was always far from certain. Over the past year, significant research and public reporting have focused on the durability of the immune response following the first and second doses of the COVID-19 mRNA vaccines. This work has been critical to scientists’ understanding of how long the immune responses from vaccination can provide protection, and whether that protection extends to new and emerging variants of the SARS-CoV-2 virus.

Waning antibodies

The good news is that the mRNA vaccines do appear to provide continued efficacy against serious illness or death caused by new strains of the coronavirus, including the highly infectious delta variant.

But data on the longevity of this protection has been more mixed and is still limited in scope. Although there are indications that immune “memory” is being established in vaccine recipients – almost certainly providing partial protection in the long term – the antibodies responsible for stopping the virus in its tracks before infection occurs appear to wane over the course of months following the second dose.

This is not surprising to immunologists and does not mean the vaccine isn’t working. Antibodies wane as a normal course of an immune response to any vaccine. This is why you need a tetanus booster every decade or so, and why the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine is administered in three doses – not just two.

The question is simply how fast antibodies decline, and at what point they no longer provide adequate protection. At that point, an additional dose of the vaccine is recommended to “boost” the antibody numbers back up to protective levels. In this case, widespread reporting of breakthrough infections – infections in individuals who have been fully vaccinated – and research citing the possibility of declining immunity in populations vaccinated early in the pandemic brought discussions of the need for boosters quickly to the forefront.

Against this backdrop of mixed data, the FDA panel had to weigh the risks and benefits surrounding booster shots. While the third dose of vaccine would have been identical to those already fully approved – and as such deemed safe – they would not be without side effects similar to those seen in the first and second doses.

In addition, serious conditions such as myocarditis – an inflammation of the heart – that have been recorded in rare and isolated cases after the initial vaccine shots will likely occur following the booster as well. This, in addition to a debate around the absolute benefit of a third shot to maintain current protection levels in otherwise healthy vaccinated individuals, has led many public health officials to express concern that the review is premature and risks further confusing and alienating an already divided American public.

Separating politics from data

With the Biden administration having already publicly backed a third dose for all vaccinated Americans in August, the committee was tasked with separating the politics from the data to weigh in on whether the benefits of a booster shot outweighed the risks to an already-hesitant American public.

In rejecting the proposal, the FDA panel has signaled its confidence in the original vaccination course among healthy individuals, and will wait for additional data before identifying waning antibody levels as a significant threat to public safety. However, its support for boosting those at high risk or exposure to COVID-19 suggests a recognition that additional shots may yet be necessary to fully protect the public at large.

[Get the best of The Conversation, every weekend. Sign up for our weekly newsletter.]

This article is republished from The Conversation, a nonprofit news site dedicated to sharing ideas from academic experts. It was written by: Matthew Woodruff, Emory University.

    Matthew Woodruff's research is supported by the National Institute of Health, and is a co-founder of Jefferson's Electorate.

    Internet Explorer Channel Network
    News Related


    What is salmonella and what are the symptoms?

    SALMONELLA has key signs for detection once it enters the human body. The Centers for Disease Control announced on October 20, 2021, that people across 37 states had a salmonella ... Read more »

    Phase 2 Trial On Ayahuasca's Active Ingredient Puts Small Pharma On Track To Winning The Psychedelics Race

    © Provided by Benzinga Small Pharma Inc. (OTCQB: DMTTF) (TSXV: DMT), a biotech company focused on psychedelic therapies, has begun its phase 2a clinical trial on SPL026. SPL026 is a ... Read more »

    The FDA just authorized booster shots of Moderna's and Johnson & Johnson's COVID-19 vaccines and is letting users mix and match shots

    © Provided by Business Insider An employee of Japan’s Suntory Holdings receives the Moderna coronavirus vaccine for Covid-19. KAZUHIRO NOGI/AFP via Getty Images The FDA authorized booster shots of the ... Read more »

    ‘Untethered' judge causes pain for pharmacies that filled legal painkiller prescriptions

    No matter how often plaintiffs’ attorneys and leftist activists pretend otherwise, it is insanely unfair to blame the opioid epidemic on pharmacists filling otherwise valid prescriptions from licensed physicians. © ... Read more »

    GPs refuse to dish out booster jabs ‘as they're too busy with other jobs'

    DOCTORS are refusing to dish out booster jabs — claiming they are too busy with other jobs. Family doctors say they can’t deal with routine appointments and top-up vaccines as ... Read more »

    Parents in Michigan, Virginia sue DOJ over response to school board threats

    A lawsuit accuses Attorney General Merrick Garland of trying to criminalize free speech by ordering a review of threats made against school personnel. Read more »

    Vulnerable OAP, 92, finally gets her booster thanks to Give Britain A Booster campaign

    SOME Sun readers have struggled to get boosters despite being eligible. The NHS booking service will not allow appointments without an invitation. Vulnerable Irene Turi, 92, could not secure her ... Read more »

    FDA OKs Moderna, J&J boosters, along with 'mix and match' approach

    The move will greatly expand access to booster shots. Read more »

    Vaccines are 90% effective at preventing deaths from Delta variant, study says

    Vaccination is 90% effective at preventing deaths from the Delta variant of Covid-19, according to recent research. The data, released by the University of Edinburgh, was gathered using a Scotland-wide ... Read more »

    Sajid Javid begs Brits to get their Covid booster jabs or face return to resitrctions

    SAJID Javid begged Brits last night to get their booster vaccinations or face a return to Covid restrictions. The Health Secretary, backing The Sun’s Give Britain a Booster campaign, warned ... Read more »

    Nats on a hot tin roof

    © Provided by Crikey Barnaby Joyce Nationals MAKING A JOYCE Nationals Leader Barnaby Joyce says the Liberals can expect a net zero position today, but told Sky News it would ... Read more »

    Heart health key to Type 2 diabetes prevention: researchers

    Heart health is a key component to the prevention of Type 2 diabetes, according to researchers.  In a September study published in the European Journal of Preventive Cardiology, Netherlands scientists ... Read more »

    Can My Dog Eat Spicy Food?

    Some spicy foods are so good that it’s tempting to sneak your dog a bite. But can dogs eat spicy food? And do they even like it? Not all spicy ... Read more »

    Slow Sales of Alzheimer's Drug Costing $50K a Year Partially Blamed on Supply Chain Issues

    Biogen’s new Alzheimer’s drug, Aduhelm, brought in an unexpectedly low $300,000 in sales during its first full quarter on the market. The company blamed the tepid debut on coverage questions ... Read more »

    Democrats weigh vouchers for Medicare dental benefits amid funding squeeze

    Congressional Democrats looking to cut at least a trillion dollars from their social spending package are considering converting one of the most expensive health care pieces — dental benefits for ... Read more »

    This New Nasal Swab Test Can Predict Whether COVID Patients Will Be Hospitalized

    For nearly two years, public health systems have been playing a game of Russian roulette when it comes to severe COVID-19. Some people get extremely sick or die. Others escape ... Read more »

    Blunt praised for medical research funding during dedication of University of Missouri facility

    Administrators, scientists and politicians praised U.S. Sen. Roy Blunt on Tuesday for years of securing medical research funding while dedicating the NextGen Precision Health facility in his name on the ... Read more »

    Front-line health care worker shortage due to COVID-19 vaccine mandates, burnout

    Hospitals have seen shortages in health care workers due to disputes over COVID-19 vaccine mandates and burnout. AP Photo/Jae C. Hong Hospital staffing shortages due to COVID-19 vaccination disputes have ... Read more »

    Nation's vaccine experts debate goal of booster campaign

    Are boosters meant to prevent infections? Or to keep people out of the hospital? Read more »

    Fact check: Are smokers at less risk for contracting the coronavirus?

    The claim: Nicotine substitutes could have a positive effect in fighting COVID-19 Amid coronavirus news, claims have surfaced that nicotine could contribute to preventing people from contracting COVID-19. This followed ... Read more »

    Vaccine breakthrough! Needle-free flu jab could suppress winter crisis

    British biotech firm Enesi Pharma announced it will begin clinical trials to help contain the outbreak of a ‘super cold’. Enesi Pharma joined forces with National Institutes of Health (NIH) ... Read more »

    Feeling anxious? Here are our top picks for apps to help calm your inner panic

    March 2020 marked the beginning of change – and not in a good way. No longer could we distract our minds by throwing ourselves into socialising or work. The gym ... Read more »

    St James Quarter's Bonnie & Wild hosts Champagne tasting event, running alongside Seafood Week treats

    Partner oysters with a couple of different fizz brands © Bonnie & Wild They say real pain for your enemies, Champagne for your friends. Thus, make a date to celebrate ... Read more »

    Alandas opens gelato shop in historic Edinburgh building that was once Greyfriars Bobby's lunch spot

    © Alandas gelato “One of the most noticeable and arguably most challenging differences between ice-cream and gelato is the way it is served”, says Carla Black, head of marketing and ... Read more »

    Cavity-Prone? A Dentist Explains Why You Should Be Careful About Mouthwash

    © Photo: Stocksy/ Milles Studio Side view of black female in sleepwear using toothbrush to clean teeth while looking at mirror in modern bathroom in morning. The rules of good ... Read more »

    Don't Write Off Vaxart, As Its Oral Vaccine Still Has a Chance

    © Source: Ascannio / Shutterstock.com VXRT stock First off, it makes sense why many may be skeptical about Vaxart (NASDAQ:VXRT). One of the lesser-known Covid-19 vaccine companies, VXRT stock has seen ... Read more »

    Meghan Markle is urging Democratic leaders in Congress to support for paid family and medical leave

    © WPA Pool/Getty Images WPA Pool/Getty Images Meghan Markle urged Democratic leaders in a letter Wednesday to support paid family and medical leave. The letter comes as Biden’s paid leave ... Read more »

    COVID vaccine rollout for kids under 12: What to know

    Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine is expected to be authorized and recommended for kids ages 5-11 in early November, and the Biden administration “will be ready to begin getting shots in arms ... Read more »

    Scientists search for cause of mysterious Covid-related inflammation in children

    More than 5,200 of the 6.2 million U.S. children diagnosed with Covid have developed MIS-C, or multisystem inflammatory syndrome. Read more »

    Is It Safe to Trick-or-Treat This Year? Expert Advice for Celebrating Halloween During COVID

    © Provided by Health Getty Images In fall 2020, when masks were already mainstream but vaccines were just a pipe dream, the scariest part about Halloween was the prospect of ... Read more »

    How to Stay Connected to Your Loved One in a Nursing Home

    We all need to feel connected to the outside world. For people living in nursing homes, staying in touch has always been more of a challenge, particularly with family members ... Read more »

    Ending the opioid crisis starts with proper distribution of settlement payouts

    The opioid crisis is an ever-present and increasingly deadly epidemic impacting the lives of families in every community across America. The BAD news is that 2020 saw a devastating increase ... Read more »

    TODAY ONLY: 5 Grooming & Beauty Deals You Need to Know About From Amazon

    © Courtesy of Amazon Shaving your face? Brushing your teeth? We’re absolutely sure of it — we aren’t living in the 1800s. But maybe your toothbrush is getting a little ... Read more »

    Abbott Laboratories (ABT) Q3 2021 Earnings Call Transcript

    © Provided by The Motley Fool Abbott Laboratories (ABT) Q3 2021 Earnings Call Transcript © The Motley Fool Logo of jester cap with thought bubble. Abbott Laboratories (NYSE: ABT) Q3 2021 Earnings ... Read more »

    Jennifer Garner Stays Fit and Glowing Thanks to Her Amazing Wellness Routine

    Jennifer Garner reveals her top wellness practices, like exercising and meditating. The actress also opened up about her skincare routine and the importance of wearing sunscreen. Garner stays social and ... Read more »

    The US Is Getting Ready to Start Vaccinating Kids Ages 5–11 Against COVID-19—Here's How

    © Provided by Health Getty Images If you’ve been waiting for news on a kids’ COVID vaccine, you might at least take comfort in the newest information that dropped today: ... Read more »

    This Dietitian Explains 3 Things You Can Do to Reduce Cravings, and It's Not Just "Drink Water"

    © Getty / Westend61 This Dietitian Explains 3 Things You Can Do to Reduce Cravings, and It’s Not Just “Drink Water” Craving your favorite foods, even after you’ve eaten a ... Read more »

    'Flu could be a real problem' Britons urged to get flu jab to avoid UK sickness storm

    The health secretary has warned that cases of influenza could soar this winter, as a result of strict coronavirus measures that reduced the number of cases during the 2020-21 season. ... Read more »

    Exclusive: Dia Mirza On Gardening In A Concrete Jungle & Getting Off The Treadmill Of Anxiety

    Author: Dia Mirza, Actor, UN Environment Goodwill Ambassador, and United Nations Secretary-General Advocate for Sustainable Development Goals and Global Ambassador IFAW Former Miss India and Miss Asia Pacific, actor Dia ... Read more »

    Back in society with good teeth

    Groningen Thanks to a collaboration between the Municipality of Groningen, the Center for Dentistry and Oral Hygiene of the UMCG (UMCG-CTM) and Menzis, clients of Addiction Care North Netherlands (VNN) ... Read more »
    On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic