Farmer’s daughter who sued father’s estate over sexism wins £650k payout

farmer’s daughter who sued father’s estate over sexism wins £650k payout

Julie Mate – Champion News

A farmer’s daughter who claimed sexism resulted in her brothers being favoured in her father’s will has won a £650,000 payout.

Julie Mate and her sisters were left just £12,000 each after their father, Donald Mate, died in 1992. He left his share of the farm to her brothers, Andrew and Robert, and his wife Shirley, who later handed her portion to her sons.

Julie, 62, claimed she had sacrificed school and her social life as a child to work alongside her brothers on the family’s 140-acre West Yorkshire dairy farm, and that she and her sisters were the victims of old-fashioned sexist tradition.

She said that she had wanted to return to the farm to work full-time as an adult, but her brothers had told her “you’re not coming back” after she went on to study animal science at university.

She has now won a £652,000 payout from her brothers’ fortune after a judge found it was her work which saw the value of part of the land increase from £300,000 to £9 million.

Judge Andrew Sutcliffe KC said the brothers had been “unjustly enriched” by Julie’s years of work in getting the land removed from the Green Belt so it could be sold to developers to build a 250-house estate, and that it was right she should share in the windfall.

Looked into ways of making money

A few years after her father died, Julie started to look into ways of making money from the land in order to realise some gains in which she and her sisters could also share, she claimed.

She said that she had been encouraged by her mother, Shirley, to look into the potential for redevelopment of 40 acres of farmland, known as Netherton Moor.

She deployed a planning consultant and worked on the project between 2008 and late 2015, claiming she relied on promises made to her by her mother that if she secured its allocation for housing, the proceeds would be shared equally in the family.

The land was ultimately included in the council’s Local Plan in 2015, but Julie soon discovered that Shirley and her brothers had already agreed a £9 million sale to developers Persimmon Homes to build a 250-house estate without her knowledge.

And the following year, despite knowing she would be due a massive windfall, Shirley executed a deed of trust handing her beneficial interest in the land to her two sons.

In a letter written to her sister Virginia, read out to the court, Julie wrote: “To be extremely blunt, given the value of the farm – when dad died, but particularly now – we three have been extremely badly done to.

‘Male chauvinism doesn’t wash now’

“You can call it the outcome of a male-dominated farming tradition, bloody mindedness, or simply male chauvinism – whatever it was, and with no disrespect to dad, it really doesn’t wash nowadays.”

Julie sued her mother and two brothers in 2020, claiming unsuccessfully that she had been promised an equal share of the proceeds of sale if she managed to have the land removed from the Green Belt.

The judge said there was no documentary evidence to show that such promises were made and the first time Julie even mentioned them was in a letter in 2020.

But she also sued for “unjust enrichment”, claiming that they had benefited hugely from her work and that she never intended to do it “for nowt”.

The judge ruled in her favour on this point, accepting her evidence that “at no time did she tell either of her brothers or Shirley that she would work on this project for nothing, without expectation of any reward”.

The judge awarded Julie a payment of £652,000 from her brothers, representing a 7.5 per cent share of the uplift in value of the land from its original value of £300,000 to the £9 million it sold for.

Sign up to the Front Page newsletter for free: Your essential guide to the day’s agenda from The Telegraph – direct to your inbox seven days a week.

News Related


Style stakes in Kerry at all time high as Listowel’s summer meeting launches in the sun

THE style stakes are to the max at the Listowel Races this summer with none other than North Kerry’s very own international fashion designer Colin Horgan deploying his discerning eye ... Read more »

Government parties set for fresh row after Taoiseach says houses for private sale ‘highest priority’ over social housing

Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil are set for a fresh row after Taoiseach Leo Varadkar insisted the Government’s “highest priority” in housing policy is providing more houses for private sale. ... Read more »

Twice Oscar-nominated Cork director’s movie wins big at the Irish Animation Awards

A movie directed by Cork born Nora Twomey has emerged as the winner of the most accolades at this year’s Irish Animation Awards ceremony. ‘My Father’s Dragon’ won the award ... Read more »

Iconic popstar 'signs up for Strictly Come Dancing' after bosses 'spent years asking'

Iconic 80s pop legend Shakin’ Stevens has signed up for the next series of Strictly Come Dancing. Sources claim that in recent years, bosses behind the show had been asking ... Read more »

Thousands of teenagers missing out on £2,100 in savings - how to claim cash

Many people may not realise they have a Child Trust Fund Tens of thousands of teenagers could be missing out on unclaimed savings worth an average of £2,100. The money ... Read more »

Kerry road-racer Stephen Walsh fourth on his Isle of Man debut

Road racer Stephen Walsh finished on his Isle of Man debut on Sunday. The Ardfert man competed in the pre-TT Classic Road Races on the Billown closed road circuit for ... Read more »

Man appears in court after pipe bombs found in bag at Tallaght Garda Station

Tallaght Garda Station A MAN HAS appeared in court after two pipe bombs were found in a bag at a Garda station in Dublin. Tallaght Garda Station in west Dublin ... Read more »

Cork woman’s sculpture to take centre stage at this year’s Bloom festival

A CORK woman who took up fine art following a serious illness will see the fruits of her labours take centre stage at Ireland’s largest garden festival, this week. Ireland’s ... Read more »

Pilot who killed his wife with hammer could be first prisoner to have his release blocked

A former British Airways pilot who bludgeoned his wife to death could be the first prisoner to have his release blocked by ministers. Robert Brown was sentenced to 26 years ... Read more »

Crowd cheers as man proposes to Ryanair flight attendant in Dublin Airport

A Ryanair flight attendant was proposed to by her boyfriend in Dublin Airport in front of a cheering crowd. A video posted to Twitter by bystander Vincent Hughes shows a ... Read more »

Ronan Keating announces vasectomy plans after abandoning snip op two years ago

Ronan Keating has revealed that he will be getting a vasectomy in just over a week’s time. However, the former Boyzone star had previously announced that he had already gone ... Read more »

Doctor quits medicine to become a priest in the Diocese of Elphin

A 59 year old oncologist has turned his back on medicine to become a priest. On Sunday last at the Cathederal of the Immaculate Conception in Sligo, Chris Garrett was ... Read more »

Garden Rescue star Charlie Dimmock's life off camera from net worth to living in the middle of nowhere

Charlie Dimmock has been a household name since shooting to fame in the late 1990s and is currently fronting the BBC show Garden Rescue alongside the Rich brothers as they ... Read more »

“It could take me a year to write a song” – Hozier on finding inspiration in Dante’s nine circles of Hell

At 6ft 5in, Andrew Hozier-Byrne is the kind of man who should stand out in a crowd. Yet there is something unassuming about the singer-songwriter, an air of modest quietness ... Read more »

Louth man smashes ‘100k in One Day’ to raise vital funds for IWA

You often hear of people going the extra mile for charity but how about 100k in ONE day! That’s exactly what Declan Hamilton did last Thursday, May 25, in aid ... Read more »

Garda appeal for help finding teen missing from Julianstown

Gardaí are appealing to the public for help in tracing the whereabouts of 15-year-old Martin O’Donoghue who was last seen on Old Dublin Road, Julianstown, Co. Meath on the evening ... Read more »

Crowd cheers as man proposes to flight attendant in Dublin Airport

A flight attendant was proposed to in Dublin Airport (Vincent Hughes/PA) A Ryanair flight attendant was proposed to by her boyfriend in Dublin Airport in front of a cheering crowd. ... Read more »

‘Personal element’ to attack on PSNI detective, court hears, as seven men are charged

Caldwell attending a Garden Party at Hillsborough Castle Co Down last week. SEVEN MEN HAVE been remanded in custody after appearing before a court charged with the attempted murder of ... Read more »

Mizzy tells Piers Morgan 'I do what I want' after 'pathetic' £365 fine for pranks

Piers Morgan has told the TikToker known as Mizzy he is a ‘complete moron’ after the prankster said he ‘can do what I want’. Mizzy, whose real name is Bacari-Bronze O’Garro, ... Read more »

Rolf Harris' final words to daughter just before the disgraced TV presenter died at home

Rolf Harris told his only child Bindi to take care of her mother, just before the disgraced paedophile entertainer died from neck cancer and old age. Rolf, who died aged ... Read more »

Ahmed Baba: DeSantis’s glitchy 2024 launch shows he could be more dangerous than Donald Trump

The Trump clone wars have begun. With Florida Governor Ron DeSantis’s extremely online campaign announcement, the 2024 GOP primary just kicked into high gear. In an audio-only conversation on Twitter ... Read more »

Former Mayo defender Oisin Mullin to make his AFL debut for Geelong

Oisin Mullin is in line for his AFL debut after being named on the Geelong squad for this weekend’s AFL round 11 game with Great Western Sydney Giants. Mullin’s rapid ... Read more »

Why workplace romances are on the rise

Common lore would have us believe that it is never a good idea to mix business with pleasure, but it would seem that we’ll make an exception to the rule ... Read more »

Ahmed Baba: DeSantis’s glitchy 2024 launch shows he could be more dangerous than Trump

The Trump clone wars have begun. With Florida Governor Ron DeSantis’s extremely online campaign announcement, the 2024 GOP primary just kicked into high gear. In an audio-only conversation on Twitter ... Read more »

How Red Bull keeps improving its RB19 F1 car

While its rivals search for ways to close the yawning performance gap, Red Bull is not sitting still as work continues on the car that evolved from last year’s dominant ... Read more »

Sligo Chamber of Commerce lashes Transport Minister Eamon Ryan for pulling plug on West’s vital road project

Sligo Chamber of Commerce has urged Transport Minister Eamon Ryan to allow the much-needed upgrade of the N17 between Ireland West Airport and Sligo to go ahead. Shelving the project ... Read more »

Uncovering the Health Benefits and Risks of Cherimoya: Curated by Health Experts

Cherimoya image Perspective from Kiran Dhaliwal Master’s Degree Nutrition and Dietetics · 3 years of experience · Australia Benefits It is loaded with antioxidants which help fight free radicals in ... Read more »

Defending champions East Kerry survive a real scare from Mid Kerry in U-21 football quarter-final

COUNTY U-21 FOOTBALL CHAMPIONSHIP QUARTER-FINAL East Kerry 1-12 Mid Kerry 1-11 East Kerry’s long unbeaten run in this competition stretches all the way back to 2018, but their quest for ... Read more »

Tralee Chess Club players receive trophies won in the Munster League

Tralee Chess Club presented the Munster League winners with their trophies won in Charleville in Division 2 of the Munster League The Tralee Chess Club, which has been playing together ... Read more »

Furious Speaker halts PMQs to throw Tory MP out of the Commons after losing his temper

Lindsay Hoyle kicks out Tory MP Speaker of the Commons Sir Lindsay Hoyle kicked a Tory MP out of PMQs this lunchtime during a rowdy sparring match between Rishi Sunak ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự