Family of grandfather, 74, who died after drunkenly falling 8FT over a stair rail and landing on his head sue JD Wetherspoon for £150,000 blaming its 'unusual design' for causing his death

Brian McAlister had to use a wheelchair for the rest of his life after the fallLawyers for his family said  the 'unsafe' stairs had caused his death Wetherspoons lawyers denied the claim, blaming a 'freak set of circumstances' The Suffolk grandfather died from two years after falling at the pub in Norwich

The 74 year-old grandfather died on New Year’s Day 2018 after he fell eight feet from the stairs and landed on his head at Norwich’s Queen of Iceni pub in April 2016.

Brian McAlister, from Brandon in Suffolk, was walking to the toilet when he lost his balance, suffered ‘catastrophic’ injuries.

He was left confined to a wheelchair, and later died from the impact of paralysis.

His family, led by daughter Pamela Suttle, are now suing JD Wetherspoon Ltd for more than £150,000, blaming the ‘unusual design’ of the pub’s staircase for his death.

In a High Court action, Ms Suttle’s lawyers claim the ‘unsafe’ layout of the staircase made it more likely that someone who fell on the steps would fall over the bannister.

Lawyers representing Brian McAlister's family claimed the 'unusual' stairs at The Queen of Iceni pub in Norwich had caused his death

Lawyers representing Brian McAlister’s family claimed the ‘unusual’ stairs at The Queen of Iceni pub in Norwich had caused his death

Brian McAlister, 74, had been drinking in the Norwich pub in April 2016 when he fell, sustaining horrific injuries which led to his death less than two years later

Brian McAlister, 74, had been drinking in the Norwich pub in April 2016 when he fell, sustaining horrific injuries which led to his death less than two years later

The pub chain denies any responsibility and says Mr McAlister was himself to blame for what happened, having drunk so much he needed alcohol detoxification medication afterwards.

Writing in documents filed at the London court, the family’s barrister Elizabeth-Anne Gumbel QC said Mr McAlister had been on his way to the toilet on the upper floor when he fell.

‘As can be seen from the available CCTV footage, he slid down the stair rail and fell over the balustrade at a distance of 2.6 metres [8.5ft], falling on his head and suffering catastrophic injuries,’ she says.

‘His fall and consequent injuries leading ultimately to his death were caused by the unsafe design of the staircase that was unsafe for a public house, where lawful visitors had to ascend the stairs to access the lavatory and where it was foreseeable that lawful visitors would also be drinking.’

The staircase had later been criticised in an environmental health report in October 2016, she says, pointing out that its design provided a risk of a serious fall to pubgoers.

‘A person who falls on the stairs at the Queen of Iceni is more likely to hit the handrail because it cuts across the direction in which a person falling is likely to travel,’ said the report.

Angela Suttle, Brian's daughter, has brought the case against the Wetherspoons pub chain and hope to win £150,000 in compensation for his death

Angela Suttle, Brian’s daughter, has brought the case against the Wetherspoons pub chain and hope to win £150,000 in compensation for his death

Grandfather Brian had to use a wheelchair for the rest of his life following the accident, before dying on New Year's day in 2018

Grandfather Brian had to use a wheelchair for the rest of his life following the accident, before dying on New Year’s day in 2018

‘The staircase was of such an unusual design that customers attending for the first time would not appreciate the increased risk when climbing the stairs.’

Having fallen over the side, Mr McAlister landed on his head, sustaining a skull fracture and devastating spinal injuries, which required gruelling surgery, but which led to his death in 2018.

But for Wetherspoon, barrister Jonathan Payne claims that the fall was an ‘unforeseeable’ tragedy caused by a ‘freak set of circumstances’ which were unconnected to the staircase design.

On top of that, he says Mr McAlister was drunk at the time, claiming he ‘used the staircase at a time when he was intoxicated to the extent that he was unsteady on his feet’.

‘The deceased was intoxicated to the extent that he required alcohol detoxification medication,’ he added.

He said the stairs would have been trodden by ‘many millions of customers’ in the 15 years since the pub started trading, adding: ‘Save for one customer who chose to jump voluntarily from the staircase, there have been no reported similar accidents.’

Mr McAlister may have toppled backwards after suddenly fainting, he added, and then spun round as he fell, sending him onto and then over the rail.

‘It is denied that the staircase had an unsafe design either as claimed or at all. The staircase complied with all relevant building regulations,’ he says.

‘It appears from the evidence collated after this unfortunate incident that at the material time the deceased was engaged on a stag party and was intoxicated.

‘When the deceased ascended the staircase he appeared to be unstable and tripped up the first landing, albeit he regained his footing.

‘This was not a normal or foreseeable use of the staircase. It represented a freak set of circumstances.’

The case reached court last week for a brief hearing ahead of a full trial of the claim at a later date.

News Related


Barcelona sets new restrictions for tourists ahead of summer holidays

© Owen Humphreys/PA Wire People on a beach in Barcelona Hundreds of thousands of Brits head to Spain for the consistently stunning weather and there’s lots to do. As Covid ... Read more »

Neil Parish: Porn scandal ex-MP had guns confiscated by police 'in case I shot myself'

The 66-year-old farmer admits he was "not feeling in the best place" having "blown up" his parliamentary career of 12 years and claims he was left to "drown" by the Tory chief whip Chris-Heaton Harris in the wake of the controversy. Read more »

Olivia Munn pushes son Malcolm in his stroller as she goes for leisurely morning walk... after John Mulaney's latest sold-out show at Madison Square Garden

Olivia Munn went for a morning stroll with her son Malcolm after attending boyfriend John Mulaney’s sold-out show at Madison Square Garden. The actress, 41, was spotted pushing her seven-month-old ... Read more »

Video: Khloe Kardashian shows off toned tummy in crop top and leggings in gym mirror selfies...after sister Kim reveals she widened 'vagina area' of SKIMS bodysuit at Khloe's request

Read more »

Two police officers killed in north Benin attack

COTONOU (Reuters) – Two police officers were killed and one wounded in an attack on a police station in northwest Benin on Sunday, police sources said, the latest in a ... Read more »

Neil Parish: Police took away my guns to stop me shooting myself

© Geoff Pugh/For the Telegraph Neil Parish said he had ‘blown up’ his parliamentary career of 12 years – Geoff Pugh/For the Telegraph Neil Parish, the former Tory MP caught ... Read more »

Video: The mastermind behind Sir Paul McCartney's virtual duet with John: As fans praise the Glastonbury performance, FEMAIL reveals how director Peter Jackson engineered it by using 'custom AI' to 'isolate Lennon's vocals'

Read more »

Video: Size matters! Justin Trudeau and Boris Johnson joke about who has the BIGGER jet... with the British PM admitting his own official plane is 'very modest'

Read more »

Child abusers will be jailed for LIFE under Tony's Law: Legislation inspired by seven-year-old boy who lost his legs due to being tortured by his parents comes into force this week - in wake of tragic deaths of little Arthur and Star

The government is introducing measures so that child abusers face longer in jailKnown as 'Tony's Law', the most serious offenders could face life behind barsTony Hudgell lost his legs due to his cruel parents who were jailed for 10 years Read more »

300 bottles of Cognac recovered from ship sunk in WWI could fetch nearly £8,000 EACH: French shipment on Swedish steamer bound for tsarist Russia ended up at bottom of the Baltic Sea after German U-boat strike

Bottles were salvaged in 2019 by a specialist Swedish team near the Baltic Sea600 bottles of cognac and 300 bottles of Benedictine were brought to shoreSwedish steamer Kyros was sunk by German submarine during First World WarNow bottles have been cleaned, refilled and are on sale for nearly £8,000 each  Read more »

Homes evacuated as huge fire sweeps through playing fields and shrubland: 80 firefighters battle blaze sending huge smoke cloud over south London

Nearly 20 people had to be evacuated due to a blaze in Norbury, south London Large fire swept over seven acres of wasteland, shrubs and school playing fieldsOver 80 firefighters were called into action with 12 engines present at the sceneThe London Fire Brigade and the Metropolitan Police are investigating the cause  Read more »

Comparing Nunez to the best U23 strikers: Haaland, Mbappe, Vlahovic…

Darwin Nunez has completed his big-money move to Liverpool this summer – but how does he compare to the  best young strikers in the world? Kylian Mbappe and Erling Haaland ... Read more »

Hill thinks Mercedes are ‘still some way off’ the pace

© PA Images Mercedes’ George Russell and Lewis Hamilton during the Canadian Grand Prix. Montreal, June 2022. Damon Hill has warned that Mercedes are still “some way off” the pace ... Read more »

Piers Morgan furiously defends Sir Paul McCartney after Glastonbury set complaints

Former Beatles bassist and musical legend Sir Paul McCartney has been slated for ‘not playing enough’ of his old band’s tunes during his appearance at Glastonbury this weekend – but ... Read more »

Antonio Conte's ideal Tottenham bench vs Southampton after Fabio Paratici transfer masterclass

© David Rogers/Getty Images Antonio Conte had little to choose from off the bench at times last season The final few months of the 2021/22 Premier League season highlighted Tottenham’s ... Read more »

Inter Milan 'must seize' Paulo Dybala when his Juventus contract runs out next week, claims ex-Nerazzurri striker Diego Milito - with forward linked to Man United, Arsenal and Spurs

Paulo Dybala scored 115 goals in 293 appearances for Juventus in seven seasonsThe 28-year-old won nine trophies with the Old Lady, including five Serie A titlesHe is set to leave the club next week after an emotional farewell in his final gameFormer Inter Milan striker Diego Milito urged his club to sign Dybala if they can  Read more »

'I couldn't be more proud': Olympic legend Daley Thompson heaps praise on his son Elliot for winning the British decathlon title in Manchester... 46 years after his father first won it!

Daley Thompson said he 'couldn't be more proud' of his son Elliot's title winElliot Thompson won the British decathlon title 46 years after his dad first didDaley heaped praise on his son for managing to step out from under his shadow After winning, Elliot Thompson has chosen to step down from full-time athletics  Read more »

Juventus 'turn down Chelsea's player-plus-cash bid for Matthijs de Ligt despite Timo Werner and Christian Pulisic being offered to them' - with Serie A giants not 'crazy' about either player as they hold firm over defender

Chelsea are eyeing up ambitious move for Juventus centre back Matthijs de LigtAs Sportsmail has revealed, De Ligt is hesitating over signing fresh terms in Italy Thomas Tuchel is set to be backed this summer, with a new defender a priorityReports say a bid including Timo Werner and Christian Pulisic has been rejected  Read more »

Widow of British journalist Dom Phillips weeps at his cremation in Brazil - as police probe 'ordered killing' of reporter and aide in the Amazon

British journalist Dom Phillips and guide Bruno Pereira were killed in the AmazonNow their families are demanding justice as Phillips's funeral took place todayGuardian writer's cremation took place today after Pereira was buried on Friday Pair went missing during investigation into mistreatment of Indigenous tribes  Read more »

Wetherspoons drinker ‘could have died’ after chunk of ceiling crashed down on his table

Sam Ireton and the piece of ceiling which fell while he was at the pub (Picture: SWNS) A man has revealed how a heavy piece of ceiling fell down on ... Read more »

Khloe Kardashian shows off toned tummy in crop top and leggings in gym mirror selfies...after sister Kim reveals she widened 'Vagina area' of SKIMS bodysuit at Khloe's request

Khloé Kardashian left little to the imagination in a tiny crop top and tight leggings in a pair of clips she posted to her Instagram story on Sunday. The 37-year-old ... Read more »

Video: Will Mick 'The Grinch' Lynch steal Christmas? Mass strikes in August threaten to disrupt freight trains carrying billions of pounds of festive gifts... as it's revealed walkouts last week stopped rail buffs from attending TRAIN convention 

Read more »

Video: NASA launches its first rocket Down Under in 27 years with local Indigenous community playing a key role in the historic mission

Read more »

Branded a criminal for playing sport, surrounded by bombs and BANNED from leaving the country without a man's permission - new documentary reveals the reality of life for a teenage girl in Gaza

New documentary The Girl From Gaza shows the realities of children in warThe film follows  16-year-old Mariam Al-Muzainy, as she copes with the Gaza warIn the movie, the teenager described being labelled a criminal for playing sports Read more »

Derby County make short-term decision following Wayne Rooney’s departure

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Derby County v Luton Town Derby County have confirmed that Liam Rosenior is the new Interim Manager following Wayne Rooney’s exit. Liam ... Read more »

AOC says Supreme Court justices lied under oath, Congress should consider impeachment

© Getty Images GettyImages-1390151283.jpg Rep Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez called for the impeachment of two Supreme Court justices on Sunday following statements from senators indicating that they believed two recent additions to ... Read more »

Hay fever warning: The daily drink that could almost double your risk of symptoms - study

A potential link between alcohol and hay fever has been considered for some time, as many drinks contain histamine. This is created by the yeast and bacteria in the drinks ... Read more »

Three Antony right-wing alternatives Manchester United can target for Erik ten Hag this summer

© Soccrates/Getty Images Antony has been linked with a reunion with Erik ten Hag at Manchester United this summer, but his €80m pricetag may make him unattainable. Manchester United are ... Read more »

Sonay Kartal ready to grasp Wimbledon chance after impressive return from injury

Sonay Kartal has been making up for lost time in rapid fashion and now the 20-year-old has a Wimbledon breakthrough in her sights. A talented junior, the Brighton player saw ... Read more »

Juan Mata’s no look, one touch assist for Chris Smalling just isn’t talked about enough

Juan Mata really was a Premier League treat. Whether it was in the colours of Chelsea or Manchester United, you just always felt that the little Spanish magician was on ... Read more »

Women threaten to go on SEX STRIKE in protest over SCOTUS overturning Roe v Wade as marches continue to erupt across the US and rioters in Portland smash windows

Pro-choice supporters are calling for a 'sex strike' in response to SCOTUS decision to overturn Roe v. Wade on FridayMany women who marched with thousands of protesters in New York City on Friday and Saturday held signs that read 'No sex until we have abortion rights' The hashtag #SexStrike began trending on Twitter following the protestsProtests are expected to carry on through the weekend in major cities  Read more »

Sunday evening headlines as ex-England star reveals rugby racial abuse horror and South Africa 'to join Six Nations' fresh claim

© Action Images / Paul Harding Former England star Luther Burrell has given a candid interview There are some of the stories making the rugby news on the evening of ... Read more »

Tennis-Tsitsipas says he proved doubters wrong with first grasscourt crown

© Reuters/YVES HERMAN French Open LONDON (Reuters) – Stefanos Tsitsipas believes he has proved a point to his critics ahead of Wimbledon by winning his maiden grasscourt title at the ... Read more »

Tennis-Wimbledon doesn't care what looks cool, says Kyrgios on strict dress code

© Reuters/ASANKA BRENDON RATNAYAKE Australian Open (Reuters) – Nick Kyrgios would rather wear all black when competing at Wimbledon instead of adhering to the all-white dress code, with the Australian ... Read more »

Elton John's health tour! Guitarist Davey Johnstone says vitamins and herbal tea are the order of business for Farewell Yellow Brick Road gigs

Elton John’s guitarist has told how the days of boozing and taking drugs while on tour are long gong and its vitamins and herbal teas that keep him going. The ... Read more »

That time Keith Emerson and Lee Jackson from The Nice visited the Prog office!

© Provided by LouderSound The Nice Keith Emerson and Lee Jackson have a professional and personal relationship that stretches back close to the 50s. This comes through with the relaxed ... Read more »

Demians and the making of their second album Mute

© Provided by LouderSound Demians DATELINE: Paris, April 22, 2008. A local act, Demians, are about to make their debut live appearance. However, Demians are only a ‘band’ in the ... Read more »

Henry VIII’s hidden Hull castle and how it could be transformed

A specialist design company has been appointed to help work up plans for a new £1.25m visitor attraction in Hull. The council-backed South Blockhouse Project aims to bring the history ... Read more »

'I think it is the stupidest thing EVER!': Nick Kyrgios hits out at men's doubles matches being best-of-five-sets at Wimbledon... and insists he is happy to play the 'villain-type role' when he faces British wildcard Paul Jubb in the singles

Men's doubles matches at Wimbledon are best-of-five-sets contestsEvery other major tournament plays best-of-three-sets matchesNick Kyrgios does not agree with Wimbledon's decision to play extra setsHe has claimed that this is the reason that he has not entered the event before  Read more »

Video: Darren Lockyer is left DANGLING from Optus Stadium roof 42 metres ABOVE the field after losing Origin bet with Paul Gallen

Read more »