Falsifying Russia's History Is a Step Toward More Violence

Asia's Tech News Daily

Falsifying Russia’s History Is a Step Toward More Violence
© Getty; The Atlantic

One night in October, a group of masked men burst into the Moscow offices of Memorial, the celebrated Russian historical society and civil-rights organization, and disrupted a screening of Mr. Jones, a film about the Ukrainian famine of 1932–33. They shouted, gesticulated, and chanted “fascists” and “foreign agents” at the audience. Police were called, but they allowed the masked men to escape. Instead of chasing the intruders, officers barred the doors of the building and interrogated members of the audience until long past midnight.

This week, as Russian troops and armored trucks are inexplicably gathering on the borders of Ukraine, the event at the Moscow theater seems retrospectively more ominous, the moment when the “normal” pressure on Memorial and other Russian civic institutions turned more sinister. Something about it also felt familiar to Irina Shcherbakova, a Russian historian who writes about Germany and is one of the organization’s original founders. That evening, she told me, reminded her of another one: In 1930, Joseph Goebbels, then the Nazi Party leader in Berlin, sent a mob of thugs to block the showing of a movie. They shouted, gesticulated, released mice into the theater, and threw stink bombs. Frightened, the audience left.

The movie Goebbels didn’t like was All Quiet on the Western Front, which graphically depicted the horrors of the First World War and thus disrupted the more heroic version of German history preferred by the Nazis. Mr. Jones, the film the Russian government doesn’t like, tells the story of a Welsh journalist, Gareth Jones, who was the only Western writer to report on the Ukrainian famine. Filmed by the great Polish director Agnieszka Holland, Mr. Jones contains horrific scenes of peasants who are starving to death. They are starving not because their harvest failed, but because the Soviet leadership has confiscated their food. That story disrupts the more heroic version of Soviet history preferred by Russian President Vladimir Putin, a former officer of the KGB, the institution that organized the famine 90 years ago.

[From the September 2020 issue: A KGB man to the end]

The attack on All Quiet on the Western Front was a harbinger of what was to come: In 1933, the Nazis took over Germany and banned the movie altogether. A few years later, the entire country, blinded by the Nazi vision of Germany’s past, was at war. Dictators distort the past because they want to use it: to stay in power, to bully opponents, to persuade people to commit acts of mass violence.

The attack on Mr. Jones also heralded a change. In November, the Russian prosecutor general asked the Russian Supreme Court to shut down Memorial altogether. Ostensibly, this was because Memorial had been designated a “foreign agent” and hadn’t complied with all of the laws that foreign agents are required to obey. But this excuse is farcical. Memorial was founded in 1987 by Russians, for Russians, and it has been dedicated to Russian history and Russian civil liberties ever since. If it is closed, that’s because the Russian government is determined to return to the pre-1987 Soviet world of repression, state-sponsored terror, and falsified history.

How did Russia get to this point? Thirty years ago, after the U.S.S.R. came to an end, the Russian state that succeeded it was focused on the present and the future: economic reform, political reform, opening to the world. Thirty years ago, Memorial was a hive of energy, each corner of its small pink-stone building in central Moscow stuffed with books, papers, and people drinking tea. When I first started spending time there, in the 1990s, Memorial was assembling a library that would eventually contain a wide assortment of memoirs and monographs on Soviet repression, in multiple languages. It was archiving photographs and oral histories, and assembling the world’s largest collection of objects from the Gulag: prisoners’ uniforms, tools, paintings, sketches, carvings.

Some of these projects had started before Memorial even existed. One of the group’s other founders, the late Arseny Roginsky, began collecting the names of Stalin’s victims back in the 1970s, when doing so was still illegal. This was an act of faith: “I had to assume that history would outlast stupidity and cruelty,” he told David Remnick, who quotes him in his book Lenin’s Tomb. Roginsky went to jail for his efforts. But in the years following the collapse of the Soviet Union, Memorial ceased to be a dissident organization. Historians from Memorial often worked in tandem with state archivists. They used newly available Soviet sources to produce an astonishing array of books and document collections. In 2000, they produced the first complete list of the Soviet Gulag camps, with a brief history of each one; in 2016, this material became an interactive online map. Over time, Memorial created a list of more than 3 million victims of Stalinism, and eventually made that available online too. In that era, I met historians affiliated with Memorial in many obscure corners of Russia—Syktyvkar, Vorkuta, Petrozavodsk—where there used to be Gulag camps. In some places they had cordial relationships with local governments, though in others the state was simply indifferent. In the 1990s, many officials viewed archival work, including mine, as a somewhat eccentric and harmless activity. Some girl from America wants to look at old papers? She’s welcome to them.

Putin’s determined re-politicization of history has changed all of that. He began by bringing back annual celebrations, complete with Soviet flags and uniforms, of the 1945 victory in what is still called, in literal translation, the “Great Fatherland War”—as if no one else fought the Nazis. He brought back the Soviet national anthem. Slowly, Stalin was whitewashed. Nostalgia for his victories was pumped up to new levels. In 2014, when Russia invaded Ukraine, Russians were repeatedly told on state television and in thousands of social-media posts that they were fighting a war against “fascism” once more.

[Read: Vladimir Putin’s risky ploy to manufacture history]

As stupidity and cruelty again began to outpace history, clashes between Memorial and the organs of the state intensified. Perhaps this was to be expected, because Roginsky, Shcherbakova, and the others at Memorial were not doing history for history’s sake. They were investigating Stalinism in the past precisely because they wanted to block the return of Stalinism in the present. Toward that end, Memorial helped create public monuments to Stalin’s crimes, including a boulder from the Solovetsky Islands, the site of the first Soviet camp for political prisoners, which was placed right in front of KGB headquarters in Lubyanka Square. They also began investigating modern Russian human-rights violations in the present—most dramatically in Moscow’s campaign against rebels in Chechnya.

Memorial ended that project after one of its investigators, Natalia Estemirova, was kidnapped and murdered there in 2009. But since then other, less obviously political activities have become dangerous too. For years now, Memorial has worked with schoolteachers all over Russia, among other things encouraging children to ask their grandparents what they remember of the Soviet Union, and to write down those stories. This, Shcherbakova told me, is now the most controversial thing Memorial does. “It’s dangerous for schools to work with us. Sometimes it is forbidden to work with us.” But not only schools are intimidated. Archives, libraries, academic institutions—all of them, she told me, are now afraid to work with the organization that pioneered the study of Soviet repression in Russia.

Educators’ and researchers’ fear is not unreasonable. Memorial employees are now regularly questioned and investigated by police. Sometimes their family members are subjected to similar harassment. Yuri Dmitriev, a historian and an archaeologist who heads Memorial’s local chapter in Karelia, a region in northwest Russia, has paid an even higher price. Since 2016, Dmitriev—who has probably identified more mass-burial sites and found more bodies of Stalin’s victims than anyone else in Russia—has been in and out of prison while fighting grotesque, clearly fabricated charges of sexual assault.

[From the January/February 2018 issue: What Putin really wants]

In the face of this aggression, Memorial has not backed down. Instead, the organization has been systematically preparing itself for the worst by digitizing its archives. In recent days, thousands of people have come to Memorial’s Moscow headquarters to view its public exhibits, but also to sign petitions and express their support. Even if they don’t know much about the organization, Shcherbakova told me, people come because they understand what its closure would symbolize: “If this is happening to Memorial, then something bad may be coming.”

They may be right. Let me return to where I began: Dictators distort the past because they want to use it. Putin certainly wants to use the past to stay in power. If Russians are nostalgic for their old dictatorship, then they have less reason to push back against the new one. He may also want to use the past to give legitimacy to violence—Russians who have no awareness of what Moscow did to Ukraine in the past will feel no sense of guilt about repeating old patterns of aggression. History does contain lessons, and here is one of them: If Putin plans to turn his falsely heroic vision of Russia’s past into a justification for another war in the present, he won’t be the first autocrat to do so.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Daily roll call of arrests, NPA prosecutions and convictions – 18 January 2022

Our daily roll call of successful criminal prosecutions, arrests and ongoing matters in South Africa’s courts. We do this to reflect on the rule of law and to make justice ... Read more »

Covid news LIVE – Plan B could be ‘significantly reduced' in days as daily cases drop by 20% thanks to vaccine boosters

THE Covid-19 pandemic is nearly over as far as the UK is concerned, the World Health Organisation has declared. Infections and hospital cases are falling across the country — the ... Read more »

Labour has chosen to back vandals and thugs by blocking sensible protest laws

Crusties’ party WHOSE side is Labour on? Certainly not the hard-working public’s. Keir Starmer’s unelected peers have inflicted defeats on the Government which had Insulate ­Britain and Extinction Rebellion’s crusties ... Read more »

Wife of critically ill Covid patient wins court battle to keep husband on ventilator

© KMSP Scott Quiner, 55, has been on life support with Covid-19 since early November – KMSP When a hospital allegedly planned to take a Covid-19 patient off life support, ... Read more »

Comoros 3-2 Ghana: Minnows dump Thomas Partey and Co OUT of AFCON

Ghana’s Africa Cup of Nations campaign came to a humiliating end on Tuesday as they were beaten 3-2 by debutants Comoros Islands at Garoua’s Roumde Adjia Stadium to finish bottom ... Read more »

Texas synagogue attack: Two teenagers arrested in Manchester released without charge

Two teenagers who were arrested in Manchester in connection with the Texas synagogue attack have been released without charge. The pair were arrested by counter-terrorism officers in the south of ... Read more »

Hearts surge further ahead in European quest with Josh Ginnelly and Barrie McKay a bigger tale than John Souttar

© Josh Ginnelly scores the opening goal for Hearts against St Johnstone. Josh Ginnelly’s two goals against St Johnstone combined with Motherwell’s defeat at Ross County ensured an excellent evening ... Read more »

Preston North End 2-2 Sheffield United – FLW report as 10-man Lilywhites stage epic comeback

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Preston North End v Brentford Preston North End came from two goals down to share the spoils with Sheffield United at Deepdale ... Read more »

Trump plans major expansion at one of his Florida resort properties

© Getty Images A sign is seen near the entrance to the Trump National Doral golf resort on April 20, 2020 in Doral, Florida – Getty Images Donald Trump is ... Read more »

Iowa State vs. Texas Tech odds, prediction: Red Raiders seek retribution

The Iowa State Cyclones scored a 51-47 victory over Texas Tech when these two faced off in Ames earlier in January, and Texas Tech will be at home in a ... Read more »

Duke vs. Florida State college basketball betting odds, lines, trends

The Florida State Seminoles (10-5, 4-2 ACC) are underdogs (+5) as they attempt to continue a three-game win streak when they host the No. 6 Duke Blue Devils (14-2, 4-1 ... Read more »

Lewis Hamilton's threat to quit F1 is NOT stunt with Mercedes star ‘disillusioned' following controversial end to season

LEWIS HAMILTON's threat to quit F1 should NOT be dismissed as a stunt, according to McLaren CEO Zak Brown. Hamilton is “disillusioned” after the controversial end to the Abu Dhabi ... Read more »

Red Wall Tories planning the oust Boris Johnson in a coup dubbed the ‘Pork Pie Plot'

TORIES elected on Boris Johnson’s coat-tails in 2019 met yesterday to discuss ditching him  — in a move dubbed the Pork Pie Plot. They sharpened knives as battered Boris insisted ... Read more »

Calgary man to serve 15 years before parole eligibility for random, violent attack

CALGARY — A Calgary man who randomly killed a Nigerian nursing student more than three years ago will have to serve 15 years of a life sentence before he is ... Read more »

S&P/TSX composite down more than 200 points amid broad selloff led by tech sector

TORONTO — Canada’s main stock index closed down 1.2 per cent Tuesday as part of a broad selloff caused by surging bond yields that also pushed U.S. stock markets down.  ... Read more »

Ford to record $8.2 billion gain from Rivian investment

(Reuters) -Ford Motor Co said on Tuesday it gained $8.2 billion on its investment in Rivian Automotive Inc in the fourth quarter, following the electric-vehicle maker’s initial public offering in ... Read more »

Indiana vaccine exemption bill advances, faces GOP hurdles

© Provided by Associated Press House Majority Leader Matt Lehman, R-Berne, speaks during the first day of the legislative session at the the Statehouse, Tuesday, Jan. 4, 2022, in Indianapolis. ... Read more »

Rabbi credits security training for life-saving acts at US synagogue

© Brandon Bell A law enforcement vehicle outside Congregation Beth Israel synagogue in Colleyville, Texas, where a gunman held several people hostage before he was killed by security forces When ... Read more »

Nasdaq falls nearly 3% as US stocks plummet on interest rate worries

© Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images Traders work on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) on March 20, 2020 in New York City. Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty ... Read more »

Buccaneers fans threw Eagles fan down stairs in playoff brawl

Wild Card weekend had no shortage of wild moments on and off the field. During the Buccaneers win over the Eagles in Sunday’s NFC wild card matchup, fights broke out ... Read more »

Piers Morgan enjoys a HUGE steak and £70 bottle of wine as he jokes about ‘Blue Monday'

PIERS Morgan shrugged off so-called 'Blue Monday' by tucking into a massive steak and a pricey bottle of plonk. Piers, 56, showed the 'most depressing day of the year' who's ... Read more »

Canada's 'biggest winter playground' offers a connection to nature

Sure, cold temperatures and snow can be a deterrent to going outside during the winter, but it doesn’t mean you should hunker down indoors for the entire season. In fact, ... Read more »

Senate candidate Gary Chambers puffs on blunt in campaign ad

He’s got high aspirations! A Louisiana community advocate running for US Senate released a campaign ad Tuesday showing him puffing on a joint while pushing for marijuana reform. The video, ... Read more »

Gov. Hochul's budget projects $1.25 billion in revenue from pot sales over 6 years

New York is set to reach new highs starting in 2023 — thanks to legalized pot. The state plans to reap more than $1.25 billion in new revenue from legal ... Read more »

Mask mandate to remain in place — Department of Health

The National Department of Health confirmed on Tuesday that the mandatory wearing of masks in public spaces and on public transport will remain in place. This comes as South Africa ... Read more »

Bobby Kotick is Reportedly Expected to Leave Activision Blizzard After Microsoft Deal Closes

Activision Blizzard CEO Bobby Kotick is expected to leave the company after Microsoft’s $68.7 Billion deal closes, according to a report by The Wall Street Journal on Tuesday. Microsoft’s deal ... Read more »

All shiny Pokémon in the Power Plant event in Pokémon Go

© Provided by GamePur With every event in Pokémon Go, there will be several Pokémon you can find in the wild, from Research Field tasks and raids that have a ... Read more »

Green Goblin skin has been datamined in the latest Fortnite update

© Provided by GamePur The two Hawkeyes aren’t the only new Marvel characters coming to Fortnite. Spider-Man’s archnemesis the Green Goblin will also be bringing terror onto the island. The ... Read more »

More Valorant x League of Legends crossovers are coming

It seems like more Valorant and League of Legends crossovers are coming following developer posts for both games. Following acknowledgments of the similarities between new LoL champion Zeri and new ... Read more »

2022 GRAMMY Awards Announce Rescheduled Date

© DON EMMERT/AFP via Getty Images The 64th Annual GRAMMY Awards have officially been rescheduled.  Postponed from their previously planned date of Jan. 31 due to COVID-19 concerns, the 2022 ... Read more »

You got omicron. Should you still get a booster?

© Provided by Live Science A medical worker administering a vaccine to a patient. As omicron surges across the country, the coronavirus variant is infecting many people who have received ... Read more »

Road & Track Invites Drivers on a 1-Day Texas Hill Country Rally

Our friends at Road & Track have a ton of new events coming up, and they (and we) want you to join in. Among them is their first one-day rally ... Read more »

Achraf Hakimi scored one of the best free-kicks you'll ever see for Morocco v Gabon at AFCON

The 2021 Africa Cup of Nations has well and truly burst into life in recent days. After a slightly dull start to the tournament out in Cameroon, the goals are ... Read more »

Ghana 2-3 Comoros: Ahmed Mogni sends Black Stars crashing out of AFCON after huge shock

© AFP via Getty Images comoros.jpg Ghana finished bottom of Group C as they crashed out of the Africa Cup of Nations with a shock 3-2 defeat to Comoros despite ... Read more »

Daniel Radcliffe to star in Weird Al Yankovic biopic

© Bang Showbiz Daniel Radcliffe is set to play Al Yankovic Daniel Radcliffe is set to play ‘Weird Al’ Yankovic in an upcoming biopic. The 32-year-old actor – who is ... Read more »

Comedian Louie Anderson admitted to hospital following cancer diagnosis

© Richard Shotwell/Invision/AP Louie Anderson – Richard Shotwell/Invision/AP Comedian Louie Anderson has been admitted to hospital after being diagnosed with cancer. On Tuesday (18 January), representatives for the former Family ... Read more »

Port of Prince Rupert set to master 2021 challenges with 2022 upgrades, improvements

PRINCE RUPERT, B.C. — Port officials in Prince Rupert, B.C., say 2021 was a difficult year as cargo volumes fell, but they are optimistic about a strong recovery. © Provided ... Read more »

Prehistoric fertility symbol that looks like curvy Kim Kardashian sells for staggering £114k

A PREHISTORIC fertility symbol looking like curvy Kim Kardashian has sold for a fabulous figure. Experts say the 25,000-year-old stone carving has an exaggerated bust and bottom to depict a ... Read more »

Brianna Kupfer news - latest: New suspect photos released as LAPD hold press conference on Croft House killing

LIVE – Updated at 21:17 A manhunt is underway for a suspect accused of stabbing 24-year-old Brianna Kupfer to death at the furniture store where she worked in Los Angeles. ... Read more »

Queen launching a royal brown sauce to rival HP for £6.99 a bottle

THE monarchy is to battle again with the Houses of Parliament — launching a brown sauce to rival HP. A royal ketchup is also splattering on the market — but ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic