Facebook's risks for young people add to bipartisan backlash in the US

Cambridge Analytica privacy scandal

Politicians have pledged to hold social media companies accountable for their impact on mental health, civil discourse and democracy.

WASHINGTON (BLOOMBERG, AFP) – Facebook is facing renewed fury from Washington after reports suggested the company knew, but did not disclose, that its Instagram platform could pose risks to teenagers.

The report from the Wall Street Journal citing Facebook’s own internal research gives fuel to politicians who have pledged to hold social media companies accountable for their impact on mental health, civil discourse and democracy.

While previous rounds of outrage over issues such as the Cambridge Analytica privacy scandal have not dented Facebook’s business model or profitability, this backlash could bring chief executive officer Mark Zuckerberg and other company executives back to testify before Congress about the shortcomings.

United States Senators Mr Richard Blumenthal, a Connecticut Democrat, and Ms Marsha Blackburn, a Republican from Tennessee, the chair and ranking member of the Senate consumer protection subcommittee, said they have been in contact with a Facebook whistle-blower and “will use every resource at our disposal to investigate what Facebook knew and when they knew it”.

The senators said on Tuesday (Sept 14) they planned to seek further documents and speak with witnesses as part of the investigation. The Senate Commerce Committee has the power to issue subpoenas for records and witness testimony.

“It is clear that Facebook is incapable of holding itself accountable,” the senators said. “The Wall Street Journal’s reporting reveals Facebook’s leadership to be focused on a growth-at-all-costs mindset that valued profits over the health and lives of children and teens.”

When asked about the Journal articles on Wednesday, White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki said US President Joe Biden thinks there are “serious issues around how much power Internet platforms have amassed in our society and certainly some of that reporting is an example of that.”

Tech giants, including Facebook, have been under increasing pressure from lawmakers questioning how companies handle user data, protect user safety and expand their market share and influence.

While legislation aimed at regulating content moderation and privacy practices have stalled, there is momentum for antitrust measures that take aim at the companies’ size and dominance.

A spokesman for Colorado Representative Ken Buck, the ranking Republican on the House antitrust subcommittee, said the recent revelations about Facebook underscore why legislation is needed to curb the power of dominant tech firms.

“Because Big Tech operates with almost unchecked power and answers only to themselves, it is not surprising they continue to peddle their products to children even though they are aware of the massive negative consequences children experience from engaging with their sites,” Mr Buck’s spokesman Mr Nick Givas told Bloomberg.

A Facebook spokesman referred to an earlier blog post from Ms Karina Newton, Instagram’s head of public policy, about what internal and external research found regarding social media’s impact on young people.

“The question on many people’s minds is if social media is good or bad for people,” Ms Newton wrote. “The research on this is mixed; it can be both. At Instagram, we look at the benefits and the risks of what we do.”

Lawmakers from both parties previously raised concerns about tech’s impact on young people. Washington Representative Cathy McMorris Rodgers, the ranking Republican on the House Energy and Commerce Committee, opened a March hearing with Mr Zuckerberg and other tech executives by saying their platforms are her “biggest fear as a parent” – a complaint she echoed Tuesday.

Ms McMorris Rodgers and other House Republicans wrote to Facebook after that March hearing to request the company’s internal research on the impact its platforms have on mental health.

She said the company did not comply, “and we now know why”.

“We will continue to demand transparency from Facebook and other Big Tech companies, especially as it relates to the harm their products have on our children,” Ms McMorris Rodgers said Wednesday. “Parents deserve the truth.”

Senator Ed Markey, a Massachusetts Democrat, on Wednesday sent a letter to Mr Zuckerberg asking if he was personally aware of the internal research that showed mental health risks and requesting copies of those studies.

The letter, also signed by Democratic Representatives Ms Kathy Castor of Florida and Ms Lori Trahan of Massachusetts, demands that Facebook abandon plans to create an Instagram for children and gives the company until Oct 6 to respond.

The Journal story focuses on the mental health risks such as anxiety and depression for young people, especially girls, who use Instagram, the photo-sharing app.

The article references a letter that Mr Blumenthal and Ms Blackburn sent to Facebook last month seeking more information on how the company’s internal research informs products designed for children and teens.

But Facebook’s reply to the senators did not include the company study detailed in the article.

“When given the opportunity to come clean to us about their knowledge of Instagram’s impact on young users, Facebook provided evasive answers that were misleading and covered up clear evidence of significant harm,” the senators said.

Facebook also exempts certain celebrities, politicians and other high-profile users from some its own rules for posts as part of a programme launched as a quality-control mechanism, the Wall Street Journal reported on Monday.

The programme, referred to as “cross check” or “XCheck”, shields millions of elite users from rules that Facebook claims to apply equally at the social network, according to a report citing internal documents.

Facebook spokesman Andy Stone in a series of tweets defended the programme, but noted the social media giant is aware its enforcement of rules is “not perfect”.

“There aren’t two systems of justice; it’s an attempted safeguard against mistakes,” Mr Stone tweeted in response to the Journal report.

“We know our enforcement is not perfect and there are trade-offs between speed and accuracy.”

The article cites examples of posts from high-profile people, including one from soccer star Neymar showing nude images of a woman who accused him of rape and that Facebook subsequently removed.

A double-standard regarding content moderation would defy assurances Facebook gave to an independent board set up as a final arbiter of disputes regarding what is allowed to be posted at the leading social network.

“The Oversight Board has expressed on multiple occasions its concern about the lack of transparency in Facebook’s content moderation processes, especially relating to the company’s inconsistent management of high-profile accounts,” board spokesman John Taylor said in response to an AFP inquiry.

The Journal article reports that some users are “white-listed”, given protection from enforcement actions, while in other cases reviews of potentially problematic content simply fail to take place.

“White-listed” accounts have shared claims that Ms Hillary Clinton had covered up “paedophile rings”, and that then-president Donald Trump had called all refugees seeking asylum “animals”, according to the Journal.

XCheck grew to include at least 5.8 million users in 2020, the report indicated.

Facebook said in a post about cross-checking three years ago that it does not protect the profile, page or content from being removed but “is simply done to make sure our decision is correct”.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Legendary wrestler has both legs amputated after walking struggle revealed as deadly infection

Former wrestler Jimmy Rave has had both of his legs amputated following an MRSA infection, just months after he had his left arm removed. “Apparently it’s time for me to ... Read more »

33 great gifts for babies and newborns

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Babies may not realize the holiday season is upon us, but ... Read more »

Could a technological fix save the planet from climate change?

Pessimism is growing about humanity’s ability to save the planet as world leaders prepare to convene for climate change talks at the COP26 summit in Glasgow on October 31. Faced ... Read more »

China says it has a quantum computer a million times more powerful than Google's

Researchers from the University of Science and Technology of China recently published a paper indicating they’ve created a quantum computer that’s one million times faster than Google’s Sycamore machine. According ... Read more »

Cyber Monday computer deals 2021: the best computers for less

Cyber Monday computer deals are a few weeks away but it’s never too early to plan to get the best prices possible on a new computer, whether it be one ... Read more »

Rome could have flying taxis by 2024

Passengers flying into Rome from 2024 onwards will be able to go airborne for their taxi ride into the city centre, if a project between the company operating its main ... Read more »

The Maldives is threatened by rising seas – but coastal development is causing even more pressing environmental issues

Coastal erosion and dwindling resources driven by tourism are some of the challenges facing the Maldives. Author provided As UN climate conference COP26 approaches, vulnerable nations are rightly highlighting how ... Read more »

Violence and mental health are likely to get worse in a warming world

As heat levels increase, mental health conditions are likely to be worsened. Pxfuel Extreme weather has been the cause of some of the biggest public health crises across the world ... Read more »

Millions of healthcare records exposed in mega data breach

A non-password protected database containing millions of healthcare records and 68.53GB of medical related data has been discovered by security researcher Jeremiah Fowler and the Website Planet research team. The ... Read more »

Great White Sharks Have Bad Eyesight, Which Can Cause Them to Attack Humans, Study Finds

great white shark Getty Sharks appear to have trouble seeing the difference between humans and seals. A new study, published in the Journal of the Royal Society Interface, revealed that ... Read more »

Intel, Microsoft brining Android apps & developer tool chain to Windows

Panos Panay, Microsoft Executive Vice President and Chief Product Officer & Gregory Bryant “GB”, Executive Vice President and General Manager of Client Computing Group at Intel, joins Yahoo Finance to ... Read more »

It's time CEOs gave SEO the attention it deserves - here's why

CEOs likely know from their marketing departments that paid techniques are just one branch of their digital marketing efforts. In reality, the tactics for digital marketing constantly evolve in line ... Read more »

Microsoft 365 skvallrar för din chef om du beter dig riskabelt på nätet

Microsoft jobbar på ett par nya uppdateringar av sin upplaga produktivitetsverktyg som ska låta företagen hålla ett öga på hur de anställda använder webben. Enligt en uppdatering av företagets roadmap ... Read more »

The end of Olympus cameras is sad, but OM Systems' plans could soften the blow

If you’ve seen a camera-loving friend gently whimpering today, it’s likely because they heard the news that Olympus cameras are officially finito – instead, from today new models will be ... Read more »

Budget: Universal credit changes will mean the 'poorest get nothing'

The chancellor has been accused of giving the poorest “nothing” (Getty Images) The poorest people on universal credit will receive no extra from the budget help to make up for ... Read more »

Murderer denied parole as Helen's law used for first time

In its judgment, the parole board said Glyn Razzell’s failure to disclose the location of his wife’s body revealed a controlling behaviour – PA Helen’s law has been used for ... Read more »

Female politician raped multiple times by 'insidious' partner as she slept, court rules

Details emerged at the Family Division of the High Court in London. (Getty) A female politician was a victim of “multiple” domestic rapes, a family court judge has concluded. The ... Read more »

Surfshark is the first VPN provider to launch a Cookie popup blocker

Cookie popups in your browser can distract you while you work which is why the VPN provider Surfshark has added a new feature to its browser extensions designed to block ... Read more »

Tuft & Needle makes our favorite mattress in a box—and it's 30% off right now

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. With the Black Friday shopping rush underway, one great gift to ... Read more »

India needs National cybersecurity strategy: Leaders at Microsoft ExpertSpeak

As part of Cybersecurity Awareness Month, Microsoft organized the third edition of ExpertSpeak, a curated dialogue series with industry experts, on India’s evolving threat landscape and securing cyberspace at scale. ... Read more »

Top-rated All-Clad pans are on sale at Macy's now—shop our picks

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. It’s Black Friday early at Macy’s, with a great deal on ... Read more »

Amazon's new smart TVs are available now – but here's why you should wait to buy one

Amazon announced that its new Omni Series smart TVs are now on sale through its website – but you might want to wait a few weeks before you buy one. ... Read more »

Want to look better on video calls? This 'dummy proof' Logitech webcam is now $27 at Amazon

We may receive commission from purchases made via links on this page. Pricing and availability are subject to change. Believe it or not, this wildly popular webcam is on sale ... Read more »

Intel unveils 12th Gen Intel Core; launches 'world's best gaming processor', i9-12900K

Today at Intel Innovation, Intel unveiled the 12th Gen Intel Core processor family with the launch of six new unlocked desktop processors, including what it claims is the world’s best ... Read more »

Chicago just approved one of the US's largest basic-income pilots: $500 monthly payments for 5,000 people

Marquisha Byrd makes face shields for frontline responders at Dimo’s Pizza in Chicago, April 16, 2020. Kamil Krzaczynski/AFP/Getty Images Chicago's city council voted Wednesday to approve one of the US's ... Read more »

[Awards] Incheon Free Economic Zone communicates with globe

Kim Jae-beomINCHEON FREE ECONOMIC ZONE AUTHORITY By Kim Jae-beomDirector of media & culture division I am very glad to see the Incheon Free Economic Zone Authority being recognized at The ... Read more »

Cybercriminals claim to have hacked NRA

A ransomware group that experts say is based in Russia has posted what it claims are 13 National Rifle Association files to the dark web. Read more »

A beginner's guide to AI: Ethics

Welcome to Neural’s beginner’s guide to AI. This multi-part feature should provide you with a very basic understanding of what AI is, what it can do, and how it works. ... Read more »

Adobe Photoshop and Illustrator are coming to your web browser

Collaborating with others using Adobe’s graphic design software will soon be even easier as the company has announced that two of the most popular products from Creative Cloud will soon ... Read more »

22 awesome gifts wine lovers actually want

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Finding the right gifts for wine lovers is no easy fête. ... Read more »

Maryland congressman deactivates Facebook account

ANNAPOLIS, Md. (AP) — A Maryland congressman announced Wednesday that he has deactivated his official congressional and campaign Facebook and Instagram accounts until their parent company and Congress make substantial ... Read more »

Watch: When Google CEO Sundar Pichai forgot to unmute himself

Google parent Alphabet CEO Sundar Pichai has shared a video where while talking he forgot to unmute himself. Pichai has shared the two-minute long video of the incident on Twitter. ... Read more »

Sony might release a terrible VR headset soon, but don't worry, it's not PSVR 2

This week’s VR headset updates keep coming with the latest being a leak suggesting Sony is working on a non-PSVR 2 virtual reality device. Earlier this week Pimax unveiled its ... Read more »

Call of Duty: Vanguard won't eat up as much hard drive space as previous games

Activision Blizzard Lawsuit Publisher Activision Blizzard, responsible for the game this article refers to, is currently embroiled in ongoing litigation in regards to claims reporting a workplace culture that allegedly ... Read more »

The new Nokia G300 elevates what an affordable phone can do

Getting the best value when buying a new phone can be tricky. You can always just buy the latest and greatest thing, but not everyone has $1,000 to drop on ... Read more »

Should you buy a new Kindle Paperwhite now or wait for the Black Friday deals?

Read more »

Apple's new SharePlay feature for FaceTime will soon support TikTok, NBA and Disney+

On Monday, Apple rolled out an update to iPhones so users could talk on FaceTime while watching their favorite shows and movies or listening to music. Soon, iPhone owners on ... Read more »

Amid a computer chip and car parts shortage, GM third-quarter profits plummet 40%

General Motors reported Wednesday that its third-quarter net income plummeted 40% as it struggled against production constraints and thin new car inventory. The auto industry has faced a global shortage ... Read more »

Early Black Friday deal drops the Surface Pro 7 to $599 - the lowest price ever

Early Black Friday deals are live at Best Buy, and we’ve just spotted a massive price cut on Microsoft’s versatile Surface Pro 7. Right now, you can get the Surface ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic