Facebook's policing of vitriol is even more lackluster outside the US, critics say

Asia's Tech News Daily

On a cloudy evening in Nairobi, Berhan Taye is scrolling through a spreadsheet in which she has helped document more than 140 Facebook posts from Ethiopia that contain hate speech. There are videos of child abuse, texts of hate speech against different ethnic groups, and hours-long live streams inciting hatred. These posts breach Facebook community guidelines in any context. Yet for Taye and her colleagues, this is what Facebook’s news feed has looked like for years in Ethiopia.

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Sascha Steinbach/EPA
© Photograph: Sascha Steinbach/EPA A float depicting hate speech at Facebook shaped like the monster from the movie Alien in Düsseldorf, Germany.

Because there aren’t enough content moderators focused on Ethiopia, it has been up to Taye, an independent researcher looking at technology’s impact on civil society, and a team of grassroots volunteers to collect and then report misinformation and hate speech to Facebook.

Related: WhatsApp to bring in encryption for backup chats after privacy fears

It’s dangerous work – people who put out the hate speech are organized – so volunteers are anonymous. They spend hours watching violent live streams and collating hateful content. It takes a toll on their mental health.

Once they send their report over email it can take a week for Facebook to respond – if they’re lucky – and sometimes 70% of the content will be removed, according to Taye. In some situations, the big tech company has come back to the activists requesting translations of the content. “Over and over again, we’re seeing they’re actively failing every time,” Taye says.

“They’re not willing to invest in human rights, invest in resources, and in languages that are not making them money.”

Facebook disputes that it does not crack down on abuse with the same intensity outside the US, saying it spends $13bn globally to tackle this in work that involves 15,000 people across dozens of languages.

Researchers like Taye say that’s not enough.

In June, Facebook reported it had removed a network of fake accounts in Ethiopia targeting domestic users ahead of the country’s elections.

Taye, however, said she has been in conversations with Facebook since 2018 about the situation in Ethiopia, a country where there has been ethnic cleansing, where armed conflict is escalating, and where Facebook is a crucial platform for information.

Now, Taye is calling for Facebook to release any human rights impact assessment reports it may hold on Ethiopia.

Like many digital activists around the world, Taye and her colleagues have been urging Facebook for years to take seriously how its algorithm incites misinformation, hate-speech, and ethnic violence in non-English speaking regions.

It’s an issue Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen highlighted in her testimony to US congress at the beginning of October, when she said Facebook’s system of content ranking had led to the spread of misinformation and hate speech.

Content ranking works by using machine-learning models to remove or demote bad content, but it is only trained for certain types of content. Haugen said Facebook knows: “Engagement-based ranking is dangerous without integrity and security systems.”

She added the problem was far worse in regions where posts are in languages other than English. She said the “strategy of focusing on language-specific, content-specific systems for AI to save us is doomed to fail”.


For digital rights activists, Haugen’s testimony in Congress came as no surprise. “We’ve been the victims of that,” Taye says. “It’s good for Americans to know. But we’ve been saying this. The first thing you see when you open your Facebook is the most heinous content.

“What do they think the Rohingya were saying? What was [Philippines journalist] Maria Ressa saying? Most Facebook users are not in America and Europe,” she says.

Haugen was the whistleblower who gathered documents that formed the Wall Street Journal’s Facebook Files investigation. The WSJ reported that one internal document revealed that Facebook’s work on misinformation in 2020 included 3.2m hours of searches, but only 13% of this was outside the US; more than 90% of Facebook users are outside the US. Facebook disputes the 13% statistic, which it says reflects just one program of many.

Networks of digital rights and human rights activists around the world have been pressing Facebook to release their reports and to run risk-assessments before they enter markets.

Eliška Pírková, the global freedom of expression lead of Access Now, a human rights organisation, called for human rights-centric regulation of online platforms such as Facebook. She said Facebook users needed to be protected by default from dark patterns that are a result of interface design that nudges users towards certain behaviour.

Haugen’s testimony confirmed what civil society already knew, Pírková said, and revealed the company’s “inherent opacity and unwillingness to disclose information and how algorithms operate”.

“Civil society shouldn’t have to hold Facebook to account,” she said, adding engagement with the company had not been very meaningful and there had been no follow-up.

She pointed to Facebook’s moderation process during the events of May 2021, when Palestinians were evicted from Sheikh Jarrah in Jerusalem and during the 11-day bombardment of Gaza, which led to mob violence against Palestinians incited on WhatsApp groups, while pro-Palestine posts were removed from Facebook platforms.

If Facebook did not learn lessons from the past, it would be countries in the global south and historically oppressed and marginalized groups that would “pay the highest price for our mistakes”, she said.

Myanmar is an often cited case study when it comes to the catastrophic impact of disinformation and hate speech shared on Facebook. Myanmar became a “textbook example of ethnic cleansing” according to the UN, where in August 2017 more than 700,000 Rohingya were forced to flee violence in Rakhine state.

The country has seen a rapid rise in Facebook users: there were 1.2 million Facebook users in Myanmar in 2014, and by January 2019 there were 21 million.. By January 2021 there was 23.65 million users, about 40% of the population.

Victoire Rio, a digital rights researcher focusing on Myanmar, said Haugen’s testimony shone a spotlight on the discrepancies between what Facebook does in the US and the “lack of action and intervention” in the rest of the world.

At the beginning of Facebook’s presence in Myanmar, there were only two Burmese moderators at Facebook. Now there are 120, according to Rio.

“The amount of investment that’s going into trying to clean up and sanitize the content that gets through in the US is just not there in other parts,” Rio said. “But it took a genocide, it took the UN calling them out on it, and took the US Congress calling them out on it, the western press calling them out on it for, for us to finally be heard,” she said.

In a statement, a Facebook spokesperson said: “Our track record shows that we crack down on abuse outside the US with the same intensity that we apply to it within the US. We have invested $13bn globally to tackle this challenge and have 15,000 people reviewing content outside the US, covering more than 50 languages and working in more than 20 locations across the world.

“Our third-party fact-checking program includes over 80 partners who review content in more than 60 languages, with over 70 of those partners located outside of the US. We have also taken down over 150 networks seeking to manipulate public debate since 2017, and they have originated in over 50 countries, with the majority coming from or focused outside of the US.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


«Ich bin mir sicher, dass ich wieder der alte Tauli werde»

Taulant Xhaka steht beim 3:1-Sieg des FCB in Luzern in der Startformation – etwas, was in dieser Saison nicht mehr selbstverständlich ist. © Foto: Martin Meienberger (Freshfocus) Zupackend in Luzern: ... Read more »

Das «Ja» zum Covid-Gesetz war eindeutig – das fordern die Befürworter nun

© keystone Teaserbild «Die Demokratie funktioniert», sagte Gesundheitsminister Alain Berset nach dem klaren «Ja» zum Covid-Gesetz. Denn 62 Prozent der Stimmberechtigten haben sich zum Covid-Gesetz – und damit zum Corna-Zertifikat ... Read more »

COVID-19 varian Omicron: Maklumat yang anda perlu tahu

WHO telah mengeluarkan satu amaran tentang varian virus COVID-19 yang lebih berbahaya daripada varian Delta. Berdasarkan siaran media yang bertarikh 26 November 2021, Omicron adalah varian COVID-19 yang diberikan kod ... Read more »

Three things we learned: Griezmann, Atlético Madrid thrash Cádiz

© Photo By Joaquin Corchero/Europa Press via Getty Images All smiles. Coming off a defeat to AC Milan on Wednesday night, Atlético Madrid needed a big result in Cádiz. And ... Read more »

Thomas Tuchel's decisions in Man Utd draw questioned by ex-Chelsea assistant Jody Morris

Former Chelsea assistant boss Jody Morris has questioned Thomas Tuchel ‘s reluctance to make changes during the Blues’ 1-1 draw with Manchester United on Sunday. A huge error from Jorginho ... Read more »

Pundit delivers clear verdict on West Brom's promotion chances

© Provided by Football League World West Bromwich Albion v Stoke City – Barclays Premier League Danny Mills has revealed that he hasn’t been impressed with West Brom this season, ... Read more »

Gabriel Martinelli reignites Arsenal flame after spell in the cold

It had been 676 days since Gabriel Martinelli picked up the ball deep in Arsenal’s half, put his head to the floor, and sprinted like nothing could stand in his ... Read more »

Djokovic's father says world No 1 likely to skip Melbourne over vaccine rules

Novak Djokovic’s father says the world No 1 is unlikely to play at the Australian Open early next year unless rules on Covid-19 vaccinations are relaxed. Organisers of the year’s ... Read more »

Lin-Manuel Miranda, Sara Bareilles and More Perform Tribute to Stephen Sondheim in Times Square

© YouTube; Douglas Elbinger/Getty Images Celebrating the legacy of a theater legend. Hundreds of stage stars and members of the Broadway community came out to pay musical tribute to the ... Read more »

Covid-19 daily infections under 3,000 mark, with 18 hospital admissions

© Provided by SowetanLive The proportion of positive new cases/total new tested is 9.8% which is higher than yesterday (9.2%). The seven-day average is 6.1%. Six Covid-19 related deaths have ... Read more »

‘Panic-driven decisions must end': Madonsela slams reports calling Omicron ‘SA variant'

© Provided by Times Live Madonsela’s call comes after the new variant was labelled a “SA variant” by international commentators and on social media. The variant was first detected in ... Read more »

Transfer update involving Blackburn Rovers and Leeds United comes to light

© Provided by Football League World Premier League – Leeds United v Liverpool A decision is yet to be made over the loan of Ian Poveda to Blackburn Rovers from ... Read more »

Thiago Alcantara and Diogo Jota help paint picture of Liverpool's tactical evolution

In the aftermath of Storm Liverpool, Ralph Hasenhuttl was still a little shook, still a lot in awe. The Southampton manager was at pains to try and paint how “hard ... Read more »

Robredo signs covenant promoting workers' welfare

Vice President Maria Leonor “Leni” Robredo signed a covenant with a group of labor leaders to promote the welfare of workers. Robredo inked the covenant on Monday with the Alliance ... Read more »

Can you solve it? Yule devour these festive treats

Read more »

Rod Stewart Admits He And Elton John ‘Don't Speak To Each Other Much Any More'

Rod Stewart is discussing his rocky relationship with Elton John. © Photo: KMazur/WireImage Rod Stewart and Sir Elton John While speaking to the BBC Sounds podcast “Headliners”, Stewart revealed how ... Read more »

Celebrity birthdays for Nov. 29

Celebrity Birthdays for Nov. 29:   Hall of Fame sportscaster Vin Scully is 94. Blues musician John Mayall is 88. Actress Diane Ladd is 86. Musician Chuck Mangione is 81. Country singer ... Read more »

Waukesha residents hold vigil and a moment of silence a week after parade car attack that killed six as a ninth child is discharged from hospital, with seven others recovering from injuries

Residents of Waukesha, Wisconsin held a moment of silence on Sunday and lit the city blue to honor the victims of the Christmas parade tragedy Mayor Shawn Reilly held the silence at 4:39 pm on Sunday exactly one week after the tragedy which saw a driver plow through a crowd in a parade It resulted in the deaths of six people, including an 8-year-old boyOn Sunday, a ninth child was discharged from the hospital - with a further seven still recovering from their injuries  Read more »

B4SA calls for unjabbed citizens to be banned from restaurants, public transport

© Kaylynn Palm/Eyewitness News Jody Ziervogel gets his COVID-19 vaccine shot at the ATlone Stadium drive-through facility in Cape Town on 2 September 2021. CAPE TOWN – Unvaccinated South Africans ... Read more »

Honduras set for woman president as leftist Castro declares victory

1 / 4Honduras set for woman president as leftist Castro declares victoryGeneral election in Honduras By Gustavo Palencia and David Alire Garcia TEGUCIGALPA (Reuters) – Honduran opposition leader Xiomara Castro ... Read more »

Omicron update: What the UAE is doing to tackle the new variant

© Motivate Publishing dubai skyline The NCEMA has urged residents to get boosters jabs… The National Emergency Crisis and Disaster Management Authority (NCEMA) has made a series of announcements in ... Read more »

Atrangi Re song Chaka Chak: Don't miss Sara Ali Khan's dance moves to A.R Rahman's catchy tune! - Watch

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Anand L Rai’s Atrangi Re’s first song ‘Chaka Chak’ is finally out on YouTube and is already winning the hearts of fans. Sung ... Read more »

Kanye West dedicates Sunday Service to late friend Virgil Abloh

© Bang Showbiz Kanye West dedicates Sunday Service to Virgil Abloh Kanye West dedicated his Sunday Service to his late friend and longtime collaborator, Virgil Abloh. The influential fashion designer ... Read more »

BTS concert: Jin turns up in a Squid Game doll inspired ponytail; ARMY has a swell time playing 'red light green light' with him – view tweets

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com And just like that the Day 2 of Permission To Dance on Stage has come to an end. Today Megan Thee Stallion performed at the concert ... Read more »

Weekly Tarot Card Readings: Horoscope from November 29 to December 5, 2021

© Provided by Zee News Aries It appears that things are not going perfect in your love life at the moment. Insecurities, lack of trust or deceit might affect your ... Read more »

Lady Gaga hails Tony Bennett's wife Susan 'remarkable'

© Bang Showbiz Lady Gaga hails Tony Bennett’s wife ‘remarkable’ Lady Gaga has heaped praise on Tony Bennett’s “remarkable wife” Susan for “the love” she has for her husband. The ... Read more »

Anil Bishnoi to debut in Bollywood with Abbas-Mustan thriller based on 'Money Heist'

© IANS Anil Bishnoi. Mumbai, Nov 29 (IANS) TV actor Anil Bishnoi is excited to join upcoming Bollywood movie ‘Three Monkeys’ directed by Abbas-Mustan which is based on the hit ... Read more »

Greenpeace: half a century on the frontline of environmental photo activism

Fifty years ago, on 15 September 1971, a ship named the Greenpeace set out to confront and stop US nuclear weapons testing at Amchitka, one of the Aleutian Islands in ... Read more »

Mob attacks Pakistan police, fail to grab blasphemy suspect

PESHAWAR, Pakistan — A Muslim mob burned a police station and four police posts overnight in northwest Pakistan after officers refused to hand over a mentally unstable man accused of ... Read more »

Food, gas prices pinch families as inflation surges globally

The Associated PressFILE – A Black Friday shopper wearing a face mask leaves a Walmart store with a TV in Pic Rivera Calif., Friday, Nov. 26, 2021. From appliance stores ... Read more »

'I know the truth and she knows the truth': Man jailed for the murder of Meredith Kercher is freed from prison and points the finger at Amanda Knox over 2007 murder of British student in Italy

Rudy Guede, 34, served 13 years in prison for the murder of Meredith Kercher in Perugia, Italy, in November 2007His DNA was found at the scene and he agreed to a fast-track trial and a guilty pleaGuede was released on November 23 and said that he was on the scene because he tried to stem the bleeding from Kercher's stab woundsHe said that he was not the one who wielded the fatal blow, implying that Amanda Knox was behind the murderKnox and her then-boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito spent almost four years in prison before being acquitted in 2015, and have always protested their innocence  Read more »

Video: Stampede at the O2: Shocking moment music fans storm arena knocking down security guards and scanners to get into sold out Wizkid gig 

Read more »

End of an era: Prince Charles touches down in Barbados for ceremony to remove his mother Queen Elizabeth as head of state after Caribbean nation decided to become a republic

Queen's oldest son arrived in Barbados on Sunday ahead of a ceremony marking the dawn of their republicHer Majesty will no longer be head of state. Dame Sandra Mason will be sworn in as Barbados's first presidentBarbados is one of the Queen's 16 realms, countries where she's head of state, but will this will end on Tuesday Read more »

Kansas Democrat Representative, 21, is arrested for DUI weeks after he was detained for 'hitting and spitting on his brother and threatening to attack his grandfather'

Kansas Democrat Representative Aaron Coleman, 21, was arrested for a DUI on Saturday morningColeman had been on bail on charges of misdemeanor battery after allegedly hitting and spitting on his brother as well as threatening his grandfather Other state officials have vocalized their support for Coleman's resignation following his string of erratic behaviorHe had also been accused of previous violence against women which had surfaced before he took position in office  Read more »

Video: Shocking moment Arizona man IMPALES his neck on kitchen knife after brandishing it at cop called out to suspicious house fire, prompting officer to tase him 

Read more »

DoJ accuses Steve Bannon of 'misleading and frivolous' attempts to turn his prosecution for refusing to testify before January 6 committee into a 'public spectacle'

Bannon on November 17 pleaded not guilty to criminal charges filed after he defied a subpoena issued by a congressional panel Bannon, the first person to face charges in connection with the House probe, handed himself in to the FBI on Monday after last week being indicted He claims communications with the former president are covered by 'executive privilege' and that the investigation is politically motivated Prosecutors for the DoJ accused Bannon's defense team - led by Evan Corcoran - of stalling their efforts to reach an evidence-sharing agreement Instead, according to the Justice Department, Bannon's lawyers used a public court filing to complain about the case  Read more »

Museums must take responsibility for history of benefiting from slavery, claims curator of new Tate Britain exhibition

Museums 'must take responsibility for their history of benefitting from slavery'Tate Britain curator David A Bailey said exhibit explored museum's own pastOriginal collection was funded in 19th Century by sugar refiner Sir Henry TateMuseum said 'it is not possible to separate the Tate galleries from the history of colonial slavery from which in part they derive their existence' Read more »

Jennifer Hawkins and husband Jake Wall dress down in activewear as they step out for a walk with their newborn son Hendrix and daughter Frankie

Jennifer Hawkins and Jake Wall enjoyed a family day out in Sydney on Monday.  The model, 37. and her property developer husband, 38, dressed down as they took a stroll with ... Read more »

British pubgoers trapped in bar with Oasis cover band amid blizzard

British fans of an Oasis tribute band spent the weekend confined to a remote Yorkshire pub with the group when a mountain of snow trapped them all in the bar. ... Read more »

'Pressure is a privilege' for Ireland's US-born striker and Danish club's captain

© Laszlo Geczo INPHO Kyra Carusa was a second-half substitute against Slovakia on Thursday night. WITH THE HUNT on for a winner down the home straight of the Republic of ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic