Facebook whistleblower warns ‘dangerous' encryption will aid espionage by hostile nations

Asia's Tech News Daily

Former Facebook employee and whistleblower Frances Haugen speaking before a Senate Committee – Drew Angerer/Reuters

Earlier this month, Facebook’s founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg posted a short video on Instagram of him with his wife Priscilla Chan serenely enjoying a sailing trip with friends.

The intimate clip was seemingly part of a new PR strategy to distance the 37-year-old from his company's mounting scandals and associate him with Facebook’s futuristic gadgets, such as the video-shooting sunglasses he filmed the nautical scene on.

Yet within 48 hours of the sailing post that strategy was sunk as a former Facebook executive, Frances Haugen, dramatically unmasked herself as the whistleblower behind a devastating series of leaks that have since plunged the social media giant into its deepest crisis to date.

After going public, Ms Haugen called on Facebook to “declare moral bankruptcy” over the way it had prioritised “growth at all costs” when addressing the harms its addictive algorithms are wreaking on users.

Now in her first UK interview, Ms Haugen, who is coming to London to give evidence before Parliament on Monday, is warning that Facebook’s controversial encryption plans mean it will lose sight of espionage operations being perpetrated on its apps by hostile nations.

Speaking to the Sunday Telegraph she also expressed concern about the effect Facebook-owned Instagram may have had on the British schoolgirl Molly Russell, who took her life after viewing self-harm and suicide material on the app.

Frances Haugen arrives to testify during a Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation hearing – Jabin Botsford/Pool via CNP / Avalon

Ms Haugen has taken issue with her former Facebook boss Sir Nick Clegg, comparing the argument that some users are also responsible for the problematic material Facebook shows them to that of a domestic abuser blaming their victim for making them violent.

Ms Haugen, who was responsible for detecting and disrupting espionage operations during her time at Facebook, tackled efforts by Chinese operatives to implant spying software onto the phones of Uighur dissidents.

She warned that Facebook will not be able to uncover such operations if it goes ahead with its controversial plans to encrypt its Messenger app as well as Instagram’s direct messages – meaning not even the company will be able to see what users are sending.

Describing her work, Ms Haugen said: “A key part of [Chinese operatives’] strategy was to send malware to Uighurs who lived in places that weren’t China, as if they could compromise one phone they could compromise a whole community. We said we won’t be able to see the malware anymore [with encryption].”

Her comments come as Facebook is facing mounting pressure from the UK Government to ditch its encryption plan.

Earlier this year, Priti Patel, the Home Secretary, criticised the proposals saying they would allow harmful material such as child abuse images to “proliferate” on Facebook’s apps.

Ms Haugen warned that Facebook’s encryption plans, which the company argues are to enhance privacy, are in reality an attempt to hide the harmful material circulating on its apps rather than tackle it.

She said: “End-to-end encryption definitely lets them sidestep and go ‘look we can’t see it, not our problem’.”

A Facebook spokesman said: “The reason we believe in end-to-end encryption is precisely so that we can keep people safe, including from foreign interference and surveillance as well as hackers and criminals.

“We will maintain the ability to receive user reports of suspicious messages, which will help indicate if there is a coordinated abuse of our services.”

Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen is interviewed by Scott Pelley for a CBS News 60 Minutes programme – Robert Fortunato/Reuters

In her interview, Ms Haugen expressed concern about the impact Facebook algorithms within its Instagram app may have had on British teenager Molly Russell, who took her life just six days before her 15th birthday in 2017.

Her father, Ian, later accused Instagram of “helping to kill” his daughter after he discovered she had been viewing self-harm and suicide material on the app.

An inquest is due to be held next year to establish if social media algorithms “overwhelmed” the teenager with the content they showed her, which is yet to be determined.

Ms Haugen said she recognised the Russell family’s fears about the impact Instagram may have had on their daughter and warned its algorithms may have started showing her self-harm material even without the teenager directly searching for it.

She said: “In the case of Molly Russell, she may have been feeling kind of blue and might have followed some stuff related to feeling a little blue. I guarantee you that, with the algorithm, if she kept engaging, it just kept getting worse.”

“Imagine you are kind of a fragile teen and you are being exposed to a little bit of stuff talking about how you are worthless, and then [you] engage a little bit and it keeps getting worse and worse. It is bad.”

A Facebook spokesman said: “We’ve never allowed content that promotes or encourages suicide, self-harm or eating disorders, and in the last few years we’ve updated our policies to ban even more content, including all graphic imagery.”

Photo of Molly Russell in school uniform – PA

Ms Haugen, who holds an MBA from Harvard, joined Facebook in 2019 after a high-flying career in Silicon Valley that saw her work at Google as well as the social media site Pinterest and the business review app Yelp.

During her career she had worked on those companies’ algorithms – which decide what users see in their apps – impacting everything from which websites come top of search results to the order of posts in users’ social media feeds.

The 37-year-old initially joined Facebook to work as the lead product manager countering misinformation ahead of the 2020 Presidential election before moving onto counter-espionage operations.

However, during her two years at the company Ms Haugen said she became increasingly disheartened at what she saw as the company repeatedly made decisions to put its vast profits above fixing the harms its algorithms were causing.

Her main concern is over the way Facebook uses “engagement-based ranking” to choose what people see in their newsfeeds. In layman's terms, this means its algorithms select videos and posts that it deems a user is most likely to engage with by liking or sharing them with their friends.

The danger with this system, Ms Haugen argues, is that the posts people are most likely to engage with are ones that elicit an “extreme reaction” such as conspiracies and hate speech, leading algorithms to show people increasingly dangerous content.

To back-up her concerns, the former executive has released pages of documents of Facebook’s own research that lay bare the impact engagement-based ranking can have on users.

Among the research, according to Ms Haugen, is one investigation showing how the algorithm can lead people from being shown innocuous content to far more harmful material, such as searches for healthy recipes leading to the algorithm eventually recommending eating disorder posts.

Other documents leaked by Ms Haugen earlier this month showed research indicating that Instagram can be particularly toxic for teenage girls. Internal papers found the app made one in three feel worse about their bodies and that one in seven teenage girls with suicidal thoughts traced their origin to using the app.

More details from the cache of research documents are due to be released later this week as they are poured through by an international coalition of journalists.

Frances Haugen photographed in the Russell Building corridor – Tom Williams/Getty Images

Facebook has argued that the leaked findings are not representative of how Instagram affects young users and that its research also showed the app helps teenagers struggling with anxiety and loneliness.

Ms Haugen’s bombshell intervention comes as the UK Government is drawing up legislation to impose a statutory Duty of Care on tech companies to prevent their algorithms harming people, a measure the Sunday Telegraph has campaigned for since 2018.

The regime, which will be policed by Ofcom, will see tech companies face fines that could run into the billions if they breach the duty or even be barred from the UK in the most serious cases.

Ms Haugen backed the Sunday Telegraph’s Duty of Care campaign saying tech companies should be legally “responsible for the decisions they make”.

She added: “If they intentionally pick their algorithms, they should be responsible for their algorithms.”

As Ms Haugen arrives in London, Westminster is also debating whether to tighten online laws in the wake of the death of MP David Amess.

Boris Johnson this week said he is considering allowing criminal prosecutions of executives at tech companies that allow “foul content to permeate the internet”.

Ms Haugen argued that the spectre of criminal prosecution for tech bosses would make them take regulation “more seriously”.

“I do think when you have higher consequences people do take things more seriously and personalising those effects mean people take personal sanctions even more seriously,” she said.

Yet, Ms Haugen warned that simply banning certain content would not stop extremist and conspiratorial material circulating on social media unless the algorithms spreading it are checked.

During her time at Facebook, she said she watched its algorithms ‘concentrate’ misinformation and hate content on small groups of users who engaged with it, meaning that in effect around 80 per cent of all Covid misinformation went to less than five per cent of the app’s users.

She said: “The real problem and the thing that leads to extremism is when a small group of people overwhelmingly get hate content.”

Facebook has hit back at Haugen’s accusation that it put its profits before its users' safety, with Mr Zuckerberg saying in a recent blog post the characterisation “just isn’t true”.

The CEO said the idea that Facebook actively promotes harmful content is “illogical”’ as its advertisers don’t want to see their ads next to it.

Former Leader of the Liberal Democrats Nick Clegg speaks at the Liberal Democrat Party Conference – Jack Taylor/Getty News

Former Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg, who is now Facebook’s head of policy and communications, has also previously defended how the company’s algorithms work. In a blog post in March entitled ‘it takes two to tango’, Sir Nick argued Facebook users were not “the playthings of manipulative algorithmic systems”, but actively influence what the app shows them by deciding what they click on.

Ms Haugen rejected Mr Clegg’s argument.

She said: “That article, it is almost like a domestic abuser saying ‘if you didn’t make me so angry I wouldn’t hit you so much’.

“He said it takes two to tango, but no. If you go and follow pretty innocuous things just following the algorithm you get led to more and more extreme things because engagement based ranking is dangerous.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


This is now the world's most expensive city to live in, study says

© Provided by CNBC A cityscape of Tel Aviv, with the first skyscraper, The Meir Shalom tower, in front, and newer buildings such as the Azrieli towers and Moshe Aviv ... Read more »

Report: University of Chicago sees rise in anti-Black sentiment after murder of Asian student

An increase in anti-Black sentiment has reportedly been observed at the University of Chicago after the fatal shooting of a Chinese international student in early November. Driving the news: Shaoxiong ... Read more »

INOVIO Announces Strategy to Address Omicron (B.1.1.529) and Future SARS-CoV-2 Variants

INO-4800 has maintained broad T cell responses against previously known variants of concern PLYMOUTH MEETING, Pa., Nov. 30, 2021 /PRNewswire/ — INOVIO (NASDAQ:INO), a biotechnology company focused on bringing to ... Read more »

Officials investigate Oak Run deaths as double homicide

After two men were found shot to death in Oak Run on Monday, the Shasta County Sheriff's Office is investigating the incident as a double homicide. Sheriff's deputies and California ... Read more »

DC area leaders react to omicron variant

Leaders in the DMV are looking at options for responding to the looming omicron variant of COVID-19. Read more »

New rift opens between U.S. House Republicans over racism claims

A new fault line opened between Republicans in the U.S. House of Representatives on Tuesday, as lawmakers squabbled publicly over accusations of religious bigotry and racism among party conservatives. Read more »

Omicron: Two new cases of Covid variant found in London

Omicron: Two new cases of Covid variant found in London Two new cases of the Covid-19 variant Omicron have been detected in England, making it a total of five, the ... Read more »

Best TFT Set 6 11.23 B-patch comps

© Provided by Dot Esports Qualifiers for Teamfight Tactics Worlds have begun across multiple regions, showcasing a mostly established meta that will likely see a few shakeups via Patch 11.24.  ... Read more »

Twitch adds Suspicious User Detection tool to flag ban evaders

© Provided by Dot Esports Twitch shared with its users today a new safety tool has been added to the platform that will help detect users engaging in suspicious activities, ... Read more »

Residents' power saves Sheffield street names with links to the Empire

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Street names which have fallen foul of woke campaigners will be kept because residents do not want them changed. It comes after experts claimed ... Read more »

Rafa Benitez warned he will 'feel the heat' if Liverpool beat Everton

Everton manager Rafa Benitez has been warned that he will “feel the heat” if his side fail to stop Liverpool from picking up all three points in Wednesday night’s derby. ... Read more »

Captain Tom's Memorial Woodland unveiled in honour of NHS charity fundraiser

A swathe of ancient woodland and open ground will be renamed and planted with more trees in honour of Captain Sir Tom Moore, the Woodland Trust has said. © Provided ... Read more »

UK watchdog's action against Facebook over Giphy proves it has teeth

Big tech has two faces. One face presents a new form of company: inclusive, socially liberal, very much with the zeitgeist, supporting the Democrats rather than the Republicans, and different ... Read more »

Mikel Arteta shows he's learned from Pep Guardiola as Arsenal get boost for Man Utd game

Mikel Arteta has endured a difficult start to his managerial career at Arsenal. It’s nearly exactly two years since the Spaniard took charge at the Emirates Stadium, and he has ... Read more »

‘Cashback at the till' service being rolled out to more than 2,000 shops

A scheme enabling people to get cash from retailers’ tills without needing to make a purchase is to be rolled out to more than 2,000 shops before the end of ... Read more »

Murder investigation launched after 'at least three men were killed by drug dealers who forced them to overdose on meth'

South Australian Police launch major investigation into three deaths Robert Atkins, Trevor King and Jeff Mundy were allegedly murdered in Adelaide It is believed the three were intentionally given a lethal dose of a drug Multiple people may be involved in the alleged murders of the three men  Read more »

Time for my close-up! Curious meerkat is among VERY photogenic creatures which feature in Wildlife Photo of the Year awards (and YOU can help pick the best)

These images are in running for the People's Choice Award in Wildlife Photographer of the Year competition Organisers sifted through over 50,000 entries from 95 countries to put together a shortlist of just 25 pictures Public are being asked to vote for the winning image and have until February 4, 2022, to choose a favourite  Read more »

'I will NEVER fall out with him!': Leeds midfielder Kalvin Phillips denies any rift with boss Marcelo Bielsa amid reports of a feud following his half-time withdrawal against Brighton at the weekend

Kalvin Phillips had started out of position at defence against BrightonBut after moving to midfield he was replaced at half-time at the Amex StadiumBoss Marcelo Bielsa had denied a rift with the England star on MondayPhillips echoed a similar sentiment following Leeds' 1-0 win over Crystal Palace  Read more »

Video: Simon Baker admits he's NEVER watched The Devil Wears Prada despite starring in the movie - insisting he simply 'hasn't found the time'

Read more »

'Rust' armorer says barely checked gun before fatal shooting: police

© Patrick T. FALLON No charges have been levelled over the fatal shooting on the set of ‘Rust’ though investigators have refused to rule them out The woman in charge ... Read more »

RET Twitter accounts fire salvos at CABC, Daily Maverick and City Press in puzzling legal challenge

In a 377-page lawsuit filed by former EFF secretary-general Godrich Gardee, Twitter accounts identified with the RET advocacy network are accusing a UCT research contractor and media outlets including Daily ... Read more »

Police spent nearly £2MILLION unsticking Insulate Britain protesters from major roads

COPS spent nearly £2million ‘unsticking’ crusties from Insulate Britain protests on major roads it emerged. The huge policing cost comes as the Home Office has unveiled a raft of new ... Read more »

BREAKING NEWS: Biden administration is considering forcing all travelers returning to the US to quarantine for SEVEN DAYS to curb spread of COVID omicron variant - and may FINE people who flout it

Biden is considering whether to mandate a seven-day quarantine for all travelers returning to the U.S.Travelers would not be able to forego the quarantine, even with a negative Covid test, and could be fined for flouting itIt would be the first time a federal fine is linked to quarantine or testing measures for U.S. travelers Read more »

Being poor is fatal: Figures show the worrying gap in cancer death rates depending on wealth and postcode

Australians living in poorer areas are 40 per cent more likely to die from cancer, the latest government statistics show. People living in the wealthiest areas of Australia have a ... Read more »

Stonehenge builders fuelled themselves on sweet treats including 'Neolithic mince pies', excavation suggests

Excavation work has been led by English Heritage at Durrington Walls, WiltshireDurrington Walls was inhabited by the builders of Stonehenge in about 2,500 BCEvidence suggests traces of hazelnuts, sloes, apples and other fruits at the site  Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: 'I discovered it's actually really good fun!' Craig Revel Horwood says Covid helped him fall in love with Strictly all over again after virus forced him to miss first show in 17 years

Craig hilariously claimed he discovered that Strictly Come Dancing - on which he has been a judge since its 2004 launch - is 'actually really good fun'The choreographer, 56, made the revelation after testing positive for Covid-19 nearly two weeks ago, which forced him to pull out of his Saturday night dutiesHaving watched the BBC show on the small screen for the very first time, the ballroom veteran told MailOnline: 'I can see why people love it so much!''It was an interesting experience to watch the show as a normal person at home because, usually, I feel like I'm working' Latest Strictly Come Dancing 2021 news on Series 30 judges, dancers and contestants here Read more »

Gulls are as smart as parrots when they are foraging for food, study suggests

 Gulls could be as smart as parrots when it comes to getting a hold of food The birds are renowned for snatching chips from unwary visitors to the seaside They analysed wild ring-billed gulls to see if they could ‘work out’ a simple test Read more »

Video: Em Rusciano makes a VERY awkward observation about MasterChef judge Melissa Leong's new boyfriend after meeting him for the first time at Melbourne Fashion Week

Read more »

Marcus Rashford to write first fiction book inspired by his own childhood in fight against child poverty

MANCHESTER United ace Marcus Rashford is to publish his first fiction book in his latest fight against child poverty. The striker, 24, will co-write a story about a group of ... Read more »

Cheapest supermarket to buy your Christmas dinner revealed by Which?

THE cheapest supermarket Christmas dinner has been revealed – and you can get it from Aldi. Turkey and all the trimmings from all the major supermarkets have been put to ... Read more »

Emmanuel Macron wants Britain to set up an asylum-seeker processing centre in Calais to deal with migrant crisis

FRENCH President Emmanuel Macron wants Britain to set up an asylum-seeker processing centre in Calais to deal with the migrant crisis. He is expected to outline France’s solutions to the ... Read more »

Heinz releases unusual Terry's Chocolate Orange mixed with mayonnaise – will you try it?

DINERS with a taste for the unusual are in for a treat from today — mayonnaise mixed with Terry’s Chocolate Orange. Creator Heinz says the sweet festive concoction is for ... Read more »

Turns Out, The Office Finale Originally Featured A Scene That Would Have Disproved A Major Fan Theory

© Provided by CinemaBlend The Office cast The Office’s tearjerker of a series finale was released back in 2013, but it’s pretty safe to say the whole series is still ... Read more »

US expected to toughen testing requirement for travelers

© Provided by Associated Press President Joe Biden speaks to members of the media before boarding Air Force One at Minneapolis-Saint Paul International Airport in Minneapolis, Tuesday, Nov. 30, 2021, ... Read more »

The hot-button issues that will shape impending MLB shutdown

It’s about time to pay the tax on one heck of a Hot Stove League week. No, no one must pay actual taxes yet on the more than $1 billion ... Read more »

U.S. energy chief hints California may grant reprieve to its last nuclear plant

© Reuters/PHIL NOBLE FILE PHOTO: COP26 in Glasgow By Timothy Gardner WASHINGTON (Reuters) – California may reconsider whether to close its last nuclear power plant as public support has grown ... Read more »

Take our sex personality quiz to find out what REALLY turns you on… and who's your perfect match

FEELING unfulfilled between the sheets due to mismatched libidos or sexual desires can be a huge issue. Figuring out what makes you tick could be the key to enjoying better ... Read more »

Won't force LS adjournments, opposition leaders assure Speaker

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Raising the possibility that Lok Sabha could function from Wednesday, most opposition floor leaders assured Speaker Om Birla that they are ... Read more »

Rural wages: Kerala tops list, 15 states lag national average

© Provided by The Indian Express Rural workers in Kerala earn way more than their counterparts in more developed states like Gujarat and Maharashtra and over double the national average. ... Read more »

Digital technology rules as NFT tops art world power list

(Nyan Cat @prguitarman/Christopher Torres) The rise of digital art is complete after game changing technology NFT topped a chart of the most powerful influencers in the art world. NFT, which ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic