Facebook papers: What we know about how misinformation and extremism spread from whistleblower

Asia's Tech News Daily

Misinformation and extremism spreading unchecked. Hate speech sparking conflict and violence in the U.S. and abroad. Human traffickers sharing a platform with baby pictures and engagement announcements.

Despite its mission to bring people closer together, internal documents obtained by USA TODAY show that Facebook knew that users were being driven apart by a wide range of dangerous and divisive content on its platforms.

The documents were part of the disclosures made to the Securities and Exchange Commission by Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen. A consortium of news organizations, including USA TODAY, reviewed the redacted versions received by Congress.

The documents provide a rare glimpse into the internal decisions made at Facebook that affect nearly 3 billion users around the globe.

Concerned that Facebook was prioritizing profits over the well-being of its users, Haugen reviewed thousands of documents over several weeks before leaving the company in May.

►A tale of two accounts:The story of Carol and Karen: Two experimental Facebook accounts show how the company helped divide America

►Facebook rebrand on the horizon?:Is Facebook changing company name? Shift to metaverse ignites rebranding plan, report says

The documents, some of which have been the subject of extensive reporting by The Wall Street Journal and The New York Times, detail company research showing that toxic and divisive content is prevalent in posts boosted by Facebook and shared widely by users.

Concerns about how Facebook operates and its impact on teens have united congressional leaders. More political fallout could come when Haugen testifies Monday before the British Parliament.

Facebook’s response

Facebook is now facing the most intense scrutiny it has encountered since it launched in 2004.

CEO Mark Zuckerberg has defended the company and its practices, sharing in an internal staff memo that “it’s very important to me that everything we build is safe and good for kids.”

The company’s spokesman Andy Stone said in a statement to USA TODAY, “At the heart of these stories is a premise which is false. Yes, we’re a business and we make profit, but the idea that we do so at the expense of people’s safety or wellbeing misunderstands where our own commercial interests lie. The truth is we’ve invested $13 billion and have over 40,000 people to do one job: keep people safe on Facebook.”

Facebook papers: What we know about how misinformation and extremism spread from whistleblower

Nick Clegg, Facebook’s vice president of global affairs, echoed a similar sentiment in an extensive memo to staff on Saturday obtained by USA TODAY. Clegg told staff that they “shouldn’t be surprised to find ourselves under this sort of intense scrutiny.”

“I think most reasonable people would acknowledge social media is being held responsible for many issues that run much deeper in society – from climate change to polarization, from adolescent mental health to organized crime,” Clegg said. “That is why we need lawmakers to help. It shouldn’t be left to private companies alone to decide where the line is drawn on societal issues.

Sunday, Sen. Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., chair of the Consumer Protection Subcommittee that held Haugen’s testimony, told CNN that Facebook “ought to come clean and reveal everything.”

The spread of misinformation

The documents reveal the internal discussions and scientific experimentation surrounding misinformation and harmful content being spread on Facebook.

A change to the algorithm which prioritizes what users see in their News Feed rolled out in 2018 and was supposed to encourage “meaningful social interactions” and strengthen bonds with friends and family.

Facebook researchers discovered the algorithm change was exacerbating the spread of misinformation and harmful content and actively experimenting with ways to demote and contain that content, documents show.

►Who is Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen:Everything you need to know

►From Facebook friend to romance scammer:Older Americans increasingly targeted amid COVID pandemic

News Feeds with violence and nudity

Facebook’s research found that users with low digital literacy skills were significantly more likely to see graphic violence and borderline nudity in their News Feed.

The people most harmed by the influx of disturbing posts were Black, elderly and low-income, ​among other vulnerable groups, the research found. It also said Facebook also conducted numerous in-depth interviews and in-home visits with 18 of these users over several months. The researchers found that the exposure to disturbing content in their feeds made them less likely to use Facebook and exacerbated the trauma and hardships they were already experiencing.

Researchers found: A 44-year-old who was in a precarious financial situation followed Facebook pages that posted coupons and savings and were bombarded with unknown users’ posts of financial scams. A person who’d used a Facebook group for Narcotics Anonymous and totaled his car was shown alcoholic beverage ads and posts about cars for sale. Black people were consistently shown images of physical violence and police brutality.

By contrast, borderline hate posts appeared much more frequently in high-digital-literacy users’ feeds. Whereas low-digital-literacy users were unable to avoid nudity and graphic violence in their feeds, the research suggested people with better digital skills used them to seek out hate-filled content more effectively.

Curbing harmful content

The documents show the company’s researchers tested various ways to reduce the amount of misinformation and harmful content served to Facebook users.

Tests included straightforward engineering fixes that would demote viral content that was negative, sensational, or meant to provoke outrage.

In April 2019, company officials debated dampening the virality of misinformation by demoting “deep reshares” of content where the poster is not a friend or follower of the original poster.

Facebook found that users encountering posts that are more than two reshares away from the original post are four times as likely to be seeing misinformation.

By demoting that content, Facebook would be “easily scalable and could catch loads of misinfo,” wrote one employee. “While we don’t think it is a substitute for other approaches to tackle misinfo, it is comparatively simple to scale across languages and countries.”

Other documents show Facebook deployed this change in several countries – including India, Ethiopia and Myanmar – in 2019, but it’s not clear whether Facebook stuck with this approach in these instances.

►Done with Facebook?:Here’s how to deactivate or permanently delete your Facebook account

►’Profits before people’:After Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen argued her case, will Congress act?

How to moderate at-risk countries

Facebook knows of potential harms from content on its platform in at-risk countries but does not have effective moderation – either from its own artificial intelligence screening or from employees who review reports of potentially violating content, the documents show.

Another document, based on data from 2020, offered proposals to change the moderation of content in Arabic to “improve our ability to get ahead of dangerous events, PR fires, and integrity issues in high-priority At-Risk Countries, rather than playing catch up.”

A Facebook employee made several proposals, the records show, including hiring individualsfrom less-represented countries. Because dialects can vary by country or even region, the employee wrote, reviewers might not be equipped to handle reports from other dialects. While Moroccan and Syrian dialects were well represented among Facebook’s reviewers, Libyan, Saudi Arabian and Yemeni were not.

“With the size of the Arabic user base and potential severity of offline harm in almost every Arabic country – as every Arabic nation save Western Sahara is on the At-Risk Countries list and deals with such severe issues as terrorism and sex trafficking – it is surely of the highest importance to put more resources to the task of improving Arabic systems,” the employee wrote.

One document from late 2020 sampled more than 1,000 hate speech reports to Facebook in Afghanistan, finding deficiencies in everything from the accuracy of translation in local languages in its community standards to its reporting process. (Afghanistan was not listed among Facebook’s three tiers of at-risk countries in a document Haugen collected before her departure in May, which was before the United States’ withdrawal.)

The report found for one 30-day set of data, 98% of hate speech was removed reactively in response to reports, while just 2% was removed proactively by Facebook.

The document recommended Facebook allow employees in its Afghanistan market to review its classifiers to refine them and add new ones.

“This is particularly important given the significantly lower detection of Hate Speech contents by automation,” it said.

Platform enables human trafficking

Facebook found that its platform “enables all three stages of the human exploitation lifecycle” – recruitment, facilitation and exploitation – via complex real-world networks, according to internal documents.

Though Facebook’s public-facing community standards claim the company removes content that facilitates human exploitation, internal documents show it has failed to do so.

Facebook has investigated the issue for years, proposing policy and technical changes to help combat exploitation on its platforms, records show. But it’s unclear whether those changes were adopted. In at least one case, Facebook deactivated a tool that was proactively detecting exploitation, according to internal documents.

In October 2019, prompted by a BBC investigation, Apple threatened to remove Facebook and Instagram from its app store because it found it had content promoting domestic servitude, a crime in which a domestic worker is trapped in his or her employment, abused and either underpaid or not paid at all. An internal document shows Facebook had been aware of the issue prior to Apple’s warning.

In response to Apple’s threat, Facebook conducted a review and identified more than 300,000 pieces of potentially violating content on Facebook and Instagram, records show. It took action on 133,566 items and blocked violating hashtags.

Contributing: Mike Snider

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Private space stations are coming. What can tourists expect?

A new era of space stations is about to kick off. NASA has announced for development, joining an earlier proposal by Axiom Space. These proposals are the first attempts to ... Read more »

Google is testing a design change for its Search app

Google has been introducing new features and designs for its apps to match its look and feel with the Android 12 user interface. Now, the company is reportedly working on ... Read more »

Cybercriminals flood online forums with malicious Microsoft Excel files

Websites with contact forms and comment sections, as well as discussion forums, are being used to distribute a known password-stealing malware through a compromised Microsoft Excel file. According to a ... Read more »

Today is the last day you can download a forgotten Harry Potter mobile game

If you haven’t already tried out Harry Potter Wizards Unite you don’t have much time left to do so, because the augmented reality game (ARG) for mobiles is only available ... Read more »

Amazon's Audible is giving over 100 free audiobooks on Alexa

Amazon-owned Audible has made over 100 audiobooks completely free of cost on Alexa, which can be accessed on the Amazon Echo and Fire TV range and other Alexa built-in devices. ... Read more »

Big North Carolina factory likely to be Toyota battery plant

The Associated PressToyota vehicles are displayed at the AutoMobility LA Auto Show Thursday, Nov. 18, 2021, in Los Angeles. (AP Photo/Marcio Jose Sanchez) RALEIGH, N.C. — North Carolina government officials ... Read more »

Why the UK shouldn't introduce mandatory COVID vaccination

As coronavirus infections surge across Europe, and with the threat of the omicron variant looming, countries are imposing increasingly stringent pandemic controls. In Austria, citizens will be subject to a ... Read more »

5G revenues will reach $600m by 2026

5G networks will account for three quarters (77%) of global mobile operator revenues by 2026, with demand for consumer and businesses services driving adoption. A report from Juniper Research predicts ... Read more »

Qualcomm may have a ‘plan' for handheld gaming devices

The advent of smartphones have more or less made handheld gaming devices rather redundant. Unless you are a ‘fan’, handheld gaming devices these days don’t find too many takes. The ... Read more »

Leica M11 leak reveals controversial design tweak for rangefinder camera

Some new leaked images of the upcoming Leica M11 rangefinder camera appear to confirm it’ll have what would be, for Leica fans at least, a polarizing new design tweak. Leica’s ... Read more »

Garmin Fenix 7: release date rumors, news, and what we want to see

The Garmin Fenix 7, the next instalment in Garmin’s line of flagship running watches, is expected to land some time in 2022, and although the company itself has yet to ... Read more »

BioShock 4 will take us back to a familiar time period, according to reports

New details on BioShock 4’s setting have reportedly been leaked, claiming that the next title in the first-person shooter series will take place in a fictional Antarctic city during the ... Read more »

Apple M1 Max chips could be stacked together to create monster 40-core processor

New images of Apple’s latest silicon appear to hint at the possibility of connecting multiple M1 Max chips together to create an extremely powerful multi-chip module (MCM), which would be ... Read more »

PSVR 2 patent shows off Sony's next-gen VR controller from every angle

While we’ve still yet to see Sony’s PSVR 2 headset itself, the controllers for the PS5’s virtual reality device have already been revealed. However, a recently uncovered patent for the ... Read more »

Astronomers decode why our Solar System is shaped like a croissant

BU-led scientists say the protective bubble around the solar system is shaped like a croissant (Image courtesy of Opher, et. al) Hydrogen particles slamming into the Solar System from outside ... Read more »

Chromecast with Google TV's best feature is being delayed

One of the most useful and anticipated Chromecast with Google TV features, that being individual user profiles, has now been pushed back into next year, Google confirms. Due to release ... Read more »

Does vaping really damage DNA and increase the risk of cancer?

Vapers experience DNA changes, according to a recent paper published in Nature, and the changes are similar to those seen in smokers – although much less pronounced. Crucially, this evidence ... Read more »

Most of India's USD 1.1 trillion growth in next 11-year can come from yet to be invented digital businesses: Report

Most of India’s USD 1.1 trillion in total economic growth in the next 11 years can come from ancillary digital asset-related businesses that are yet to be invented, according to ... Read more »

Microsoft is making Windows 11 less annoying

Microsoft is working on a new Windows 11 feature that’ll remember if you turned on Wi-Fi or Bluetooth while the computer was in Airplane mode. With the current version of ... Read more »

Why celebrate pizza? Google Doodle shares the cultural heritage of pizza around the world

You may have sliced a few pizzas on Monday’s Google Doodle, which features versions of the culinary favorite from all over the world. Google’s interactive Doodle allows you to slice ... Read more »

Is the Galaxy S21 FE Samsung's worst-kept secret? New leak suggests so

It feels like every day we’re hearing a new Samsung Galaxy S21 FE leak, and it’s starting to rival the Galaxy S22 as the most-rumored product right now. Case in ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy S22 series could feature Snapdragon 8 Gen 1 chipset in India

The Samsung Galaxy S22 is reportedly arriving in India with the Snapdragon 8 Gen 1 chipset rather than the Exynos 2200. Samsung’s 2022 flagship is slated to arrive in Exynos ... Read more »

One in four colds is likely down to COVID, expert warns

Boris Johnson will review current COVID-19 measures on 18 December. (PA Images) One in four colds is likely down to people having coronavirus, an expert has said. Tim Spector, a ... Read more »

Doja Cat's latest interactive music video will teach you how to code

Doja Cat has partnered with nonprofit organization Girls Who Code to create what they claim to be the first-ever codable music video, allowing users to control the story to the ... Read more »

If Apple's next watch is built for extreme sports, it'll need an extreme redesign

One of the main selling points of this year’s Apple Watch 7 was its tougher screen and improved dust resistance, and new rumors suggest that Apple is planning to take ... Read more »

Johnson: We need to invest in rehab to help drug users

Boris Johnson says “everybody who knows about drugs crime will tell you” there needs to be more investment in rehab to drive down crime. He argues, however, that the government ... Read more »

I'm a Celebrity: Snoochie Shy opens up about revealing her birthmark for the first time

The radio presenter said she used to cover up her birthmark with make-up but feels more like herself for revealing it. Read more »

iRobot Roomba i3 Plus review

One-minute review iRobot is a US-based robotics company that was founded in 1990 and launched the first Roomba robot vacuum in 2002. It’s one of the biggest manufacturers of robot ... Read more »

This humanoid robot makes perfect human-like faces

London: As robots evolve to do more work around us, the UK-based humanoid robot manufacturer Engineered Arts has infused more human-like facial expressions into one of its robots, which may ... Read more »

Oppo signs a Memorandum of Understanding with IIT Delhi to offer scholarships

New Delhi: To empower young minds of India, Oppo has signed a Memorandum of Understanding with IIT Delhi to offer scholarships covering academics expenses for the shortlisted students.The brand has ... Read more »

Microsoft wants to revolutionise copy and paste in Edge and Chrome for Windows 11

It looks like Microsoft is planning a radical overhaul of how you copy and paste in its Edge web browser in Windows 11 – and those changes could also come ... Read more »

Oura ring review: Does the celeb-favourite activity tracker live up the hype?

We considered its tracking ability, how comfortable it was to wear and the app’s features (The Independent) Since hitting the smart tech market a few years ago, Oura’s health tracker ... Read more »

Arthur Labinjo-Hughes: Father and stepmum sat in hot tub while boy left in hallway for hours

The case of Arthur Labinjo-Hughes has shocked the nation. (PA) The killers of Arthur Labinjo-Hughes relaxed in a hot tub while the six-year-old boy was left alone for hours, it ... Read more »

Apple could launch lots of new Macs in 2022, including new cheaper MacBook Pro

Apple is rumored to have a bunch of new Macs coming next year – five of them to be precise – and that might include a new cheaper MacBook Pro. ... Read more »

Scientist behind UK vaccine says next pandemic may be worse

On Location: December 3, 2021 Catch up on the developing stories making headlines.ABCNews.com LONDON — One of the scientists behind the Oxford-AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine is warning that the next pandemic ... Read more »

Is a Daredevil Disney Plus show in the works?

Marvel chief Kevin Feige has seemingly confirmed that the studio plans to bring Charlie Cox on board so he can reprise his role of Daredevil in the MCU – suggesting ... Read more »

Apple starts legal action against Russian regulator in App Store dispute: Report

Apple has started legal proceedings against Russia’s anti-monopoly regulator in a dispute concerning alternative payment options on its App Store platform, the RIA news agency reported on Sunday citing court ... Read more »

iPad Pro redesign and more iPad updates tipped for 2022

Over the last year Apple has treated us to new models of the iPad Pro, the iPad mini, and the entry-level 10.2-inch iPad, but it doesn’t appear to be slowing ... Read more »

We're finally getting a PS5 pro controller, but it's not being made by Sony

A PS5 pro controller is finally on the way thanks to renowned manufacturer Scuf, which should give PlayStation gamers an edge when playing online. Sony doesn’t have its own version ... Read more »

Sony HT-A9 review

Two-minute review When it comes to home theatre, there are casual users that are satisfied with soundbars and enthusiasts that want a cinema-like experience with multiple speakers all around them. ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic