Facebook: latest court case shows how Europe is clamping down on big tech

Facebook’s approach to users’ data has just been dealt a major blow from the European court of justice (ECJ). In an answer to a question from Germany’s highest court, the ECJ’s advocate general – whose opinion is not binding but is generally followed by the court – has made an essential clarification to Europe’s data protection law to confirm that consumer associations can bring actions on behalf of individuals.

If followed by the ECJ, this will make it much easier for people to defend their rights against tech giants in future. Coming on the back of a decision by the European general court against Google several weeks ago for using its platform power to restrict competitors, it is the latest example of European regulators making the business climate increasingly chilly for the companies that control our data – in sharp contrast to the US.

Facebook and consent

The current case is about the way that Facebook, now known as Meta, in its early years encouraged users to play quizzes and games such as FarmVille, before sharing the results with all their friends. In an action brought by the Federation of Germany Consumer Organisations (VZBV), that was originally heard in 2014, it claimed that Facebook’s data protection notice did not clearly explain to users how their data could be shared. It wants the company to be forbidden from using similar consent forms in future.

VZBV won the original case and on appeal, before it was heard by Germany’s highest court in May 2020. The judges agreed that Facebook had misled users with the notice, but sought an opinion from the ECJ on Facebook’s argument that only individuals and not consumer organisations can bring complaints under the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), which governs this area.

The advocate general’s recommendation, ahead of a final ECJ decision in 2022, reflects the fact that individuals do not typically start legal proceedings against large companies for a small breach of a rather technical regulation. Suing big firms on behalf of society is what consumers’ organisations do, so it would limit people’s protection if this was disallowed.

Facebook’s approach to games is not the only time there have been questions about how it obtained users’ consent over data. It famously sent unsolicited emails to users’ contacts when they joined the social network. It also placed “like” buttons on third party websites and harvested the data without seeking users’ consent.

One by one, national European regulators have ruled these practices illegal, but always long after the fact. When Facebook was ordered to pay €100,000 (£85,138) by German regulators in 2016 for sending unsolicited emails, for instance, it was clearly too late to affect the company’s behaviour on that individual issue.

A picture of phone apps with FarmVille in the middle

VZBV has been at the forefront of fighting to make tech giants accountable for customer data since the early 2010s, though not always successfully. It failed in an attempt to stop Facebook claiming its platform is “free and will always be”, while making users pay with their private data. It was also unable to require the company to allow users to adopt a pseudonym. Facebook had resisted citing safety concerns, but perhaps also because data on identifiable consumers is more valuable than anonymous ones.

The GDPR and future regulations

As Facebook and other social media companies have continued to develop new techniques to harvest consumer data, the GDPR was adopted by the EU in 2018 as a general framework to clarify the rules. It gives users more control and rights over their own data, requiring clear consent before it can be used.

Pending a decision on consumer organisations, the ECJ has already recently decided that national privacy watchdogs can directly fine tech firms under the GDPR for breaches affecting their citizens. Facebook had claimed only the Irish authority was competent, since its EU headquarters are there. A forthcoming ECJ case will look at giving similar powers to antitrust authorities.

The EU rules around big tech are also set to be strengthened in 2022 with the Digital Services Act and Digital Markets Act. This package of extra restrictions is set to include curbing the uncontrolled spread of unverified and often hateful content, with the potential for penalties of 10% of a company’s annual revenue.

And for all the talk of a bonfire of EU data protection rules after Brexit, the forthcoming UK Online Safety Bill goes arguably even further in the same direction, with not only similar fines but potential prison sentences for executives over breaches. The bill may even make Facebook responsible for scams by other companies advertising on the platform.

Facebook icon next to a virus

Major EU countries such as Germany, France and the Netherlands also want the Digital Services Act to block what has become big tech’s major strategy to attract new users: identifying non-profitable but successful internet companies, and buying their technology and user base. The UK is now decisively on the same path, as the Competition and Market Authority just ordered Facebook/Meta to sell Giphy, the largest repository of GIFs on the internet, which it bought in 2020 for US$400 million (£301 million).

European regulators are therefore unravelling tech giants’ business models one decision after the other. European data regulation is also becoming the de facto global standard because to be allowed to operate in Europe (which generates a quarter of Facebook’s annual profits), global tech often has to obey the stricter European rules across the board.

The European logic is that harvesting private data is often a rip-off. People care about privacy but give away their data in exchange for almost nothing, and the government should protect them. American regulators consider this patronising, with the Supreme Court ruling almost 20 years ago that a dominant firm is free to exploit its consumers. Recent whistleblower Frances Haugen has provoked some soul searching in the US, but will probably ultimately struggle to secure meaningful changes to the rules around data and content.

With the likes of the UK now strongly following the path of the EU, the US is becoming increasingly isolated in this area. Meta is still free to make money out of their existing Facebook users in Europe. But as younger generations leave Facebook for the likes of TikTok and Snapchat, it faces increasing difficulties in reaching them and gathering the necessary information to sell their profiles to advertisers. It may therefore be time for companies like Facebook to find new sources of revenue.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The Conversation

Renaud Foucart does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

News Related


Samuel L. Jackson shows off full beard on set of Secret Invasion

Samuel L. Jackson was seen on the set of Marvel’s Secret Invasion at The Piece Hall in Halifax on Wednesday as he continued filming for the upcoming mini-series. The actor, 73, ... Read more »

Best telescopes 2022: Top picks for viewing planets, galaxies, stars and more

If you’re looking for the best telescopes of 2022, then you’ve come to the right place. Our handy guide of the best telescopes is perfect for seasoned astronomers, who want ... Read more »

No Way Home director Jon Watts says he sat Tom Holland, Andrew Garfield and Tobey Maguire down for a ‘Spider-Man therapy session'

Spider-Man: No Way Home director Jon Watts has spoken about holding a “Spider-Man therapy session” ahead of filming. In a new interview with Variety, Watts opened up about the making ... Read more »

Homeless encampment pulled down to make way for Super Bowl in Los Angeles

Los Angeles County demolished a homeless camp near the football stadium where Super Bowl LVI will be held, prompting outrage. Local media reports that about 60 people were living in ... Read more »

Report: Rivian Boosts Production Towards 200 Units Per Week

© InsideEVs Assembly team members inserting a windshield on a Rivian R1T on the Validation Production line at Rivian’s manufacturing plant in Normal, IL. According to rumors, the plant paused ... Read more »

I'm a proud mistress and serial cheat – desperate, angry wives often call me but I never feel guilty, I just love sex

HAVING multiple flings with millionaires means tonnes of luxury perks from private jets, mansions to regular holidays. However, for Gweneth Lee as one of Britain's most well known mistresses, the ... Read more »

RFK Jr: How the pandemic made JFK's nephew even ‘more dangerous' in the world of anti-vax propaganda

In the spring of 2005, staff at the Natural Resources Defence Council, an environmental group, got word of an incoming storm. It was not a storm in the usual sense, ... Read more »

Andrew's civil sex trial threatens monarchy, says leading lawyer

The Queen’s Platinum Jubilee celebrations will be “overshadowed” by the Duke of York’s civil sex trial and lead to questions about the “relevancy” of the royal family, a leading lawyer ... Read more »

NY Attorney General Tish James says Trump changed his mind about her investigation into his company only after being subpoenaed for a deposition

© Provided by Business Insider New York Attorney General and governor candidate Letitia James and former President Donald Trump. David Dee Delgado/Getty Images; Paul Hennessy/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images New ... Read more »

Mali vs Equatorial Guinea live stream: How can I watch AFCON game on TV in UK today?

© AFP via Getty Images TunisiavsMali1201A The final match of the Africa Cup of Nations last 16 takes place tonight when Mali face Equatorial Guinea. Mali are very much the ... Read more »

Boris Johnson's parliamentary assistant 'contacted charter firm to secure plane to evacuate animals from Afghanistan' telling them 'boss was keen'

The PM has dismissed claims made by a former Foreign Office official that the government prioritised animals over people as "complete nonsense". But emails released by the Foreign Affairs Select Committee suggest he did personally authorise rescue efforts for pets and animals. Read more »

Patient rejected for transplant over vaccine refusal

© AP Covid vaccine A heart patient has been rejected for a transplant because he has not had the Covid vaccination, his family say. DJ Ferguson, 31, has been in ... Read more »

Seven holocaust survivors feature in paintings commissioned by Charles

The Prince of Wales has hailed seven portraits of some of the nation’s last remaining Holocaust survivors as a “powerful testament” to their lived experience. Charles commissioned the paintings of ... Read more »

Julia Stiles welcomes second child

© Provided by Cover Media Julia Stiles Julia Stiles is a new mum. The Riviera actress took to Instagram on Wednesday to announce that she had given birth to her ... Read more »

Canada expands training mission in Ukraine, promises non-lethal aid

© Vayar Military Agency Agency via AP Belarusian military vehicles gather preparing to attend Belarusian and Russian joint military drills in Belarus on Tuesday, Jan. 25, 2022. Russia has sent ... Read more »

TCS No. 2 in global IT services brand value: Report

© Provided by The Times of India BENGALURU: India’s software supremacy continues to show itself on the global stage. Indian IT services firms have outpaced their peers in the US, ... Read more »

Köniz gelingt die Revanche gegen Wiler-Ersigen

Der Meister gewinnt ein unterhaltsames Berner Unihockey-Derby 7:3. Zu Beginn des Schlussdrittels bangen beide Teams um Manuel Engel. © Foto: Raphael Moser Tim Aebersold feiert sein Tor zum 6:2 mit ... Read more »

Republic Day parade: Socially distant event sees 6,000 in attendance

© Provided by The Indian Express A flypast with 75 aircraft, women officers performing stunts on bikes and a tableau with technology illustrating the ‘metaverse’ were among highlights at Rajpath ... Read more »

Video: Abbie Chatfield BLASTS Elly Miles and unfollows her on Instagram for attending another boozy party on Australia Day - insisting 'you should know better by now'

Read more »

Biden KICKS OUT 24 Russian diplomats from Washington embassy over Ukraine invasion threat: President 'plans to deploy just 1,000 troops to Eastern Europe' as part of NATO effort after putting 8,500 on standby

The State Department asked 24 Russian diplomats to depart Washington and return home on Tuesday, according to the Russian Embassy'At the @StateDept request our collegues [sic] were forced to leave earlier than their tenure expired,' the embassy wrote in a tweetThe US is reportedly discussing the deployment of additional troops to countries like Hungary, Bulgaria and Romania but not every NATO member is on board, meaning it may be a bilateral rather than coalition actionSecretary of State Antony Blinken said on Wednesday that the U.S. has delivered the written response Moscow requested to address the Kremlin's demands and Biden was 'intimately involved'Russia warns of 'retaliatory measures' if U.S. rejects security demands and continues 'aggressive' policies'If the West continues its aggressive course, Moscow will take the necessary retaliatory measures,' Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said Wednesday U.S. is prepared to send answers to Russia's demands on Wednesday, administration officials saidResponse will outline areas where Washington is willing to work with Moscow, like missile placement, but will fall short of meeting top demands like banning Ukraine and other countries from joining NATO  Read more »

DCP wins 11th President's Medal for Gallantry

© Provided by The Indian Express From heading a team in the Batla House encounter to busting the terror group of Indian Mujahideen, Delhi Police’s Deputy Commissioner of Police (Special ... Read more »

Texas teen brothers and their friend are arrested 'for beating stepdad to death with BRASS KNUCKLES after he sexually abused their half-sister, nine'

Siblings Christian Trevino and Alejandro Trevino, both 18, were arrested in Pharr, Texas, on SaturdayThe boys along with their friend Juan Eduardo Melendez, 18, were taken into custody for last Thursday's murder of their stepfather, Gabriel QuintanillaThe Trevino brothers approached Quintanilla after their nine-year-old half-sister came forward and said her 42-year-old father had sexually assaulted herQuintanilla was beaten on three different occasions and was thrown into the back of a pickup truck before they abandoned his body in a McAllen field  Christian Trevino and Melendez were charged with capital murder Read more »

Robin Goodfellow's Racing Tips: Best bets for Thursday, January 27

Sportsmail’s racing expert Robin Goodfellow dishes out his tips for Thursday’s meetings at Southwell, Wetherby and Newcastle. Sportsmail’s racing expert Robin Goodfellow dishes out his tips for Thursday’s meetings WETHERBY ROBIN ... Read more »

Generic GOP candidate would beat Biden in a hypothetical election by nearly 10 points - but it would be too close to call against Trump, poll finds

Biden's projected loss in the latest poll comes at a critical time as Democrats grapple with how to hold onto their razor-thin Congressional majority in Nov.The president would lose to a hypothetical Republican by nine points but the same survey shows him beating Ron DeSantis and Mike PenceHe would poll one point higher than Trump -- well within the margin of errorTrump also dominates potential 2024 GOP primary candidates with 49%DeSantis is a distant second place with 14% of support after TrumpHowever without Trump, DeSantis and Donald Trump Jr. come out on top  Read more »

Visually-challenged man's papers for sarpanch rejected because he signed in Braille

© Provided by Hindustan Times A livid Shantilal Sabar of Odisha’s Nuapada district asked why when he could pass the matric examination conducted by the Odisha Board of Secondary Education ... Read more »

US: Fed likely to raise rates in March amid soaring inflation

© Provided by DW US inflation reached a four-decade high of 7% in December Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell indicated on Wednesday that the US central bank was ready to ... Read more »

Russia, Ukraine agree to uphold ceasefire in Normandy talks

© Provided by DW A service member of the Ukrainian armed forces walks at combat positions near the line of separation from Russian-backed rebels in the Donetsk region With tensions ... Read more »

Meet the China-born Olympic skiing phenom Kai Owens, 17, who was abandoned as a child, adopted by Colorado couple and will return to Beijing to compete for America

Kai Owens, 17, will compete for Team US against her home country of China in the Beijing 2022 Winter GamesOwens, one of the world's best female mogul skiers, was abandoned in China and adopted by Colorado couple Amy and John Owens fell in love with skiing and became became the youngest US skier to ever win a NorAm moguls event at age 14 in 2019 Last year, the teen placed sixth in the World Championships was named the FSI World Cup's Rookie of the YearHer success and inclusion in Team US draws parallels to Californian skier Eileen Gu, 18, a fellow Chinese-born athlete, who has decided to compete for China Read more »

Rationalise levies for clean energy tech: Sumant Sinha, senior V-P, Assocham

© Provided by The Financial Express Given that there is no GST on power output, all these input taxes are a cost to the developer and impact the viability of ... Read more »

Ukraine crisis: US offers no concessions in response to Russia's demands

The Biden administration and Nato told Russia on Wednesday there will be no US or Nato concessions on Moscow’s main demands to resolve the crisis over Ukraine. In separate written ... Read more »

Tesla Q4 2021 Earnings Report: Beats Expectations Yet Again

© InsideEVs Tesla Model Y Another profitable quarter in the books. Tesla just released its Q4 2021 earnings report and the numbers are impressive. Tesla again turned a profit, which makes ... Read more »

Another TikTok exec heads for the exit

TikTok executive Sean Kim left the company earlier this month. Main: Getty Images; Inset: Linke A week after TikTok ousted its marketing chief Nick Tran, the short-video app’s head of ... Read more »

Budget may provide booster dose to meet climate goals

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: At a time when India is focusing on decarbonising its economy, industry is pitching for steps to encourage green mobility in ... Read more »

Boris Johnson came out fighting in style against Keir Starmer – especially for a man under pressure

Battler Boris FOR a man under insane pressure Boris Johnson came out fighting yesterday and with some style. Of course nothing short of a nuclear blast will wipe away Keir ... Read more »

Highway Code rule changes LIVE – Every new 2022 change REVEALED including safety for cyclists at roundabouts & junctions

THERE are major changes happening to the Highway Code from next week The new rules are split into three main categories and ultimately aim to improve safety for pedestrians, cyclists ... Read more »

Arizona marks 2 years since state's first COVID-19 case

© Provided by Associated Press FILE — Dr. Rebecca Sunenshine, of Maricopa County Department of Public Health, left, and Dr. Shauna McIsaac, of Pinal County Department of Public Health, speak ... Read more »

GOP redistricting plan passes in Kansas; court fight looms

© Provided by Associated Press This image shows the “Ad Astra 2” congressional redistricting plan for Kansas drafted by the Kansas Legislative Research Department for Republican leaders in the GOP-controlled ... Read more »

Gates Foundation adds board members following Bill and Melinda's divorce

The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation named four new members to its board of trustees on Wednesday, marking the first outsiders added to the charity’s board in its two-decade history. ... Read more »

Israeli settlers rage through Palestinian town, marking the latest 'nationalistically-motivated' attack in the region

Israeli settlers in a convoy of cars rampaged through a Palestinian town in the West Bank near Nablus on Monday evening, marking the latest in a string of violent incidents ... Read more »

Moderna begins testing omicron-matched COVID shots in adults

The Associated PressFILE – A sign marks an entrance to a Moderna building in Cambridge, Mass., on Monday, May 18, 2020. On Wednesday, Jan. 26, 2022, the pharmaceutical company announced ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic