Facebook and the dangers of a single-minded focus on profit maximisation

Asia's Tech News Daily

#CEO Mark Zuckerberg, #Facebook, #Facebook CEO, #opinion, testimony, The Facebook Files podcasts, easier to inspire people to anger, allegedly show

Mark Zuckerberg (Image: Reuters)

Data engineer-turned-whistleblower Frances Haugen’s testimony at the United States congressional hearing, on October 5, was clear, and articulate as she spoke about how Facebook Inc (FB) ignored its own research that raised concerns over the harmful effects of its platforms, Facebook and Instagram.

According the Wall Street Journal (WSJ)’s seven-part The Facebook Files podcasts, FB lowered its content filtering standards for favoured elites (celebrities) — if its algorithm misinterpreted their content and blocked it, FB would be subject to public ridicule. By dropping its standards, the company allowed the larger influencers to get away with dangerous behaviour.

One such instance was of an influencer publicly identifying an alleged rape victim and posting explicit photographs of her on Instagram.

The WSJ podcasts suggest that FB knows that Instagram makes one in three teen girls feel bad about their body, which has affected the mental health, and resulted in eating disorders for some of the girls. The podcasts also suggests that an entire eco-system of human trafficking, and drug cartels were operating openly on Facebook, which despite being aware of, FB did not curb.

FB’s algorithms amplify the worst of human nature — hate and violence: it is easier to inspire people to anger than to other (happier) emotions. Several of the curbs that FB has put into place to avoid disinformation during the Donald Trump election campaign were unwound once the elections were over, raising questions on whether FB shares any responsibility for the Capitol Hill insurrection. The FB documents allegedly show that the military used Facebook to launch a genocide in Myanmar in 2018.

Haugen explains that when faced with a conflict between profits and people, FB consistently chose to make decisions that favoured profits. She believes that FB would not change its behaviour as long as the incentives of its employees were driven by metrics that promoted more engagement with the platform, which effectively translates into higher revenues and profits. In answering these questions, she raised an important question: Is profit maximisation the only goal? This warrants a larger debate.

Over 170 years ago, Jamsetji Tata believed that “in a free enterprise, the community is not just another stakeholder in business, but is in fact the very purpose of its existence”. That seemed the prevalent thinking at that time. Several Indian business houses have been responsible for building infrastructure and even cities, supporting the arts, and building education.

As our economy has opened up, many of these values appear to have waned. Corporate India shifted from a socialist mindset to a capitalist one, with profit maximisation the primary goal. Even as corporates talk about the importance of ESG (Environmental, Social, and Corporate Governance), they lobby against measures to promote better citizenship — be it dual air bags in cars, tighter emission standards, or stronger governance structures.

The good news is that many still have a conscience — car manufacturers flipped their vacant capacities to make ventilators, and those that could, provided oxygen to hospitals during the COVID-19 second wave. But corporate India’s citizen responsibilities, seen largely as CSR spends, operate separately from its profit maximisation motive.

The test of corporate responsibility is seen in how boards make choices. As Haugen suggested, Mark Zuckerberg did not start out by trying to make a hateful platform — he just didn’t take the hard decisions, and chose profits over people. The pitfall is to think that these decisions are trade-offs — they are not. As she explains, if the platforms were safer, more people would use them, and for longer, which in turn would attract more ad revenues. If the history of old Indian business houses is anything to go by, taking decisions in the larger interest builds trust and longevity, and keeps companies competitive, and relevant. Long term greedy, is how a bank describes such behaviour.

Will corporate India learn from this as its ownership changes, with private equity playing a larger role? They come with their own belief system. In several Indian companies, employees are promised a share of the returns, when private equity make its exit, and hits its numbers. At a superficial level this aligns with shareholders that have a sole focus on their own returns. But for value pickers, and passive investors, this may be inimical in the long run. If FB’s own creator seems unable to make choices for the longer term, can one expect private equity, with a three-to-five-year investment horizon, to make better choices?

A single-minded pursuit of profit may bring with it reputation risks too. Social media giants are now being compared to Big Tobacco, drawing parallels to the addictiveness, and the negative health impact of both products — as also the steadfast refusal of their corporate giants to address these. FB is accused of ‘moral bankruptcy’. Most importantly, questions are being raised on the transparency of FB’s disclosures — has it earned the blind trust of its stakeholders?

With a generation of new customers focused on social responsibilities, companies are re-learning responsible behaviour. But this cannot be seen as optional. These measures need to be embedded in the profit and loss statement — only then will the pursuit of profits be beneficial to all stakeholders.


Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Hold Mindtree; target of Rs 4450: Emkay Global Financial

Emkay Global Financial’s report on Mindtree MTCL’s simple and focused 4*4*4 growth strategy, investments in partnerships and whitespace opportunities led to superior growth in the last few quarters. Though Q2 ... Read more »

Hainan to boost development of modern agriculture

The province plans to create an artificial selection "Silicon Valley" in the city of Sanya Read more »

Buy Macrotech Developers; target of Rs 1600: Emkay Global Financial

Emkay Global Financial’s report on Macrotech Developers We believe Macrotech’s scale of operations is geared for a reset following the soonerthan-anticipated Rs40bn capital raise. Over the next 12-18 months, the ... Read more »

LIC invites its policyholders to become shareholders by updating PAN and demat details

Representative image Indians have been used to the Life Insurance Corporation of India’s (LIC) advertisements in newspapers and on television sets exhorting them to buy policies. Now, the life insurance ... Read more »

Explainer: The Yes Bank-Dish TV saga and what transpired between them

Representative image The boardroom battle between satellite TV service provider Dish TV and Yes Bank, its largest shareholder with a 25.63 percent stake, took another turn on November 30, when the Supreme ... Read more »

ACM investigates cartel in food processing sector

Photo: ANP The Netherlands Authority for Consumers & Markets (ACM) is investigating a possible cartel in the food processing sector. The regulator has recently raided several companies in the Netherlands ... Read more »

Parts shortage dents Maruti Suzuki sales to 139,184 units in November

Representative Image Shortage in electronic components weighed on India’s largest carmaker Maruti Suzuki with sales going down to 1,39,184 units in November as against 1,53,223 units it had reported a ... Read more »

LazyPay launches BNPL EMI facility, integrates with PayU payments gateway

LazyPay, a major player in the Indian Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) space, recently launched LazyPay EMI, which will empower merchants to offer instant and cardless Equated Monthly Instalments (EMI) options ... Read more »

Rick Bayless, Smashburger collaborate to launch Chorizo Cheeseburger

Photo by: Smashburger Press Release Smashburger and Rick Bayless have teamed up to create a new delectable burger sandwich. The American chef and restaurateur and the fast-casual hamburger restaurant chain ... Read more »

Petrol, diesel cannot be brought under GST in pandemic times: Govt official

A government official on December 1 told CNBC-TV18 that petrol and diesel can’t be brought under the goods and services tax (GST) regime amidst the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. The decision ... Read more »

HDFC and Bajaj Finance increase rates on fixed deposits: Should you invest?

Couple of non-bank lenders have taken cues from global and local inflationary trends and hiked the interest rates on their fixed deposits (FDs). These interest rate increases are effective from ... Read more »

Help vaccinate poor countries or face more new variant shocks, rich economies told

The OECD's Laurence Boone said Omicron would mean a downgrade for its growth outlook but that it was too early to say quite how much damage it would cause. Read more »

McDonald's Ireland recalls popular product over food safety issue

Photo by: akiragiulia/Pixabay McDonald’s Ireland recently issued an urgent recall on one of its well-known food products. The fast-food giant warned its customers that there is an undeclared ingredient that ... Read more »

Volkswagen expects battery, raw material drive to cost up to $34 billion

Image Source: Reuters Volkswagen’s planned European battery cell plants and securing vital raw materials will cost as much as 30 billion euros ($34 billion), board member Thomas Schmall said, putting ... Read more »

IT spending in India will reach $100 billion by 2022: Gartner

The IT spending in India will reach $101.8 billion by 2022, up 7 percent from the 2021, driven by the digital transformation in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, according ... Read more »

Walmart: Brett Biggs to step down as chief financial officer of the company

Photo by: Marques Thomas @querysprout.com/Unsplash Walmart will be letting go of one of its executives that have been with the company for more than two decades now. It was reported ... Read more »

China's depressed land market offers buying opportunity for Hong Kong developer HKR International

The debt crisis affecting Chinese developers, which has reduced the bidding frenzy at land auctions in the mainland, has given a Hong Kong property firm an opportunity to acquire a ... Read more »

Hainan Airlines plans to raise US$7.9 billion via a stock sale to slash debt

Hainan Airlines Holding plans to sell new shares to raise around US$7.9 billion , the majority of which will be used to reduce financial obligations as the struggling carrier inches ... Read more »

Q2 GDP expands on pent-up demand; Omicron, services sector key to growth in coming quarters

Representative Image: Shutterstock India’s gross domestic product (GDP) at constant prices grew at 8.4 percent in July-September this year, just about covering up the loss in output due to COVID-19 ... Read more »

Removed 48,594 content pieces in October in India: Google compliance report

Source: AP Google received 24,569 complaints from users and removed 48,594 pieces of content based on those complaints in October, the tech giant said in its monthly transparency report. In ... Read more »

Elon Musk embarrasses whistleblowers with Tesla whistle

It looks like he’s trying to throw a sneer at former co-worker Owen Diaz with the whistle. That whistleblower, in English whistleblower, complained several times about a racist work environment ... Read more »

Buy Divis Laboratories; target of Rs 5711: Hem Securities

Hem Securities report on Divis Laboratories Total Revenue stood at Rs 1987.51 Cr for Q2FY22, registering a growth of 13.6% YoY. Profit for the period increased 16.7% YoY to Rs. ... Read more »

Nissan wholesales surge 60% to 5,605 units in November

Source: Reuters Automaker Nissan India on Wednesday said its total wholesales jumped around 60 per cent to 5,605 units in November compared to 3,502 units in the same month of ... Read more »

World AIDS Day: Is the world closer to an HIV vaccine in the face of Covid-19?

Dr. Anthony Fauci said in a recent op-ed that it was “likely” that an HIV vaccine could build upon the pioneering technology of mRNA coronavirus vaccines. Read more »

Full-time employed residents work fewer hours a week compared to a decade ago: MOM

SINGAPORE – Full-time employed residents put in fewer hours of work per week this year compared to a decade ago, according to an annual report by the Ministry of Manpower ... Read more »

Tel Aviv most expensive city to live in, Amsterdam drops on list

Tel Aviv is the most expensive city to live in, according to an annual survey by The Economist Intelligence Unit. The main reason, according to the researchers, is that the ... Read more »

Buy Manappuram Finance target of Rs 209: Geojit

Geojit’s research report on Manappuram Finance Manappuram Finance (MGFL) is one of the leading gold loan NBFCs in India and is well diversified into other business segments like housing loan, ... Read more »

Everton news: Rafa provides injury latest, Doucouré on return, Derby day

© Photo by Serena Taylor/Newcastle United via Getty Images Your daily dose of Everton news and rumours “The group of players is the same [as for Sunday’s game at Brentford] ... Read more »

BTS law controversy: should the K-pop superstars be exempt from military service? The pros and cons Korea is debating over Jin, V, Jungkook and the rest of the boy band's mandatory army enlistment

All the members of BTS recently applied to defer the start of compulsory military service – a deferment only potentially possible thanks to a legal amendment widely credited to the ... Read more »

Reforming global trade rules is tough but doable: WTO chief

The head of the World Trade Organization stressed the importance of reforming the global trade body to prevent further trade wars but warned it would be “very tough” amid high ... Read more »

Global airlines prepare for Omicron volatility, agility will be key

Global airlines are bracing for more volatility due to the Omicron variant of COVID-19 that could force them to juggle schedules and destinations at short notice and to rely more ... Read more »

Buy Birlasoft: target of Rs 580: Sharekhan

Sharekhan’s research report on Birlasoft Birlasoft has transformed its business significantly from enterprise business to enterprise digital solutions in the last few years and is well-placed to capitalise opportunities by ... Read more »

Musk ridicules whistleblowers with Tesla whistle sales

Photo: ANP Tesla has launched a special whistle, the ‘cyberwhistle’. “Blow the whistle on Tesla!” CEO Elon Musk wrote on Twitter. It looks like he’s trying to throw a sneer ... Read more »

This city is world's costliest to live in. And the cheapest is...

Tel Aviv is the world’s most expensive city to live, according to a ranking compiled by the Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU). Tel Aviv is the world’s most expensive city to ... Read more »

Mahindra & Mahindra reports 15% dip in November tractor sales at 27,681 units

Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd on Wednesday reported a 15 per cent decline in total tractor sales at 27,681 units in November 2021. The company had sold 32,726 units in the ... Read more »

World's AIDS Day 2021 | Four decades of research but still no vaccine

With hopes of eradicating AIDS badly hit by the coronavirus pandemic, we look at the fight against the deadly condition since its emergence 40 years ago, as the planet marks ... Read more »

Impact of Omicron on emerging economies to depend on restrictions, policy support: Moody's

Representative image The economic impact of the Omicron variant of COVID-19 on emerging economies will depend on a mix of government restrictions, public comfort with social interactions, and capacity of ... Read more »

China's video game freeze enters fifth month, as NetEase faces challenges over Harry Potter game

China’s suspension of new video game licences has stretched into the final month of the year, clouding prospects for gaming giants Tencent Holdings and NetEase. NetEase shares fell as much ... Read more »

Kaisa loses control of Nam Tai's board in epic revolt led by activist shareholder IsZo, adding to the indebted developer's woes

Kaisa Group Holdings has lost control of a New York-listed property affiliate after a shareholders’ revolt, in a boardroom defeat that adds to the developer’s woes amid its asset sales ... Read more »

Royal Enfield ties up with Belstaff for exclusive range of apparel

Royal Enfield (Representative image) Mid-sized motorcycle maker Royal Enfield on Wednesday said it has joined hands with British brand Belstaff to market an exclusive range of apparel. Launched in 1924, ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic