Extensive powers given to ministers can lead to abuse: Tan Cheng Bock on Foreign Interference Countermeasures Act

© The Independent Singapore

Singapore ― Chairman of opposition Progress Singapore Party (PSP) Dr Tan Cheng Bock, aired serious concerns on Saturday (Sept 25) on the Foreign Interference Countermeasures Act (FICA), noting it would give ministers “extensive powers” to execute the bill.

Under FICA, the government will obtain powers to compel Internet and social media service providers to disclose information on users or remove online content to counter foreign attempts to influence domestic politics.

“From the title of the bill, it would seem a reasonable piece of law upholding the international principle that no country should interfere with the affairs of another country,” said Dr Tan, noting that PSP fully supported noninterference.

It is the basis for international peace and cooperation between countries, he added.

“Singapore, being a small nation, does not wish nor can afford to have foreign interference in our own domestic affairs.”

However, Dr Tan highlighted that there was more to the bill than what the title suggests.

The bill consists of 249 pages of details covering many areas from definitions of Politically Significant Persons or entities to rules governing political donations and disclosure, said Dr Tan.

FICA includes requirements for operating online sites and various directives affecting stakeholders.

“What is significant is the extensive powers given to the ministers to execute the bill,” said Dr Tan.

He noted that such power can lead to abuse, especially when many areas of the bill are “vaguely defined” and decisions are “left to the discretion of ministers, who could simply act based on suspicion.”

According to Dr Tan, FICA gives the government far more reaching power and latitude to prosecute than the Protection from Online Falsehoods and Manipulation Act (POFMA).

Urgency to pass the bill ‘troubling’

Another issue Dr Tan highlighted in his statement was the urgency FICA is being pushed through amid the Covid-19 pandemic with more urgent matters on hand.

He noted that FICA is scheduled for a second reading on Oct 4, meaning only three weeks passed from the bill’s introduction on Sept 13 to the second and third readings on Oct 4.

“What is the hurry for such a lengthy piece of legislation to be brought through Parliament and pass as law in three weeks?” he asked.

Dr Tan mentioned there wasn’t enough time for all Members of Parliament to study the impact and implications of the bill thoroughly.

“Given that this FICA bill has lots of implications and potential for abuse, the second reading should not proceed until a comprehensive review of the bill has been carried out,” he suggested.

Dr Tan compared FICA to POFMA, which is a much shorter piece of legislation yet went through public consultations and a review by a select committee.

“Is FICA really to prevent foreign interference?” Dr Tan asked.

“Or is it a means to stifle freedom of expression, alternative views and political discourse in the name of foreign interference?”

He called it “irresponsible” of the government to push the bill through “hastily” over three weeks. /TISG

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Refugee puppet Little Amal welcomed at St Paul's Cathedral

A giant puppet of a Syrian refugee has been welcomed at St Paul’s Cathedral as the dean said he hoped London could be a refuge for all those who need ... Read more »

Popular Spanish holiday destinations could end up underwater- ‘Destructive'

The volcano on La Palma erupted in September and has destroyed hundreds of homes and caused thousands of residents to be evacuated. The Canary Islands are situated above the African ... Read more »

Covid news - live: UK ‘faces lockdown Christmas' if ministers delay plan B as WHO warns vaccines ‘not enough'

© Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. Virus Outbreak Vaccine Supply LIVE – Updated at 12:07 The World Health Organisation (WHO) has warned that the vaccine alone will ... Read more »

Halyna Hutchins death: Film and TV stars call for law to ban real guns from sets after fatal shooting

© Instagram Halyna Hutchins – Instagram Stars of film and television are calling for a law to ban real guns on sets following the death of Halyna Hutchins. The 42-year-old ... Read more »

'It is a tough place to come, a niggly team that try to get under your skin'

© Ben Brady INPHO IT MAY HAVE been a reasonably routine win for Leinster as they came away with all five points from Glasgow but Leo Cullen, the head coach, ... Read more »

Focus on reports of injection spiking detracts from broader safety threats faced by young women, say experts

The focus on the reported phenomenon of spiking by injection is detracting attention away from broader safety threats faced by young women on nights out, experts have said. Several UK ... Read more »

‘Our loss is enormous' Halyna Hutchins' husband pays tribute after her death

© Provided by Evoke.ie Halyna Hutchins attends the SAG indie Sundance Filmmakers Reception in 2019. Pic: Getty Halyna Hutchins’ heartbroken husband Matthew has penned an emotional tribute to his wife ... Read more »

Slip this into your routine for smoother skin by Christmas

© Provided by Evoke.ie Autumn is well underway but as the colder weather creeps in it’s the best time of year to work on getting smoother skin before the festive ... Read more »

Blacklist reaches MPL PH S8 lower bracket finals with sweep of NXPE

Photo: Screencap of Mobile Legends Bang Bang/Youtube Blacklist International thoroughly dominated Nexplay Evos from start to finish en route to a 3-0 sweep and book their spot in the lower ... Read more »

ICC T20 World Cup 2021: Yuvraj Singh Claims India's Batting Depth as Strong as Mumbai Indians'

© Provided by News18 ICC T20 World Cup 2021: Yuvraj Singh Claims India’s Batting Depth as Strong as Mumbai Indians’ As the Super 12 round of the ICC T20 World ... Read more »

Anupamaa, October 2021, Written Update: Anupama takes a stand for her friendship

© Provided by Pinkvilla As the episode starts, Anupama prays so that she will be able to keep her emotions in control as she speaks her heart. Anupama says that ... Read more »

Harssh A Singh on playing hawaldar in comedy series 'Bharat Nagar Dairies'

© IANS Harssh A Singh on playing hawaldar in comedy series ‘Bharat Nagar Dairies Mumbai, Oct 23 (IANS) Actor Harssh A Singh who is known for his performances in ‘Thappad’, ... Read more »

'Tryst With Destiny' to stream on SonyLIV from November 5

© IANS Tryst with destiny Mumbai, Oct 23 (IANS) Drishyam Films is one production house that has always served path-breaking stories to treat the audience. Continuing this legacy, the production ... Read more »

After WhatsApp chats with Aryan Khan, NCB to grill Ananya Panday again over suspicious financial transactions

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com After two rounds of questioning, NCB has called Bollywood actress Ananya Panday for the third round in connection with drug case on Monday. While NCB has ... Read more »

VIDEO: Onto Thigh pad, one bounce, and bowled- De Kock comical, almost slow-mo, dismissal against Australia- WATCH

In the first Super 12 match of the ongoing T20 World Cup, South Africa got off to a difficult start as they lost three early wickets inside the Powerplay. Skipper ... Read more »

How a Wisconsin Republican survived a disagreement with Trump over mail-in voting

Rohn Bishop went to war against Donald Trump — and won. © Provided by Washington Examiner In 2020, after the chairman of the Republican Party in Wisconsin’s Fond du Lac ... Read more »

New Hampshire polls signal tight 2022 Senate race

Approval ratings for New Hampshire Democratic Sen. Maggie Hassan and GOP Gov. Chris Sununu have fallen recently, suggesting a tight race if the Granite State political titans face off for ... Read more »

ICICI Bank Q2 Result | Profit grows 30% to Rs 5,511 crore, net NPA lowest since December 2014

© Ruchira Kondepudi ICICI Bank Q2 Result | Profit grows 30% to Rs 5,511 crore, net NPA lowest since December 2014 Country’s second largest private sector lender ICICI Bank on ... Read more »

Google Pixel Smartphones Facing App Crashes, Issues With Touch Post Android 12 Update

© Provided by News18 Google Pixel Smartphones Facing App Crashes, Issues With Touch Post Android 12 Update Google started rolling out Android 12 on Pixel smartphones after the company’s launch ... Read more »

NTSE Stage II Admit Card 2021: Last date to download today, direct link here

National Council of Educational Research and Training, NCERT has released NTSE Stage II Admit Card 2021 on October 9, 2021. The admit card is available on the official site of ... Read more »

NASA now targeting February 2022 for its Artemis I mission

© Suhasini Jha NASA now targeting February 2022 for its Artemis I mission NASA said on October 23 that it is now targeting February 2022 for its uncrewed Artemis 1 ... Read more »

Ex-Virginia Gov. Doug Wilder says state Democrats have not earned black support

Virginia’s only black governor accused fellow Democrats of taking the African American vote for granted, even as they neglect historically black colleges and tell parents to stay out of their ... Read more »

College Admissions Are Still Unfair

This week Amherst College announced that it was ending the use of legacy preferences in its admissions process. Its president, Biddy Martin, acknowledged that providing an advantage to applicants who ... Read more »

Go First to introduce direct flights from Srinagar to Sharjah from October 23

© Shubhangi Mishra Go First to introduce direct flights from Srinagar to Sharjah from October 23 Go First has introduced Jammu and Kashmir’s first direct international flight and cargo operations from ... Read more »

Mystery of exotic infectious disease traced to aromatherapy room spray

It was a mystery by any definition of the word — a rare tropical infection that had sickened people in the decidedly non-tropical states of Minnesota and Kansas, as well ... Read more »

Sovereign Gold Bond Scheme Subscription Starts from Monday: Price, Discount, How to Buy

© Provided by News18 Sovereign Gold Bond Scheme Subscription Starts from Monday: Price, Discount, How to Buy Sovereign Gold Bond Scheme Subscription 2021-2022, Series 7, is set to start from ... Read more »

Judge dismisses juror in the Elizabeth Holmes trial for playing Sudoku during court proceedings, reports say

© Justin Sullivan/Getty Images Elizabeth Holmes, former CEO of Theranos, in a San Jose courtroom in September. Justin Sullivan/Getty Images A juror in the Holmes trial was sent home for ... Read more »

ICICI Bank Q2 Result | Profit grows 30% to Rs 5,511 crore, NII rises 25% to Rs 11,690 crore

© Ruchira Kondepudi ICICI Bank Q2 Result | Profit grows 30% to Rs 5,511 crore, NII rises 25% to Rs 11,690 crore Country’s second largest private sector lender ICICI Bank ... Read more »

DNA Explainer: Why Paytm is coming up with its mega IPO?

© Provided by DNA One97 Communications, the parent company of Digital payments Paytm is bringing India’s biggest initial public offering (IPO). The Digital payments company has got approval for its IPO from market ... Read more »

5,828 kes Covid-19, 9,178 pesakit sembuh

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today PETALING JAYA: Kementerian Kesihatan melaporkan 5,828 kes baharu Covid-19 dan 9,178 pesakit sembuh dalam tempoh 24 jam lalu. Angka itu menunjukkan penurunan berbanding 6,630 kes ... Read more »

9 booked for thrashing man over 10-year-old rivalry in Ludhiana

© Provided by Hindustan Times The complainant said that he had 10 years ago indulged in a scuffle with the main accused over some issue, but they later struck a ... Read more »

COMMENTARY: Bloc leader's threat to unleash ‘fires of hell' over Quebec seat proposal might just backfire

A proposed rejigging of Canada’s electoral map could see Quebec lose one of its seats in the House of Commons by 2024 while Alberta gains three and Ontario and B.C. ... Read more »

O'Toole's Tories outliers in Canadian politics for keeping vaccination status secret

OTTAWA — The federal Conservatives’ refusal to disclose how many of their elected members are fully vaccinated makes them something of an outlier in the Canadian political sphere. © Provided ... Read more »

Lucid CEO Peter Rawlinson is obsessed with besting Tesla and Elon Musk. Here's his game plan for making it happen.

© Provided by Business Insider Unlike other EV startups that have floundered in the industry, Lucid is so far holding its own. Lucid Motors Only a few budding EV startups ... Read more »

Hailey Bieber ist nach Set-Unfall «untröstlich»

© Birdie Thompson/AdMedia/ImageCollect Hailey Bieber spricht den Beteiligten des Set-Unfalls ihre Anteilnahme aus. Während der Dreharbeiten zum Western «Rust» hat Schauspieler Alec Baldwin aus Versehen eine Kamerafrau erschossen. Hailey Bieber, ... Read more »

Hunter Shot Multiple Times in Apparent ‘Cold-Blooded' Ambush, Killed While Attempting to Set Up Deer Blind

A hunter was killed in a residential Tennessee forest earlier this week while in the process of working on his deer blind. © Provided by Law & Crime Timothy Ring ... Read more »

F1's hottest young prospect George Russell discusses being more than just a race driver and how he stays focused in the sport's pressure cooker

© Dan Istitene – Formula 1/Formula 1 via Getty Images Russell was the subject of months of speculation. Dan Istitene – Formula 1/Formula 1 via Getty Images Insider spoke to ... Read more »

Amitabh Bachchan shares memories from 'Yaarana' set on film's 40th anniversary

© Provided by Khaleej Times Amitabh Bachchan shares memories from ‘Yaarana’ set on film’s 40th anniversary Bollywood buffs will surely recall this famous scene from the hit Amitabh Bachchan film ... Read more »

Handre Pollard tops rugby's SA-dominated Top 10 highest paid list

© Provided by The South African Springbok star winger Cheslin Kolbe recently completed a move from Toulouse to Top 14 rivals Toulon on a deal that makes him the fourth ... Read more »

Forget payday loans, this is Canada's new generation of high-interest loans

All Kathleen Zane wanted to do was buy a couch. Instead, she says she ended up with $5,850 in debt and a personal loan with an annual interest of 29.99 ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic