Explainer: Why NATO allies are unlikely to send more advanced jets to Ukraine

In one of the most significant escalations of military support to Ukraine from a NATO member since the Russian invasion, Polish President Andrzej Duda on Thursday became the first leader from the security alliance to pledge fighter jets to Kyiv.

Duda announced that four MiG-29 fighters will be handed over to Ukraine in the coming days – the rest, he said, are being serviced and will likely be handed over successively. Four might sound a modest number, but it is a monumental step from a year ago, when a NATO member sending such sophisticated lethal support to Ukraine was politically unthinkable.

It is unsurprising this step was taken by Poland – a country with a pronounced anxiety of Russian expansionism kindled by deep historical experience of Russian aggression.

Will it make a difference? On a political level, it certainly could. By normalizing such support, it could start a domino effect whereby more European countries go on to provide fighter jets to Ukraine.

Less than a day after Poland’s pledge, Slovakian Prime Minister Eduard Heger announced his government would send a fleet of 13 MiG fighter jets to support the defense of Ukraine. It is plausible that more European countries will follow suit, and free up their Soviet-designed MiGs as they modernize their own air forces.

This is exactly what Poland is doing. Last year the country signed a historically large $14.5 billion defense deal with South Korea which included the purchase of 48 FA-50 light aircraft, and it has also added American F-35 Lighting II stealth fighters to its fleet. Another practical advantage is that because many European countries have MIG-29s, their parts are more readily available for the repair and maintenance of Ukrainian aircraft.

On the question of a military advantage, the Kremlin has been predictably dismissive, claiming the gift of more Soviet-era MiGs to Ukraine will not alter the course of the conflict. Which might be why it is F-16s – and not MiGs – that are in fact at the top of President Volodymyr Zelensky’s wish list.

For obvious reasons, the precise make-up of Ukraine’s air force, most likely around a tenth of the size of Russia’s, remains shrouded in secrecy. Ukraine inherited dozens of Soviet-made MiG-29 planes after the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, about five years after they entered service. But its fleet took a hit after Russia illegally annexed Crimea.

MiG-29s are analog aircraft, using older flight technology. Zelensky’s sought-after F-16s are digital. MiGs can be used for short combat missions, they can deploy weaponry and shoot down Russian aircraft with good maneuverability at short range. But F-16s can fly for longer, are more versatile, possess integrated weapons systems and have dramatically better long range and radar capability, therefore providing improved early warning.

explainer: why nato allies are unlikely to send more advanced jets to ukraine

Explainer: Why NATO allies are unlikely to send more advanced jets to Ukraine

Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky has requested F-16 fighter jets. – Paulo Whitaker/Reuters/File

Defense analyst Alex Walmsley, an associate fellow of the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) in London, uses the analogy of comparing a “1990s laptop with the latest MacBook. Or a Ford Escort and a Porsche. Basically they do the same things – fly and launch missiles – but MIGs are not as responsive or powerful.”

The US has so far resisted calls to provide F-16s to Ukraine on the grounds of avoiding escalation with Russia, as well as impracticality. The desire to avoid a cataclysmic spill-over of the conflict was front of mind this week after the downing of a $32 million US Reaper drone over the Black Sea by a Russian jet – the first time Russian and American aircraft have come into direct contact since the war began. The potentially incendiary incident was seized on by Russia as proof of direct American involvement in the conflict.

Still, the shift from resistance to delivery has happened before; the US came around to supplying Ukraine with M1 Abrams tanks after Germany reversed their own policy on Leopard II tanks.

But the impracticality argument is not a mere political fig leaf. The Ukrainian Air Force already operates MiG jets so they will be able to use them as soon as they arrive, whereas it would take months to train a MiG-29 pilot to a high level of comfort and efficacy on an F-16. Not to mention that Ukrainian pilots are in short supply.

Retired US Lieutenant General Mark Hertling notes that while the Ukrainians have been very adaptable incorporating new kit like user-friendly Himars and Javelins, F-16s are a “whole different ballgame.” They have different engine parts, design and fire control systems for shooting and dropping bombs. “Lots of people want things to happen right now in Ukraine,” says Hertling, “but without years of peacetime training and establishment of sustainment and repair, you’re just not going to get the results you think you’re going to get.”

The first pledges of jets will uplift Ukraine’s air defense, but in no way decisively alter or provide an edge for Ukraine in the conflict. Former RAF F-16 Fighter Pilot William Gilpin tells CNN: “There’s a saying – if you’re a generation behind, there’s no point turning up. Right now the Ukrainian Air Force is a generation behind the Russians. The F-16s would move them a generation ahead.”

This is the dilemma. The impracticality of supplying Ukraine with F-16 jets, requiring a huge burden of training in the middle of an active conflict, is clear. But without them, obtaining air superiority is further out of reach.

For more CNN news and newsletters create an account at CNN.com

News Related


Look: NFL World Reacts To The Bills Stadium Photos

DETROIT, MICHIGAN – NOVEMBER 24: A Buffalo Bills football helmet is pictured during the game between the Buffalo Bills and Detroit Lions at Ford Field on November 24, 2022 in ... Read more »

‘RHOM’ Alum Joanna Krupa’s Husband Douglas Nunes Files For Divorce After Nearly 5 Years Of Marriage

Joanna Krupa and Douglas Nunes. Joanna Krupa’s husband Douglas Nunes has reportedly filed for divorce. According to documents obtained by ET, Nunes filed for divorce in Los Angeles, citing irreconcilable ... Read more »

Wisconsin school bans Miley, Dolly duet from class concert

MADISON, Wis. (AP) — Administrators at a Wisconsin elementary school stopped a first-grade class from performing a Miley Cyrus and Dolly Parton duet promoting LGBTQ acceptance because the song “could ... Read more »

What can Google's AI-powered Bard do? We tested it for you

What can Google’s AI-powered Bard do? We tested it for you To use, or not to use, Bard? That is the Shakespearean question an Associated Press reporter sought to answer ... Read more »

Amy Jo Johnson Shuts Down Rumours She Missed ‘Power Rangers’ Reunion Special Due To Money

Amy Jo Johnson Amy Jo Johnson is clearing up rumours. Fans had been in speculation mode after it was revealed that the actress wouldn’t be appearing in the upcoming “Mighty ... Read more »

Drake ‘Humbled’ A Woman In His Toronto Home, According To Viral TikTok

Drake It can be challenging, but keeping your cool around Drake is essential. A woman named Rowan recently shared her embarrassing run-in with the globally famous superstar on TikTok, in ... Read more »

Startups claim Microsoft is squeezing out search competition as it takes on Google

Startups claim Microsoft is squeezing out search competition as it takes on Google Microsoft’s Bing Chat put the company’s Bing search engine back on the map, but now search engine ... Read more »

Jets coach sounds off on Aaron Rodgers

Aaron Rodgers and the New York Jets defense While Aaron Rodgers has already made his intentions clear, the New York Jets and Green Bay Packers remain very much in a ... Read more »

iOS 16.4 Is Out. How to Download the Latest iPhone Update

Apple’s latest mobile software will work on the iPhone 8 and up. James Martin/CNET Apple has just released iOS 16.4. The latest software update for the iPhone brings several new ... Read more »

Bills release stunning new renderings of their proposed $1.4 billion stadium that's scheduled to open in 2026

Bills release stunning new renderings of their proposed $1.4 billion stadium that’s scheduled to open in 2026 The Buffalo Bills haven’t broken ground on their new $1.4 billion stadium just ... Read more »

Canada Revenue Agency: What to Do With the GST/HST Payout to Build Lasting Wealth

Two colleagues working on new global financial strategy plan using tablet and laptop. The goods and services tax (GST) and harmonized sales tax (HST) is a tax credit provided by ... Read more »

More than 2,000 ram skulls discovered in Egypt's temple of Ramses II

Cairo — Archaeologists have announced the discovery of more than 2,000 rams’ heads at the temple of the ancient Egyptian pharaoh Ramses II — a find that the man in ... Read more »

Space Force should prepare for the threat we have — not the one we prefer

Space Force should prepare for the threat we have — not the one we prefer As the one-year anniversary of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine came and went, many commentators discussed and ... Read more »

Powassan resident talks about his Avro Arrow collection of photographs

People in general who have an interest in Canada’s Avro Arrow interceptor jet can thank individuals like Pete Bonell of Powassan who scooped up photographs of the doomed jet when ... Read more »

'Unsanctioned' giant spider chilling under a bridge in Vancouver asked to leave

The sculpture is created by Montreal artist Junko Playtime. A giant spider sculpture has found itself stuck in a web of by-laws. The sculpture created by Montreal artist Junko Playtime ... Read more »

Look: Florida Makes Decision On Tim Tebow's No. 15 Jersey

GAINESVILLE, FL – OCTOBER 06: Tim Tebow is inducted into the Ring of Honor during the game between the Florida Gators and the LSU Tigersat Ben Hill Griffin Stadium on ... Read more »

Fear The Walking Dead: Watch the final season trailer

Fear The Walking Dead: Watch the final season trailer Watch the first trailer for Fear The Walking Dead, an American post-apocalyptic horror drama television series starring Kim Dickens and Cliff ... Read more »

Tornado destruction could take years to repair, FEMA administrator says

0327-cbsm-tornadoguest-criswell-1830172-640×360.jpg Over the weekend, officials from FEMA visited a tornado-ravaged community to meet with residents and evaluate the extent of the damage after a twister caused destruction across Mississippi and ... Read more »

Uninspired Jets scrape out two points against lowly Coyotes

Arizona Coyotes’ Connor Mackey (12) and Winnipeg Jets’ Morgan Barron (36) fight during the second period in Winnipeg on Tuesday. It was neither a convincing nor momentum-building victory, the kind ... Read more »

Antetokounmpo, Bucks to host Jones and the Spurs

San Antonio Spurs (19-53, 14th in the Western Conference) vs. Milwaukee Bucks (51-20, first in the Eastern Conference) Milwaukee; Wednesday, 8 p.m. EDT FANDUEL SPORTSBOOK NBA LINE: Bucks -17.5 BOTTOM ... Read more »

Golden Knights down Canucks 4-3, grab top spot in Western Conference

Golden Knights down Canucks 4-3, grab top spot in Western Conference VANCOUVER — Rick Tocchet is still in teaching mode two months into his tenure with the Vancouver Canucks. And ... Read more »

How to save Twitter videos: Step-by-step guide to download viral videos for offline viewing

Twitter doesn’t provide a built-in save button to download videos on its platform. While that’s a bummer, it’s not entirely impossible to download videos from Twitter. Sometimes the most interesting ... Read more »

NCT DREAM Talk U.S. Tour, New Music & Why ‘Everything Comes With Timing’ for ‘7DREAM’

NCT DREAM Talk U.S. Tour, New Music & Why ‘Everything Comes With Timing’ for ‘7DREAM’ When NCT DREAM made their live Stateside return last August as one of KCON’s most anticipated performers, a ... Read more »

Your Daily Astrology: March 22 for 03/22/23

Magi Helena (TNS) WEDNESDAY, MARCH 22, 2023 BIRTHDAY STAR: Actor Matthew Modine was born in Loma Linda, California, on this date in 1959. This birthday star earned a 1994 Emmy ... Read more »

Amazon Shoppers Are Calling This Just-Launched Blouse the “Cutest Top Ever,” and It’s Just $26

A reviewer confirmed it’s “lightweight, but not sheer.” Amazon/ InStyle When it comes to spring fashion, one of the hardest things to shop for is a cute, high-quality blouse. You ... Read more »

South Korean capital announces plans for ‘floating’ swimming pool and art pier

Just two weeks after announcing plans to build the world’s largest spokeless Ferris wheel, Seoul’s city government has shared its intention to construct urban ‘floating’ swimming zones along the South ... Read more »

Peter Werner Dies: Prolific TV Director & Oscar Winner Was 76

Peter Werner Dies: Prolific TV Director & Oscar Winner Was 76 Peter Werner, Emmy-nominated TV director who won a Best Short Film Oscar in 1977, died suddenly this morning in ... Read more »

Your Health Insurance Plan Could Make This Fitness Expense Cheaper

Two smiling middle age adults outdoors with yoga mats. If you’re an American paying a high premium for health insurance coverage, you’re not alone. Thankfully, your health insurance plan may ... Read more »

How Xi and Putin’s new friendship could test the US

As two autocrats traded tributes over a feast of quail, venison, Siberian white salmon and pomegranate sorbet, China and Russia seemed to conjure the anti-Western compact the US has long ... Read more »

YouTube Music contractors say their office is promoting anti-union messages on TVs ahead of the union election

YouTube Music workers at Cognizant’s Austin, TX office are surrounded by screens that cycle through anti-union messaging. Sam Regan Contracting firm Cognizant is pushing back as contractors for YouTube Music ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự