EXPLAINER: Must employers follow Biden's vaccine mandates?

Asia's Tech News Daily

FILE - New York City municipal workers protest against the coming COVID-19 vaccine mandate for city workers, Thursday, Oct. 28, 2021, outside the Gracie Mansion Conservancy in New York. Millions of health care workers across the U.S. were supposed to
Image Icon
The Associated PressFILE – New York City municipal workers protest against the coming COVID-19 vaccine mandate for city workers, Thursday, Oct. 28, 2021, outside the Gracie Mansion Conservancy in New York. Millions of health care workers across the U.S. were supposed to have their first dose of a COVID-19 vaccine by this coming Monday, Dec. 6, under a mandate from President Joe Biden’s administration. But that has been placed on hold by federal judges (AP Photo/Jeenah Moon, File)

Millions of health care workers across the U.S. were supposed to have their first dose of a COVID-19 vaccine by this coming Monday under a mandate issued by President Joe Biden’s administration. Thanks to legal challenges, they won’t have to worry about it, at least for now.

Same goes for a Jan. 4 deadline set by the administration for businesses with at least 100 employees to ensure their workers are vaccinated or tested weekly for the virus.

Judges responding to lawsuits brought by Republican-led states, businesses and other opponents have blocked some of Biden’s most sweeping initiatives intended to drive up vaccination rates. Numerous other legal challenges are pending, contesting the Democratic president’s vaccine requirements for federal employees and contractors and members of the military, as well as mask requirements for people using public transportation.

More than four-fifths of adults nationwide already have received at least one dose of a COVID-19 vaccine. But Biden contends his various workforce vaccine mandates are an important step in curtailing the virus, which has killed more than 780,000 people in the U.S.

Opponents have taken a three-tiered approach to challenging Biden’s requirements. In lawsuits, they contend the vaccine mandates were imposed without proper public comment, were not authorized by Congress and infringe on states’ rights to regulate public health matters.

“The reasoning across the cases is basically the same, which is that these statutes don’t give the president or the agency in question the authority to issue the mandates,” said Gregory Magarian, a constitutional law professor at Washington University in St. Louis.

The Biden administration contends its rule-making authority is firm and supersedes any state policies prohibiting vaccine requirements. Recent experience shows that such mandates generally prompt people to get vaccinated. By the time a Biden requirement for federal workers to be vaccinated took effect last month, 92% had received at least their first dose of the shot.

Following is a rundown of some of Biden’s most sweeping vaccine requirements and the status of the legal fights over them.

LARGE BUSINESS MANDATE

What it would do: Under a rule published by the U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration on Nov. 5, businesses with 100 or more workers are to require employees to be vaccinated. If they are not, they would need to be tested weekly and wear masks while working, with exceptions for those who work alone or mostly outdoors. The rule was to go into effect Jan. 4. The requirement would affect businesses with a cumulative 84 million employees, and OSHA projected it could save 6,500 lives and prevent 250,000 hospitalizations over six months.

Who’s challenging it: The requirement is being challenged by 27 Republican-led state governments plus conservative and business groups and some individual businesses. The states mostly filed lawsuits in groups, though Indiana challenged it alone. Their arguments include that it’s the job of states, not the federal government, to deal with public health measures. The Biden administration maintains that the measure is legal. Some labor unions also contested the rule, though not for the same reasons as the Republicans and business group. They say it doesn’t go far enough to protect workers.

Where it stands: The rule is on hold. A day after states challenged the rule, a panel of three judges in the New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals blocked it. At first, it was a temporary suspension, then a more permanent one. The legal challenges originally were filed in various U.S. appeals courts. The cases subsequently were consolidated into a court that was selected at random, the Cincinnati-based 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

What’s next: The Biden administration is asking the 6th Circuit to set aside the order from the 5th Circuit and allow the vaccine requirement. In the meantime, OSHA has suspended implementation of the rule. Groups that are suing want the questions decided by all the judges on the 6th Circuit rather than a panel of just some of them.

HEALTH WORKER MANDATE

What it would do:: Under a rule published by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid on Nov. 5, a wide range of health care providers that receive federal Medicare or Medicaid funding were to require workers to receive the first dose of a COVID-19 vaccine by Dec. 6 and be fully vaccinated by Jan. 4. The rule would affect more than 17 million workers in about 76,000 health care facilities and home health care providers.

Who’s challenging it: The rule was challenged in four separate lawsuits filed by Republican-led states, mostly in groups. Florida and Texas mounted their own challenges. The states argued that there were no grounds for an emergency rule, that CMS had no clear legal authority to issue the mandate and that the rule infringes on states’ responsibilities.

Where it stands: The rule is on hold. A Missouri-based federal judge issued a preliminary injunction Monday barring its enforcement in 10 states that had originally sued. The next day, a Louisiana-based federal judge also issued a preliminary injunction barring enforcement in the rest of the states.

What’s next: Both court rulings are being appealed by the Biden administration. The case filed in Missouri is being considered by the St. Louis-based 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. The case filed in Louisiana, which was brought by a coalition of 14 states, is being considered by the 5th Circuit. So far, there’s been no move to consolidate the challenges in a single court.

FEDERAL CONTRACTOR MANDATE

What would it do: Under an executive order issued by Biden on Sept. 9, contractors and subcontractors for the federal government are required to comply with workplace safety guidelines developed by a federal task force. That task force on Sept. 24 issued guidelines requiring that federal contractors ensure their employees are fully vaccinated by Dec. 8. There are limited exceptions for medical or religions reasons. The requirements could apply to millions of employees.

Who’s challenging it: The guidelines have been challenged through more than a dozen lawsuits, including seven brought by Republican-led states or coalitions of states. The arguments are similar to those against other vaccine mandates, asserting the Biden administration exceeded the procurement rule-making powers granted by Congress, infringed on states’ responsibilities and didn’t properly gather public comment.

Where it stands: A federal judge in Kentucky issued a preliminary injuncting Tuesday barring enforcement of the vaccine requirement for contractors in three states that collectively sued — Kentucky, Ohio and Tennessee. Judges in Mississippi and Washington state have declined to block the requirements; the question is pending before other courts.

What’s next: Legal challenges pending in several other states could lead to additional court rulings this month on requests for injunctions. The Kentucky ruling also could be appealed. Barring a nationwide court order, there could be a patchwork of requirements for contractors depending on the states where they work.

A quick consolidation of the federal contractor lawsuits appears unlikely.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Man Utd coaches' Donny van de Beek fears explain midfielder's severe lack of game time

Manchester United’s coaches have privately conceded that Donny van de Beek does not have the speed or strength to succeed in the Premier League, according to reports. Van de Beek ... Read more »

Four Tottenham U23 players who may have earned themselves a loan move after draw vs Blackburn

Spurs U23s drew 1-1 to Blackburn Rovers U23s at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium on Monday night, keeping the Lilywhites third in the Premier League 2 table. Jack Clarke found the ... Read more »

ICC Under-19 World Cup 2022: Haseebullah Posts Tournament's Highest Score as Pakistan Beat Zimbabwe by 115 Runs

© Provided by News18 ICC Under-19 World Cup 2022: Haseebullah Posts Tournament’s Highest Score as Pakistan Beat Zimbabwe by 115 Runs Pakistan’s opener Haseebullah put on the highest score of ... Read more »

Five facts about disaster-hit Tonga

© STAFF Factfile on the Hunga Tonga-Hunga Ha’apai volcano, which erupted January 15, triggering tsunami waves around the Pacific and causing ‘significant damage’ to Tonga’s capital Nuku’alofa. The Pacific island ... Read more »

DOTr: Day 1 of 'no vax, no ride' was 'generally peaceful' thanks to compliant commuters

© Provided by Top Gear Philippines Day one of the ‘no vaccination, no ride’ policy in Metro Manila went pretty smoothly—at least according to the Department of Transportation’s (DOTr) initial ... Read more »

Starbucks ties up with Meituan to bolster presence in crucial China market

By Sophie Yu and Brenda Goh © Reuters/TINGSHU WANG A barista serves coffee at a Starbucks flagship store in Beijing BEIJING (Reuters) -Starbucks, which has seen sales slow in China ... Read more »

Inmates sue jail over ivermectin treatment for Covid as ‘medical experimentation'

Four inmates at an Arkansas jail have filed a lawsuit against the facility and its doctor after they said they were unknowingly prescribed ivermectin to treat Covid-19 as a form ... Read more »

Shabana Azmi's birthday wish for Javed Akhtar ft Zoya, Farhan Akhtar, Shibani Dandekar is ode to family love

© Provided by Pinkvilla Legendary lyricist and writer Javed Akhtar is celebrating his 77th birthday today and on his special day, wishes have been pouring in on social media for ... Read more »

Does POPIA prevent publication of matric results? Court to hear arguments

© Provided by CapeTalk The High Court in Pretoria will hear arguments against the Basic Education Department’s decision not to release 2021 matric results on media platforms. The department made ... Read more »

Mbalula confident CT's central line will be fully operational by end of July

© @MbalulaFikile/Twitter Transport Minister Fikile Mbalula during his inspection tour of Cape Town’s railway infrastructure on 17 January 2022. CAPE TOWN – Transport Minister Fikile Mbalula said that there was ... Read more »

Monday Musings: Lavasa, from dream city to ghost town... now what?

© Provided by Hindustan Times More than two decades ago, then-billionaire Ajit Gulabchand envisioned something different after Sharad Pawar floated the idea of developing Lavasa hill city while travelling in ... Read more »

US sanctions on Zimbabwe's elite ricochet across economy

© Jekesai NJIKIZANA There are plenty of Zimbabwean dollars, but greenbacks are rare Callisto Jokonya stands in the cavernous factory of Imperial Refrigeration and recalls the halcyon days. In the ... Read more »

There was not enough time to move Life Esidimeni patients, inquest told

© Kgothatso Mogale/EWN FILE: Life Esidimeni Waverley Care Centre Hospital in Boksburg. CAPE TOWN – There was not enough time to move mentally ill patients from Life Esidimeni facilities. That’s ... Read more »

Odisha: Former employee stays overnight inside bank to loot 1.6 kg gold worth Rs 1 crore, arrested

Odisha: Former employee stays overnight inside bank to loot 1.6 kg gold worth Rs 1 crore, arrested A former employee of a bank managed to sneak inside the premises and ... Read more »

‘Waiter! A bottle of 1975 Warhol please' – why every great artist has to do a wine label

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Sothebys/PA Here’s a good pub quiz question: what do David Shrigley, Tracey Emin and, er, Prince Charles have in common? The answer is they’ve ... Read more »

Krushna Abhishek calls uncle Govinda ‘Bade Miyan'; Hopes to solve ongoing feud

© Provided by Pinkvilla Actor Krushna Abhishek and Govinda’s family rift has not settled till now. Both families are not on talking terms for the last three years. However, Krushna ... Read more »

‘Loud' academic awarded more than £100,000 for unfair dismissal

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Christopher Thomond/The Guardian A senior academic who says she was sacked from her post in a university’s physics department because of her loud voice ... Read more »

Viral image of Kejriwal and Bhagwant Mann sitting in front of liquor stores is photoshopped

© Provided by The Print New Delhi: An image showing Delhi Chief Minister and Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) convener Arvind Kejriwal and the party’s Punjab unit chief, Bhagwant Mann, sitting ... Read more »

Almost 500K healthcare workers received SRAs as of Jan. 14 —DOH exec

© Unang Balita Deployment of nurses and healthcare workers abroad Almost half a million healthcare workers have received their special risk allowances (SRA) amid the pandemic, an official from the ... Read more »

Dramatic love story of Bollywood; Ranjish Hi Sahi

© Provided by The Statesman Dramatic love story of Bollywood; Ranjish Hi Sahi The series revolves around a fledgling maverick film director who gets drawn into an extra-marital affair with ... Read more »

Austria raises alarm about 'dramatic' femicide plague

© ANDREA KLAMAR-HUTKOVA Austria is gripped by a public debate about femicide after several particularly shocking and widely reported cases last year Painted in blood red on an improvised memorial ... Read more »

Beth Mooney out of Ashes with broken jaw; Huge setback to Australia

© Provided by The Statesman Beth Mooney out of Ashes with broken jaw; Huge setback to Australia On Tuesday, World No.1-ranked T20 batter Beth Mooney ruled on the eve of ... Read more »

Gericht prüft Antrag: Massenmörder Breivik will freikommen

Der Massenmörder Anders Behring Breivik, der nach den rechtsextremen Terroranschlägen in Oslo und auf der Insel Utøya in Norwegen in Haft sitzt, stellte einen Antrag auf vorzeitige Haftentlassung. Dieser wird ... Read more »

Peter Crouch makes 'mechanical' Rafa Benitez claim and Everton players admission

Peter Crouch has given an insider’s view on Rafa Benitez’s training methods and has admitted he can understand why his former manager was unsuccessful at Everton. The ex-England striker played ... Read more »

Former KKR player offered r₹r40 lakhs to fix matches - Report

Rajagopal Sathish, 40-year-old, lodged a police complaint in Bengaluru, claiming he was offered a sum of ₹40 lakh to fix matches. As per a report in The Indian Express, Satish ... Read more »

Analysis: Dak Prescott hands it to all the wrong people

Dak Prescott kept handing it to all the wrong people. He should have delivered the football to umpire Ramon George instead of to his center Tyler Biadasz before time ran ... Read more »

Spread a little kindness this New Year in Midlothian by volunteering

Midlothian Council and Midlothian Health and Social Care Partnership are joining forces with voluntary organisations to encourage local people to give a few hours of their time for the benefit ... Read more »

Man City challenge for Kevin De Bruyne spells trouble for Premier League

What do you get when you combine the best player in the Premier League with the best manager in the Premier League? Trouble for the rest of the Premier League. ... Read more »

Indonesia passes law to relocate capital to remote Borneo

© Reuters/WILLY KURNIAWAN Indonesia’s 76th Independence Day celebrations in Jakarta JAKARTA (Reuters) – Indonesia’s parliament has approved a bill to relocate the nation’s capital from Jakarta to Kalimantan on Borneo, ... Read more »

Anne Frank betrayal suspect named by researchers after new investigation

A team of historians, criminologists and data specialists have been using modern investigative techniques and believe a relatively unknown figure, Arnold van den Bergh, gave the Frank family up to the Nazis. Read more »

Motel among buildings destroyed by raging blaze in Massachusetts

Dozens of people are displaced and homes evacuated as coastal fire rips into a motel and adjacent structures in town of Salisbury. Read more »

How Emirates 'air hostess' stood unfazed atop Burj Khalifa as A380 whizzed by in viral video

© Provided by Khaleej Times Emirates Airline’s bravest ‘air hostess’ gave the world , as she stood atop the Burj Khalifa in a viral video recently. And this time, she ... Read more »

Explosion and Fire In Abu Dhabi Brought Under Control

© UAEMoments Explosion and Fire In Abu Dhabi Brought Under Control According to the national news agency WAM, no “significant damages” have been reported following explosion and fire incidents in ... Read more »

How Republicans are driving the national agenda, even though Democrats hold unified control of government

Republican-controlled state legislatures across the country are approving a wave of new voting restrictions on virtually party-line votes that require only a simple majority to pass. The US Supreme Court ... Read more »

The Best FIFA Football Awards 2021: When, Where and How to watch the event in India

© Provided by Firstpost The Best FIFA Football Awards 2021: When, Where and How to watch the event in India After missing out on the Ballon d’Or, Robert Lewandowski may ... Read more »

Renting in the free sector is rising again

“The increase is not surprising,” says Jasper de Groot, director of Pararius. “The demand is very high, and the supply is low. Then the prices rise.” The demand for rental ... Read more »

India records 2,38,018 fresh Covid-19 cases, more than 20,000 less than yesterday

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: For the second day in a row, India witnessed a decline in its daily Covid-19 count. On Tuesday (January 18), the country saw ... Read more »

Toddler drowns in hotel pool in Ras Al Khaimah

An Emirati toddler drowned in the swimming pool of a hotel in Ras Al Khaimah on Saturday. The details of the incident are not known as police are still investigating, ... Read more »

Dakwaan hakim ‘berbogel': Menteri Agama perlu selesai segera polemik perpecahan dalaman

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Menteri Agama sebagai menteri bertanggungjawab kepada Jabatan Kehakiman Syariah Malaysia perlu menyelesaikan polemik itu dengan segera, menurut Zainul Rijal Abu Bakar. PETALING JAYA: Persatuan ... Read more »

Covid: Liquor shops in Andhra Pradesh to remain open till 10 pm

© Provided by DNA The Andhra Pradesh government on Monday (January 17) extended the business hours of liquor retail shops by one hour till 10 pm.  Special chief secretary to ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic