Explained: Why World Bank is under fire over set of rankings

#Business, #Word Bank

Representative Image (Reuters)

Under fire for allegations that it bowed to pressure from China and other governments, the World Bank has dropped a popular report that ranked countries by how welcoming they are to businesses.

The report is important to many companies and investors around the world: They use the to help decide where to invest money, open manufacturing plants or sell products.

Eager to attract investment, countries around the world, especially developing economies, have sought to improve their rankings in the World Bank’s report.

Sometimes, nations would pursue substantive policy changes by, for example, making it easier for businesses to pay taxes, obtain loans or enforce contracts. Sometimes, they would take a more aggressive tack: Like pushy high schoolers cajoling a teacher for a higher grade, they would lobby the World Bank to provide a higher score on the Doing Business report

Countries that have scored a high ranking have often touted their success. In 2017, for example, Prime Minister Narendra Modi took to Twitter to celebrate India’s big improvement in 2017. In Rwanda, the country’s development board employs a Doing Business economist.

But the World Bank has long been accused of using sloppy methodology and of succumbing to political pressure in producing the Doing Business rankings.

This week, the bank dropped the report after investigators had reviewed internal complaints about data irregularities in the 2018 and 2020 editions of Doing Business and possible ethical matters” involving World Bank staff members.

In an investigation conducted for the bank, the law firm WilmerHale concluded that staff members fudged the data to make China look better under pressure from Kristalina Georgieva, then the CEO of the World Bank and now head of the International Monetary Fund, and the office of Jim Yong Kim, then the World Bank’s president.

Here is a closer look at the controversy:


Founded in 1944, the 189-country World Bank makes grants and loans, often to finance big public works projects, and offers economic advice, mostly to developing nations. The bank, based in Washington, has also pledged to reduce poverty around the world.


In 2002, the bank introduced the report, whose annual rankings highlight which countries have adopted policies favorable to businesses and which havent and how much theyre improving or regressing. The bank, which collects information from about tens of thousands of accountants, lawyers and other professionals in 190 countries, assesses how easy it is to do such things as start a business, obtain a construction permit or connect to the electrical grid. Last year, New Zealand ranked No. 1 and Somalia No. 190. The United States was No. 6.


Its rankings have been interpreted by the media and by investors as a proxy for how much countries welcome foreign investment.

Any quantitative model of country risk has built this into ratings, says Timothy Ash, an emerging market strategist at the fixed income manager BlueBay Asset Management. Money and investments are allocated on the back of this series.


Questions surrounding the report date back to at least 2018, when Paul Romer, then the chief economist of the World Bank, who would go on to win a Nobel Prize in economics for his earlier work, resigned after complaining about how Doing Business treated Chile.

As a result of methodological tinkering, the South American country had plunged in the rankings while socialist Michelle Bachelet occupied the presidency, rebounded under conservative Sebastian Pinera, then slumped again when Bachelet returned to power. The ups and downs occurred despite little actual change in policy, according to a summary of events by the Center for Global Development think tank, which called then for the bank to ditch the report.

Justin Sandefur, a senior fellow at the center, contends that the rankings have always reflected a bias against government intervention in the economy. He said, for example, that the rankings have failed to properly assess any benefits from state spending or worker and consumer protections.

It came from a very strong anti-regulatory anti- tax, get-the-state-out-of-the-way-so-the-private-sector-can-thrive approach, Sandefur said. That was the original sin. It is deep in the DNA of the report.

WilmerHale delivered another blow to the World Bank and the Doing Business rankings. World Bank staffers who were compiling the 2018 report were preparing to knock China down to No. 85 in the rankings from No. 78 the year before. The downgrade would have come at a time when the World Bank was trying to raise capital an effort in which Beijing, the bank’s No. 3 shareholder, was expected to play a key role, according to the law firms report.

The investigation found that Georgieva became directly involved in efforts to improve China’s ranking.'”

According to the investigation, she also lambasted the bank’s China director for mismanaging” the bank’s relations with Beijing and for failing to appreciate how important the Doing Business rankings were to the Chinese leadership. Under pressure from the top, the investigators found, the bank staff decided to give China more credit for a new law involving so-called secured transactions typically, loans that involve collateral. The upshot was that China ended up back where it was the rankings No. 78. (Other changes affected the rankings of Azerbaijan, the United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia.)

WilmerHale concluded that bank staffers knew that the changes to the report were inappropriate” but feared retaliation including dismissal if they expressed concern. The law firm referred to a toxic culture” at the bank.

In a statement, Georgieva rejected the report: I disagree fundamentally with the findings and interpretations of the Investigation of Data Irregularities as it relates to my role in the World Banks Doing Business report of 2018.”

Eswar Prasad, a professor of trade policy at Cornell University, said the Doing Business report was already losing favor:

In recent years, the increasing politicization of the reports presentation and analysis of data had already undercut its credibility and diminished its value to international investors.

The incident also highlights Chinas growing willingness to throw its weight around in international organizations such as the World Bank and the World Health Organization.

China is clearly not shy about using its rising clout in international organizations to control the narrative about its economy and its government’s policy choices, Prasad says. For international institutions trying to remain relevant in a fast-changing world, keeping a major shareholder such as China happy can sometimes override more objective analytical considerations.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Food services industry contracts 53% due to pandemic: NRAI report

Representational image The restaurant industry or the food services industry contracted by about 53 percent in the financial year 2021 as the COVID-19 pandemic wreaked havoc, a report released by ... Read more »

Ramco Cements Standalone September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 1,493.12 crore, up 18.79% Y-o-Y

Reported Standalone quarterly numbers for The Ramco Cements are: Net Sales at Rs 1,493.12 crore in September 2021 up 18.79% from Rs. 1,256.99 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Profit ... Read more »

Tech Mahindra Consolidated September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 10,881.35 crore, up 16.11% Y-o-Y

Reported Consolidated quarterly numbers for Tech Mahindra are: Net Sales at Rs 10,881.35 crore in September 2021 up 16.11% from Rs. 9,371.80 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Profit at ... Read more »

Quick Heal Tech Consolidated September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 103.79 crore, up 22.95% Y-o-Y

Reported Consolidated quarterly numbers for Quick Heal Technologies are: Net Sales at Rs 103.79 crore in September 2021 up 22.95% from Rs. 84.41 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Profit ... Read more »

Tesla races toward $1 trillion market capitalization club on record Hertz order

Tesla Inc on Monday neared $1 trillion in market capitalization as the company founded by Elon Musk received its biggest-ever order from Hertz, which announced plans to buy 100,000 electric ... Read more »

Mangalam Organ Consolidated September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 143.05 crore, up 66.57% Y-o-Y

Reported Consolidated quarterly numbers for Mangalam Organics are: Net Sales at Rs 143.05 crore in September 2021 up 66.57% from Rs. 85.88 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Profit at ... Read more »

Digicontent Consolidated September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 82.76 crore, up 18.23% Y-o-Y

Reported Consolidated quarterly numbers for Digicontent are: Net Sales at Rs 82.76 crore in September 2021 up 18.23% from Rs. 70.00 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Profit at Rs. ... Read more »

Largest order for plug-in cars ever: 100,000 Teslas to Hertz for rental

The order from Hertz is the largest order for electric cars ever. It is also striking that Hertz pays the list price for Tesla’s Model 3s, while normally hefty discounts ... Read more »

Just months after bankruptcy, Hertz says it will buy 100,000 Teslas for new electric fleet

Shares of Tesla surged on Monday, with the Hertz deal expected to net the electric car maker more than $4 billion. Read more »

Sebi levies fine on 3 employees of Titan for violating insider trading norms

Markets regulator Sebi on Monday imposed monetary penalty on three employees of Titan Company Ltd for violating insider trading norms. The regulator had received a letter from Titan wherein it intimated about violation of Prevention of Insider Trading (PIT) ... Read more »

Visa closes $5 million investment as part of Open's Series C fundraise

Payments technology and card company Visa has closed its investment of $5 million in Open which was part of the neobank’s $100 million Series C fundraise, said sources aware of ... Read more »

NSE surpasses 5 crore registered investors; Maharashtra tops with 17% new investor registrations

The number of registered investors on the National Stock Exchange of India (NSE) crossed five crore on Monday. While the journey from three crore registered investors to four crore registered ... Read more »

Rocket builder ABL raises $200 million, increasing valuation to $2.4 billion

An RS1 rocket booster is shipped out of the company's headquarters in El Segundo, California.ABL Space Rocket builder ABL Space on Monday announced the close of a $200 million round ... Read more »

Google failed to remove over 2,600 illegal materials by early October — lawmaker

Vasily Piskaryov recalled that, during the meeting with the company's management in April, this number stood at over 5,700 Read more »

Facebook top execs interfered to allow US celebrities, politicians violate content rules: Internal documents

Representative image Senior executives of social media giant Facebook intervened to allow politicians and celebrities in the United States to share posts that violated rules related to misinformation and harmful content, reports ... Read more »

Serum Institute of India seeks regular marketing authorisation from DCGI for Covishield

(Image: AFP) Pointing out that over 100 crore doses of Covishield have been supplied in India and many other countries, Serum Institute of India on Monday sought regular marketing approval ... Read more »

Dr. Scott Gottlieb says he'll get his young kids Covid vaccinated as soon as they're eligible

Dr. Scott Gottlieb told CNBC on Monday he plans to get his young kids vaccinated against Covid “as soon as they're eligible.” Pfizer said Friday its two-shot vaccine at smaller ... Read more »

Ceat Q2 net profit skids 77% to Rs 42 crore; approves plan to raise Rs 500 crore

Tyre maker Ceat Ltd on Monday reported a 77 per cent decline in consolidated net profit at Rs 42.28 crore for the the second quarter ended September 30, impacted by ... Read more »

Fate of world's oldest bank, Italy's BMPS, unclear as talks fail

The fate of the world’s oldest bank, Italy’s Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena (BMPS), was hanging in the balance on Monday after the collapse of talks for its sale ... Read more »

Wall Street pause ahead of earnings from tech giants

Source: Reuters Wall Street stocks were mostly little changed early Monday ahead of a deluge of earnings reports later in the week from many of the biggest US companies. Tech ... Read more »

Online searches for housing properties at record high in September; Delhi-NCR tops the list: Housing.com

Online searches for residential properties touched an all-time high in September 2021, with Delhi-NCR topping the chart. This was on the back of positive consumer outlook amid easing concerns on ... Read more »

Facebook allowed politicians, celebrities to flout rules, report reveals

It is reported that the company's management intervened to allow US politicians and celebrities to post anything without any restrictions Read more »

CCI approves HDFC Bank's acquisition of 4.99% stake in HDFC ERGO General Insurance Co

Fair trade regulator Competition Commission of India (CCI) on Monday approved HDFC Bank’s acquisition of 4.99 per cent shareholding in HDFC ERGO General Insurance Company. In June, HDFC Bank had ... Read more »

Tesla stock pops as Hertz orders 100,000 cars in electric rental revamp

Hertz purchased 100,000 Teslas as an “initial order” that will be delivered by the end of 2022. John Thys/AFP via Getty Images Shares of Tesla popped more than 4 percent ... Read more »

Indian economy likely to register 9.5% growth this fiscal: UBS Securities

Representational image. The economy is likely to register a 9.5 percent growth this fiscal over 7.3 percent contraction last year, as the ongoing recovery is faster and more credible than ... Read more »

Bank of Russia does not rule our lower profits of banks in 2022

At the end of 2021, the regulator forecasts a record profit for the banking sector of around $35.75 bln Read more »

Bombay HC: PhonePe cannot claim exclusivity over ‘Pe', in tussle with BharatPe

PhonePe has been asked to stake claim on the entire name, and not a portion of it (Source: ShutterStock) The Bombay High Court has said that PhonePe cannot claim exclusivity ... Read more »

BPCL Privatisation: Bidders struggle to find partners, process may get delayed

The sale of Bharat Petroleum is said to fetch $13 billion for the exchequer and other shareholders. Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited’s (BPCL) privatisation is facing roadblocks as bidders are finding ... Read more »

Nord Stream 2 certification requires legitimacy for exploitation, says German ambassador

The construction of Nord Stream 2 was fully completed on September 10 Read more »

Gold prices back above Rs 48,000 on safe-haven billing, rupee slips; silver up Rs 359

Gold prices soared Rs 337 to Rs 48,142 for 10 gram in the Mumbai bullion market, tracking a positive overseas trend and a sharp fall in the rupee. The precious ... Read more »

Wealth of Tesla CEO Elon Musk peaks above $250 billion

Especially the very prosperous ride up in recent weeks of the Tesla share, in which Musk has a large stake, gives his wealth wings. According to data agency Bloomberg, the ... Read more »

Tech Mahindra added 14,930 employees in Q2 FY22, attrition soared to 21%

Attrition was lower in tier two cities IT services company Tech Mahindra added 14,930 employees for the quarter ending September 2021 as the demand for technology services continue to increase. With ... Read more »

Solar power tariffs may rise next fiscal on increased taxes: Crisil

Following the recent hike in taxes on critical components and the proposed customs duty on modules, solar power tariffs may rise to Rs 2.6-2.7 per unit from an all-time low ... Read more »

IndiGo partners with Kotak Mahindra Bank to launch Ka-ching credit card

Representative image (Source: Shutterstock) Kotak Mahindra Bank (KMBL) and IndiGo airlines announced on October 25 that they have partnered to launch a co-branded credit card called Ka-ching under IndiGo’s 6E ... Read more »

2021 BMW 6-Series Gran Turismo: The oft-overlooked but glorious mix of performance, space and utility

The BMW 6-Series is one of the greatest cars in BMW’s modern line-up that nobody talks about. When it comes to utility, the spotlight falls squarely on the X-badged brigade, ... Read more »

Sneakers generated $70B last year. Black retailers saw little of that.

Richard Newstead | Getty Images The guest bedroom in Earl West's home in suburban Atlanta looks more like a sneaker warehouse. From floor to ceiling, covering the entire space, shoe ... Read more »

Anand Rathi Wealth, Tarson Products, ESAF Small Finance among 7 to get Sebi nod for IPOs

Representative image The Securities and Exchange Board of India has approved the initial public offerings (IPOs) of seven companies including One 97 Communications, the owner of finetch firm Paytm, Anand ... Read more »

Why SpiceJet has lost passenger loads and faces loads of troubles

In May, SpiceJet ferried less than 2 lakh passengers, leading to a single-digit market share When the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) declared the market numbers for September, SpiceJet ... Read more »

Technical View: Nifty forms Hammer pattern, experts say risk-taking traders can go long

The Nifty snapped its four-day losing streak and closed a volatile session with moderate gains on October 25, as buying interest continued in banking and financials. The Nifty touched an ... Read more »

Govt signs share purchase agreement with Tata Sons for Rs 18,000-crore Air India sale

Air India | Representative image The government on Monday signed the share purchase agreement with Tata Sons for the sale of national carrier Air India for Rs 18,000 crore. Earlier ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic