Explained: Why Facebook is holding off on kids' Instagram

#Business, #Children, #Facebook, #Instagram, #Technology, it will “pause”, explosive mid-September report, earlier this year called it

Bowing — perhaps only for a moment — to pressure from lawmakers, critics, the media and child development experts, Facebook said Monday it will “pause” its work on a kids’ version of its photo and video-oriented Instagram app.

But what’s not yet clear is just how seriously Facebook is taking the concerns of experts and parents. Its decision to merely pause the project suggests it still plans to expose a much younger audience to Instagram, its well-documented harms and possibly the user profiling that feeds Facebook’s targeted ad machine. That ad machine, of course, has made the company one of the most profitable on the planet.

WHY IS FACEBOOK DOING THIS NOW?

The company’s move follows an explosive mid-September report by The Wall Street Journal that found Facebook knew from its own research that Instagram was harming some teems, especially girls, leading to mental health and body image problems and in some cases eating disorders and suicidal thoughts.

In public, however, Facebook has consistently played down the app’s negative side and until now has barreled ahead with the kids’ version despite alarms from experts, lawmakers and its own research. It has also relentlessly criticized the Journal article as cherry-picking from Facebook’s research, though it did not dispute the facts. That story, however, was based on internal research leaked by a whistleblower at the company.

It’s likely not a coincidence that on Thursday, a panel of the Senate Commerce Committee will hold a hearing examining the “toxic effects” of Facebook and Instagram on young people. It’s the latest of several hearings to look at whether Big Tech companies are hiding what they know about the harms their products cause.

SO IS INSTA FOR KIDS CANCELED?

Facebook has very specifically not said that it will abandon the project. Instead, Adam Mosseri, the head of Instagram, said in a blog post Monday that the company will use its pause time “to work with parents, experts and policymakers to demonstrate the value and need for this product.”

Translation: Expect Facebook to sharpen its message on the “benefits” of Instagram for Kids in hopes that the furor will die down.

Consider that Facebook had already said it was working with parents, experts and policymakers back in July when it introduced safety measures for teens on its main Instagram platform. In fact, the company has been “working with” experts and other advisors for another product aimed at children — its Messenger Kids app that launched in late 2017.

“Critics of Instagram Kids’ will see this as an acknowledgement that the project is a bad idea,” Mosseri wrote. “That’s not the case.”

WHO ARE THE EXPERTS WORKING WITH FACEBOOK?

Four years ago, Facebook said it gathered a group of experts in the fields of online safety, child development and children’s media to “share their expertise, research and guidance.” The group it calls Youth Advisors include some well-known and some lesser-known nonprofit groups, including the Family Online Safety Institute, Digital Wellness Lab, MediaSmarts, Project Rockit and the Cyberbullying Research Center.

All of these groups receive some form of funding from Facebook, according to their websites. Meanwhile, some of the best-known children’s online advocacy groups — and Facebook’s biggest critics on this matter — such as Common Sense Media and Fairplay (formerly known as the Campaign for Commercial-Free Childhood) are notably absent.

Critics acknowledge that many of the cooperative experts mean well, but say their influence has been negligible. “Facebook has shown time and time again that it is incapable of governing or advising itself with any integrity,” said Kyle Taylor, program director for the Real Facebook Oversight Board, a group critical of the social network. “Facebook’s funding of research and civil society is hugely problematic, and prevents the kind of direct, open process that is required for any real change to occur.”

When Facebook seeks feedback for its projects, Taylor added, “the decks are always stacked with experts who have a financial interest or who will never criticize Facebook’s core issues – their algorithm and their profit margin.”

COULD FACEBOOK STILL PULL THE PLUG?

Fairplay executive director Josh Golin argues that Instagram for Kids may have already sunk beneath the waves. The “pause,”′ he said, is a good way for Facebook to save face and hope that after a while people will forget about it.

He acknowledges that his group and other advocates failed to pressure Facebook into canceling its kids’ messaging product, but says Instagram for Kids is different.

“Instagram is a much much worse platform for children” than Messenger, he said, noting Facebook’s own internal research and a “wealth of evidence” supporting this point. The climate has also changed since 2017 and 2018, when the “techlash” against Big Tech’s harmful effects on society was just emerging. Now, it’s in full force and much more organized. Finally, there’s tech product inertia.

“With Messenger Kids, the backlash didn’t start until it had already came out,” he said. “It is much easier for a corporation to walk back a product that doesn’t yet exist than to take a product off the market,”

WHAT ABOUT OTHER PLATFORMS?

Facebook, of course, is not the only tech platform whose products have caused ripples of concern about the well-being of children. And creating kids’ versions in the face of these concerns is a popular response. After getting in trouble with U.S. regulators for violating children’s privacy rules, for instance, TikTok created a “limited, separate app experience” for users who are under 13. They can’t share videos, comment on other people’s videos or message people. But as with any other app, if kids enter a fake birthdate when they register with the app, they can get around that provision.

YouTube has a kids version too. Lawmakers earlier this year called it a “wasteland of vapid consumerist content” and launched an investigation that’s still ongoing.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Prize-Winning Female Spanish Novelist Exposed as Male Screenwriting Trio

The Spanish literary world was rocked on Friday night by the revelation that one of the country’s most celebrated female novelists, Carmen Mola, was in fact a work of fiction. ... Read more »

FWD Group's IPO hits potential roadblock as US regulator asks questions about Beijing's hold over Hong Kong companies, sources say

FWD Group’s initial public offering has hit a potential regulatory roadblock as the Hong Kong-based insurer backed by tycoon Richard Li Tzar-kai seeks to raise as much as US$3 billion ... Read more »

Newshub proposes to make radio reporter roles redundant

By Anan Zaki of RNZ Newshub is proposing making all its radio reporters redundant. RNZ understands the journalists were told this morning via a PowerPoint presentation. There are more than ... Read more »

PM Narendra Modi speaks to CM Pushkar Singh Dhami, Ajay Bhatt as heavy rains lash Uttarakhand

Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday spoke to Uttarakhand Chief Minister Pushkar Singh Dhami to take stock of the situation in the state hit hard by ... Read more »

Buy Hindalco; target of Rs 650: ICICI Direct

ICICI Direct’s research report on Hindalco Hindalco is the world’s largest aluminium company by revenues, and a major player in copper. Its wholly owned subsidiary Novelis is the world’s largest ... Read more »

Metaverse, Teknologi Masa Depan yang Disasar Facebook hingga Alibaba

© ANTARA FOTO/Moch Asim/aww. PERESMIAN LABORATORIUM VIRTUAL REALITY DAN MICROTEACHING Raksasa teknologi seperti Facebook hingga Alibaba gencar mengembangkan teknologi metaverse. Teknologi tersebut disebut-sebut menjadi teknologi masa depan di dunia digital. ... Read more »

Audi opens bookings for new Q5 SUV in India

Dynamic photo Color: District green German luxury carmaker Audi on Tuesday opened bookings for its upcoming new Q5 SUV in India ahead of its launch next month. The new version of the Q5 can ... Read more »

‘Nastier than ever': have Covid lockdowns helped fuel online hate?

The coronavirus pandemic has been punctuated by outbursts of online hate that have had real-world consequences. The most alarming examples are the 6 January riot in Washington, which was spurred ... Read more »

The Great Resignation: Millions of Aussies predicted to leave jobs

Kelly Knowles* sees resigning from her senior leadership role at a major bank, where she earns a six-figure salary, as leaving an “abusive relationship”. She is one of millions of ... Read more »

163 oxygen plants set up in Madhya Pradesh after shortage during 2nd COVID-19 wave: Shivraj Singh Chouhan

The State Administration Council — as the junta calls itself — says there is no need for alarm. “Actually we have enough Oxygen,” ran the headline in Global New Light ... Read more »

Buy Ultratech Cement target of Rs 8600: Prabhudas Lilladher

500bps growth outperformance over FY21-24E as compared to 250bps earlier). We roll over valuations to Sepemtember-23E and increase target multiples for most of the companies in our coverage universe. We remain broadly constructive ... Read more »

K-pop entrepreneurs: 5 idols who founded successful businesses, from BTS member Jin's Japanese restaurant Ossu Seiromushi to G-Dragon's fashion brand Peaceminusone

We all know that music artists make bank from concert tours and endorsement deals … but the savviest stars make millions from endeavours that have nothing to do with their ... Read more »

Michele Gumabao talks about mom amid criticisms on MOCHA party-list

© Provided by InterAksyon Beauty queen Michele Gumabao shared a post about her mother after receiving criticisms about her move to join a party-list representing mothers which is led by ... Read more »

Five US lawmakers accuse Amazon of possibly lying to Congress following report

Five members of the U.S. House Judiciary committee wrote to Amazon.com Inc’s chief executive Sunday, and accused the company’s top executives, including founder Jeff Bezos, of either misleading Congress or ... Read more »

Filing your income tax returns? Here are answers for five frequently asked questions

Representative image (Source: Shutterstock) The deadline to file your income-tax returns is a couple of months away – December 31, 2021. But it is good to get started early. If ... Read more »

Fespaco, 52 años del mejor cine africano

© Fespaco (EL PAÍS) Una de las salas de proyección del festival Fespaco. Ni la pandemia ni la situación de inseguridad han impedido que se celebre el vigésimo séptimo Festival ... Read more »

Hiring a financial advisor? Your investing style must be the deciding factor

Imagine this: you know three persons with similar profiles – all around 40, in the prime of life, having promising careers, with loving families (spouse, couple of kids). They also ... Read more »

Gold Price Today: Yellow metal likely to witness breakout, traders can initiate fresh buy at current level

Gold prices inched up on October 19 as a decline in the US dollar and US bond yields provided some support to the precious metal. On the Multi-Commodity Exchange (MCX), ... Read more »

What should investors do with L&T Infotech: buy, sell or hold post Q2 results?

Larsen & Toubro Infotech share price touched a 52-week high of Rs 6,680, rising nearly 14 percent on October 19 after the company reported better numbers in the quarter ended ... Read more »

Empleados, padres y estudiantes protestan mandatos de vacunación

© Proporcionado por Telemundo San Diego Parents in Carlsbad are protesting the state’s vaccine mandate for students and employees. SAN DIEGO – Tanto los padres como los empleados de escuelas ... Read more »

DSP Nifty 50 Equal Weight ETF review: Why the scheme when an index fund already exists?

A month after Edelweiss converted two of its exchange-traded funds (ETFs) to index schemes, DSP Mutual Fund has done the opposite thing. DSP Nifty 50 Equal Weight ETF (DNEWE) is ... Read more »

What should investors do with UltraTech Cement after Q2 results: buy, sell or hold?

UltraTech Cement share price fell in the early trade on October 19, a day it reported a consolidated profit after tax (PAT) of Rs 1,313.53 crore for the September quarter, ... Read more »

Dollar falls to 71.25 rubles

Euro grows to 82.76 rubles Read more »

Auto sector shifts gear towards recycling parts, batteries

PARIS (REUTERS) – From ageing electric batteries to old engines to rearview mirrors, the auto industry is revving up its recycling efforts as it faces pressure to reduce its colossal ... Read more »

Taher Badshah of Invesco on pockets in mid and small-caps where valuation comfort exists

Stock markets rallied massively in the last one-and-a-half years. Taher Badshah, chief investment officer of Invesco Mutual Fund, who is known for his contrarian style, decodes how market valuations are ... Read more »

First healthcare premium known: monthly basic insurance premium 3.25 euros more expensive

Everyone with basic insurance with health insurer DSW will pay 3.25 euros more each month next year, bringing the premium to 127.75 euros. As usual, DSW is the first insurer ... Read more »

Evergrande: US fund unimpressed as China treats credit distress, bond defaults with kid gloves

China is treating recent credit crunches involving private companies like China Evergrande Group with kid gloves, leaving much to be done to strengthen investor confidence in the world’s second-largest bond ... Read more »

Mexico to begin packaging Sputnik V vaccine in second half of November - statement

The Mexican regulator issued a permit for the emergency use of Sputnik V in the country to protect residents from the coronavirus infection in early February Read more »

Inox Wind Standalone September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 231.03 crore, up 70.98% Y-o-Y

Reported Standalone quarterly numbers for Inox Wind are: Net Sales at Rs 231.03 crore in September 2021 up 70.98% from Rs. 135.12 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Loss at ... Read more »

California Soft Standalone September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 3.35 crore, up 503.6% Y-o-Y

Reported Standalone quarterly numbers for California Software are: Net Sales at Rs 3.35 crore in September 2021 up 503.6% from Rs. 0.56 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Profit at ... Read more »

Eco Recycling Consolidated September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 4.47 crore, up 129.23% Y-o-Y

Reported Consolidated quarterly numbers for Eco Recycling are: Net Sales at Rs 4.47 crore in September 2021 up 129.23% from Rs. 1.95 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Profit at ... Read more »

PM Narendra Modi, President Ram Nath Kovind greets people on Milad-un-Nabi

Prime Minister Narendra Modi (Illustration: Moneycontrol) Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday greeted people on the occasion of Milad-un-Nabi, the birthday of Prophet Muhammad. Modi said, may the virtues of ... Read more »

HDFC Bank Standalone September 2021 Net Interest Income (NII) at Rs 17,684.39 crore, up 12.09% Y-o-Y

Reported Standalone quarterly numbers for HDFC Bank are: Net Interest Income (NII) at Rs 17,684.39 crore in September 2021 up 12.09% from Rs. 15776.39 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net ... Read more »

Cyient Standalone September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 429.40 crore, up 22.58% Y-o-Y

Reported Standalone quarterly numbers for Cyient are: Net Sales at Rs 429.40 crore in September 2021 up 22.58% from Rs. 350.30 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Profit at Rs. ... Read more »

Eco Recycling Standalone September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 4.44 crore, up 127.69% Y-o-Y

Reported Standalone quarterly numbers for Eco Recycling are: Net Sales at Rs 4.44 crore in September 2021 up 127.69% from Rs. 1.95 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Profit at ... Read more »

UIDAI to host ‘Aadhaar Hackathon 2021' for young innovators from October 28

Aadhaar Enrolment and MBU (at 5 & 15 yrs) are free. Charges for updating Aadhaar are fixed: Rs 50 for demographic update & Rs 100 for biometric update (with or ... Read more »

Inox Wind Consolidated September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 165.84 crore, down 3.07% Y-o-Y

Reported Consolidated quarterly numbers for Inox Wind are: Net Sales at Rs 165.84 crore in September 2021 down 3.07% from Rs. 171.09 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Loss at ... Read more »

California Soft Consolidated September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 3.35 crore, up 503.6% Y-o-Y

Reported Consolidated quarterly numbers for California Software are: Net Sales at Rs 3.35 crore in September 2021 up 503.6% from Rs. 0.56 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Profit at ... Read more »

Gagan Gases Standalone September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 0.81 crore, up 53.23% Y-o-Y

Reported Standalone quarterly numbers for Gagan Gases are: Net Sales at Rs 0.81 crore in September 2021 up 53.23% from Rs. 0.53 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Profit at ... Read more »

Den Networks Standalone September 2021 Net Sales at Rs 295.53 crore, down 4.7% Y-o-Y

Reported Standalone quarterly numbers for Den Networks are: Net Sales at Rs 295.53 crore in September 2021 down 4.7% from Rs. 310.09 crore in September 2020. Quarterly Net Profit at ... Read more »