Experts Push Back Against Rush for COVID Booster Shots

© Provided by HealthDay

© Provided by HealthDay

FRIDAY, Sept. 3, 2021 (HealthDay News) — Opposition is mounting among U.S. and international health experts against President Joe Biden’s push to make COVID-19 booster shots available later this month.

The scientific evidence simply isn’t there to support booster shots, and those doses would be better used in the arms of the unvaccinated around the world to prevent future mutations of COVID, infectious disease experts said in an interview with HealthDay Now.

“The important thing to remember is this is being driven by the unvaccinated. That’s what’s in the hospital right now. It’s not vaccinated people that are the issue in this pandemic,” said Dr. Amesh Adalja, a senior scholar with the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security. “The whole debate over boosters needs to be framed by that, because putting third doses into highly vaccinated populations isn’t going to change what’s happening in the United States.”

Unfortunately, the Biden Administration’s advocacy for booster shots has created a rush by some Americans to get a third dose — even though the additional jabs haven’t yet been approved by federal regulators, said Dr. Camille Kotton, an infectious disease specialist with Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston.

“I will say that I’m shocked at the number of people that have gone out and just helped themselves to booster doses,” Kotton said. “It’s a little bit greedy to do something that’s not really recommended yet, just because they’ve read the newspaper and thought that was a good idea for themselves.”

Last month, Biden told the nation that booster shots would be available the week of Sept. 20 for the earliest recipients of the COVID-19 vaccines, although he added that the plan was pending approval from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

The FDA will hold an advisory board meeting on Sept. 17 to review data from Pfizer regarding booster shots for its vaccine, the agency announced this week.

WHO, EU don’t back booster shots

Both the World Health Organization and the European Union have counseled against booster shots, urging that nations instead focus on getting shots into the arms of the unvaccinated.

That’s the approach Adalja and some other health experts are promoting.

“The longer this virus is unchecked anywhere in the world, the more likely we are to see variants. Until we control this pandemic in all corners of the globe, we’re still going to have variants,” Adalja said. “The way we control this pandemic is by getting first doses, second doses into people’s arms all around the world, even in the United States.”

Kotton and Adalja both noted that at this point, the scientific evidence doesn’t seem to support the need for booster shots in fully vaccinated people.

“Really what we’re seeing is higher rates of breakthrough disease, which is still generally mild symptoms,” said Kotton, who serves on the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), the board that will review booster shots prior to their approval. “People aren’t going to the hospital the vast majority of the time. They just have a little bit of a viral syndrome.”

Check out the full HealthDay Now interview:

ACIP recently approved a third dose of vaccine for people with compromised immune systems, but Kotton noted that the dose isn’t a booster. Rather, people who are immune-compromised will receive a three-dose vaccine series rather than a two-dose series.

“This is not actually a booster dose,” Kotton said. “This is a third dose that is considered part of their primary vaccine series.”

In that case, medical evidence showed that people with immune system deficiencies — solid organ recipients, bone marrow transplant patients, folks fighting cancer — needed a three-dose series to achieve sufficient protection against COVID, Kotton said.

But for the general population, the evidence continues to show that the vaccines protect people against severe illness and hospitalization, Kotton and Adalja said.

“Primarily we’ve been trying to prevent this virus from causing severe disease, hospitalization and death,” Adalja said. “By that standard, the vaccines — even when you see antibody levels wane or you see breakthrough infections occurring — they’re still performing off the charts, because that’s what they were designed to do.”

Let scientists make the call

“Vaccines are not bug zappers. They’re not force fields. They’re not meant to stop every breakthrough infection,” Adalja continued. “Because the breakthrough infections are generally mild, I don’t know that we want to be in the business of chasing them with booster shots when this is not a virus that’s ever going to go away.”

Adalja said he’s “very eager” to see the ACIP debate the data and discuss when healthy people might need a booster.

“This is something we want to be proactive about. We want to have a plan in case it’s necessary,” Adalja said. “But I think giving a date certain that [is] six months or eight months or Sept. 20, that doesn’t really strike me as something that’s evidence-based. I think that’s why you see many infectious disease doctors question the clinical need for these boosters.

“These types of decisions shouldn’t be announced by the White House,” Adalja noted. “They should be announced by the ACIP and the CDC. If we reverse this process, we kind of go back to the old days of the pandemic where you had politicians making decisions about what treatments were effective or were not effective.”

In the meantime, Kotton cautions people not to seek out a booster until it’s been formally approved.

She noted that doctors or pharmacists could wind up in trouble for providing a booster, since it’s “a significant violation of federal policy,” Kotton said.

In addition, people might be on the hook for the cost of their booster dose, since it hasn’t been approved.

“I would really not recommend that people do that of their own accord until such time as we have good scientific evidence to support that,” Kotton said.

More information

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has more on COVID-19 vaccines.

SOURCES: Amesh Adalja, MD, senior scholar, Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security, Baltimore; Camille Kotton, MD, infectious disease specialist, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Fatal stabbing of U.K. lawmaker declared a terrorist incident by police

London's Metropolitan Police Department has declared the fatal stabbing of British lawmaker David Amess a terrorist incident. Amess died earlier Friday after he was stabbed multiple times while meeting with ... Read more »

Ruling could block Alabama execution scheduled next week

FILE – This undated file photo provided by the Alabama Department of Corrections shows Willie B. Smith III. Federal judges heard arguments Wednesday, Oct. 13, 2021 about whether Willie B. ... Read more »

Ida flooding victim says Queens not getting federal aid that de Blasio promised

Woodside resident Julia Nieves ripped Mayor Bill de Blasio and FEMA for failing to get any federal aid to victims of Hurricane Ida. Matthew McDermott A Hurricane Ida flooding victim ... Read more »

Anti-vaxxer claims doctors banished unvaccinated from surgeries

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A furious patient claims he was forced to wait outside a medical centre in a makeshift plastic booth after the practice banned him ... Read more »

David Ortiz clowns Alex Rodriguez's yoga video: ‘WTF is that?'

View this post on Instagram A post shared by Alex Rodriguez (@arod) Alex Rodriguez worked out with David Ortiz, then he got worked over by the ex-Red Sox slugger. “Much ... Read more »

Female former Afghan lawmakers, judges meet Greek PM

1 / 3Greece AfghanistanAfghan women attend a meeting with Greece’s Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis at Maximos Mansion, in Athens, Friday, Oct. 15, 2021. The Afghan women, part of a group ... Read more »

2nd Judicial Circuit Judge, Clifton Newman to hear Alex Murdaugh bond hearing Tuesday morning

Oct. 15—On Friday afternoon, Attorney General Alan Wilson announced Alex Murdaugh's bond hearing on charges of obtaining property by false pretenses will take place at the Richland County Courthouse before ... Read more »

Wagener man charged with attempted murder in Holley Street shooting

Oct. 15—A Wagener man was arrested Wednesday in connection to a May shooting . Frankie Lee Walker II, 34, is charged with attempted murder and possession of a weapon during ... Read more »

Police say accomplice in Wagener Road murder drove a getaway car, police warn suspect is 'armed and dangerous'

Oct. 15—The Aiken County Sheriff's Office is seeking the public's assistance in locating a suspect in an Oct. 2 shooting death . Robert Gene Payne II, 29, is wanted for ... Read more »

Aiken man charged with sexual exploitation of a minor, criminal sexual conduct with a minor

Oct. 15—An Aiken man was arrested Wednesday in connection to multiple sex crimes against a minor. Matthew Ramon Drayton, 23, is charged with first-degree sexual exploitation of a minor, second-degree ... Read more »

UK police review security as Sir David Amess' killing declared extremism

© Provided by The National Sir David Amess attends Old Leigh Regatta in Leigh-on-Sea, in 2019. Alamy Prayers were offered for the British Conservative MP Sir David Amess on Friday ... Read more »

Join the race for half-term hols with savings up to £1,000 for families

WILL you be joining the race for cut-price half-term hols? As testing and red-list restrictions ease, the next weekend offers the best chance for a low-cost and hassle-free overseas trip ... Read more »

Jeff Bezos' Girlfriend Lauren Sanchez Gives Her Little Brown Dress a Sporty Twist in Alexander McQueen Sneakers on Lunch Date

© Christopher Peterson / Billionaire Jeff Bezos And His Girlfriend Lauren Sanchez Leave Cipriani Soho In New York City Lauren Sanchez gives a lesson in being effortlessly chic. The ... Read more »

Josh Gordon plans on making most of his latest opportunity

© Provided by NBC Sports Chiefs receiver Josh Gordon had not played a game since Dec. 15, 2019, when he stepped on the field last week. Gordon saw nine snaps ... Read more »

NFL: No one else in league cited with violation for vulgar emails

The NFL has found no other current team or league personnel to have sent emails containing racist, homophobic or misogynistic language similar to messages written by Jon Gruden that led ... Read more »

Bill Clinton to spend 4th night in Orange County ICU for IV treatment

Former President Clinton, hospitalized at an Orange County hospital because of an infection, will remain another night in the intensive care unit to continue intravenous antibiotic treatment, a spokesman said ... Read more »

'Lawless city?' Worry after Portland police don't stop chaos

PORTLAND, Ore. (AP) — A crowd of 100 people wreaked havoc in downtown Portland, Oregon, this week – smashing storefront windows, lighting dumpsters on fire and causing at least $500,000 ... Read more »

Louisiana-Monroe vs. Liberty: How to watch, schedule, live stream info, game time, TV channel

© Provided by CBS Sports Oct 6, 2018; Oxford, MS, USA; Louisiana Monroe Warhawks head coach Matt Viator at right waits to lead his team onto the field to face ... Read more »

Earn Your Pilot Wings with a Drone Made for Beginners

© Amazon There are two things you no longer need in order to capture excellent aerial camera footage: a helicopter or a $2,000 drone. There are plenty of drones for ... Read more »

FDNY announces first-ever anti-nepotism rules

NEW YORK — New York City’s Fire Department has released its first-ever anti-nepotism policy, prompting eye rolls from critics who say “FDNY family” is more than just a feelgood catch ... Read more »

What happens with the Jeff Pash email situation?

© Provided by NBC Sports Last week, it appeared that Raiders coach Jon Gruden would weather the storm of a single email containing a racist trope. Then, more emails were ... Read more »

LRA Semangar rosak: Lebih 3,000 penduduk kecewa

JOHOR BAHRU – Lebih 3,000 penduduk Kampung Sinaran Kempas dan Kampung Maju Jaya di sini kecewa dengan ketidakcekapan pengurusan Ranhill SAJ Sdn Bhd menyediakan bantuan bekalan air yang terjejas sejak ... Read more »

ADUN Kota Anggerik sah bergelar suami Syahira

© Provided by Sinar Harian KUALA LUMPUR – Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri (ADUN) Kota Anggerik, Najwan Halimi, 36, sah bergelar suami kepada pasangannya Syahira Razak, 27, selepas diijabkabulkan dalam majlis ... Read more »

China's Shenzhou-13 spacecraft docks for 6-month mission

© Provided by Associated Press In this photo released by Xinhua News Agency, the crewed spaceship Shenzhou-13, atop a Long March-2F carrier rocket, is launched from the Jiuquan Satellite Launch ... Read more »

Police report: Victim's skull was visible following violent attack, two charged

Oct. 15—EDITOR'S NOTE — This story contains graphic detail of the victim's injuries, and may not be suitable for all readers. WINNER — Two Winner men are facing serious charges ... Read more »

Missouri man gets life plus 107 years in Jackson County sex abuse case: prosecutors

A Nevada, Missouri man has received 16 concurrent life sentences plus 107 years in prison after he was convicted on dozens of sex crimes involving children, the Jackson County Prosecutor’s ... Read more »

Fatal stabbing of Sir David Amess declared terrorist incident

The fatal stabbing of Conservative MP Sir David Amess has been declared a terrorist incident, Metropolitan Police have confirmed. The 69-year-old, who had been an MP since 1983, was fatally ... Read more »

Mitchell Police use stun gun on man twice after being threatened with knife, charges allege

Oct. 15—Police in Mitchell had to utilize their stun guns twice earlier this month after a man with a knife squared off with them, a police report says. Shortly after ... Read more »

How to view and delete your Amazon Prime Video watch history

© Marko Geber/Getty Images How to view and delete your Amazon Prime Video watch history To view and delete your Amazon Prime watch history, go to the Settings page of ... Read more »

How to reset an Amazon Echo speaker from the Alexa app or from the device

© Charles Brutlag/Shutterstock How to reset an Amazon Echo speaker from the Alexa app or from the device You can reset an Amazon Echo by pressing buttons on the physical ... Read more »

Midland's history stretches back thousands of years before the railways put the area on the map

© Provided by ABC NEWS Midland Town Hall opened in 1907, the dome was added after World War I as a memorial to the fallen. (ABC Radio Perth: Emma Wynne) ... Read more »

Rescued in Alabama, sea turtle dies at Mississippi Aquarium

A threatened loggerhead sea turtle was found dead Friday at the Mississippi Aquarium, eight days after being accidentally hooked and then rescued at a state park on Alabama’s Gulf Coast. ... Read more »

Former President Bill Clinton to remain in hospital

Former President Bill Clinton will remain hospitalized in Southern California but “all health indicators are trending in the right direction,” a spokesperson said on Friday. © Provided by NBC News ... Read more »

UK Parliament member dies after being stabbed in terrorist attack

David Amess, a conservative British member of Parliament, died Friday after being stabbed multiple times, officials said. Amess, 69, represented Southend West in Essex. He was attacked while holding his ... Read more »

Kadarius Toney's composure will be put to test by Jalen Ramsey

There are parts of the game every NFL rookie must work on. There are edges to be smoothed to extract the full amount of talent. For Kadarius Toney, it is ... Read more »

The Best Marvel Halloween Costumes for Kids Who Love Superheroes

© ShopDisney If your little one has Marvel mania, then a superhero costume is in order for Halloween. Whether they want to channel Brie Larson‘s look in Captain Marvelor Tom Holland‘s ... Read more »

Denis Villeneuve spent days flying in helicopters over the desert looking for 'Dune' filming locations because he refused to use green screens

© Provided by INSIDER Denis Villeneuve (inset) directed Timothée Chalamet and Rebecca Ferguson in “Dune.” Michael Loccisano/Getty Images; Chiabella James/Warner Bros. Pictures Denis Villeneuve insisted on filming “Dune” in real-life ... Read more »

Halle Berry's Second Sweaty Betty Collection Is Launching Soon -- Get the Details

© Stefanie Keenan/Getty Images for CDGA Halle Berry is teaming up with Sweaty Betty again! The actress, along with her health and wellness platform Respin, is collaborating with the activewear brand for the ... Read more »

2023 IndyCar won't take major toll on tires, says Firestone

© Chris Owens Alex Palou, Chip Ganassi Racing Honda Yesterday’s test at Mid-Ohio by Chip Ganassi Racing-Honda’s new champion Alex Palou and two-time champ Josef Newgarden of Team Penske-Chevrolet saw ... Read more »

David Amess: Fatal Stabbing Of MP Declared A Terrorist Incident

David Amess was stabbed several times at a surgery in his Southend West constituency. (Photo: Chris McAndrew via PA Media) The fatal stabbing of Conservative MP David Amess has been ... Read more »