Experts predict the legal fallout from the Alec Baldwin prop gun shooting

Asia's Tech News Daily

Halyna Hutchins, photographed at the Sundance Film Festival in 2019, was shot to death Thursday on set in Santa Fe, N.M. (Fred Hayes / Getty Images)

The shooting death of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins on a New Mexico film set could have far-reaching legal ramifications, experts said — not only for the companies involved but also for individuals, including star and producer Alec Baldwin.

Hutchins was killed and director Joel Souza injured Thursday by a gun that Baldwin discharged during the filming of “Rust.”

No criminal charges have been filed in the case, which is being investigated by Santa Fe authorities.

Baldwin, the film's leading actor as well as one of its producers, said Friday he is “fully cooperating with the police investigation” into the death. “There are no words to convey my shock and sadness regarding the tragic accident that took the life of Halyna Hutchins, a wife, mother and deeply admired colleague of ours,” Baldwin wrote in a series of tweets.

A representative for Baldwin declined to comment further Saturday.

Attorneys and law professors said multiple people and entities involved in the production could face civil liabilities as a result of the death. Fatal on-set accidents involving firearms are rare, and film and television productions have rigorous protocols for the use of guns to prevent injury. When deaths do happen, lawsuits typically follow.

“Somebody has to have been negligent,” said USC Gould School of Law professor Gregory Keating. “This doesn’t happen without negligence. There are safety protocols that are supposed to be followed. It’s really just a matter of who’s negligent and how the responsibility gets parceled out. Then it gets murky because the facts are murky.”

Lawsuits can result in millions of dollars in damages. The family of Sarah Jones, a crew member killed in a 2014 train accident during the making of “Midnight Rider,” was awarded $11.2 million after filing a wrongful-death lawsuit.

Who faces liability in the “Rust” case will depend on how far the alleged negligence extends. The armorer, the person responsible for gun props used while filming, could be sued, as could the assistant director who reportedly handed Baldwin the weapon, Keating said.

The Associated Press, citing court records, reported Friday that Baldwin was given the gun by assistant director Dave Halls, who indicated it was safe to use in the moments before the actor fired it. The assistant director did not know the prop gun was loaded with any live rounds, according to a search warrant filed in a Santa Fe County court. Halls did not respond to The Times' request for comment.

In the film industry, a live round refers to a gun being loaded with some material such as a blank ready for filming, a source close to the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees told The Times.

The armorer, Hannah Gutierrez Reed, could not be reached for comment. The 24-year-old is the daughter of veteran armorer Thell Reed and had recently completed her first film.

The “Rust” production company could face significant damages in a civil suit, legal experts said, especially if producers of the low-budget feature were found to have cut corners to save time and money and skirted standard safety procedures. Baldwin could be named in a lawsuit for negligence, not because he was holding the weapon but because he is one of the producers.

“I’d be shocked if there wasn’t a lawsuit against the production company,” said Bryan Sullivan, a partner at Early Sullivan Wright Gizer & McRae. “They might name Alec Baldwin to get leverage, or the armorer or the lead producer, but in the end all of them are employees of the production company and any liability would be docked from the company and whatever insurance they have.”

“Rust” crew members told The Times that safety protocols, including gun inspections, were not strictly followed on the set. One of the camera operators complained last weekend to a production manager about gun safety, they said.

Baldwin’s stunt double accidentally fired two rounds Oct. 16 after being told the gun was “cold,” two crew members who witnessed the incident said. A colleague alarmed by the misfires sent a text message to the unit production manager, The Times reported.

The production company, Rust Movie Productions, said Friday in a statement that it was “not made aware of any official complaints concerning weapon or prop safety on set.”

“The safety of our cast and crew is the top priority of Rust Productions and everyone associated with the company,” the statement said. It added: “We will be conducting an internal review of our procedures while production is shut down. We will continue to cooperate with the Santa Fe authorities in their investigation and offer mental health services to the cast and crew during this tragic time.”

The producers did not respond to requests for additional comment on Saturday.

“There’s no explanation where you have this happen on a set where there’s not civil negligence,” said attorney Jeff Harris, who has worked on cases involving injuries and deaths on film and TV sets. “Could it rise to the level of criminal negligence? That’s what we’re going to have to hear more information about. In terms of liability up the chain, you’re hearing anecdotally from people saying that the set was in chaos. That, to me, is the sort of systemic recipe for trouble.”

Lawyers cautioned that there are still many unanswered questions regarding the incident, which has quickly become the dominant topic of conversation among crew workers in Hollywood.

“What safety protocols did they have in place?” said Stuart Fraenkel of Nelson & Fraenkel, who has represented clients including Olivia Jackson, the stuntwoman badly injured in an accident while filming “Resident Evil: The Final Chapter.” “Did they have safety meetings? We don’t know that yet.”

Some could face charges of involuntary manslaughter, depending on the outcome of the investigation, said Richard Kaplan, a Los Angeles defense attorney who represents white-collar clients.

In New Mexico, involuntary manslaughter charges can be brought against someone who commits a lawful act that results in death because of negligence or a lack of due caution.

“There is somebody who’s supposed to make sure things like this don’t happen,” Kaplan said. “If anyone has liability, it would be that person who was in charge of the armory on the set.”

Still, experts said there may not be criminal charges in this case. Asked about Baldwin's vulnerability, several lawyers noted that the actor reportedly was told the weapon was safe when it was given to him.

Criminal cases involving on-set deaths are rare, but they have happened. Director John Landis and other filmmakers were found not guilty of involuntary manslaughter in the deaths of actor Vic Morrow and two child actors killed in 1982 on the set of “Twilight Zone: The Movie.”

“A lot of prosecutors' offices watched that case and learned a lesson from it, which is: Don’t take what is basically civil negligence and turn it into a criminal action,” said criminal defense attorney Glen T. Jonas of Torrance-based firm Jonas & Driscoll. “There are circumstances where you could criminally prosecute someone for gross negligence, but just because you can doesn’t mean you should.”

In a counter-example, director Randall Miller spent one year in jail after he pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter over the death of Jones, the camera assistant who was killed in Georgia when a train collided into a crew filming “Midnight Rider.”

This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Chitrangda Singh: I would be lying if I said I am not frustrated

© Provided by Radio City She remembers watching the spine-chilling contract killer in Sujoy Ghosh’s Kahaani (2012). Nine years later, Chitrangda Singh finds herself immersed in the world of Bob ... Read more »

Gazprom reports record quarter on surging gas prices, sees even better Q4

By Vladimir Soldatkin and Oksana Kobzeva © Reuters/Maxim Shemetov Logo of Gazprom Neft oil company is seen at petrol station in Moscow MOSCOW (Reuters) -Russia’s Gazprom on Monday reported a ... Read more »

Ange Postecoglou turns Celtic into passing kings of the world as 'Ange-ball' leads Manchester City and Bayern Munich

After some initial uncertainty over his appointment, Celtic fans are loving life under Ange Postecoglou. The Greek-Australian boss has clear and uncompromising ideas about how the game should be played, ... Read more »

One in 16 UK homes changed hands in 2021

© Provided by This Is Money MailOnline logo This year is set to be the UK’s busiest in terms of housing transactions since the financial crisis, as one in 16 ... Read more »

The Guardian editorial: how does a newspaper decide what it thinks?

Photograph: Van Hoepen/Getty Images A newspaper’s views evolve but its leader columns represent a palimpsest of its history, where layer upon layer of thought has been inscribed. So how does ... Read more »

Cash in the Attic reboot with Chris Kamara and Jules Hudson

© Bang Showbiz Chris Kamara is joining as co-host ‘Cash in the Attic’ is returning with co-hosts Chris Kamara and Jules Hudson. The football pundit has signed up for the ... Read more »

Chelsea face nightmare Premier League fixture pile-up as Club World Cup dates confirmed

Chelsea are set to go a month without playing a Premier League fixture after the dates for the Club World Cup were confirmed. The Blues are currently top of the ... Read more »

Saya terima sumbangan wang untuk baiki sekolah, Nazri beritahu mahkamah

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Nazri Aziz berkata, beliau memperkenalkan ahli perniagaan Zarul Ahmad Mohd Zulkifli kepada bekas Ketua Menteri Pulau Pinang Lim Guan Eng. KUALA LUMPUR: Seorang bekas ... Read more »

Tory Woke Wars: 5 New 'Nonsense' Culture Rows Whipped Up This Week

This week has seen a flurry of anti-woke stories (Photo: HuffPost UK) First it was statues, then it was footballers taking the knee, now the new culture war is about ... Read more »

Fake thermometers that only show 37°C sold online, worth more than S$14,000 seized, woman busted

© The Independent Singapore Singapore — A Singapore Police Force (SPF) press release on Sunday (Nov 28) confirmed that a 33-year-old woman was arrested for her suspected involvement in the ... Read more »

Saudi Arabian Grand Prix will suit Lewis Hamilton more than Max Verstappen, Red Bull chief admits

This weekend’s Saudi Arabia Grand Prix will suit Lewis Hamilton more than Max Verstappen, according to Red Bull chief Christian Horner. © Getty Images Hamilton and Verstappen will lock horns ... Read more »

Gio must avoid 1st Rangers disaster with £21k-p/w "student" who's a "joy to work with" - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast 2021-09-30T162603Z_2080354581_UP1EH9U19NC1Q_RTRMADP_3_SOCCER-EUROPA-SPP-RFC-REPORT (1) An update has emerged regarding interest in Rangers gem Ianis Hagi from mainland Europe… What’s the talk? According to Romanian outlet Eurosport, via ... Read more »

Prince Charles calls in lawyers over claims he was ‘royal racist' after aides blast allegations as ‘fiction'

PRINCE Charles last night called in lawyers over claims he was the “royal racist” — branding them “fiction”. Aides rubbished allegations that Charles questioned the future skin tone of Prince ... Read more »

I quit my £90k job but still saved £24k in one year – here's my 13 tips for a VERY budget Christmas your kids will love

FORMER high-flyer Kel Galavan quit her job in 2018 – but still managed to save an astonishing £24k.  The former high-flyer, from Kildare, 30 miles west of Dublin, lives with ... Read more »

Michelle Keegan stuns in black blazer as she glams up for date night with husband Mark Wright

MICHELLE Keegan looked incredible last night as she glammed up for a fancy dinner date with husband Mark Wright. The actress, 34, posed for a smiley snap after polishing off ... Read more »

Our favourite IPL hair removal machine has 22% off this Black Friday weekend

The attachment head rotates 180-degrees, an industry-first according to the brand (iStock/The Independent) Black Friday 2021 is in full swing, with the final day of the huge event, known as ... Read more »

Fussball-Legende Evra enthüllt: «Ich gehörte der Mafia»

© Bereitgestellt von Blick Manchester’s Patrice Evra dribbles the ball in the UEFA Champions League semi-finals first leg FC Schalke 04 vs. Manchester United at the Arena AufSchalke in Gelsenkirchen, ... Read more »

I'm a double lung transplant patient and my damp and mouldy council flat will KILL me, doctors have warned

A DOUBLE lung transplant patient fears her mouldy council flat could kill her. Doctors warned Lisa Grainger her damp home “could hasten her death” if she continues to live there ... Read more »

MoUs worth over Rs 14,000 cr signed before Vibrant Gujarat Summit

As many as 12 MoUs entailing proposed investment of Rs 14,000 crore in Gujarat were signed as part of the upcoming Vibrant Gujarat Global Summit 2022 at an event here ... Read more »

36 Jahre nach ihrer letzten WM-Medaille schlägt Ni Xia Lian (58) wieder zu

© Michael Wyke/ Ni Xia Lian schlägt im WM-Halbfinal auf. Der Begriff «Legende» wird manchmal etwas gar oft verwendet. Auf Ni Xia Lian trifft er aber definitiv zu. Bei der ... Read more »

TV-Kritik zur neuen SRF-Serie «Tschugger»: Feiner Walliser Raclette-Western

Gestern Sonntag ist die fünfteilige SRF-Serie «Tschugger» (auch Play Suisse und Sky Show) gestartet. Blick hat sich alle Folgen angesehen und meint: Das Werk des Oberwalliser Multitalents David Constantin um ... Read more »

Diese Promis sind schon in Weihnachtsstimmung

© Bloomberg via Getty Images Jill Biden empfängt den Weihnachtsbaum für das Weisse Haus. Juhu – die Adventszeit ist endlich da. Guetsli backen, Geschenke kaufen, Weihnachtsbäume schmücken … Pünktlich zum ... Read more »

LIC to up stake in Kotak Mahindra Bank to nearly 10%

New Delhi: Insurance behemoth LIC will raise its stake in private sector lender Kotak Mahindra Bank to nearly 10 per cent, after receiving grant of approval from t:he Reserve Bank ... Read more »

Correction or no correction? Hope lingers for market amid gloom over new corona variant

NEW DELHI: Benchmark indices the Nifty and Sensex have fallen as much as 8 per cent from their all-time highs last month. High valuation was already a hurdle for the ... Read more »

HC directs Centre to inform it about introduction of bill on cryptocurrency

The Bombay High Court on Monday directed the Union government to apprise it on January 17, 2022 about the introduction of the bill on cryptocurrency and what further action has ... Read more »

Spanish squad Team Queso want to be Wild Rift champions someday

Team Queso may not have had a stellar run at the recently concluded Wild Rift Horizon Cup 2021, but the team remain undeterred. Queso’s squad were in pretty good spirits ... Read more »

China not inviting Western politicians who threaten boycott of Beijing Winter Games, media says

© Reuters/TINGSHU WANG FILE PHOTO: Beijing marks 100 days to the opening of Beijing 2022 Winter Olympics BEIJING (Reuters) – China does not plan to invite Western politicians who threaten ... Read more »

WATCH: How IAXE's Song 'Ako'y Sa'yo, Ika'y Akin' Was Written In Less Than 30 Minutes

© Provided by Cosmopolitan Philippines How long do you think it would take you to write a four-minute song? Do you think you can do it in less than 30 ... Read more »

Russland wirft Spanien aus dem Turnier

© KEYSTONE/EPA/Rodrigo Jimenez Der Titelverteidiger Spanien scheidet am späten Sonntagabend nach einer 1:2-Niederlage gegen Russland beim Davis-Cup-Finalturnier nach der Vorrunde aus. Damit stehen die Russen ebenso in den Viertelfinals wie ... Read more »

WC ready for fourth wave of COVID-19 infections, say health officials

© Kaylynn Palm/EWN A new facility will soon come online in Mitchells Plain to assist with the caseload as officials battle to cope with COVID-19 hospitalisations. CAPE TOWN – Health ... Read more »

Covid live news: Six cases of Omicron variant found in Scotland; WHO says ‘very high' global risk from new strain

© Photograph: Amer Ghazzal/REX/Shutterstock A “stay safe, save lives” sign in Waterloo, London. LIVE – Updated at 08:39 Cases confirmed in Lanarkshire and Greater Glasgow and Clyde area; World Health ... Read more »

I love looking glam and buying new clothes but never spend more than £5 – here's how to nab anything for bargain prices

A THRIFTY mum has revealed how she's built a wardrobe full of chic and on-trend outfits but never spends more than £5 for each. Emily Firmin, 41, from Warwickshire, loves ... Read more »

'No point in living' - Pensioners pushed into poverty due to energy bill hike

Those over the state pension age are sounding the alarm that “there won’t be any point in living” unless more support is provided. In response to this ongoing problem, experts ... Read more »

Mum-of-22 Sue Radford forced to defend her spending after flaunting ‘disgusting' wealth at her ‘millionaire mansion'

MUM-of-22 Sue Radford has been forced to defend her ‘extravagant’ spending after trolls accused her of flaunting a ‘disgusting display of wealth.' The mum of Britain’s biggest family took to ... Read more »

Great news for savers as new savings bond offers 3.5% interest - but there is a ‘caveat'

With interest rates on savings accounts being so low recently, this new savings bond offering 3.5 percent may seem like an “attractive” offer, and it may encourage people to lock ... Read more »

Did Vice Ganda, John Prats unfollow each other on Instagram?

In a recent Ogie Diaz’s vlog released on November 23, he shared a comment from a netizen who discovered that Vice Ganda and John Prats allegedly unfollowed each other on ... Read more »

I'm A Celeb's Richard Madeley opens up on hospital dash: 'I didn't know where I was'

Richard Madeley has spoken out on his exit from ITV’s I’m A Celebrity… Get Me Out Of Here! as he returned to Good Morning Britain on Monday, 29 November. The ... Read more »

Over 80s could be entitled to state pension top up - are you eligible?

As people get older, it is vital for them to maximise their money, as they may not have a salary coming in each month to support living expenses. The state ... Read more »

Pharmally's Ong, Mohit Dargani turned over to Pasay City Jail

— Pharmally Pharmaceutical Corporation officials Linconn Ong and Mohit Dargani were transferred to the Pasay City Jail on Monday. Dargani and Ong, who were accompanied by the officers of the ... Read more »

Britain to offer everyone a COVID-19 booster eventually - vaccine official

© Reuters/Toby Melville FILE PHOTO: An NHS COVID-19 vaccination health campaign advertisement is displayed, amidst the spread of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19), in London LONDON (Reuters) – Britain is moving ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic