Experts broadly positive about digital Covid vaccination certificates

Plans to issue a digital vaccination certificate to people who have been jabbed were announced last week, but so far details have been sparse. Spotlight asked several experts for their views on what we know about the certificates so far.

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved

Last week the Department of Health announced plans to issue digital vaccination certificates to people who have received Covid-19 jabs. While the details were sparse, Minister of Health Dr Joe Phaahla said the certificates would become available in “just over a week or so”.

But at a press conference on 17 September Phaahla said a team in the department was still working on the certificates and that an implementation plan would be presented to the National Coronavirus Command Council in the next 10 days. Other government departments, including Home Affairs, would be involved in the process since this was not an undertaking the department could do on its own.

What we know so far

At last week’s press conference Phaahla announced that the digital certificate will be in line with World Health Organization (WHO) guidelines.

The WHO issued a guideline document on 27 August outlining the implementation of digital vaccination certificates that contain an individual’s Covid-19 vaccination status, to support member states in adopting “interoperable standards for recording vaccination status”.

The document said digital certification might take the form of barcodes, QR codes or more advanced systems using smartphone applications.

Phaahla said vaccinated individuals who have been captured on the EVDS system (presumably almost everyone who has been jabbed) will be given access to a digital certificate that can be downloaded on a smartphone and printed. That the certificate can be printed suggests a printable barcode or QR code solution will be made available.

Phaahla also reassured the public that the certificate will not be required to gain access to public or essential services, but may be needed to access some entertainment, sports and other events. He reiterated this point at the press conference, stressing that people will not have to show vaccination certificates when visiting government clinics or Sassa pay points.

He also explained that the government was providing a “platform” or “facility” with the certificates. It would be up to universities, employers, sporting organisations and so on to decide whether to use the platform to limit access based on vaccination status. “We will not interfere with institutions’ internal policy. The aim is not to punish anybody, but to protect each other,” Phaahla said.

Whether the certificates will be able to prove vaccination status when travelling abroad and exactly how this would work, is not yet clear.

President Cyril Ramaphosa, in an address last Sunday, also referred to these certificates. He said further information would be provided on so-called vaccine passports that can be used as evidence of vaccination “for various purposes and events”.

“The Department of Health is looking at a variety of mechanisms, like they have in other countries, to either do it electronically through a cellphone or some other form of demonstration,” he said.

Spotlight asked the department for more information. Spokesperson Foster Mohale said before the press briefing that the matter was still under discussion and that a public announcement would be made in the next week or two once all the systems were ready.

Certificate not controversial, but its use may be

Andy Gray, a senior lecturer in pharmacology at the University of KwaZulu-Natal, said he welcomed the chance to have electronic and secure documentation of vaccination that is compliant with the WHO’s standards.

Gray said the certificate itself is not controversial as it is similar to the yellow fever vaccination certificate required for some international travel, but the use of the certificate could be problematic, particularly since only a small percentage of the country has been vaccinated.

By 15 September, the Health Department’s vaccination dashboard showed only 28.16% of the adult population had received at least one Covid-19 shot.

Gray added that the certificate may be used to limit access to certain venues or activities, which could be an acceptable incentive to get vaccinated, but only once a larger proportion of the population had been vaccinated.

“It is only viable once there is a high level of access to vaccination. It can be used appropriately as an incentive (to get vaccinated)… but care must be taken to avoid it being used in a discriminatory way, especially against those denied access to vaccination,” he said.

Public health lawyer Safura Abdool Karim was also in favour of the certificate and said it was an important first step in being able to verify someone’s vaccination status in real time. She added that a digital certificate will be less vulnerable to fraudulent copies than the cardboard vaccination cards currently being issued.

According to Phaahla, “from a government perspective, [they] want to make available the certificate and make sure it has good protection and that it is reliable information derived from the EVDS”. 

“So, when the certificate says you’ve had one Pfizer dose, it must be real. When you update on your phone, the certificate will upgrade you to say now you’ve had two jabs.”

Distinguished professor and bioethicist at Stellenbosch University, Keymanthri Moodley, also welcomed the announcement, saying it would increase vaccine uptake:

“It is a move in the right direction. By requiring proof of vaccination, vaccine uptake will increase and more people will be protected from serious disease and death. We can reopen our economy. It’s a win-win scenario for all. A public health ethics approach supports this development. The benefits outweigh the disadvantages.”

She cited several benefits, including improved vaccination uptake which will prevent serious illness, hospital admission and death. This, in turn, would reduce strain on the healthcare system and improve the safety of healthcare workers, as well as free up more space at healthcare facilities to treat non-Covid patients.

Digital format must not exclude those without access 

Public health specialist and president of the Public Health Association of South Africa, Dr Harsha Somaroo, said using a digital platform to show proof of Covid-19 vaccination was in keeping with international trends.

“However, I think that South Africa needs to have a hybrid approach to this. [For example] despite the availability of the digital option, we need to continue to issue paper vaccination certificates, as [fewer] than 50% of the population use a smartphone,” she said.

Gray said: “If the electronic format excludes some people such as those without access to a smartphone, that is a concern. It remains to be seen how the national Department of Health will manage access for those without smartphones, in particular.”

According to Moodley, the concerns about lack of access owing to the certificate being digital could be addressed by having a paper certificate with a barcode that can be scanned (similar to our ID cards).

She added that in the extremely rare event that someone was not able to be vaccinated for a medical reason, regular Covid-19 tests could be required to access indoor or high-risk venues.

Phaahla said at the Friday briefing that people would also be able to get the printout at the nearest vaccination sites that have printing facilities. “If there is no printer they will have to refer you to where you can get it printed, so it is not just for those with smartphones.”

More information needed

According to Somaroo, while a digital vaccination certificate that complies with the WHO standards was proactive and likely to support more travel to and from South Africa, more information was needed.

“It would be important to understand the costs and resources involved, that it does not disadvantage anyone, and the background to how this strategy was judged to present an overall benefit for South Africans,” she said.

Somaroo added it was essential that the government issued clear guidelines around the digital certificates and how these should be used to avoid inequities or affecting the rights of people who don’t have access to a smartphone.

Karim cautioned that concerns may emerge regarding the policies implemented in relation to the certificates.

“We are going to need to think very carefully about how these certificates are used,” she said.

According to Abdool Karim, concerns could include discrimination against those of lower socioeconomic status, abuse by private actors, or use that violates human rights to an unjustifiable degree.

‘More important issues’

Russell Rensburg, director of the Rural Health Advocacy Project, told Spotlight that he thinks the digital certificates are merely an administrative issue and while a lot of people care about these certificates, it is distracting us from more important issues around the country’s Covid-19 vaccination efforts.

“I don’t want to be dismissive; I just think we should be focusing our energies on getting at least the most at-risk population fully vaccinated and our conversation does not need to get distracted from that,” he said.

“I don’t think we’re talking enough about breaking down the data, understanding who is not taking it (Covid-19 vaccination) up – whether it’s vaccine hesitancy or access. We can’t just assume that it’s vaccine hesitancy… it could be other things.”

Possible reasons for a lack of vaccine access were a lack of transport, not being able to wait the whole day for a vaccine, or vaccinations being administered primarily at healthcare facilities instead of community centres. DM/MC

* This article was produced by Spotlight – health journalism in the public interest.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


How to remove tartar from teeth without a dentist by reducing plaque build-up for a healthier smile

How to remove tartar from teeth without a dentist is a common question that most oral health professionals are asked. Sadly, the reality is that this is not a procedure ... Read more »

Ronaldo reveals how he will shut up the critics this season

© PA Images Cristiano Ronaldo setting up for a corner Cristiano Ronaldo has responded to criticism that he is hampering the Manchester United team this season as he believes he ... Read more »

The 'simply superb' food capital of Wales - ‘lucky to have this on our doorsteps"

Britons heading to Wales for a holiday may want to consider Monmouthshire. The county’s foodie capital title is still firmly in place, with a new Michelin starred restaurant and plenty ... Read more »

The fatal prop-gun shooting on the set of Alec Baldwin's film 'Rust' is a tragedy. It's also not the first time this has happened.

© Barry King/WireImage/Getty Images Brandon Lee died on the set of the “The Crow” after being hit by a gunshot from a prop firearm. Barry King/WireImage/Getty Images Alec Baldwin shot ... Read more »

Prince Kaybee throws shade at Cassper Nyovest with an R. Kelly quote

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) DJ and music producer Prince Kaybee has taken a shot at hip hop heavyweight Cassper Nyovest, again. Following news that “The Braai Show with ... Read more »

The new Hermes Birkin 3 En 1 is a transformer - here's why it's on everyone's covet list

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) IF there’s one thing that luxury French brand Hermes is certain of, is that it’s iconic leather bags will never be out of style. ... Read more »

Harry Kane backed for goal glut starting with Tottenham trip to West Ham

© PA Images Harry Kane playing for Tottenham Hotspur against Newcastle United Nuno Espirito Santo is tipping talismanic Tottenham striker Harry Kane to go on a scoring run after breaking ... Read more »

Shanks for the memory! Collin Morikawa strikes new first in Japan

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Inzai, Japan – Collin Morikawa has already won two majors in his fledgling pro career, but the 24-year-old American managed a new first at ... Read more »

Klopp drops Salah contract hint as Liverpool boss hails ‘pretty special' moment

© PA Images Mohamed Salah, Danny Rose, Watford v Liverpool Liverpool manager Jurgen Klopp admitted that he hopes Mohamed Salah can continue to deliver for the Reds in the future, ... Read more »

Are Arsenal fans starting to trust the process?

© PA Images Emile Smith Rowe and Aubameyang embrace after Arsenal goal v Aston Villa Arsenal beat Aston Villa on Friday night so we have mails from Gunners fans. We ... Read more »

How Two Kidney Swaps Helped Four People at This Bangalore Hospital

© Provided by News18 How Two Kidney Swaps Helped Four People at This Bangalore Hospital Humanity over religion always strikes a chord for Indians. They hit closer to home and ... Read more »

Saudi Arabia says it aims 'net zero' emissions by 2060

© Provided by Saudi Arabia is the world’s top oil exporter and its economy relies heavily on the fossil fuel industry Saudi Arabia unveiled new green goals on Saturday, ... Read more »

Pitso Mosimane names Al Ahly squad, decision made on Percy Tau!

© Provided by The South African Reigning CAF Champions League champions Al Ahly have confirmed their 22-man squad for Saturday’s second leg, second preliminary round tie against Union Sportive de ... Read more »

Mamelodi Sundowns gave Teko my No.10 shirt without my consent – Zothwane

© Provided by The South African Former Mamelodi Sundowns midfielder Papi Zothwane has recalled how the No.10 shirt was taken away from him without his consent. READ | KAIZER CHIEFS OFFERED ... Read more »

Paper Talk: Man Utd get food for thought as Conte sets out ambitious demands

© PA Images Antonio Conte during his Chelsea days Antonio Conte has outlined his ambitions for his next job amid links with Manchester United, while the chances of a key ... Read more »

German COVID rate soars to highest level since May

© Provided by States are pushing for measures such as mask mandates to be retained on a national basis Germany’s coronavirus infection rate rose again on Saturday, touching exactly ... Read more »

Italy: Former minister Matteo Salvini on trial for preventing migrant ship from docking

© Provided by Matteo Salvini is on trial for alleged deprivation of liberty and abuse of authority The trial of former Italian Interior Minister Matteo Salvini for his role in preventing ... Read more »

SA homeschooling 'explosion': Deciding on the best option for your child

© Provided by CapeTalk – The Education Department says the number of learners enrolling in homeschooling has doubled in a year – This is despite the fact that during the ... Read more »

PSL strugglers Marumo Gallants shock AS Vita to reach CAF Confederation Cup next round

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Cape Town – PSL strugglers Marumo Gallants caused the biggest upset of the CAF Confederation Cup season yet after eliminating DR Congo giants AS ... Read more »

Fittipaldi says 2022 F1 calendar is "too much" for drivers

© Mark Sutton / Motorsport Images Emerson Fittipaldi on the grid Last week the FIA’s World Motor Sport Council rubber-stamped F1’s longest-ever season with a 2022 calendar comprising 23 grands ... Read more »

Happy birthday, Malaika Arora: 5 easy home workout tips from diva for toned body

Always the one to push fans towards a healthier lifestyle, Bollywood’s Chaiyya Chaiyya girl Malaika Arora is fitness inspiration for all to become the best version of ourselves. Apart from ... Read more »

Bengaluru: Two kidney-swap transplants give four a new lease of life

Bengaluru: Two kidney-swap transplants give four a new lease of life Two kidney-swap transplants were performed in a single week in the same hospital in Bengaluru as the four families ... Read more »

Mamelodi Sundowns turn to birthday boy Peter Shalulile for CAF Champions League goals

© Provided by The South African Mamelodi Sundowns will have home ground advantage when they face DR Congo’s Maniema Union in their CAF Champions League second leg second preliminary round ... Read more »

SA homeschooling 'explosion': How to decide what's best for your child

© Provided by CapeTalk – The Education Department says the number of learners enrolling in homeschooling has doubled in a year – This is despite the fact that during the ... Read more »

Horner: Mercedes struggles on engine reliability "very unusual"

© Giorgio Piola Mercedes W12 rear wing detail Mercedes revealed on Friday ahead of the United States Grand Prix that Valtteri Bottas would be taking a third grid penalty in ... Read more »

Chris Boyd full of praise for debutant Courtnall Skosan

© PA Images Chris-Boyd-Northampton-v-Worcester-Premiership-2021-PA Northampton Saints debutant Courtnall Skosan has received praise from his club’s director of rugby, Chris Boyd, after the Springbok wing scored a hat-trick of tries in ... Read more »

Australia overcome Japan in Oita to extend winning streak

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) The Wallabies had a minor scare late in the game but held on to launch their end-of-season tour with a 32-23 victory over Japan ... Read more »

Ranking every player to play for both Real Madrid and Barca since 1990

© PA Images luis-figo-real-madrid Real Madrid and Barcelona share one of the most fierce rivalries in world football – so it’s not surprising that not many players have played for ... Read more »

Porous funding policy sees students falling through the cracks

© Provided by Eyewitness News JOHANNESBURG – A storm is brewing at many institutions of higher learning over the N+2 policy of the National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS). Under ... Read more »

Covid-19: SA records 517 new cases, 56 deaths in 24 hours

© Provided by Times Live It was another day of low Covid-19 infections, with 517 cases recorded in the past 24 hours. The National Institute for Communicable Diseases said on ... Read more »

Police rescue 11 kidnapped Ethiopians from Johannesburg storage facility

© Provided by SowetanLive Suspected Ethiopian extortionists have been bust in Johannesburg for kidnapping fellow countrymen across SA.   Western Cape detectives and their Gauteng counterparts rescued 11 men from ... Read more »

Shake & Bake Beer Pie – When craft beer has a whole new meaning

© Provided by The South African Do you love being a creative baker? Do you have a South African themed party planned and looking for something special as your main ... Read more »

El Loco? Maybe Marcelo Bielsa is the only sane one among us…

© PA Images Marcelo-Bielsa-Leeds-mural Johnny Nic joins the Pep, Poch and most of West Yorkshire in bowing down at the altar of Marcelo Bielsa…   Who’s this then? Marcelo Alberto ... Read more »

‘Sport is a results business,' says Andy Murray as he pinpoints where he needs to improve

© PA Images Andy Murray attends a press conference Being more solid during important moments, getting the balance between attack and defence right and making the right decisions are key ... Read more »

Endometriosis – Symptoms, Causes, Treatment and Everything You Need to Know

© KS Swati | Lifestyle Staff Endometriosis – Symptoms, Causes, Treatment and Everything You Need to Know. Picture Credits: Pixabay Endometriosis is the tissue lining the inside of the ... Read more »

Covid-19 jabs safe in early pregnancy, Norwegian data shows

© Provided by Times Live Covid-19 vaccinations do not increase the risk of first-trimester miscarriages in pregnant women new research shows. Data from nearly 20,000 women in Norway provides further ... Read more »

Ankita Konwar chases period blues away with quick 5km run, impresses Milind Soman

Milind Soman’s wife Ankita Konwar is an avid runner, just like the celebrated supermodel and actor. The 30-year-old never misses a chance to include a fulfilling run to her schedule, ... Read more »

Here's what Rashmika Mandanna does when she is annoyed; Watch VIDEO

© Provided by Pinkvilla Rashmika Mandanna is one of the most gorgeous and popular actresses in the South film industry. With just a few films, the actress has made a ... Read more »

Cristiano Ronaldo's ‘top dog' duel with Mo Salah takes centre stage as Manchester United host Liverpool

© Provided by The South African Cristiano Ronaldo and Mohamed Salah will go head to head for the right to be billed as the Premier League’s top dog when Manchester ... Read more »

Mercedes ‘hanging on for dear life' with engine

© PA Images Valtteri Bottas at COTA with floodlights behind planetF1 Toto Wolff has admitted Mercedes are “hanging on for dear life” with the engine supply to their customer teams, ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic