Expert: Here's how the FBI knew what to search for at Trump's Mar-a-Lago

expert: here's how the fbi knew what to search for at trump's mar-a-lago

Donald Trump

Donald Trump MANDEL NGAN/AFP via Getty Images

The FBI search of former President Donald Trump’s Florida estate, Mar-a-Lago, on Aug. 8, 2022, has sparked a vigorous outcry from Trump and his allies. The details of the search are not clear, but reporting by The New York Times confirms that the search was “at least in part” for presidential records that Trump had taken from the White House and which were being sought by the National Archives and Records Administration. We asked Shannon Bow O’Brien, a scholar of the presidency at the University of Texas, Austin College of Liberal Arts, to discuss the history, law and customs associated with presidential archives.

How do the archivists actually know what’s missing? Isn’t that hard to figure out?

The archivists probably have a really keen idea of what is and what isn’t missing, based upon things that they’ve gotten out of other offices, like the vice president’s office and things that got deposited from the secretary of state, for example. There are a lot of papers that are referenced and cross-referenced, multiple copies or multiple things going in and out of offices.

One scholar did a study of the presidents’ annual Christmas speech at the Ellipse in Washington. He looked at how the speeches – from the Roosevelt administration to the present – developed, and it was kind of a ring-around-the-rosy inside the West Wing and within the departments – what went in, what went out, what went in, what went out. Who won and who didn’t win. Everybody left their marks on the speeches. All of those changes and requests appear in documents, and if part of the conversation is missing from the National Archives, it’s obvious.

We know from other presidents’ records that really comprehensive records are kept via daily manifests of what the presidents are doing. And while I am not a historian, it’s not unreasonable to assume that the other departments and agencies likewise have daily manifests of their top officials. So if they know that someone at an agency sent something over to the White House that was this or that, and it came back from the White House with this or that, then there should be a document somewhere that’s got something from the White House on it – and if you’re missing that, that’s a problem.

Will the public find out what was in these documents, given that they are classified?

We’ll be lucky to know if, and when, the documents get declassified. We might get some hints of what is there if Trump does get indicted for a crime related to removing the documents or based on something found in them. We’ll possibly find out what grade of classification the documents had – they get different levels based on the level of seriousness.

What’s the law that governs what happens to a president’s documents?

It’s the Presidential Records Act. It came about originally because these guys, the presidents, were just kind of doing whatever the heck they wanted with their records. Hoover donates his; FDR doesn’t.

The act, first passed in 1978, says administrations have to retain “any documentary materials relating to the political activities of the President or members of the President’s staff, but only if such activities relate to or have a direct effect upon the carrying out of constitutional, statutory, or other official or ceremonial duties of the President.”

An administration is allowed to exclude personal records that are purely private or don’t have an effect on the duties of a president. All public events are included, such as quick comments on the South Lawn, short exchanges with reporters and all public speeches, radio addresses and even public telephone calls to astronauts in space. Diaries and journals are off limits, but any papers to carry out the job are public records.

Have there been other controversies over presidential records?

There’s one that poses an essential question: What value can you place on history? In 1998, the Nixon estate felt his records had a monetary value of over US$200 million and sued the government, which had seized the records, for what they believed their value amounted to.

There’s a two-decade background to the case. After he left the presidency, Nixon brokered a deal with the General Services Administration about the retention of his records, but when knowledge of it became public, there was considerable outcry. A large amount of material was to be withheld from public view, and there was concern the depth of Nixon’s true involvement in Watergate would be obscured.

Congress responded and in 1974, President Gerald Ford signed the Presidential Recordings and Materials Preservation Act to specifically apply to Nixon’s presidential materials. It gave the archivists the power to seize materials from Nixon’s time in the White House and return those deemed private.

Nixon immediately sued over who possessed his records. While he had already been pardoned when it was enacted, Nixon was concerned about his reputation and legacy. He wanted control over what the public saw about his time in office. One of the major issues in front of the court involved the disposition of documents he believed were private. Given the scandal associated with his resignation, should these documents be inspected by archivists for veracity?

More important, did the government have the right to seize presidential documents?

In a 7-2 decision, the Supreme Court rejected all of Nixon’s arguments. They said his privacy rights were still intact because the archivists were not making things immediately public but inspecting them and retaining public items while returning family ones. The court noted the “unblemished record of the archivists for discretion.”

In 2000, the lawsuit was settled over the Nixon records, with the bulk of the settlement money going to pay attorney fees. Some observers were unhappy, because these documents should have already been considered public, but the decision was likely made to finally close this chapter on American history. In 2007, the Nixon library in California became public and integrated into National Archives.


This story includes parts of an article originally published on Feb. 11, 2022.

Shannon Bow O’Brien, Associate Professor of Instruction, The University of Texas at Austin College of Liberal Arts

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

News Related


Video: Jones won't re-take stand in Sandy Hook defamation trial

Read more »

Houston, get ready for the excitement that is the Savannah Bananas

The circus-style baseball team will be playing at Constellation Field on March 17. Read more »

Bonds bailout aimed at stemming financial chaos has cost £3.7billion so far after fears the bill could top £65billion

Bank of England’s bond market bailout looks set to cost far less than £65billionIt pledged to buy up to £5billion worth of long-term UK bonds a day for 13 daysBut so far it has bought less than £3.7billion – with none purchased yesterday Read more »

The bucolic scene that shows L.S. Lowry wasn't just about matchstalk men: Three lost sketches by the famed artist are revealed after being stashed in a teacher's folder for 60 years

Three lost Lowry sketches are found, two of which were hidden in picture frameAmong them is a colourful drawing of a lady visiting a country cottage The sketches by the artist are expected to fetch over £60,000 at auction Read more »

Nick Kyrgios' girlfriend Costeen Hatzi wears $40,000 worth of jewellery as she supports the tennis star at the Japan Open

Costeen Hatzi looked every inch the glamorous WAG on Tuesday as she cheered on her boyfriend Nick Kyrgios at the Japan Open while wearing more than $40,000 worth of jewellery. The ... Read more »

Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson Makes Waves in First Supreme Court Arguments

Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, in just her second day on the bench, spoke about the enactment of the Constitution's 14th Amendment Read more »

Married prime-time BBC presenter 'fathered a love child with a stripper then dumped her by text when he found out she was pregnant and forced her to sign an NDA'

A stripper alleges a married BBC star impregnated her and denied their childShe claims to have shared a relationship with the TV personality for six monthsThe dancer says he dumped her via text after learning of her pregnancyShe claims she was forced to sign an NDA and didn't receive child maintenanceHe allegedly took a DNA paternity test but the results were inconclusive  Read more »

Video: Kate Garraway is left stunned as she discovers she is related to Paddington Bear's creator Michael Bond

Read more »

Video: Today host Allison Langdon LOSES IT after making a sexual remark live on air as Karl Stefanovic and the entire crew erupt in laughter

Read more »

Hospital parking fees scandal continues as analysis shows one site charges £76 A DAY

Hospitals are charging patients up to £76.80 a day to park, campaigners warnedThey said sky-high parking fees mean many sick Britons cannot afford to driveThey are instead relying on 999 vehicles, piling pressure on ambulance services Read more »

Video: Alessandra Ambrosio bares her abs in bright green sports bra and leggings after workout session in West Hollywood

Read more »

Video: Event planner reveals her top dos and 'trashy' don'ts for weddings - and the one popular flower couples should NEVER choose

Read more »

Today host Allison Langdon LOSES IT after making a sexual remark live on air as Karl Stefanovic and the entire crew erupt in laughter

Today host Allison Langdon suffered an unfortunate Freudian slip on Wednesday after accidentally calling an American football team by the wrong name. While reporting on the previous day’s NFL clash ... Read more »

Chelsea vs. AC Milan live stream: Champions League pick, TV channel, how to watch online, odds

Chelsea vs. AC Milan live stream: Champions League pick, TV channel, how to watch online, odds Chasing their first win of the Champions League group stages, Chelsea face the toughest ... Read more »

Cuban community living in San Diego devastated by current situation on the island

In the days following Hurricane Ian, which barreled across the Caribbean before pounding Florida, many people in Cuba are still struggling without power. The Cuban people, many who are driven ... Read more »

Disruption is the price of success, insists Liz Truss

Liz Truss – Stefan Rousseau Liz Truss will on Wednesday warn that there will be further disruption as she fights to deliver economic growth. After a turbulent week, the Prime ... Read more »

Video: Volodymyr Zelensky RULES OUT peace talks with Putin's Russia and vows to 'expel the occupier from all of our land' as he boasts Kyiv troops hammered Kremlin troops in annexed regions and recaptured 'dozens' of captured towns

Read more »

The 2023 Kia Niro Hybrid Is A Cool Affordable Hatchback That Looks Awesome

The 2023 Kia Niro Hybrid Is A Cool Affordable Hatchback That Looks Awesome The first-gen Kia Niro was a cool-looking car when it was launched back in 2017! By 2022, ... Read more »

Blinken calls Colombian migration center ‘a remarkable model’

BOGOTA, Colombia —  A new program designed to help settle Venezuelans who fled to Colombia could serve as a “model for the world” in dealing with today’s unprecedented wave of immigration ... Read more »

Terrifying moment a Porsche driver was left with a black eye after a plank of wood mysteriously crashed through his windscreen while travelling at 80km/h on a freeway

A male driver, 71, and female passenger, 70, narrowly avoided injury in crash On September 20 the pair were travelling on Melbourne's Citylink at 80km/hSuddenly a wooden plank hit the bonnet and smashed through their windscreenDriver suffered a black eye while the woman was unharmed in a 'lucky escape' Read more »

Ministers are 'planning to raise the pension age to 68 by the mid-2030s' in blow to millions of people

PM Liz Truss is considering forcing people to wait longer for a state pension Under current rules, the state pension age for both men and women is 66The pension age will rise to 67 by 2028 and will not reach 68 until 2048Now the government want to raise the pension age more than a decade earlier   Read more »

Why the Reserve Bank's small interest rate rise is BAD news for home-owners - with ANZ now forecasting even more mortgage pain to come

ANZ now expecting the Reserve Bank cash rate to hit 11-year high of 3.6 per centBank said smaller 0.25 percentage point rise on Tuesday means 2023 rate rises Reserve Bank of Australia on Tuesday hiked rates for the sixth straight monthAll the major banks on Tuesday night announced they would match latest rise  Read more »

Penelope Cruz looks business chic in a black suit and tie while walking the red carpet at the premiere her new film En Los Margenes in Spain

Penélope Cruz looked like a total professional while walking the red carpet in Spain on Tuesday. The 48-year-old actress was celebrating the premiere of her new film En Los Márgenes ... Read more »

Australian tattoo artists reveal who handles the pain better out of men and women - so who do you agree with?

Tattoo artists shared whether they believe men or women handle the pain better In a TikTok video, a woman can be heard asking three artists at work  Two believe women have a higher pain tolerance but the third disagrees  The short video has been viewed more than 800K times in less than 24 hours   Read more »

Kate Garraway is left stunned as she discovers she is related to Paddington Bear's creator Michael Bond

Kate Garraway was left stunned after discovering she is related to the creator of Paddington Bear, Michael Bond. The Good Morning Britain presenter, 55, discovered her surprising family connection when ... Read more »

Aaron Judge breaks AL record with home run No. 62 at Globe Life Field in Arlington

Judge hit his 62nd home run of the regular season, breaking the American League record. Read more »

Video: Will Smith film Emancipation drops trailer as Apple TV+ announces release date in time for awards season despite actor's Oscar ban following Slapgate 

Read more »

Truss Cabinet Ministers Say Her Project May Already Be Over

(Bloomberg) — Liz Truss will struggle to drive through key parts of the economic revolution she’s planning for the UK because her standing in the ruling party is already so ... Read more »

15 LGBTQ art shows that are spicing up global museums this fall

If variety is the spice of life, the world’s museums are perfectly seasoning things this fall with an expansive range of exhibitions from LGBTQ artists, exploring myriad motifs like queer ... Read more »

Teen From Hurricane-hit Florida Catches HR, Meets Yankees

USA TODAY Sports A mother-son trip to a major league game for a Florida family in need of diversion after their home was hit by Hurricane Ian turned into much ... Read more »

I'm Too Sexy artists Right Said Fred rip Beyonce as 'arrogant' saying she didn't ask permission to sample their hit track for her song Alien Superstar

Right Said Fred appeared Monday at the 2022 BMI London Awards They made clear they were upset that Beyonce sampled their 1991 hit They said they were under-matched in a legal battle with Beyonce I'm Too Sexy has also been sampled by artists including Drake and Taylor Swift Swift used rhythmic patterns in her 2017 hit Look What You Made Me Do Drake used samples of the track for his 2021 hit Way 2 Sexy I'm Too Sexy held the top spot on the U.S. charts for three weeks in early 1992  Read more »

José Abreu's Future With White Sox Murky Entering Offseason

José Abreu’s White Sox future murky entering offseason originally appeared on NBC Sports Chicago For any questions about whether White Sox first baseman José Abreu wants to continue playing in ... Read more »

New York Yankees star Aaron Judge hits 62nd homer to break AL record

ARLINGTON, Texas —  Aaron Judge hit his 62nd home run of the season Tuesday night, breaking Roger Maris’ American League record and setting what some fans consider baseball’s “clean” standard. The ... Read more »

South Side Mailbag: Who Should Be the Next White Sox Manager?

South Side Mailbag: Who should be the next White Sox manager? originally appeared on NBC Sports Chicago Editor’s Note: “South Side Mailbag: Who should be the next White Sox manager?” ... Read more »

Federación indonesia: Portones de estadio estaban cerrados

MALANG, Indonesia —  La demora en abrir los portones del estadio tras un estallido de violencia al final de un partido contribuyó en la tragedia en la que al menos 131 ... Read more »

Aaron Judge Hits 62nd Home Run to Set Single-Season AL Record

Aaron Judge moved ahead of Roger Maris by hitting his 62nd home run of the season to set the new American League single-season record Read more »

Denver neighborhood getting a $10 million infrastructure upgrade

Denver’s Sun Valley neighborhood is getting a massive overhaul of its infrastructure. The city council approved a bill last night to funnel more than $10 million in a tax agreement ... Read more »

Refugees who cross Channel in dinghies will be BANNED from claiming asylum in UK

Refugees who cross the Channel in small boats will be banned from claiming asylum in the UK, the Home Secretary announced today. Suella Braverman recieved two standing ovations during her ... Read more »

Liverpool's Jurgen Klopp proven right on Chelsea co-owner Todd Boehly but big changes backed

A recent survey has shown that football fans would welcome NFL-style improvements to the game, but not the introduction of an All-Star game has proposed by Chelsea co-owner Todd Boehly. ... Read more »

Nordstrom Rack’s Extra Early Black Friday Deals? Yes, Please!

If you simply cannot wait to get your holiday shopping started, then Nordstrom Rack’s Early Black Friday Sale is the one sale moment you should shop this week. But the ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network