Ex-WB Chief Secy matter: Calcutta HC observations coloured with some political overtones: Centre to SC

Asia's Tech News Daily

bandopadhyay, cat, union of india, supreme court, C T Ravikumar

New Delhi, The Centre on Monday took “serious exception” to certain observations made by the Calcutta High Court in its order passed on a plea filed by former West Bengal chief secretary Alapan Bandopadhyay, and told the Supreme Court that these are coloured with “some political overtones”. The government told a bench of Justices A M Khanwilkar and C T Ravikumar that this matter relates to the service of one officer and these observations should have been avoided by the high court.

The apex court reserved its order on the Centre’s plea challenging the October 29 order of the high court which had set aside an order of the principal bench of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) to transfer an application by Bandopadhyay, challenging the proceedings initiated against him by the Centre, from Kolkata to New Delhi.

The Centre objected to certain observations made in the high court order, including the one which said the “entire modus operandi adopted by the Union of India reeks of mala fides” and, unfortunately, the principal bench of the CAT “nurtured such efforts by passing the impugned transfer order, thereby paying obeisance to the diktat of the Union of India, which has been repeatedly held by the Supreme Court and various High Courts not to be a favoured litigant.”

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Centre, told the bench that

“these are the observations coloured with some political overtone and should have been avoided,”

Mehta said there have been judgements by the apex court that say that the high courts will have to be very circumspect in making observations.

He said personal views or political ideologies can never play any role in the exercise of the judicial function.

“This is a matter of service of one officer. The chairman (of CAT) has the power to transfer the proceedings from one bench to another, without touching the merits, and the high court says this disturbs the federal structure,” Mehta said, adding, “I am taking very serious exception”.

“I am posing a question to myself with all seriousness. Where the federal structure comes into the picture,” he said.

Referring to one of the observations made in the order, the solicitor general said, “I (Union of India) am an applicant. I am before the authority having the jurisdiction. I am arguing the matter, the other side is being heard. Is it my diktat if I move my application as a respectable litigant.”

Mehta also argued on the issue of territorial jurisdiction and said the Calcutta High Court could not have exercised its jurisdiction on a plea against the order passed by the principal bench of CAT which is in New Delhi.

Senior advocate A M Singhvi, appearing for Bandopadhyay, said the IAS officer has always been a resident of Kolkata and every part of the cause of action in the matter is in West Bengal.

At the outset, Mehta told the bench that he would not take longer to advance his submissions as he was aware that the bench might be required to get up a little early.

“Get up early. On what basis you are saying this Mr solicitor? What information do you have?” the bench asked.

“Your lordships are becoming a guest in my state (Gujarat),” Mehta said without elaborating further.

“We knew that you are resourceful but so much resourceful that our moment is also tracked by you,” the bench said in a lighter vein.

The solicitor general said that when the judges are visiting someplace, the protocol department inquires whether there are any specific requirements.

“It’s more for your lordship’s convenience and if needed, any further assistance. That’s all. There is nothing. It’s not tracking,” the solicitor general said.

On November 15, the Centre had told the apex court that the high court has passed a “disturbing order” while setting aside the order of the principal bench of CAT.

The top court was hearing a plea filed by the Centre against the high court order, which had also directed the Kolkata bench of CAT to expedite the hearing of Bandopadhyay’s application and dispose of it at the earliest.

Bandopadhyay had moved the Kolkata bench of CAT, challenging the proceedings initiated against him by the Ministry of Personnel and Public Grievance and Pensions in a matter relating to attending a meeting on May 28 at the Kalaikunda Air Force station that was chaired by Prime Minister Narendra Modi to discuss the effects of cyclone Yaas.

Mehta had told the apex court on November 15 that Bandopadhyay had challenged the initiation of departmental action against him by the Centre before the Calcutta Bench of CAT.

Referring to the high court order, the law officer had said some “very disturbing” remarks have been made against the principal bench of CAT.

“We can say that the disturbing remarks will be expunged,” the bench had observed.

Bandopadhyay, who was not released by the state government, chose to retire on May 31, his original date of superannuation before having been given an extension of three months from that date.

Proceedings were initiated against Bandopadhyay by the Union government and an inquiry authority was appointed in this regard, which fixed a preliminary hearing on October 18 in New Delhi.

He then moved the Kolkata bench of CAT, challenging the proceedings against him.

The Union government had filed a transfer petition before the principal bench of CAT, which on October 22 allowed the transfer of Bandopadhyay’s application to itself in New Delhi.

This order was challenged by Bandopadhyay before the Calcutta High Court.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Finance chief in talks to quit M&C Saatchi amid takeover tussle

The finance director of M&C Saatchi is in talks to join a private equity-backed rival, a move that could undermine the London-listed advertising agency’s ability to fend off an unsolicited ... Read more »

Centre revises its guidelines for adult Covid patients' treatment

© Provided by Hindustan Times A healthcare workers tends to patients at a Covid-19 care centre, in New Delhi, on Monday. (Raj K Raj/HT Photo) If cough persists for more ... Read more »

Adams, Hochul join Biden and Harris in vow to honor MLK's legacy with policy push

Local and national politicians paid tribute to Martin Luther King Jr. on Monday’s federal holiday honoring the iconic civil rights leader, vowing to carry out his legacy with public policy. ... Read more »

The majority of PPP loans went to business owners and high-earning households, a new study shows

© Provided by Business Insider As much as three-quarters of PPP loans extended in 2020 went to business owners and shareholders, not employees. AP Photo/David J. Phillip $510 billion in ... Read more »

NYPD data shows serious crimes up — despite Mayor Adams' ‘perception'

New NYPD statistics reveal serious crime has shown no signs of slowing under the administration of Mayor Eric Adams — who has dismissed concerns about subway incidents as simply a ... Read more »

Delhi: New cases dip to 12-day low amid testing drop, positivity up slightly

© Provided by Hindustan Times Vaccination underway at a camp near Raj Ghat on Monday. (Amal KS/HT) The Capital continued to record a dip in the number of daily Covid-19 ... Read more »

BBC's future ‘up for discussion', says Nadine Dorries, as licence fee frozen

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Leon Neal/Getty Images The culture secretary, Nadine Dorries, has confirmed that the BBC’s funding will be frozen for the next two years – but ... Read more »

Jewish leaders call FBI comments on Texas hostages ‘insulting'

Jewish leaders ripped the FBI Monday and said the bureau “got it wrong” when they said the terrorist who took hostages at a Texas synagogue didn’t make demands that were ... Read more »

Rohan Bopanna hopes to build on fresh momentum at Australian Open

At the start of the 2021 season, it took Rohan Bopanna seven tournaments and four months to merely get a “W” next to his name. Two weeks into this season, ... Read more »

Coronation Street villain Geoff returns to screen in emotional BGT performance

Corrie actor Ian Bartholomew did a BGT audition to help Women’s Aid. Ian, 67, who played wife-beater Geoff Metcalfe, sang his own song on Sunday. Men should acknowledge the domestic ... Read more »

Kerala youth murdered, body dumped in front of police station

Shan Babu A youth was allegedly murdered and his body was dumped in front of a police station in Kerala’s Kottayam district on Monday. The 19-year-old victim was identified as ... Read more »

Edinburgh's Liberton through the years: 30 pictures from the 1950s and 1960s showing what life was like in the Capital's residential suburb

The name Liberton is thought to come from a combination of the Old English words ‘hlith’ and ‘beretun’, meaning ‘barley farm on a hillside’. © Pensioner and part-time petrol pump ... Read more »

3 Einrichtungs-Tricks für eine hellere Wohnung

In der kalten Jahreszeit kann die Wohnung manchmal ganz schön dunkel und erdrückend wirken. Mit diesen drei simplen Tricks wird Ihr Zuhause sofort heller © ISTOCKPHOTO 3 Einrichtungs-Tricks für eine ... Read more »

Government to launch anti-encryption ads to convince ‘easily swayed people' into wanting weaker phone security

© Getty Images iStock-1065046954.jpg The government will launch an ad campaign against end-to-end encryption, the technology that keeps messages on WhatsApp, Apple’s iMessage, and Signal secure. The Home Office has ... Read more »

UN-Chef: Fehlende globale Solidarität lähmt Weltwirtschaft

© Keystone/UN/Mark Garten Fehlende globale Solidarität lähmt nach Ansicht der Vereinten Nationen die Erholung der Weltwirtschaft. “Wenn es uns nicht gelingt, Ungleichheiten abzubauen, belasten wir den wirtschaftlichen Fortschritt für alle ... Read more »

Tamil Nadu CM transfers Namakkal custodial death case to CB-CID

© Provided by The Statesman Tamil Nadu CM transfers Namakkal custodial death case to CB-CID Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M.K. Stalin on Monday transferred the case of the custodial death ... Read more »

No charges for trans activists accused of ‘doxing' JK Rowling

© AFP via Getty Images JKRowling Police on Monday said trans activists accused of “doxing” by JK Rowling have committed no criminal offence. The Harry Potter author, 56, had accused ... Read more »

Wandsworth: 'Gentrification won't kill our high street but a lack of parking will'

Wandsworth resident Wendy Hutchinson remembers when businesses on the borough’s High Street would be bustling with customers. That was a long time ago – today, it’s almost unrecognisable to her. ... Read more »

The most exciting new hotels opening in Europe in 2022

While which destinations we will be able to travel to in the coming year remains slightly up in the air, if all goes to plan we should see the unveiling ... Read more »

At least 70 people left homeless due to flooding in Ladysmith

© Nhlanhla Mabaso/Eyewitness News Streets of Ladysmith were flooded on 17 January 2022 after heavy rains. LADYSMITH – At least 70 residents have been left homeless in Ladysmith, KwaZulu-Natal after ... Read more »

Germany expects "real debate" about fiscal rules to start in June - Lindner

© Reuters/ANNEGRET HILSE Session of the lower house of parliament Bundestag, in Berlin BERLIN (Reuters) – Germany wants to respect jointly agreed fiscal rules as this helps to control inflation, ... Read more »

Crude Oil Prices Edge Lower as Libyan Output Returns; Chinese Demand Eyed

© Reuters Crude Oil Prices Edge Lower as Libyan Output Returns; Chinese Demand Eyed By Geoffrey Smith  Investing.com — By Geoffrey Smith  Investing.com — Crude oil prices edged lower in ... Read more »

TV licence fee frozen for two years - here's how much you'll need to pay

© Provided by Metro Culture secretary Nadine Dorries said thee licence fee would stay at £159 for two years (Picture: Getty) The government has confirmed that the BBC licence fee ... Read more »

High court overturns tribunal ruling, orders compensation for miner diagnosed with noise-induced hearing loss

Judge Avrielle Maier-Frawley said Andre Knoetze had put up sufficient evidence to prove his claim, which had seemingly been ignored by a Rand Mutual Assurance tribunal. © Copyright (c) Daily ... Read more »

'Big win': Renewable diesel, canola-crushing plant to be built in Regina

REGINA — Federated Co-operatives Ltd. has announced a project that is to include a renewable diesel facility and a canola-crushing plant.  © Provided by The Canadian Press The estimated $2-billion ... Read more »

Family of murdered woman say police never responded to distress calls

© Supplied. Jaillian Chenoves van Staden was stabbed multiple times and succumbed to her wounds in her Booysens home. JOHANNESBURG – The family of a woman who was killed allegedly ... Read more »

Amazon announces major change that all customers should be aware of

Amazon today has announced a major change that all customers should know about after deciding that their potential ban on the use of Visa credit cards on their site has ... Read more »

Clubs issue statements after football match abandoned due to alleged racism

Two North Wales football clubs have issued statements after their match was abandoned due to allegations of racist abuse on Saturday. The NWCFA Intermediate Cup tie between CPD Llanberis and ... Read more »

Canada Post recognizes Eleanor Collins with stamp

TORONTO — “Canada’s first lady of jazz” Eleanor Collins is getting her own commemorative stamp. © Provided by The Canadian Press Canada Post says the 102-year-old music legend will be ... Read more »

Awesome Games Done Quick speedrun raises $3.4 million for charity

© Screenshot: Games Done Quick via YouTube Mitchriz speedruns Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice while blindfolded at AGDQ 2022. Games Done Quick has raised $3.4 million for the Prevent Cancer Foundation ... Read more »

Ludhiana reports over 1,000 fresh Covid cases for fourth straight day

© Provided by Hindustan Times With a total of 1,041 fresh Covid cases, Ludhiana has now seen a 1000-plus jump in the number of infections for four consecutive days. (HT File) ... Read more »

Shocking before and after satellite photos reveal full scale of Tonga tsunami's devastation which is visible from SPACE

SHOCKING before and after satellite photos have revealed the full scale of the devastation caused by the catastrophic tsunami in Tonga which is even visible from space. According to images ... Read more »

Man who may have betrayed Anne Frank to Nazis named, researchers say

The person who may have betrayed Anne Frank and her family to the Nazis more than 75 years ago has been identified by a team of cold case investigators. The ... Read more »

K-Way windbreaker brand taps hip new market with R&D line

The Associated PressModels wear creations as part of the K-Way men’s Fall-Winter 2022-23 collection, unveiled during the Fashion Week in Milan, Italy, Monday, Jan. 17, 2022. (AP Photo/Antonio Calanni) MILAN ... Read more »

EU leaders remember David Sassoli's 'ideals' and 'kindness' in tribute

EU leaders paid tribute to the late President of the European Parliament David Sassoli on Monday, hailing his kindness, humility, ideals, and devotion to Europe. European Council President Charles Michel ... Read more »

Strictly's Giovanni Pernice addresses reports Rose Ayling-Ellis is 'pulling out of tour'

Giovanni Pernice has joked about rumours Rose Ayling-Ellis won’t be joining him on the Strictly Come Dancing live tour. There have been rumours that Rose, the show’s first deaf contestant, ... Read more »

WVa governor resumes briefings, says COVID is 'tough stuff'

CHARLESTON, W.Va. — West Virginia Gov. Jim Justice on Monday resumed his weekly briefings on the coronavirus, six days after he tested positive for COVID-19. Justice’s return coincided with the ... Read more »

Stephen A. Smith details scary COVID-19 battle: ‘Didn't know if I was gonna make it'

After several weeks away with a serious case of COVID-19, Stephen A. Smith returned to ‘First Take’ and gave a public service announcement about his experiences with the virus, in ... Read more »

Kinnoull's second half showing "extremely pleasing" for manager Alan Cameron

Kinnoull found second half form to run out comfortable 5-1 Conference B winners against Newburgh on Saturday afternoon. Nothing could separate the teams in the opening 45 minutes of the ... Read more »

UN council members urge 'utmost restraint' in Sudan

© – Sudanese rally against last year’s military coup and demand civilian rule in Khartoum braving tear gas from security forces Britain and France were among nine UN Security Council ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic