EWS quota is a bad law, it needs to go

© Provided by The Print

The Economically Weaker Section or EWS quota will come in for judicial scrutiny soon. But it’s not only a matter for the judiciary, India’s Parliament should revisit the law too.

The Madras High Court has nixed the implementation of 10 per cent EWS reservation in All India Quota in medical admissions — popularly known as AIQ in NEET— and said that it can be implemented only with the approval of the Supreme Court. Meanwhile, 27 doctors have challenged the Union government notification to implement the OBC and EWS quota in medical education.  The Supreme Court has issued notice to the Narendra Modi government and sought its response in this matter. Not pronouncing a judgement means that EWS reservation will be put on hold as far as medical admissions are concerned.

This will probably be the first legal test the 103rd Constitution Amendment of 2019 will face. Meanwhile, a bunch of petitions have been filed in the Supreme Court (Janhit vs Union of India) to challenge the constitutionality and legality of the EWS quota and these are yet to be taken up by the apex court.

The EWS quota literally may mean quota for the economically weaker sections. But in the case of this act, SC, ST, OBCs are not considered poor or EWS. This amendment gives power to the State to make provisions for the reservation of appointments or posts in favour of any economically weaker section of citizens other than SC, ST and OBCs.

Currently, there is an income threshold of Rs 8 lakh per annum to avail this quota. So, we can say that this quota is for those poor or middle-class persons who belong to ‘upper’ castes of various religions.

There are four reasons why the EWS quota needs a rethink, even at the legislature level.

Also read: Reactions to OBC medical quota are exposing Indians’ flawed merit argument all over again

A law in haste

First, this law was passed in haste. It was legislation by stealth. The Constitution (One Hundred and Twenty-fourth Amendment) Bill, 2019 was introduced in Parliament unannounced on 8 January 2019, as if some national safety matter was involved. It was passed in both the houses within 48 hours, and got presidential approval the next day.

The Constitution (One Hundred and Third Amendment) Act, 2019 was notified on 12 January 2019 in the Union gazette. As this was a Constitution amendment bill and the purpose of the bill was to insert clause15(6) and 16(6) in the chapter on Fundamental Rights, so it should have been discussed thoroughly in the highest law-making body of India — Parliament. Ideally, the draft should have been circulated to the parliamentarians before its introduction, so that they could go through the bill and prepare their responses. Ideally, such bills with far-reaching implications should be sent to department-related committees for wider discussion and consultation. It’s not illegal to introduce and pass a bill in haste, but this is certainly against constitutional morality and propriety. The bill didn’t have a chance to go through proper scrutiny of Parliament.

Where’s the data?

Second, this Constitution amendment is based on a wrong or unverified premise. The Statement of Object and Reason in the bill clearly mentions that: “The economically weaker sections of citizens have largely remained excluded from attending the higher educational institutions and public employment on account of their financial incapacity to compete with the persons who are economically more privileged.” This is at best a wild guess or a supposition because the government has not produced any data to back this point. As a matter of fact, the Union or state governments have no such data to prove that ‘upper’ caste individuals, who have less than Rs 8 lakh annual income, are not adequately represented in government jobs and higher educational institutions. There is a strong possibility that they are actually over-represented in these places.

My assertion is based on the fact that we have different data to prove the under-representation of SC, ST, OBCs. That implies that ‘upper’ castes are over-represented. I will wait for the caste enumeration in census in this matter. I hope that the Union government will include the column of caste in Census 2021, so that if the judiciary asks for data in the EWS case, it can provide it. Without any data to prove the under-representation of the EWS upper castes, bringing them under the ambit of reservation is bad law.

There is one more problem in this regard. The SC and ST quota is based on their total population. OBC population, according to the Mandal Commission, is 52 per cent, but as there is a cap of 50 per cent on reservation, the OBCs got 27 per cent. But what is the rationale for the 10 per cent quota for the EWS? Why not 7 per cent, or 15 per cent? It sounds arbitrary.

Also read: How UPSC ‘reserve list’ helps SC/ST candidates & why it’s not a ‘backdoor entry’ for IAS

Breaches reservation cap 

Third, there is a cap on reservation. It was not in the original Constitution and Parliament never put a cap. But in the Indira Sawhney case, the nine-judge Constitution bench put a cap of 50 per cent. The judgement says that: “Reservation being an extreme form of protective measure or affirmative action it should be confined to a minority of seats. Even though the Constitution does not lay down any specific bar but the constitutional philosophy being against proportional equality, the principle of balancing equality ordains reservation, of any manner, not to exceed 50%.”

The EWS Act breaches this limit, without even putting this issue into consideration. In the purpose statement of the bill, this issue finds no mention.

Also read: Caste census is important — whether you are for or against reservation

Who is ‘backward’?

Fourth, this amendment is against the spirit of the Constituent Assembly. The provision of reservation in the Constitution finds place in clause 16, which discusses equality. In the original draft tabled before the constituent assembly, it was said:

(1) There shall be equality of opportunity for all citizens in matters of employment under the State.

 (2) No citizen shall, on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, descent, place of birth or any of them by ineligible for any office under the State. 

(3) Nothing in this article shall prevent the State from making any provision for the reservation of appointments or posts in favour of any class of citizens who in the opinion of the State are not adequately represented in the services under the State.

It was the Drafting Committee under the Chairmanship of Dr B.R. Ambedkar that inserted the word “backward” between the words “in favour of any” and “class of citizens”. This term “backward” was finally approved by the Constituent Assembly and became part of the Constitution.

Now the question is, do the EWS upper caste people pass the test of ‘backwardness’? Has the government conducted any study to find out the status of backwardness of this group of people? Do they face any stigma or discrimination? Economic backwardness is quite a fluid identity. It can change at any moment. Rich people can become poor and vice versa at any moment. Moreover, it has more to do with individuals and families, rather than a cluster of castes. Whereas being a tribal and being someone from a class of people who faced/facing untouchability, are fixed identities. Social and educational backwardness of a group is also comparatively fixed.

This amendment makes the provision of reservation just another poverty alleviation programme, which is not the purpose of reservation. Reservation is a constitutional scheme to ensure the participation of backward classes in the nation-building process. It was there to ensure representation of the backward classes. The EWS Act is the subversion of the constitutional scheme for reservation.

The author is the former managing editor of India Today Hindi Magazine, and has written books on media and sociology. Views are personal.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Opinion: Recent Killings Show Kashmiriyat Distorted by Islamism; It Needs Reform

© Provided by News18 Opinion: Recent Killings Show Kashmiriyat Distorted by Islamism; It Needs Reform On April 9, 1962, a young black man by the name of Roman Ducksworth Jr. ... Read more »

China says it will cut fossil fuel consumption to 20% by 2060, but makes no new emissions pledge

China plans to cut its reliance on fossil fuels to below 20% by 2060, according to a cabinet document published in state media Sunday. © Hector Retamal/AFP/Getty Images An angler ... Read more »

Permit extension for hospitality workers

Hospitality workers from outside of the common travel area will be allowed to stay in Jersey beyond their nine-month permit. © Getty Images All hospitality employers will have the new ... Read more »

Yahoo Sportsbook Daily: Props and more with the Saints at Seahawks

Subscribe to Yahoo Sportsbook Daily Apple Podcasts • Stitcher • Google Podcasts • Spotify Frank Schwab details the worst bad beat of the weekend before previewing his bets ahead of ... Read more »

DoH to LGUs: Prevent mass gatherings

© The Manila Times A huge crowd gather at the Dolomite Beach in Manila on Sunday, October 24,2021, prompting the Department of Health to alert government units to prevent such ... Read more »

Jennifer Aniston leads tributes to James Michael Tyler

© Bang Showbiz James Michael Tyler Jennifer Aniston and Courteney Cox have led tributes to their late ‘Friends’ co-star James Michael Tyler. The 59-year-old actor, who famously played Gunther in ... Read more »

Wir sagen, was es bedeutet: «Cringe» ist das Jugendwort des Jahres 2021

In Deutschland wurde erneut das Jugendwort des Jahres gewählt. Dieses Mal konnte sich das Wort Cringe durchsetzen. Aber was bedeutet das überhaupt? © Bereitgestellt von Blick «Cringe» ist das Jugendwort ... Read more »

Die neue Welt des Nasser Djiga

Der 18-Jährige kommt zu seinem ersten Einsatz in der Super League und ist an beiden FCB-Toren beteiligt. Auch neben dem Platz findet er sich immer besser zurecht. © Foto: Claudio ... Read more »

SelVAX Remaja sasar vaksin 10,000 remaja

SELANGOR – Program Vaksin Selangor (SelVAX) Remaja menyasarkan kira-kira 10,000 remaja di seluruh Selangor termasuk individu yang tercicir dari data serta tidak bersekolah menerima vaksin Covid-19 bermula semalam (Ahad). Menteri ... Read more »

Selamat atau tidak? Ini yang patut guru dan pelajar tahu berkenaan aktiviti bersukan

Kebelakangan ini, ramai guru dan pelajar dilihat sudah mula melakukan aktiviti bersukan mengikut hobi masing-masing. Ada yang bermain badminton, berbasikal, mengunjungi gym, berenang, joging dan banyak lagi jenis sukan yang ... Read more »

ULEZ checker LIVE – London ultra low emission zone expansion TODAY – is your area in the zone and how much for your car?

LONDON'S pollution charge zone for older vehicles has been significantly expanded, affecting tens of thousands of motorists. Drivers of vehicles which do not comply with minimum emissions standards are being ... Read more »

How much is the Winter Fuel Payment 2021? What the DWP allowance is, who can claim it and when it's paid

The Winter Fuel Payment is given to certain people to help them pay for gas and electricity at the time of year they will use it most. Many around the ... Read more »

Online trading platform Plus500 expects annual core profit to top estimates

(Reuters) – Plus500 on Monday said it expected 2021 core profit to beat analysts’ expectations, as the British online trading platform’s third-quarter revenue stayed well above pre-pandemic levels. Plus500, which ... Read more »

Sunderland gigafactory to undergo massive expansion amid rise in EV demand

© Provided by City AM The UK’s Sunderland gigafactory is set to be expanded as the Chinese firm behind the plant looks to bolster its electric vehicle battery division. The ... Read more »

Cruise drugs case: After making claim of Rs 25 cr demand, NCB witness reaches Mumbai top cop's office

Prabhakar Sail, the independent witness in the cruise drugs case, arrived at the Mumbai police commissioner’s office on Monday to meet senior security officials, a day after he claimed that ... Read more »

Co-operative Bank confirms approach to buy TSB

© Yui Mok The merger would have created a bank with millions of UK customers (Yui Mok/PA) An audacious attempt by the Co-operative Bank to take over TSB has not ... Read more »

Iceland is giving away end-of-shelf-life food for free to reduce waste

(Getty Images/iStockphoto) In a new effort to reduce food waste, Iceland is giving away food on the last day of its shelf life away for free to customers who shop ... Read more »

Navigate by Big Zuu review – an affable but bland concoction

There are good things about Big Zuu’s debut. The west London rapper, best known for TV shows such as Big Zuu’s Big Eats, proves an affable presence on record as ... Read more »

EastEnders' Adam Woodyatt's estranged wife ‘furious after he signs six-figure deal'

© Provided by Evoke.ie Adam Woodyatt has been delighting fans on screen for years now as Ian Beale and now it’s believed that he is set to head into the ... Read more »

Quiz: Do you know what club these 28 ex-Luton Town players are playing at now?

© Provided by Football League World Kenilworth Road Luton Town have made a strong start to the new Championship campaign, and have subsequently earned a place inside the play-off positions ... Read more »

Can Arsenal finally break their cycle of false dawns?

© Arsenal FC/Getty Captain Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang is mobbed by his Arsenal teammates after scoring the second goal in Friday’s 3-1 win over Aston Villa – Arsenal FC/Getty The wildest optimists ... Read more »

NCIS season 19, episode 6 release date: When does NCIS return?

NCIS season 19 has resumed on CBS and fans said an emotional goodbye to stalwart Agent Leroy Gibbs (played by Mark Harmon). The series saw Gibbs make the decision to ... Read more »

Volvo Cars sets listing price at low end of range, scales back offering

© Reuters/THOMAS PETER Beijing International Automotive Exhibition STOCKHOLM (Reuters) – Geely-owned Volvo Cars set a fixed price of 53 crowns ($6.2) per share for its planned listing on Monday – ... Read more »

Why subscription loyalty can be gold dust

© Motivate Publishing Peter Gerstle Headshot 5 (1) The travel industry faces challenging times due to the long-term impact of the pandemic. As we see signs of recovery, it’s time ... Read more »

'Children are going to die', U.N. agency warns as Afghanistan verges on collapse

By Alexander Cornwell © Reuters/JORGE SILVA Samira, 9, and other children share tea and bread for breakfast at the orphanage before going to school in Kabul DUBAI (Reuters) – Millions ... Read more »

PayPal Says It's Currently Not Pursuing Pinterest Deal

© Bloomberg Pinterest Illustrations Ahead Of Earnings Figures (Bloomberg) — PayPal Holdings Inc. said it isn’t pursuing an acquisition of Pinterest Inc., ending days of speculation over a potential $45 ... Read more »

Film about pilot Wilfred ‘Wop' May receives jury award at Edmonton International Film Festival

A new film about the legacy of pilot Wilfred ‘Wop’ May has received the jury award for best documentary short film (Alberta) at the Edmonton International Film Festival (EIFF). Blind ... Read more »

T20 World Cup 2021: Virat Kohli laughs off question on dropping Rohit Sharma after Pakistan defeat

© Provided by Firstpost T20 World Cup 2021: Virat Kohli laughs off question on dropping Rohit Sharma after Pakistan defeat After India’s 10-wicket loss to Pakistan in their T20 World ... Read more »

Ahead of Eternals release, director Chloé Zhao opens up on Marvel's first full-blown sex scene and gay character with a LGBTQ+ Family

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com Marvel’s upcoming biggie, Eternals is set to hit the screens during the Diwali weekend. While all MCU fans are supremely excited for this venture, director Chlo ... Read more »

Yami Gautam's first Karwa Chauth celebration with Aditya Dhar under the moon was everything love; PIC

© Provided by Pinkvilla Yesterday, most of the ladies celebrated Karwa Chauth. A festival, wherein ladies fast for the long lives of their husbands. Well, even our Bollywood celebs celebrated ... Read more »

Bunty Aur Babi 2 Dialogues: Saif Ali Khan – Rani Mukerji to fight epic battle with Siddhant Chaturvedi – Sharvari

© Glamsham/Instagram/Twitter Bunty Aur Babi 2 Dialogues: Saif Ali Khan – Rani Mukerji to fight epic battle with Siddhant Chaturvedi – Sharvari Bunty Aur Babli are back, and this time ... Read more »

When Shah Rukh Khan and Akshay Kumar stood together for Sanjay Dutt. Old video goes viral

An old now-viral video shows Shah Rukh Khan, Akshay Kumar, Saif Ali Khan, Salman Khan, among others, standing up for Sanjay Dutt. In 1994, when Sanjay Dutt was lodged in ... Read more »

67th National Film Awards: 'Sushant Singh Rajput made us proud' says Nitesh Tiwari on Chhichhore's win

© Provided by Pinkvilla On Monday, the National Film Awards ceremony was held in the National capital of New Delhi and many film personalities attended the same. One of the ... Read more »

This £15 Internet–Favourite Eye Cream Beats Every Pricey One I've Tried

Much like coriander or country music, eye creams are one of those things that people either enthusiastically love or wholeheartedly dislike. Personally, I enjoy a lightweight, hydrating eye cream to ... Read more »

Five huge EastEnders spoilers for this week including Zack and Martin's shock baby drama

ZACK Hudson and Martin Fowler are shocked out of their skin when a baby lands on their doorstep this week in EastEnders. Here’s the lowdown on this week from the ... Read more »

Jennifer Aniston & Courteney Cox pay tribute to Gunther actor James Michael Tyler after his death at age 59

JENNIFER Aniston and Courteney Cox paid tribute to the late Gunther actor James Michael Tyler after his death at the age of 59.  Jennifer, 52, and Courtney, 57, mourned the loss ... Read more »

Eleven of Picasso's works sold in Las Vegas for over $108 million

The painting “Femme au béret rouge-orange”, estimated between 20 and 30 million dollars, finally sold for over 40 million at a Sotheby's auction in Las Vegas on Saturday. The works ... Read more »

Anna Kendrick wears pink gown to the season two premiere of Love Life

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Anna Kendrick attended the Love Life season two premiere in a bright pink strapless mini gown on Sunday. The 36-year-old turned heads in ... Read more »

Manchester United players' comments show Ole Gunnar Solskjaer could be losing feel-good factor

Manchester United lost 5-0 to Liverpool on Sunday and the response to the manager has been obviously loud and overwhelming negative, and fairly so. United looked completely without ideas and ... Read more »

The Latest: EU, US voice 'grave' concern over Sudan upheaval

CAIRO — The European Union has joined the United States in expressing grave concern about a possible military takeover underway in Sudan. © Provided by Associated Press FILE – In ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic