Evasive eThekwini municipality comes clean on Durban beach pollution – sort of

the latest tech news, global tech news daily, tech news today, startups, usa tech, asia tech, china tech, eu tech, global tech, in-depth electronics reviews, 24h tech news, 24h tech news, top mobile apps, tech news daily, gaming hardware, big tech news, useful technology tips, expert interviews, reporting on the business of technology, venture capital funding, programing language

The eThekwini municipality has finally admitted that its overflowing sewage treatment works were responsible for the tide of black water pollution that led to the closure of Durban beaches during the New Year holiday season. But it’s refusing to publicly release the results of recent beach water quality samples.

Evasive eThekwini municipality comes clean on Durban beach pollution – sort of
© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved

the latest tech news, global tech news daily, tech news today, startups, usa tech, asia tech, china tech, eu tech, global tech, in-depth electronics reviews, 24h tech news, 24h tech news, top mobile apps, tech news daily, gaming hardware, big tech news, useful technology tips, expert interviews, reporting on the business of technology, venture capital funding, programing language

For at least 25 days, a steady stream of partially treated human waste has been emptying into Durban’s Umgeni River, just 4km upstream from Durban’s tourist beaches.

And it hasn’t stopped yet.

Global Tech News Daily

Earlier this week, Our Burning Planet filmed the continued flow of sewage effluent into the Umgeni River from a municipal outlet pipe in Willowfield Crescent in Springfield Park, close to the Northern Wastewater Treatment Works.


Global Tech News Daily

Based on photographic evidence of black water pollution at the Blue Lagoon and continued discharges from the Willowfield outlet, it appears that the flow of dangerous levels of pathogens and bacteria towards Durban’s beaches has continued almost non-stop from at least December 31.

The public health risks of municipal sewage pollution in rivers across South Africa is, sadly, nothing new. But when senior public officials appear on television in an attempt to bamboozle the public that all is well, or to deflect legitimate concerns about public health, that is another issue.

These concerns have been reinforced by reports that several canoeists fell ill this week after a canoe race along the Umgeni between Inanda Dam and Blue Lagoon.

Janet Simpkins, director of the Adopt-a-River community nonprofit watchdog group, said a survey of canoeists showed that at least 48 participants complained about gastro-related sickness after the race.

Formal academic studies by University of KwaZulu-Natal researchers have highlighted the more serious risks of cholera, hepatitis and other diseases being transmitted via exposure to sewage bacteria and pathogens in water from the Umgeni River, which flows on to Durban’s beaches.

We sent questions to the eThekwini municipality on Wednesday requesting laboratory results of all beach water quality samples from January 4 after the recent series of flip-flop decisions to close, open, close, and open beaches over the holiday season.

It was a complete “no go”, as city spokesperson Lindiwe Khuzwayo dodged our very direct questions.

We asked the municipality: “You will recall that we requested original copies (on January 7) of all E. coli laboratory test results by eThekwini’s laboratory which informed the decision to reopen beaches on January 6 (as announced by Malcolm Canham) We now repeat this request and further request full copies of lab sample results for water quality tests from January 4.”

eThekwini response: “The City’s decision to open or close beaches is always based on available information.”

We asked: “If the city declines to release the results requested above, what is the reason for refusing this request?”

eThekwini response: “The City’s decision to open or close beaches is always based on available information.”

We asked: “If the city releases the results and any beaches show E. coli readings in excess of 2,000 cfu/100ml between January 4 and today at any beaches open over this period, on what basis was the decision taken to reopen these beaches?

eThekwini response: “The City’s decision to open or close beaches is always based on available information.”

Perhaps repetition and evasion are deemed to be effective responses by eThekwini, but why not come clean and be transparent?

Be that as it may, the municipality did (indirectly) confirm that it has a big problem and that one/or more of its senior officials may have stepped too far in claiming precipitously that it was safe to reopen city beaches on January 6.

We asked the municipality: “As requested more than two weeks ago, what is the name and position of the city official who took the decision to reopen the beaches on January 6 and again on January 13?”

eThekwini response: “No City Department works in silo. The decision was a joint one, with mainly the Parks, Recreation and Culture Department, Water and Sanitation and Disaster Management leading.”

Q: “What is the city’s response to suggestions that eThekwini has misled the public about the safety and quality of the sea and several beaches over this period?”

eThekwini response: “The wellbeing and safety of our residents has always been a priority. As a caring City that always puts its residents and visitors first, we commend our EWS and PRC officials who ensured that despite the negative impact it would have on our tourism, the beaches were closed immediately upon the first test results that showed high levels of E.coli to protect the public.

Q: “Is the city contemplating any disciplinary measures or other actions due to the apparent attempts to mislead the public about the quality of sea/water beaches by:

“a) denying there was a problem?”

eThekwini response: “The City has always been transparent and always acts on available information. We are not aware of anyone being misled.”

“b) claiming that the discolouration of seawater was due to water hyacinth and rain-influenced ‘groundwater flow’ from rivers?”

eThekwini response: “Discolouration due to water hyacinth is normal, especially after rains. The city acts on available information. As soon as the water test results were made available, we acted swiftly to ensure that the beaches were closed and that this was communicated widely.”

The city did, however, appear to acknowledge that a significant proportion of the recent pollution at Durban’s northern and central beaches was due to problems at the city’s Northern Wastewater Treatment Works.

“The dark water emanating from the ponds at the Northern Waste Water Treatment Works (NWWTW) is due to the excessive inflow of stormwater into the Works that flooded the ponds and put the settled sludge into suspension, discolouring the water. This water has to flow into the river. We are currently dosing the discharging water with sodium hypochlorite and we are using alum to settle the solids in the ponds. We are also advertising an emergency contract to dredge the settled sludge from the ponds. This water will not affect beaches, however, residents are urged to stay clear of it for their safety.”

We sent further follow-up questions to the city on Wednesday afternoon to clarify several issues, but no responses had been received late in the day.

The city’s full response to our questions can be read below:



[hearken id=”daily-maverick/9041″]

News Related


Danny Murphy hails 'outstanding' Aston Villa loanee

© PA Nottingham Forest’s Keinan Davis Former Liverpool midfielder Danny Murphy has praised Keinan Davis’ ‘outstanding’ performance against Leicester City as the on loan Aston Villa striker continues to impress ... Read more »

UPPGIFTER: IFK Värnamo vill värva från Pekings samarbetsklubb

© Tillhandahålls av Fotbolldirekt Hampus Näsström, som tillhör IF Sylvia, kan vara på väg bort från Ettan norra.  Enligt uppgifter från NT-sporten är IFK Värnamo intresserade av 27-åringen.   – ... Read more »

Manchester United starlet rejected EFL move in the summer

In the summer, promising Manchester United talent, Hannibal Mejbri was offered the chance to embark on a loan spell with Reading, as per a report from The Athletic.  The report ... Read more »

Sadio Mane, Mo Salah headline best Afcon XI, Benni McCarthy's goalscoring mark erased

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Cape Town — Africa’s two most prized footballers, Sadio Mane and Mohamed Salah, headline the Africa Cup of Nations Team of the Tournament which ... Read more »

Folarin Balogun at Middlesbrough: How’s it gone so far? What issues does he face? What’s next?

Folarin Balogun arrived at Middlesbrough on a temporary spell from Arsenal midway through the January transfer window.  The 20-year-old netted 13 times in 11 Premier League 2 matches for Arsenal’s ... Read more »

Robert Snodgrass and the Aberdeen vs Hibs transfer temptation that 'elite' Scott Brown can swing

© Sammy Turner/SNS Group Brown and Snodgrass know each other well He’s enjoyed a career to remember so far and Robert Snodgrass certainly isn’t short when it comes to options ... Read more »

Everton handed massive injury boost pre-NUFC, fans will be delighted - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast calvert lewin efc Everton have further fortune in their favour after their fantastic FA Cup win at the weekend, with a fresh update on injuries ... Read more »

Max Verstappen's brutal comment to Lewis Hamilton over world title loss

Max Verstappen has brutally shown no mercy towards Lewis Hamilton after controversially pipping him to last season’s Formula One title. The 2021 world champion shrugged off talk of feeling sympathy ... Read more »

South Africa: Springboks’ home Test schedule for 2022 confirmed

© PA Images Springboks-huddle-at-training-2021-PA The Springboks are scheduled to face Wales in three Test matches in the Incoming series in July, before hosting the All Blacks and Argentina in the ... Read more »

Quiz: Did Stoke City win, lose or draw in each of these 25 games this season?

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Stoke City v Fulham Stoke City will be eager to get themselves back towards the play-off places in the coming weeks and ... Read more »

Roy Keane to Sunderland: What does he offer? What EFL experience does he have? Can he get them promoted?

Sunderland’s managerial search has come down to two candidates, Football League World exclusively learnt yesterday.  The report states that Roy Keane and Grant McCann are the two options that the ... Read more »

E' della McLaren la primissima F1 in... Lego Technic

In attesa di scoprire come sarà la McLaren che sarà sulla griglia della Formula 1 nel 2022, la cui presentazione avverrà la sera di venerdì 11 febbraio, la scuderia di ... Read more »

Pioli, Ibrahimovic è un leone in gabbia

(ANSA) – MILANO, 08 FEB – “Zlatan è un leone in gabbia. La sua ambizione è aiutare la squadra in campo. Sta facendo di tutto per recuperare domani non sarà ... Read more »

17 players we can't believe are still playing in 2022: Fred, Santa Cruz…

Footballers seem only to get younger. Every week, a new outrageously talented, fresh-faced whippersnapper pops up in some corner of the globe scoring a wondergoal or pulling off a sublime ... Read more »

Brescia nel caos: Diego Lopez ha rinunciato alla panchina

Che sta succedendo al Brescia? Il caos scatenato dal presidente Massimo Cellino dopo lo 0-0 di Cosenza non si è ancora calmato e anzi, dopo l’esonero inatteso di Pippo Inzaghi ... Read more »

Formula One bosses decide to ditch knee-taking ritual before races

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) London — Formula 1 boss Stefano Domenicali says drivers will no longer be given the formal opportunity to take a knee before races, stressing ... Read more »

Edendale Technical High School girls' football team to represent SA in continental tournaments in DRC

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) The MEC for the Department of Education in KwaZulu-Natal, Kwazi Mshengu, has congratulated the girls’ football team at Edendale Technical High School in Pietermaritzburg ... Read more »

Sprint: Norway's Johannes Høsflot Klæbo defends Olympic gold

Norwegian cross-country athlete Johannes Hoesflot Klaebo defended his men’s sprint title for his fourth Olympic gold medal. Italian Federico Pellegrino once again took silver (as was the case in 2018), ... Read more »

Logan Mailloux ratera deux à trois semaines d'activités

© Fournis par danslescoulisses.com Blessé, Logan Mailloux ratera deux à trois semaines d’activités Ça fait désormais plus d’un mois que la suspension de Logan Mailloux a été levée dans la ... Read more »

JUST NU: Mycket boll för AIK - men fortsatt slarvigt

© Tillhandahålls av Fotbolldirekt AIK mot Täby FK på Skytteholms IP. Det är en väldig rotation i AIK:s elva i jämförelse med matchen mot Degerfors. 79´ AIK har haft ett ... Read more »

Mitch Marner marque en prolongation et procure une sixième victoire d'affilée aux Leafs

Enfin!  Le hockey (de saison régulière) était de retour hier soir après une pause de quelques jours où a eu lieu le populaire week-end du match des étoiles. Le Canadien ... Read more »

PSV en NAC blijven hopen op geld voor Vloet na sanctie van FIFA

© Aangeboden door Voetbalzone NAC Breda en PSV wachten nog altijd op een transfersom die in 2018 betaald had moeten worden door FC Chiasso voor Rai Vloet. De Zwitserse club ... Read more »

We simulated Burnley vs Manchester United to get a score prediction

Manchester United will be looking to put their FA Cup woes behind them and bounce back with a win on Tuesday, as they face Burnley in the Premier League. Anthony ... Read more »

Il tennista Youtuber a caccia del Roland Garros-

© Fornito da Quotidiano.Net Non è mai troppo tardi quando si ha un sogno da seguire. È questo il motto o meglio l’hashtag (#JamaisTropTard) di Jules Marie, tennista trentenne francese ... Read more »

Afcon 2021: Salah’s ego questioned by Murphy after Egypt final defeat to Senegal

Former England and Liverpool player Danny Murphy has questioned the decision to have Mohamed Salah wait for the fifth penalty against Senegal in the Africa Cup of Nations final on ... Read more »

Derby County v Hull City: Latest team news, Is there a live stream? What time is kick-off?

Derby County host Hull City at Pride Park this evening as both sides look to get back to winning ways in the Championship.  Shota Arveladze was handed his first defeat ... Read more »

Sundlings långa väg till guldsuccéen

© Emmi Korhonen/Lehtikuva/TT Jonna Sundling jublar efter att ha korsat mållinjen som olympisk mästare. Skador, sjukdomar och krånglande halsmandlar. Jonna Sundling har mött många utmaningar – och klarat alla. Nu ... Read more »

Scolari opens up on player ‘problems’ that cost him job at Chelsea

© PA Images Phil Scolari looks at the floor in disappointment during a match Former Brazil boss Phil Scolari has revealed that there were “a few problems” that cost him ... Read more »

Eddie Howe breaks Newcastle's silence on failed transfer for Manchester United's Jesse Lingard

© Clive Brunskill/Getty Images. Opportunities have been hard to come by for Jesse Lingard at Manchester United this season. Newcastle United head coach Eddie Howe has admitted to being a ... Read more »

Kurt Zouma video: West Ham defender ‘deeply sorry’ after footage shows him kicking and slapping his cat

West Ham defender Kurt Zouma has said he is “deeply sorry” after a disturbing video surfaced online of him kicking and slapping a cat. Zouma, 27, is seen in the ... Read more »

Update emerges after Newcastle United’s January interest in Bournemouth player

Newcastle United remain interested in Bournemouth’s Lloyd Kelly, with the Premier League outfit set to offer a deal for the 23-year-old regardless of what level of football they will be ... Read more »

Former Rangers star gives club backing over transfer interest in 'very promising player'

Former Rangers star Ronald de Boer has given the club his backing over the possible signing of Danilho Doekhi. © Danilho Doekhi has been strongly linked with Rangers. (Photo by ... Read more »

Schools ordered shut in India as hijab ban protests intensify

© Money SHARMA Activists held a demonstration in New Delhi to protest after students at government-run high schools in India’s Karnataka state were told not to wear hijabs Authorities in ... Read more »

Newcastle United owners can learn Liverpool lesson as Man Utd show what not to do

Newcastle will have to replicate last month’s lavish spending in future windows if they are to achieve their dream of mixing it with the Premier League big boys. Five new ... Read more »

Paul Heckingbottom explains the role Sheffield United supporters can play in the club’s play-off push

Sheffield United have carried on their resurgence up the table since Slavisa Jokanovic’s departure and they look more likely than ever to make an assault on the play-off places. The ... Read more »

Kurt Zouma apologies after former Everton loanee filmed kicking cat

© Visionhaus/Getty Images Kurt Zouma of West Ham United during the Premier League match between Wolverhampton Wanderers and West Ham United at Molineux Former Everton defender Kurt Zouma will reportedly ... Read more »

Grant McCann to Sunderland: What does he offer? What EFL experience does he have? Can he get them promoted?

A new Sunderland head coach is expected to be appointed this week and Football League World understands that the search for Lee Johnson’s replacement has been narrowed down to just ... Read more »

32-y/o starts: The predicted Cardiff City XI to face Peterborough on Wednesday night

Cardiff City will be looking to bounce back from their FA Cup defeat to Liverpool by picking up a positive result in their upcoming Sky Bet Championship game with Peterborough ... Read more »

How to watch every Premier League match on TV this week and kick-off times

© Michael Regan/Getty Images Nine Premier League midweek fixtures will be shown live on BT Sport across Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday. The Premier League returns this midweek with most teams ... Read more »

Noel Whelan predicts Lewis will ‘not be part of the squad’ next season

© Stu Forster/Getty Images Sport Jamal Lewis – 4 Jamal Lewis was controversially left out of Newcastle United’s 25-man Premier League squad for Matt Targett and reports suggested he would ... Read more »