European Union’s Covid-19 travel pass discriminates against the developing world

vocal about hate, targeted racist attacks, physical or bodily harm, Digital Covid Certificate, Sputnik V, since March, since early May, Covax, Covid-19 vaccines, vaccine inequity, 1 per cent, terrible surge, 70 million doses., funded, efficacy data, falsely claimed, WHO issued a statement


  • [11:03pm, 7 Jul, 2021] An earlier version of the article said the AstraZeneca vaccine manufactured by SKBio was not accepted by the EU green pass programme. This is incorrect; the SKBio vaccine is among the list of approved vaccines.

Ever since the coronavirus pandemic began, Asians have been vocal about hate that has rocked their communities worldwide. Much of that unreasonable prejudice has been in the form of targeted racist attacks. However, discrimination can take many forms.

Often, it is far more insidious and subtle than blatant threats or outright physical or bodily harm, especially when it creeps into social discourse through official policy. This kind of hidden bias is exactly what we witnessed with the European Union’s Digital Covid Certificate, which came into effect on July 1.

International travel to the EU is currently suspended, but once travel resumes, these rules would likely apply to international travellers as well. The “green pass”, as it is more popularly known, will disproportionately affect people of colour, discriminating widely against Asians, Africans and much of the developing world.

At first glance, the policy seems innocuous and well-meant. It’s a digital proof of vaccination, allowing vaccinated travellers greater freedom of movement across the European Union, without the need for tiresome quarantines in every country.

However, to have this privilege, travellers must have been vaccinated with one of four EU-approved vaccines – Pfizer/BioNtech, Moderna, Johnson & Johnson and Vaxzevria, the latter developed by AstraZeneca and Oxford University in Europe and the United Kingdom.

There are some notable omissions on this list – every vaccine manufactured outside the global West, for instance, despite their having received emergency approvals by the World Health Organization. The Russian-made Sputnik V has been under EU’s “rolling review” since March and the Chinese Sinovac since early May.

And while those assessments could possibly take time, even those who have taken AstraZeneca jabs manufactured in other parts of the world, such as India’s Covishield, have not been authorised for travel under the green pass as yet, even though these vaccines are being manufactured with the identical formula to the EU approved Vaxzevria.

Excluding the vaccines produced by Covishield from the green pass discriminates against a large segment of the world’s population. In February, the WHO listed both Covishield and SKBio for emergency use, approving their roll-out under the Covax Facility, the WHO initiative for the equitable distribution of Covid-19 vaccines.

While vaccines have been the source of much debate in recent months, there is one aspect on which most people tend to agree: when you cannot choose, you take the vaccine that is available and offered in your country. And with the West fuelling vaccine inequity, most of us cannot choose.

The vaccination picture worldwide is a study in stark contrasts – of the 3.5 billion doses administered worldwide, only 1 per cent have been administered in low-income countries. Richer countries have had access to a greater variety of vaccines, stockpiling excessive doses, even as lower-income countries have struggled to vaccinate their people.

In such a scenario, Covax plays a vital role in righting this wrong. Despite its many challenges, including a terrible surge of Covid-19 across South Asia in April, Covax has since February delivered over 70 million doses. to 126 low and middle income countries, with ambitious plans to reach the 1 billion mark by the end of the year.

However, if entry into the EU is being denied because these vaccines aren’t good enough protection, why are they being distributed through Covax in the first place, an alliance which is supported and philanthropically funded by many European countries, including Sweden, Germany and Italy?

It is no secret that AstraZeneca has had a rather bumpy ride with European regulators. It was authorised for use in Europe at the end of January but has since run into one controversy after another.

In March, several countries in Europe banned it briefly due to concerns over cases of blood clots emerging as a rare side-effect in people under 30. Despite its published efficacy data from Phase 3 clinical trials showing 76 per cent efficacy after the first dose and 82 per cent after the second, the AstraZeneca vaccine’s efficacy has been repeatedly questioned; a German newspaper recently even falsely claimed that it wasn’t effective in an elderly population.

However, none of this explains why the UK/European-made Vaxzevria version of AstraZeneca jabs is acceptable for the green pass, but travellers who received the Indian-manufactured version of the vaccine are not.

vocal about hate, targeted racist attacks, physical or bodily harm, Digital Covid Certificate, Sputnik V, since March, since early May, Covax, Covid-19 vaccines, vaccine inequity, 1 per cent, terrible surge, 70 million doses., funded, efficacy data, falsely claimed, WHO issued a statement

A health worker administers the Covishield vaccine, India’s version of the AstraZeneca vaccine manufactured by Serum Institute, during a special vaccination drive for students travelling overseas in Hyderabad on June 11. Photo: AP

India even threatened retaliatory action, saying it would allow ease of travel only for European countries that recognised its Covishield and Covaxin vaccines.

And in a startlingly inconsistent move since the green pass was announced, some European countries, including Estonia, Greece, Spain and Iceland, have since accepted the Indian-made AstraZeneca vaccine. Media reports suggest that they bowed to pressure, not because they realised the discrimination involved, but because they wanted to allow UK-based holiday travellers into the EU. Nearly 5 million British people have been vaccinated with batches of India’s Covishield.

On July 1, the day the green pass came into effect, the WHO issued a statement urging all countries to accept the vaccines that it has authorised. Failure to do so could undermine the authority of the global health regulator, and if every country were to cherry-pick its own vaccines, it could mean even more difficulty and chaos for travellers.

In a Covid-19 world, it’s evident that vaccines are becoming the new tools of discrimination and division. Decolonising global health should be an urgent priority, otherwise medicines meant to heal will leave deep, festering wounds.

Kamala Thiagarajan is a freelance journalist based in Madurai, southern India

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Syngene International Q2 net dips 21% to Rs 67 crore

Contract research, development and manufacturing services provider Syngene International on Thursday reported a 20.8 percent decline in its consolidated net profit at Rs 66.7 crore for the second quarter ended ... Read more »

Mudra loan scheme for micro enterprises nears 100 percent disbursal rate

Representative Image (Source: ShutterStock) Credit disbursement under Pradhan Mantri Mudra Yojana (PMMY) has neared a 100 percent disbursement level in 7 months in the current fiscal. Non-banking financial companies (NBFCs), small finance banks ... Read more »

Tech leads stocks lower in early trading on Wall Street

Source: Reuters Stocks are off to a mostly lower start on Wall Street Thursday, a day after the S&P 500 and the Dow Jones Industrials approached the record highs they ... Read more »

GAIL to build India's largest green hydrogen plant in 12-14 months

State-owned GAIL (India) Ltd will build India’s largest green hydrogen plant in the next 12-14 months, as it looks to supplement its natural gas business with carbon-free fuel. Speaking at ... Read more »

Tesla looks to pave the way for Chinese battery makers to come to US

Tesla Inc wants to shift to a less expensive battery for its electric vehicles but first needs to figure out how to overcome political tensions to get a Chinese partner ... Read more »

With recovery widening, ICRA sees Q2 GDP at 7.7%

With half of the 15 high-frequency indicators recovering to the pre-pandemic levels in the second quarter, the economy finally looks nearly out of the pandemic woods, helping the Q2 GDP ... Read more »

China to pursue digital trade expansion under new five-year plan as cross-border data flow restrictions remain in place

China is seeking to step up development of digital trade, a segment that is shaping into an integral part of the economy, amid questions that this effort might be impeded ... Read more »

What do businesses want out of Rishi Sunak's budget?

Companies battered by the pandemic and Brexit, together with the drizzle of new taxes and regulation, would like to hear the chancellor offer some relief - but on their key asks, it may be unwise for them to get their hopes up. Read more »

Investors are focusing on successful Latin American tech startups

The Latin American boom has caught the eye of some of the biggest names in private equity and venture capital with the rise of tech "unicorns" worth over $1 billion. Read more »

‘Old-fashioned silver fleet savings written off'

Amsterdam Saving silver fleet for your child, with SNS or Regiobank, will become a lot less interesting from 1 November. Instead of a maximum of 10 percent bonus interest, children ... Read more »

Hong Kong, mainland China agree to one-stop sandbox platform allowing Greater Bay Area start-ups to develop cross-border fintech tools

The monetary authorities in Hong Kong and mainland China have agreed to create a one-stop sandbox platform in the Greater Bay Area that will allow financial firms and technology companies ... Read more »

TVS Motor to set up new electric vehicle company, add new EVs

Representative Image TVS Motor Company is pushing the pedal further in the electric vehicle (EV) space as its board has given the nod to set up a new company for ... Read more »

India's one-billion vaccine mark sparks off celebrations; experts urge restraint

India has been averaging 3.6 million doses a day and needs to ramp it up to 12 million a day REUTERS/Rupak De Chowdhuri Whether the glass is half empty or ... Read more »

Sterlite Technologies Q2 net profit up over 81% at Rs 106 crore

Sterlite Technologies. (PC-PTI) Digital networks integrator Sterlite Technologies on Thursday posted an over 81 per cent year-on-year jump in consolidated net profit for the September quarter at about Rs 106 ... Read more »

Wipro strikes deal to accelerate digital transformation of London-based National Grid

Global infotech firm Wipro Limited has struck a multi-year, global strategic IT and digital deal with London-based multinational electric and gas utility provider National Grid, to accelerate their digital innovation ... Read more »

Bharti AXA Life Insurance signs bancassurance pact with Utkarsh Small Finance Bank

Life insurance policy | PC-Shutterstock Bharti AXA Life Insurance on October 21 announced its bancassurance partnership with Utkarsh Small Finance Bank Limited (USFBL) for the distribution of life insurance products ... Read more »

TVS Motor Q2 net jumps 29% to Rs 234 crore

Representative Image TVS Motor Company on Thursday posted a 29.19 per cent increase in consolidated net profit at Rs 234.37 crore for the second quarter ended September. The company had ... Read more »

Coal shortage: 59 thermal power plants have less than four days of fuel stocks

Coal shortage at thermal power plants is lingering on, with 59 non-pit head projects having the dry fuel stocks for less than four days as on Wednesday, according to official ... Read more »

Silicon Valley fund Andreessen Horowitz ropes in Aditya Rane for India Fintech and Crypto

Representative image Top Silicon Valley fund Andreessen Horowitz (a16z) has hired Aditya Rane to look at the Indian Fintech and Crypto space, signalling its growing interest in a country that’s ... Read more »

Foodpanda partners with Indian cloud kitchen firm Rebel Foods

Source: Reuters Online takeaway delivery firm Foodpanda is partnering with Indian virtual kitchen company Rebel Foods to roll out the latter’s virtual restaurant brands at 2,000 outlets across ten Asian countries, Foodpanda’s ... Read more »

Apple fails to block Huawei's MatePod trademark for AirPods rivals in China because they will ‘not cause confusion'

Apple has lost another legal attempt to block Huawei Technology Co’s use of the “MatePod” name, this time for a pair of earbuds, according to the Trademark Office of the ... Read more »

SEBI penalises 2 persons for violating insider trading norms in Mindtree case

Markets regulator SEBI on Thursday penalised two persons for violating insider trading norms with respect to shares of Mindtree Ltd. Through two separate orders, the watchdog imposed a fine of ... Read more »

Don't bet against Tesla, says former president. But here's why he's not a shareholder

The former president of electric vehicle giant Tesla said Thursday he would not bet against the company, noting that it's emerging as a “formidable competitor” to automakers around the world ... Read more »

Vaccines Cut Odds for Death From COVID Delta Variant by 90%

© Provided by HealthDay THURSDAY, Oct. 21, 2021 (HealthDay News) — The Pfizer and AstraZeneca coronavirus vaccines reduce the risk of death from the Delta variant by 90%, a new ... Read more »

Office space leasing increased by 89% QoQ in July-September: Colliers

Office rentals remained stable across the major markets in India in Q2 2021. After almost 18 months of COVID-19 pandemic, the top six cities across the country recorded 10.3 million ... Read more »

Chinese regulators suggest Hong Kong listing for Didi: Report

Representative image China‘s cybersecurity watchdog suggested ride-hailing firm Didi Global Inc and two other U.S.-listed tech companies explore listings in Hong Kong, the Wall Street Journal reported on Thursday, citing ... Read more »

Twitter buys chat app founded by a serial entrepreneur who sold his first start-up to Yahoo when he was 17

Jack Dorsey creator, co-founder, and Chairman of Twitter and co-founder & CEO of Square arrives on stage at the Bitcoin 2021 Convention, a crypto-currency conference held at the Mana Convention ... Read more »

Gold prices marginally dip to Rs 47,469/10 gm on global cues; silver touches Rs 65,000 a kg

Gold prices slightly eased by Rs 79 to Rs 47,469 per 10 gram in the Mumbai bullion market tracking muted global cues. The precious metal was also pressured by a ... Read more »

Technical View | Nifty forms bearish candle for the 3rd session, consolidation likely if index holds 18,050

Representative image The Nifty50 remained under pressure for the third day running, closing half a percent lower after recovering more than 100 points from the day’s low in the last ... Read more »

ByteDance IPO likely delayed to late 2022 and beyond amid regulatory uncertainties in China, sources say

ByteDance, owner of the popular short video app TikTok, may see its plan to go public postponed until late 2022, after regulatory hurdles in China are resolved, according to three ... Read more »

Stocks making the biggest moves before the bell: AT&T, IBM, Crocs, Blackstone & more

Crocs store in New York City.Michael Brochstein | SOPA Images | LightRocket | Getty Images Check out the companies making headlines before the bell: AT&T (T) – AT&T rose 1.5% ... Read more »

Boston Celtics star slams ‘dictator' Xi over Tibet, Tencent scraps team's NBA broadcast

Enes Kanter #11 of the Boston Celtics handles the ball against the Portland Trail Blazers at The Arena at ESPN Wide World Of Sports Complex on August 02, 2020 in ... Read more »

Fanatics' NFT company is worth $1.5 billion, and NFL legend Peyton Manning now owns a stake

Fanatics Founder/Executive Chairman Michael Rubin attends Fanatics Super Bowl Party at College Football Hall of Fame on February 2, 2019 in Atlanta, Georgia.Mike Coppola | Getty Images Sports e-commerce company ... Read more »

Ola announces plans to hire 10,000 people to ramp up its vehicle commerce platform

Ola Cars allows consumers to purchase both new and pre-owned vehicles through the Ola app. Ola plans to hire 10,000 people as the ride-hailing major looks to ramp up its ... Read more »

Beike Zhaofang, China's biggest online property agency, axes staff as housing sector heads into a bleak winter

Ke Holdings, China’s biggest online property agency, also known as Beike Zhaofang, has started laying off staff across the country as the housing sector slides into the doldrums. A former ... Read more »

Russian diplomat blasts US inaction to regulate Big Tech's unrestrained monopoly conduct

"It is regrettable that at the moment there is no proper political will to streamline this sphere in the United States, whose comfortable jurisdiction IT companies normally hide behind," Russian Foreign Ministry Deputy Spokesman Oleg Gavrilov said Read more »

STI slips as regional markets stay wary on China property sector

SINGAPORE (THE BUSINESS TIMES) – Local investors already have enough on their plate but the travails of China’s property sector just won’t go away and helped turn the market south ... Read more »

Hold Rallis India: target of Rs 305: ICICI Direct

ICICI Direct’s research report on Rallis India Rallis India is a leading agrochemical company with a presence across agri input value chain and a strong, healthy pipeline of sustainable products. ... Read more »

Hold Navin Fluorine: target of Rs 3710: ICICI Direct

ICICI Direct’s research report on Navin Fluorine Navin Fluorine (NFIL) operates one of the largest integrated fluorochemicals complexes in India with a presence in speciality chemicals, CRAMS, inorganic fluoride and ... Read more »

Buy 5paisa Capital; target of Rs 530: ICICI Direct

ICICI Direct’s research report on 5paisa Capital Paisa is a leading discount stock broker backed by the Nirmal Jain led IIFL group. Aggressive client accretion with ~84% of incremental client ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic