Seeking cost of trains, not damages, from DMRC: Reliance Infra firm to SC

seeking cost of trains, not damages, from dmrc: reliance infra firm to sc

Seeking cost of trains, not damages, from DMRC: Reliance Infra firm to SC

New Delhi, Feb 20 (PTI) The Delhi Airport Metro Express Private Limited, a Reliance Infrastructure firm, on Tuesday told the Supreme Court that it was not seeking any damages from the DMRC and wanted the cost of trains, procured by it, for plying on the airport metro line here in terms of the 2017 arbitral award.

A special bench comprising Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud and justices B R Gavai and Surya Kant reserved its verdict on the curative plea of Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC) against the dismissal of its review petition against the arbitral award to the tune of Rs 8,000 crore in favour of the Delhi Airport Metro Express Private Limited (DAMEPL).

The Anil Ambani-owned Reliance Infrastructure Limited, the flagship firm of DAMEPL, represented by senior advocates Harish Salve and Kapil Sibal, termed the curative plea of DMRC against the top court’s decisions as the “whole-sale trial by ambush”.

The appeal and the review petitions of the DMRC, challenging the arbitral award asking it to pay Rs 8,000 crore to DAMEPL, have been dismissed by the top court which heard the curative petition and reserved the verdict.

The DMRC has been challenging the arbitral award on grounds including that the notice of October 8, 2012 issued by DAMEPL terminating the concessionaire agreement related to running the airport metro line in the national capital was “illegal”.

Attorney General R Venkataramani and senior advocate K K Venugopal, appearing for the DMRC, argued that the curative plea was maintainable and the award was wrong and upholding it would amount to “miscarriage of justice”.

Venugopal assailed the agreement termination notice of DAMEPL on the ground of some structural infirmities in the airport metro line and said, “Today the trains are running at the speed of 120 km/hour.”

At the outset, Salve put forth his arguments on behalf of the Reliance firm and said, “I am not suing them (DMRC) for damages. I am not seeking even a rupee as damages. I am seeking the cost of trains.”

“They (DMRC) have the trains. They have to pay for the trains and this (arbitral) award is for the trains. Well, if the amount has ballooned then it is how the arbitration law applies,” Salve said while wrapping up his submissions.

He also referred to certain structural deficiencies in the airport metro line and said in case of any untoward incident, the firm would have been held liable and sometimes, the liability can be criminal as well.

Referring to the list of dates, Salve said there was no ambivalence in the termination of the concessionaire agreement and it was sent on October 8, 2012 and it became effective on January 7, 2013. He referred to certain “new” points raised by DMRC in its pleadings related to the curative petition and said this is “whole-sale trial by ambush”.

Sibal, also appearing for the Reliance firm, dealt with the judicial principles and the law on curative plea and said the petition of DMRC was not maintainable.

“Curative petition cannot be decided on facts of each case. It will open Pandora’s box if such types of pleas are allowed on the basis of declared facts,” Sibal said.

Earlier, the top court had said that a five-judge bench may hear the curative plea of DMRC against the arbitral award.

The DMRC had filed the curative plea in August 2022 against the dismissal of its review plea by the top court in 2021.

After the dismissal of the plea of DMRC, the Reliance firm had moved the Delhi High Court seeking execution of the arbitral award.

The Delhi High Court, on March 29 last year, had said its earlier direction on attachment of DMRC funds in case of non-compliance of its directions in the execution plea will not come in the way of payment of salaries to employees as well as payment towards operation and maintenance expenses.

On March 17, the high court had directed the Centre and the city government to attend to the DMRC’s request for extending the sovereign guarantees or subordinate debt to enable it to make the payment of the dues of an arbitral award passed in favour of the DAMEPL.

It had also said the sovereign governments cannot shirk their liability to abide by binding judgments and decrees.

The high court had also ordered that in case of a failure on the part of the parties to proceed in terms of the directions, the entire amount under “Total DMRC Funds, Total Project Funds and Total Other Funds” shall be attached.

The order was modified by the high court on the review plea of the DMRC.

In May 2017, an arbitral tribunal ruled in favour of the DAMEPL, which had pulled out of running the Airport Express metro line over safety issues, and accepted its claim that running the operations on the line was not viable due to structural defects in the viaduct through which the trains would pass.

Earlier, the court had noted that the total amount of the award with interest till February 14, 2022 was Rs 8,009.38 crore. Of this, a sum of Rs 1,678.42 crore has been paid by the DMRC and an amount of Rs 6,330.96 crore is still due.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Guru Nanak Jayanti: Rishi Sunak Highlights Punjabi Heritage In Message, Trudeau Extends Greetings

In a greeting from 10 Downing Street on the occasion of Guru Nanak Jayanti, British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak mentioned his Punjabi Indian origin, news agency PTI reported. The 43-year-old ... Read more »

What US easing sanctions on Venezuela, home to world’s largest oil reserves, could mean for India

This report is the second of a three-part series on recent Indian engagement in the Latin American and Caribbean (LAC) region. New Delhi: The US’ decision last month to ease ... Read more »

Rajshri Deshpande dedicates OTT award to innocent lives lost in Gaza, Palestine

Rajshri Deshpande dedicates OTT award to innocent lives lost in Gaza, Palestine Actor and social worker Rajshri Deshpande won the Best Actor, Series (Female) award for Netflix’s ‘Trial By Fire’. ... Read more »

‘Ramchandra Keh Gaye…’: From Jan 1, RSS to Spread Word of God, Ayodhya Inauguration Among 10 Crore People

‘Ramchandra Keh Gaye…’: From Jan 1, RSS to Spread Word of God, Ayodhya Inauguration Among 10 Crore People In its effort to take the Ram Janmabhoomi message to households across ... Read more »

Ace designer Rohit Bal critical, on ventilator: report

Ace designer Rohit Bal critical, on ventilator: report Celebrated fashion designer Rohit Bal is in critical condition and is on ventilator support, HT City reported, quoting sources. He has been ... Read more »

Bengaluru: Traffic Advisory Issued, Parking Restrictions In Place As Samyukta Horata Samiti Holds Protest | Details

Bengaluru: Traffic Advisory Issued, Parking Restrictions In Place As Samyukta Horata Samiti Holds Protest | Details The Bengaluru Traffic Police has issued a traffic advisory for November 27 and 28 ... Read more »

Vistara Flights Diverted Due To Air Congestion At Delhi Airport | DETAILS

vistara flights diverted due to air congestion at delhi airport | details Delhi: Two Vistara flight has been diverted to Lucknow and Jaipur due to bad weather and air congestion ... Read more »
Top List in the World