Epic Massachusetts crime lab scandal may involve even broader wrongdoing, judge says

A decade-old scandal at a Massachusetts crime lab — which led authorities to dismiss tens of thousands of drug convictions — may involve wrongdoing by more people than was previously known, according to a recent court order.

A state Superior Court judge said in a ruling related to the release of a trove of state investigative materials that there is evidence that other employees at the William A. Hinton State Laboratory Institute — beyond disgraced former chemist Annie Dookhan — may have engaged in misconduct. At least one person was referred to the state attorney general’s office in 2015 for potential prosecution, Judge John T. Lu wrote last week.

The ruling stokes lingering doubts about statements by the state inspector general’s office over the past eight years that Dookhan was the “sole bad actor” at the Hinton lab. And it means the vast scandal could grow.

“This is a significant development. It justifiably raises questions about the criminal convictions that the lab helped to produce with or without Annie Dookhan’s involvement,” said Matthew Segal, the legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts, who has led the fight by defense lawyers to unearth the massive misconduct at a pair of government-run Massachusetts labs that prompted the state’s highest court to dismiss 61,000 drug charges.

Annie Dookhan

Annie Dookhan, center, is escorted out of her home by authorities in Franklin, Mass., on Sept. 28, 2012.Bizuayehu Tesfaye / AP

Dookhan’s misconduct at the Hinton lab was exposed in 2012, after she had worked there for nearly a decade. She admitted to tampering with evidence, forging test results and lying about it, according to court records. She served three years in prison and was released in 2016. Most of the people she helped convict of low-level drug offenses pleaded guilty and finished their sentences long before she was prosecuted, according to defense lawyers. More than 21,000 cases she worked on have been dismissed.

Lu’s ruling Sept. 16 is connected to cases in Middlesex County in which defendants are challenging drug convictions based on evidence that defense attorneys say was processed at the Hinton lab — not by Dookhan, but by other chemists, including Sonja Farak.

Farak worked at the Hinton lab from 2002 to August 2004 before she moved to a state lab in Amherst, where she fed a drug addiction by using samples she was supposed to be analyzing in criminal cases, according to court records. She pleaded guilty in 2014 to tampering with evidence and drug theft charges and was sentenced to 18 months in jail. More than 16,000 cases she worked on have been dismissed.

Farak has not been charged with any wrongdoing in connection with her work at Hinton.

Farak and Dookhan could not immediately be reached for comment.

The Middlesex County defendants are challenging their convictions, saying the state failed to specifically investigate Farak and other chemists while they worked at Hinton.

“We have to get to the bottom of what happened at Hinton,” said James P. McKenna, who represents two of the Middlesex defendants convicted with evidence tested by chemists other than Dookhan.

Former Massachusetts Inspector General Glenn A. Cunha, who retired this year, said in 2019 that his office never specifically investigated Farak’s work at Hinton. Cunha did not immediately respond to an email requesting comment.

Dookhan’s and Farak’s misconduct and the fallout have been a persisting embarrassment for the state, and they have upended its criminal justice system. The state public defender’s office estimated last year that as many as 250,000 convictions resulted from lab work at the now-closed Hinton lab when Dookhan, Farak and other chemists worked there.

Thousands of wrongly convicted people went to prison or jail or lost their jobs, homes and parental rights, according to defense lawyers.

In June, the state agreed to pay as much as $14 million to settle a class-action lawsuit to reimburse more than 30,000 wrongfully convicted defendants for the fines and fees they paid the state in prosecutions based on problematic crime lab tests. The state has also spent more than $30 million for other costs connected to investigating and addressing the harm of the scandal.

Lu’s ruling last week, which ordered that the defendants be given access to state documents in which the names of people mentioned in the Hinton investigation are not redacted, makes it clear that the inspector general’s concerns about the Hinton drug lab went beyond Dookhan. The ruling says that “it has become evident that the OIG made and/or considered several criminal referrals to the Attorney General for other persons at the Hinton Drug Lab.”

In June 2015, the inspector general’s office referred one matter to the attorney general’s office for possible prosecution “based on test results from an independent out-of-state laboratory, which were inconsistent with the Hinton Drug Lab results, suggesting that criminal acts may have been committed by another person at the Hinton Lab,” Lu wrote.

“Also, there were other instances where other persons at the lab knew or should have known that certain substances were not considered controlled substances under Massachusetts law but caused certificates of analysis to be issued stating that the substances were illegal, resulting in defendants being wrongfully convicted,” he wrote.

Lu did not disclose the identities of those people in his ruling, and numerous records remain under seal. Lu’s order barred all parties to the cases from sharing details of the newly unredacted state investigation documents.

In 2014, the inspector general said in a report that Dookhan was the “sole bad actor” at the Hinton crime lab, and the inspector general’s office has restated that numerous times since then, even as defense attorneys and judges have raised questions about the scope of the inspector general’s $6 million investigation.

A spokesperson for state Attorney General Maura Healey, the Democratic nominee for governor, declined to comment when she was asked what action — if any — the attorney general’s office took once it received the 2015 referral.

A spokesman for the inspector general’s office declined to comment, citing ongoing litigation.

News Related


Alabama grandfather charged in hot car death of toddler drove vehicle 3 times, prosecutor says

An Alabama grandfather was charged in connection with his grandson’s death after authorities said he left the 2-year-old boy in his truck for seven hours. Arrest warrants were issued Wednesday ... Read more »

United Airlines flight circles over Atlantic for hours, makes emergency landing over mechanical issue

A United Airlines flight from New Jersey to Brazil ended up circling over the Atlantic Ocean for nearly two hours Wednesday and making an emergency landing because of a mechanical ... Read more »

Toddler fatally shoots South Carolina mom with 'unsecured firearm,' sheriff says

A South Carolina mother died on Wednesday after she was shot by her 3-year-old child, after the toddler got a hold of an “unsecured firearm” in their home, authorities said. ... Read more »

Body parts found stuffed in suitcases during wellness check on NYC woman, police say

A wellness check for a 22-year-old woman in New York City reportedly led to a grisly discovery: blood, human remains and body parts stuffed into suitcases, police said. The New ... Read more »

Tesla to recall more than 1 million vehicles because automatic windows might exert 'excessive force' while closing

WASHINGTON — Tesla is recalling nearly 1.1 million U.S. vehicles because the window automatic reversal system may not react correctly after detecting an obstruction, increasing the risk of injury. The electric ... Read more »

Sanctuary cities are straining to support the thousands of migrants arriving by bus

The arrival of thousands of migrants in New York, Washington, Chicago and beyond has sent officials in those cities scrambling to establish a system of support services, with mixed success. ... Read more »

U.S. Latino economic output would rank 5th in world GDP, according to new study

If U.S. Latinos were an independent country, their gross domestic product would rank fifth in the world, surpassing those of the United Kingdom, India and France, according to a report ... Read more »

In a political first, two gay candidates face off in congressional election

A historic number of LGBTQ candidates will appear on ballots across the country in November. At least 1,095 lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer people have run or are still ... Read more »

Truck hurtles into sea after both sets of brakes fail

Luckily, no one is injured in this extraordinary occurence, which could have been fatal, both for the driver and anyone else in the vicinity. Read more »

White woman who called 911 on Black bird watcher in Central Park loses lawsuit against former employer

The white woman who called 911 and falsely accused a Black bird watcher of threatening her in New York City’s Central Park in a 2020 incident that went viral has ... Read more »

Puppies found in shut suitcase at side of road are rescued

Passer-by noticed "a nose" poking out from an old suitcase and found four puppies inside. Read more »

Florida highway covered in Coors Light beer after semi crash

BROOKSVILLE, Fla. — A Florida highway had to temporarily close Wednesday after a semitrailer carrying cases of Coors Light crashed and turned the roadway into a silver sea of beer ... Read more »

American Airlines passenger detained by FBI after allegedly assaulting attendant on flight from Los Cabos to Los Angeles

An American Airlines passenger was detained by the FBI after allegedly assaulting an attendant on a flight from San José del Cabo, Mexico, to Los Angeles on Wednesday, officials said. ... Read more »

Man convicted of shooting 2 Indiana judges in street dispute outside White Castle

INDIANAPOLIS — A man who shot and wounded two southern Indiana judges outside an Indianapolis fast food restaurant in 2019 was convicted Wednesday on seven of eight felonies and one ... Read more »

Coors Light beer cans cover Florida highway after multi-vehicle crash

Photos released by the Florida Highway Patrol show thousands of silver beer cans and boxes covering the road. Read more »

Beer and concrete strewn over road after lorry crash in Florida

Only one person sustained injuries, which were minor, in the crash which blocked a main road in Hernando County. Read more »

Worker was dead in Belk store bathroom for 4 days before being found, police say

COLUMBIA, S.C. — A 63-year-old worker died in the public bathroom of a South Carolina department store, but her body was not discovered for four days, authorities said. Bessie Durham, ... Read more »

A Philadelphia contract killer admitted to the deaths of 6 people, authorities say

A Philadelphia contract killer admitted to the deaths of six people over a three year span, including four who he gunned down on orders from a drug trafficker, federal authorities ... Read more »

Man charged in Hawaii kidnapping kept girl shackled in bus, documents say

A man in Hawaii accused of kidnapping and sexually assaulting a 15-year-old girl last week kept the victim restrained in a yellow bus, according to court documents filed Tuesday. The ... Read more »

U.S. fugitive known as 'Fat Leonard' apprehended in Venezuela after weeks on the run

A military contractor known as “Fat Leonard,” who cut off his ankle bracelet and fled after pleading guilty in a major U.S. Navy corruption scandal, was apprehended in Venezuela, authorities ... Read more »

'They won’t let me go,' a Georgia mom texted before she was found dead. There’s no evidence she was kidnapped, authorities say.

Authorities in Georgia said Wednesday there’s no evidence suggesting a missing Georgia mother who was found dead earlier this month was kidnapped — despite a chilling text message to her ... Read more »

Scientists at America’s top nuclear lab were recruited by China to design missiles and drones, report says

At least 154 Chinese scientists who worked on U.S. government-sponsored research at the country’s  foremost national security laboratory over the last two decades have been recruited to do scientific work ... Read more »

1 person is dead after a glider crashes off the coast of North Carolina

A glider crashed into the ocean off the coast of North Carolina on Wednesday and killed one of the two people on board, authorities said. The incident occurred at about ... Read more »

Woman says Memphis police failed to investigate her rape. The suspect is now charged in Eliza Fletcher's murder.

A woman who said she was raped last year by the man charged with killing Eliza Fletcher says that Memphis police did not properly investigate her case and if they ... Read more »

Biden approves disaster declaration for hurricane-ravaged Puerto Rico

President Joe Biden has approved a major disaster declaration for Puerto Rico as it reels from Hurricane Fiona, Gov. Pedro Pierluisi said Wednesday. The declaration will grant access to emergency ... Read more »

A Florida college student was shot while trying to enter the wrong car. His family wants answers.

The family of a slain University of Tampa student who was shot while trying to get into the wrong car is struggling to grasp the “senseless tragedy,” his grieving father ... Read more »

Indiana suspect captured after hourslong search in city sewers, where officials found a scythe and machete

An Indiana man sought for throwing a hatchet at people in a park was found after an hours-long search through Bloomington’s storm sewer system Tuesday — where investigators recovered a ... Read more »

Gay meteorologist, allegedly fired for using adult webcam site, pleads for his job back

A gay meteorologist in New York City who was allegedly fired after someone sent nude webcam photos of him to his employer and to his mother is pleading for his ... Read more »

Trump and his children are being sued

Read more »

Donald Trump sued for 'years of bank, tax and insurance fraud'

The suit, more than 220 pages in length, details alleged efforts by Mr Trump to inflate his personal net worth to get better loan agreements while also deflating his worth to gain better tax benefits.  Read more »

Decomposed body found in home confirmed to be that of a former Rhode Island mayor, officials say

One of two bodies found in a severe state of decomposition in the home of former Rhode Island mayor Susan Menard earlier this week has been confirmed to be her, ... Read more »

1 killed and 16 injured in Florida crash involving a semitruck, bus and pickup

A three-vehicle collision on a central Florida highway Wednesday morning resulted in one death and 16 injuries, authorities said. The crash occurred about 6:15 a.m. on State Route 60 in ... Read more »

Body found at South Carolina home during search for missing man and woman

A man who was reported missing along with a woman has been arrested after deputies in South Carolina found a body at a home. William Loyd Cagle, who also goes ... Read more »

Ex-Minneapolis police officer sentenced to 3 years in George Floyd's murder

Thomas Lane, a former Minneapolis police officer who pleaded guilty to second-degree manslaughter in the killing of George Floyd, was sentenced Wednesday to three years in prison. Lane held down ... Read more »

Human Rights Campaign, largest U.S. LGBTQ advocacy group, names new president

The Human Rights Campaign announced Tuesday that Kelley Robinson will serve as its ninth president — the first Black queer woman to lead the nation’s largest LGBTQ advocacy organization. Robinson, ... Read more »

Illinois Lottery: 2 claim $1.34B Mega Millions jackpot after vow to split prize

CHICAGO — Two people who wish to remain anonymous have claimed a $1.337 billion Mega Millions jackpot after a single ticket to the late July drawing was sold in a Chicago suburb, ... Read more »

Inmate taken to hospital after jumping from New York City jail barge

NEW YORK — An inmate jumped from an East River barge that’s part of New York City’s jail system on Tuesday and was taken to a hospital, authorities said. The ... Read more »

Florida man kills ex-wife, stepson in dispute over lights left on in the house

A recently-divorced Florida man fatally shot his ex-wife and her adult son in a “rage” over electricity and leaving the lights on in the house, Florida authorities said. Michael D. ... Read more »

CVS, Walmart reach $147.5M opioid settlement with West Virginia

CHARLESTON, W.Va. — Walmart and CVS Pharmacy have settled with the state of West Virginia for a combined total of $147 million in a lawsuit over the companies’ roles in ... Read more »

Aaron Judge hits 60th homer, 1 away from Maris’ AL season record

NEW YORK — Aaron Judge hit his 60th home run Tuesday night, matching Babe Ruth and moving within one of Roger Maris’ American League season record. The New York Yankees slugger drove ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network