Emoji reactions were a cute addition to Facebook. They became a headache.

Asia's Tech News Daily

Facebook's algorithms gave an "angry" reaction five times the weight of a traditional "like." After years of research, employees realized the result was more "toxicity."

In late 2017, Facebook was in the final stages of preparing for a major change in how it ranked posts and comments, and at least one employee had a lingering concern: what to do about the emojis. 

The plan was to give emoji reactions such as “love” and “angry” five times the weight of a traditional “like” in Facebook’s secret formula, according to an internal company document. That would make content that elicited those reactions far more common in the news feeds of Facebook’s gigantic user base.

The employee quickly foresaw what a problem that could cause.

“Quick question to play devil’s advocate: will weighting Reactions 5x stronger than Likes lead to News Feed having a higher ratio of controversial than agreeable content?” the employee asked on an internal message board. 

“I.e. if I post a story that I bought a coffee (pretty boring example I know) I might invite a few Likes from friends. However, if I post ‘Steve Bannon Punches Hillary’ I’ll probably get more polarized reactions with Angry emojis and thus (5x?) more distribution,” the person wrote. 

The response from colleagues: It’s possible, but the company knew about the potential problem and was working hard not to promote “engagement bait.” 

It turned out that the first employee’s concern was prescient and that the angry cartoon faces would have more influence on Facebook’s billions of users than others expected, company documents show. But it took years for Facebook to realize how right the person was, and when it did, it changed course. 

The story of Facebook’s emoji reactions illustrates how the company has come to operate — sometimes at breakneck pace and other times with caution. It’s capable of using even small software tweaks to dramatically change what people see online and is persistent in testing the resulting impact. The story also demonstrates how complex Facebook has become, both as a social media app and as a corporation with a large research staff.

Documents describing the study of emoji reactions were included in disclosures made to the Securities and Exchange Commission and provided to Congress by legal counsel for Frances Haugen, who worked as a Facebook product manager until May and has come forward as a whistleblower. 

Social media execs face questions on child safety at Senate hearing

Oct. 26, 202101:28

Haugen’s legal counsel redacted most names of Facebook employees. The Washington Post reported earlier on the internal debate. 

While the documents aren’t exhaustive, the ones that have been released illustrate the evolution of one of Facebook’s most important tools — its ranking algorithm — through the words of its own employees.

Reaction buttons are important beyond Facebook. For years, online social media companies have struggled with how to design buttons that don’t encourage toxic behavior or whether to have them at all. Reddit has had “upvotes” and “downvotes” since its earliest days in 2005. Twitter has tried different approaches for its “like” button, which predated Facebook’s. A designer behind Facebook’s “like” button has since expressed misgivings, and Instagram now allows users to hide their like counts. Nextdoor also has reaction emojis. 

Facebook’s emoji saga began in February 2016 when the company redesigned the “like” button to include five more ways to react to a post: “love,” “haha,” “wow,” “sad” and “angry.” (Yet another emoji reaction, “yay,” was considered but didn’t make the cut.) 

The emojis took on renewed importance two years later when Facebook announced a new ranking system to determine which posts people saw and in which order. The system gave equal weight to the five emoji reactions, and that was true regardless of the context or the intention of the person reacting, so a conspiracy theory with a lot of “haha” reactions or a violent image with a lot of “angry” reactions would potentially get an extra boost from the algorithm. 

The more emojis, whether angry faces or hearts showing love, the more meaning that Facebook’s computers would interpret. 

Facebook spokesperson Drew Pusateri said this week that Facebook tested various versions of the ranking system — known as Meaningful Social Interactions — before launch and conducted significant research. 

“The goal of Meaningful Social Interactions is to improve people’s experience by prioritizing posts that inspire interactions between family and friends, and that goal remains unchanged,” he said in an email. “The formula for attaining the goal of MSI is continually updated and refined based on new research and direct feedback from users.”

The documents from Haugen picked up the story again in April 2019, when internal researchers expressed an inkling that something was wrong. 

“I’ve been collecting evidence around how anger reactions, overall, is weaponized by political figures and creative negative incentives on the platform,” an employee wrote on an internal message board. 

There wasn’t much evidence yet, he and colleagues wrote, but their discussion marked a renewed interest into the impact that emoji reactions had. 

“Anger reaction, reshares, and crappy comments — the three things I’ve been thinking about for a while now!” an employee wrote in the same thread, describing three possible signals for identifying toxic posts.

Someone in the thread urged more study to determine whether there really were disturbing correlations between toxic content and certain emojis: “I think a key research project would be: who is an angry engager on Facebook, and why are they doing it? Is it a frequent part of their FB participation, or are there archetypes of users who angry-engage with content?” 

By November 2019, more research had come in, and it wasn’t looking good. Not all emojis were created equal, it turned out, and employees began thinking they should change the reaction weights so they weren’t all the same. 

“We find that angrys, hahas, wows seem more frequent on civic low quality news, civic misinfo, civic toxicity, health misinfo, and health antivax content, than on other civic and health content,” a study said that month. 

At least one researcher expressed concern that even CEO Mark Zuckerberg might not understand what the “angry” emoji meant. When a Facebook user urged the company to create a “dislike” button, Zuckerberg responded in a public comment on the site, “You can use the angry face.” 

But the researcher wrote in a December 2019 report that the angry face was, in fact, the opposite of a “dislike” button, because it could deliver more of the same: “Indeed, even Mark himself has suggested that the anger reaction is a reasonable way to express that you don’t like a piece of content, even as we currently count it as 4x as important as a less ambiguous ‘like’ for giving you more such content.”

It’s not clear from Zuckerberg’s years-old remark whether he was being sincere, flippant or something else. The company declined to comment on Zuckerberg’s old remark this week, and over the years, Facebook has generally not commented on the emoji reactions except to announce new emojis and to respond to Haugen’s disclosures this week.

By January 2020, documents show, Facebook had decided that the emojis overall should get less weight in the ranking algorithm, but the weight for each remained equal. When a researcher on a message board asked why, another responded that there were strong arguments on both sides but that “the voice of caution won out” pending further study.

“The caution is indeed about imposing judgement on different emotions’ values,” the second researcher wrote. 

But on another front, Facebook was coming around to the idea that users didn’t have enough emotional options for their reactions. In April, it added a seventh emoji reaction, “care,” which could be especially useful during the coronavirus pandemic.

Months later, a proposal to stop giving any weight to the angry face reaction was circulating. 

“We see that anger and haha reactions are highly prevalent on misinfo and toxicity,” an internal report from July 2020 said. 

“The number of Hahas a Civic post has received is a strongly negative predictor of whether the post’s viewers consider it trustworthy, important, or good for their community. Nevertheless, Haha is the most common reaction on Civic content,” researchers wrote in the report. 

Documents show that in September 2020, Facebook approved an overhaul. The angry face emoji would no longer count for anything in the feed ranking; “wow,” “sorry” and “haha” reactions would count somewhat, with a weight of “1” in the formula, and “love” and “care” reactions would count more, with a weight of “2.” 

“At this point we don’t expect that we need to restate our goals, but we can discuss if the metric jumps are really big,” the internal announcement said. 

In comments on the announcement, employees were turning attention to the next problems to tackle, such as spammy photos for which an author asks for an “OK” or a “Yes” comment to get a discount code. 

“Engagement bait comments are a problem!” an employee wrote. 

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Google makes Privacy Sandbox pledge to UK competition watchdog amid fears over grip on online advertising

The competition watchdog says it has secured assurances from Google over its use of customer data amid fears its Privacy Sandbox plans could squeeze out its online advertising rivals. After ... Read more »

Black Friday gaming laptop deals 2021 - all the best live sales

Black Friday gaming laptop deals are rushing in with no signs of slowing down, as we’re witnessing everything from budget machines to the best gaming laptops that money can buy ... Read more »

Buying an Xbox Series S on Black Friday? This is the ideal companion

© MICROSOFT Thinking of getting an Xbox Series S The Xbox Series SLink is a brilliant little console, offering next-gen gaming at an affordable price and in a cute packaging. ... Read more »

New Russian module docks with International Space Station

On Location: November 26, 2021 Catch up on the developing stories making headlines.The Associated Press MOSCOW — A Russian cargo craft carrying a new docking module successfully hooked up with ... Read more »

The 15 best Black Friday camera deals that are still live right now

The Black Friday camera deals have produced some real bargains this year, thanks to a perfect storm of mature mirrorless tech and fierce competition between the likes of Canon, Sony, ... Read more »

The best Black Friday 2021 video game deals for PS5, Xbox, and Nintendo

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. The holidays are a perfect time to catch up on your ... Read more »

Who are the nuns taking on Microsoft?

Microsoft has survived brutal battles against and , but the company now faces a more formidable foe: the Sisters of St. Joseph of Peace. The congregation is leading a group ... Read more »

PC gaming on a budget is possible thanks to these Black Friday deals

Let’s face it, PC gaming can seem intimidating. The hardware is generally expensive and complicated and for someone just looking to get into PC gaming, or if you want to ... Read more »

The best Black Friday golf deals from Dick's Sporting Goods, Callaway and more

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Hunting for some impressive Black Friday golf deals? We’re tracking all ... Read more »

These are the gaming PCs we'd buy with a $1,000 budget this Black Friday

The best Black Friday gaming PC deals under $1,000 don’t feature the latest RTX 30 series graphics cards at their heart, but you’ll be able to game comfortably in both ... Read more »

This RTX 3090 gaming PC is the cheapest way to get the most powerful graphics card

If you’ve been trying to find where to buy an RTX 3090 on Black Friday, you’ve probably already noticed that, not only is the GPU hard to find, but even ... Read more »

Omicron variant: WHO names 'extremely concerning' new variant identified in South Africa

The new coronavirus variant was detected in South Africa. Scientists have raised concerns about the large number of mutations, which could mean that vaccines are less effective. (Reuters) The World ... Read more »

Health Secretary warns new COVID variant 'could pose substantial risk to public health'

Sajid Javid told MPs in a Commons statement that the new variant identified in South Africa is ‘of huge international concern’, amid fears the strain, which ‘could defeat vaccines’ may ... Read more »

Google Chromecast gets big Black Friday price cuts

© Google Google Chromecast Black Friday sale includes discounts on the third-generation and Chromecast with Google TV models. Black Friday is in full swing – and among the discounts from ... Read more »

New roadside cameras can detect drivers using a mobile phone behind the wheel

Enforcement technology company Jenoptik said it is working on a new tool that could identify drivers breaking the law in seconds. The new technology will use AI technology to automatically ... Read more »

Best Budget Graphics Cards

A powerful PC is a must-have for anyone who enjoys gaming, video editing, 3D modelling and many more jobs and hobbies. One of the trickiest parts to choose in your ... Read more »

Bryan Adams Remains Hospitalized In Italy After Testing Positive For Covid Again – Update

UPDATE FRIDAY 1:30 PM: Bryan Adams posted an update from the hospital in Milan, Italy where he was taken after testing positive for Covid upon arrival at the Milan Malpensa ... Read more »

French block British boat amid fishing row

The fishermen held aloft red flares as they circled their boats outside Saint-Malo to block the Normandy Trader’s path – a prelude to a planned blockade later on Friday of ... Read more »

Get $550 off the RTX 3060 Alienware Aurora R12 with this Black Friday deal

If you’re looking for a great Black Friday PC gaming deal, look no further than this Alienware Aurora R12 gaming PC starting at just $1,289 over at Dell right now. ... Read more »

On Black Friday you can save $500 on the Cadillac of gaming monitors

The Samsung Odyssey Neo G9 isn’t just one of the best gaming monitors, it’s honestly in its own category altogether. This is the latest and greatest in monitor technology, and ... Read more »

The best Apple Watch Black Friday deals are on three models - which should you buy?

The vast majority of Apple Watch deals over Black Friday are on three different Apple smartwatches; if you’ve been perusing the discounts, you’ve probably caught yourself wondering ‘which of them ... Read more »

Should you buy a TCL TV on Black Friday? Our verdict on TCL Roku TVs and more

TCL has built a reputation for making affordable TVs loaded with streaming smarts. In 2020, the Chinese brand ranked no.2 in North America in terms of market share – but ... Read more »

Entertainment gurus to invest in NFTs, metaverse

HYBE Chairman Bang Si-hyuk, left, and Dunamu Chairman Song Chi-hyung talk about their plans for business collaboration in the non-fungible token sector on YouTube on Nov. 5. Screen-captured from HYBE ... Read more »

Don't miss these stunning Sennheiser headphones deals for Black Friday

Sennheiser makes some of the best headphones on the planet, from noise-cancelling over-ears to tiny true wireless earbuds you can slip in your pocket – and the brand’s best models ... Read more »

Beautyrest launches $300 off hybrid mattress deal for Black Friday

A new Beautyrest Black Friday mattress sale is now live, with up to $300 off the Black foam and hybrid mattresses for cooler sleep and better back support. Thanks to ... Read more »

Japanese mobile carrier faces govt order due to 'serious' system failure

Tokyo, The Japanese government on Friday issued an administrative order to NTT Docomo Inc. (NTT Docomo), the country’s largest mobile carrier, after a system failure last month, which affected at ... Read more »

HSN Black Friday deals are here—save big on Shark, Ninja, Nintendo and more

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. If you’re planning on shopping online for Black Friday and Cyber ... Read more »

Dodge Joy-Con drift with these Black Friday PowerA Switch controller deals

Look away, Nintendo puritans, or risk being converted to the third-party agenda with some of Amazon’s Black Friday Nintendo Switch deals on PowerA controllers. Whether it’s the simple black wired ... Read more »

Holding out for the Animal Crossing Nintendo Switch this Black Friday, yes, yes?

Many of us were hoping that with the release of the Animal Crossing: New Horizons – Happy Home Paradise DLC, we might see some coveted Animal Crossing Nintendo Switch deals ... Read more »

This SanDisk NVMe SSD deal is too good to pass up – even if you don't need a new SSD

If you’re looking to upgrade to a NVMe M.2 SSD this Black Friday, you can’t go wrong with this SanDisk PCIe Gen3 NVMe internal SSD for just $79.99 at Best ... Read more »

Intel could bring out new GPUs every year to take the fight to AMD and Nvidia

Intel’s Arc Druid graphics cards, which would be the 4th-gen models, following on in alphabetical order from 1st-gen Alchemist, could be out in 2025, an employee has hinted – meaning ... Read more »

T-Mobile blocked from advertising 'most reliable' 5G

T-Mobile will no longer be able to advertise its 5G network as the ‘most reliable’ in the US according to a new ruling from the National Advertising Division (NAD) of ... Read more »

The best Black Friday deals under $50 you don't want to miss

The 2021 Black Friday deals event is officially underway, and we’ve already seen some of the best sales leaping from the virtual shelves. If you’re looking for today’s cheapest offers ... Read more »

Black Friday AirPods Pro deal sees noise-cancelling earbuds drop to lowest price

It’s no secret that the AirPods Pro are among the best true wireless earbuds you can buy, but Apple’s flagship buds usually don’t come cheap. Thanks to these amazing AirPods ... Read more »

Amazon devices are selling out on Black Friday - here's what will arrive before Xmas

Yep, the title is not simply hyperbole – Amazon’s Black Friday deals on its own devices really are selling out quickly this year. If you’re looking for a cheap smart ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic