Elden Ring is not Game of the Year but Xenoblade Chronicles 3 is – Reader’s Feature

Elden Ring is not Game of the Year but Xenoblade Chronicles 3 is – Reader’s Feature

Xenoblade Chronicles 3 – game of the year? (pic: Nintendo)

A reader argues that Xenoblade Chronicles 3 is the best game of 2022 and superior to Elden Ring, even if it’s unlikely to win many awards.

One of the side effects of 2022 being such a quiet year for games is that this year’s Game Awards are going to be a pretty straightforward affair. There are very few contenders in any of the categories and even the more general ones are pretty much uncontested. Which is another way of saying that Elden Ring is going to walk off with everything. I mean, they might as well give it the award now, and all the other game of the year nods, because there’s clearly nothing else that’s even in the running.

God Of War Ragnarök is the only upcoming games that’s guaranteed (as much as anything is guaranteed) to score well but I cannot see it beating Elden Ring unless it is something radically different to the original. I can though, easily see it being worse as they’ve got a lot of hard work to do with the story, which is a lot more restricted by the legend of what Ragnarök is than the entirely original plot of the first game.

I could easily see God Of War Ragnarök being a disappointment and, frankly, the fact they’ve showed basically nothing of it so far makes me worry that they’re hiding something. Maybe a secret that’s a game-changer, but, more likely, there’s been problems and they’ve not been confident of showing anything yet.

I’ve got similar vibes about Bayonetta 3 and I doubt anyone is expecting Gotham Knights or Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 to be challenging Elden Ring. But there is one game, that’s already out, which I think is better and, as I guess you’ve worked out from the title, that’s Xenoblade Chronicles 3.

I don’t expect Xenoblade Chronicles 3 to win many game of the year awards, and certainly not The Game Awards, because like everything from the Oscars to the Grammys, these things are just as much about popularity as they are actual quality.

Now, I’m not saying that Elden Ring is a bad game, far from it. I’ve put around 30 hours into it but that was enough for me. I’ve played Dark Souls as well and for me Elden Ring was just too bloated and too repetitive. It’s one of an increasing number of games that doesn’t gain anything from being open world, especially as not only have you got the earlier games to compare it with but all the best parts of Elden Ring are the more linear dungeons and castles.

By comparison, Xenoblade Chronicles 3’s open world is amazingly varied, filled with just as many secrets, but at no time feels bloated or unnecessary. There’s no reusing the same bosses a dozen times and the punishment for failure is not the video game equivalent of a punch in the face (but nor is it nothing, just as it should be).

Most importantly for me, there’s a story that I understand and characters I like. That’s one thing I’ve never understood about From’s game, is why is the story so obscure? Doesn’t your character know what’s going on? Why then are you as a player so in the dark? Would it have really hurt to explain what the Lands Between are between and what the Elden Ring actually is? Why are there no people around? Were there ever any people? Are those soldiers zombies? Were they always zombies?

Was the world always in pieces like this or did that just happen? What do all the other characters want and why is there only half a dozen that can talk? Who do those merchants sell things to when you’re not around? Why do some characters not seem bothered about their life? What do they do when you’re not around? Especially the ones that just seem to stand around in a small room all day?

As far as I’m concerned Xenoblade Chronicles 3 has all of the positives of Elden Ring but none of the negatives. It’s got a massive open world, enjoyable (but in its case original) combat, great graphics and art design, and plenty of secrets and rewards for exploration. On top of that it has enjoyable characters and villains with plausible motivations, an interesting but understandable plot, and no excessive repetition.

I’ve thoroughly enjoyed the 100+ hours I’ve put into it and it’s definitely my personal game of the year, I just don’t expect it to be a favourite of any of the award judges.

By reader Caliban

The reader’s feature does not necessary represent the views of GameCentral or Metro.

You can submit your own 500 to 600-word reader feature at any time, which if used will be published in the next appropriate weekend slot. Just contact us at gamecentral@metro.co.uk or use our Submit Stuff page and you won’t need to send an email.

Follow Metro Gaming on Twitter and email us at gamecentral@metro.co.uk

To submit Inbox letters and Reader’s Features more easily, without the need to send an email, just use our Submit Stuff page here.

News Related


PUBG is Getting a Spooky Dead by Daylight Crossover This October

PUBG: Battlegrounds is getting a chilling Dead by Daylight crossover just in time for Halloween, Krafton has announced. Starting in October and running until December, PUBG: Battlegrounds will be hosting ... Read more »

The national park that reversed the destruction of civil war

safari holidays africa wildlife travel conservation pangolins – Simon Parker “You just missed the painted dogs,” said our guide, Richard Lusinga, as we signed the campsite’s indemnity forms and checked ... Read more »

Trial begins over alleged rape in Australia's parliament

Bruce Lehrmann is charged with raping fellow staffer Brittany Higgins in the then-defence industry minister Linda Reynolds' office in Parliament House in March 2019. Read more »

Stop Questioning People's Invisible Illnesses – It's None Of Your Business

Double Paralympic gold medallist Kadeena Cox. (Photo: JUSTIN TALLIS via Getty Images) Double Paralympic gold medallist Kadeena Cox. (Photo: JUSTIN TALLIS via Getty Images) Paralympian Kadeena Cox lives with multiple ... Read more »

Nintendo Switch Online Missions And Rewards: October 2022 - Breath Of The Wild, Animal Crossing, Splatoon

Earn Platinum Points to unlock new icons Read more »

'It scared the hell out of me': Strictly's Matt Goss reveals he was the victim of an attempted abduction as a child

The singer, 54, revealed a man tried to 'snatch' him into a car when he was seven Matt admitted it 'scared the hell out of me' and he still remembers the man's face Read more »

Payments Giant Mastercard Launches Cryptocurrency Anti-Fraud Tool for Card Issuers

Mastercard’s Crypto Secure product helps banks to determine the risk of crime associated with crypto exchanges on its payment network. Read more »

Lost Judgment and Judgment now support Intel’s XeSS AI-upscaling tech

Ryu Ga Gotoku Studio has released a new patch for Lost Judgment and Judgment that adds support for Intel’s XeSS tech. In addition, the new patch adds support for a ... Read more »

PS Plus Essential Games for October 2022 Available to Download Now

A new PS Plus Essential monthly update has arrived, bringing with it three brand new PS5, PS4 games for subscribers to download and play. Available now across Europe and rolling ... Read more »

PICTURE EXCLUSIVE: Elizabeth Debicki is Diana's double as she films scenes for The Crown 'showing the princess's 1997 visit to Angola' where she toured landmine sites months before her death

Elizabeth Debicki donned a navy blazer as she transformed into Princess Diana for The Crown's sixth seriesThe Australian actress, 32, bore an uncanny resemblance to the late royal as she filmed scenes in SpainThe scenes portrayed the royal as she arrived at Luanda Airport Angola at the start of her Red Cross visit Read more »

Tower of Fantasy on Steam has a release date

The Steam page for Tower of Fantasy apparently has listed its release date, which is on October 20th this year. Tower of Fantasy was already available to add to your ... Read more »

Leading women in tech to debate secrets to career success

Leading professionals from Samsung, Equiem, Tapoly and Wisdom will take to the stage at Mindspace Shoreditch on 12 October 2022 to host the panel: “What I wish I’d known at the start of my tech career ”. Read more »

Maddison still holding out for a place in England World Cup squad

Leicester midfielder James Maddison has not given up hope of making England's World Cup squad. Read more »

Women face the ultimate miscarriage of justice

(Shutterstock) In 1950s America, my mother was given the care she needed to survive her miscarriages. In 2022, in some parts of this country, my mother might be considered a ... Read more »

Some leading Democrats won't debate their election-denying opponents

Some leading Democrats won't debate their election-denying opponents Candidates in Arizona and elsewhere say they want to avoid combative spectacles. Democrats in key swing states like Arizona and Michigan have ... Read more »

Join us for an hour of Fallout 76 on today's GR Live

We're jumping back into Bethesda's multiplayer RPG following the release of The Pitt expansion. Read more »

Bethesda Has Unveiled Its Plans For Fallout’s 25th Anniversary

Bethesda has plans for Fallout’s 25th Anniversary! No, we didn’t accidentally miss out “big”; if anything, the events Bethesda has revealed so far are a little underwhelming. We’re hoping that ... Read more »

Food experts have some surprising suggestions for dishes to break the Yom Kippur fast

Bagels, quiche, fish platters, honey cake and sweet kugel are just a few of the dishes people indulge in after completing their Yom Kippur fast. In order, from left: Matt ... Read more »

This Week's Deals With Gold Include a Fallout Sale, Twin Mirror, and Shadow Warrior 3

Deals With Gold return for another Tuesday, and there’s a Fallout 25th Anniversary Sale on this week for fans of all things Bethesda. The sale includes the likes of Fallout ... Read more »

‘Ru Paul’s Secret Celebrity Drag Race 2×08’ Review

The journey to this week’s final episode of Ru Paul’s Secret Celebrity Drag Race has been a rather unique one considering that the celebrities were forced to reveal themselves a ... Read more »

Bloodborne Movie, TV Show Could Be a Thing in the Future

A Bloodborne movie, TV series, or anime is not outside the realms of possibility according to PlayStation Studios lead Hermen Hulst, who says the company’s investments are about more than ... Read more »

Fans worry over apparent lack of direction for Genshin Impact end game

Fans have been discussing a recent interview that touches on the future and potential end game of Genshin Impact, of which seems unclear. TALKING POINTS Let’s start off with summarizing ... Read more »

Valkyrie Elysium Review – Strong Hack and Slash Combat In An Empty World

Valkyrie Elysium is a revival of the cult classic Valkyrie Profile RPG series. Unlike the original games which were turn-based, this game is an action RPG hack and slash title ... Read more »

Akiba Street – Bringing Anime Culture Back To The Sungei Wang Plaza, Malaysia

The venue will be holding opening events all week Read more »

Fire Emblem Heroes Reveals Halloween Alts To Divine Harvest Banner

Positively glowing in their bewitching outfits, Fire Emblem Heroes has just revealed four new Halloween Alts to units from FE Fates, Awakening and Shadows of Valentia Echoes, starting from 6th ... Read more »

Chieri’s Love Is 8 Metres Is A New Manga About A Giantess Who’s Also Your Childhood Best Friend

Chieri’s Love is 8 Metres, if nothing else, is a great example of a case study of how blatantly you can insert your fetishes into a manga before someone calls ... Read more »

Gamers Hideout celebrates 16th anniversary with giveaway, discounts

Gamers Hideout is celebrating their 16th anniversary with fanfare, unveiling a giveaway for one Limited Edition Pokemon Scarlet and Violet Nintendo Switch OLED, and discounts for a whole host of ... Read more »

Manchester City playmaker Kevin De Bruyne insists Phil Foden hasn't reached his full potential

Kevin De Bruyne has no doubt Phil Foden will keep getting better and better. Read more »

The Crown: Netflix looking for young actor to play Prince Harry aged 16 to 20 in season 6

Actor doesn’t need experience, but must have a ‘strong physical resemblance’ to royal Read more »

Nick Kyrgios' lawyer to argue he's not mentally fit to stand trial on assault charge

Nick Kyrgios' lawyers have formally requested that the common assault charge against him be dismissed on mental health grounds. Read more »

Ringo Starr cancels North American tour after catching COVID

Former Beatle Ringo Starr has been forced to cancel a string of tour dates with his band the All-Starrs in the US after testing positive for COVID. Read more »

[Guide] Genshin Impact: 3.1 Dendroculus Locations

With the recent update of Genshin Impact 3.1, they released a new region to explore, the vast Desert region of Sumeru where the Scarlet King resides. New region means more ... Read more »

Dragon Quest Treasures: Of Rival Gangs in Draconia

Square Enix has revealed new information for the upcoming Dragon Quest Treasures, this time bringing information on rival gangs scattered in the land of Draconia. The land of Draconia is ... Read more »

Roller Champions rolls new season, Dragon’s Way on October 5

Ubisoft has announced that Roller Champions brand-new season called Dragon’s Way will go live on October 5th, midnight Singapore time. The update is free for all players on PlayStaion 4, ... Read more »

Will Smith enters 2023 Oscar race with slavery drama Emancipation

After holding the film in limbo following Smith slapping Chris Rock at the Academy Awards in March, Apple will release Smith’s next big project this December Read more »

'My sister's just had her first!' Kara Tointon shares her happiness as she reveals Hannah, 34, has given birth to a baby girl with her fiancé Joe Thomas

Hannah Tointon has welcomed her first child with her fiancé Joe Thomas, her sister Kara revealed during a recent podcast interview. Actress Kara, 39, told of her happiness while chatting ... Read more »

Antonio Conte backs Tottenham Hotspur to bounce back against Eintracht Frankfurt

Antonio Conte wants Tottenham to get their north London derby disappointment out of their system when they visit Eintracht Frankfurt in the Champions League on Tuesday. Read more »

Toto Wolff not expecting Lewis Hamilton to quit Mercedes any time soon

Team boss Toto Wolff has confirmed that Lewis Hamilton will sign a new deal with Mercedes that could see him at the team for five years. Read more »

Uvalde families endorse Beto O'Rourke for Texas governor in emotional ad campaign

Uvalde families endorse Beto O'Rourke for Texas governor in emotional ad campaign The ads are running in all major markets across TX indefinitely, campaign said. Texas Democratic gubernatorial candidate Beto ... Read more »

‘I haven’t been really impressed by them’: MAD Lions Elyoya on facing NA at Worlds 2022

Photo by Ingrid Muhlenbrock via Riot Games This League of Legends Worlds 2022 coverage is brought to you by EsportsBet.IO, the official betting partner of Dot Esports. Visit EsportsBet.IO for ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network