Dutch recycling strategy needs a rethink: ‘we don’t know what is going on’

imported, fashion industry, reuse old clothes, developed a car, 2050 Circularity plan, has similar aims, bottles, cans, investigation, skyrocket

The rise in home shopping has led to more rubbish being dumped. Photo: DutchNews.nl

The Netherlands claims to be a leading light when it comes to recycling, but walk along any Amsterdam street, and you have to wonder who is recycling what. Piles of cardboard and old furniture stack up alongside the underground paper and glass containers, next to full plastic bags of household waste. Zuza Nazaruk spoke to Rob Buurman of Recycling Network Benelux to find out what is going wrong.

‘We have almost no idea what is going on with Dutch recycling,’ states Rob Buurman, director of Recycling Netwerk Benelux (RNB), an environmental NGO and one of the key drivers of the recent legislation to bring in deposits on small plastic bottles and cans.

‘The Netherlands, and Europe generally recycle a bit better than the rest of the world but then again, our consumption rates are higher’, says Buurman. ‘We owe the world a better recycling strategy.’

The word ‘recycling’ covers a variety of processes including collection, sorting and categorizing, processing, and repurposing. Every waste stream, for example, cardboard, metal, plastic, or glass, requires a separate process. And that means, every waste stream is at a different stage.

Valuable

In general, the more valuable a material, the more likely it will be recycled. Metals are expensive to produce and easy to separate, and 95% of metal used by the packaging industry in 2018 was recycled, according to Afvalfonds Verpakkingen, the industry body charged with managing recycling on behalf of packaging companies and local authorities.

imported, fashion industry, reuse old clothes, developed a car, 2050 Circularity plan, has similar aims, bottles, cans, investigation, skyrocket

Photo DutchNews.nl

Plastic, by contrast, is cheap to make but expensive to reuse, and just over half the plastic packaging used in the Netherlands in 2018 was recycled.

The packaging industry claims that the Dutch high recycling rates make the country ‘one of the leaders in Europe’. And according to the European Environment Agency (EEA), the Netherlands is fourth in the EU in terms of recycling municipal waste, with 54% being recycled in 2019. Yet a closer look reveals a bleaker picture.

Inadequate measurements 

A major issue with the percentage rates presented by both EEA and the packaging lobby is the method of calculating recycling. In EU terms, all collected and sorted waste counts as recycled, while ‘pollution’ such as left-over liquid in a bottle, is also included.

And some of the 54% actually ends up being incinerated or shipped overseas. Recent investigations by the Lighthouse Reports found that Dutch waste, marked as recycled, was shipped to Turkey and Malaysia and the latter imported 18 million tons of Dutch waste in 2019.

New EU rules which will soon be introduced will change the definitions of what counts as recycling but, as Buurman points out, they will still miss the key point of recycling: measuring the environmental gain and getting people to simply use less.

‘The goal,’ he says, ‘is not to recycle but to reduce resource consumption.’

New products

One way of doing this is using recycled material to replace virgin resources in creating a new product. The construction industry, for example, is working on reusing concrete from demolished buildings in producing new ones.

Initiatives to cut plastic waste use plastic soup to create boats and the fashion industry is coming up with a myriad ways to reuse old clothes. Eindhoven students have even developed a car made out of waste.

imported, fashion industry, reuse old clothes, developed a car, 2050 Circularity plan, has similar aims, bottles, cans, investigation, skyrocket

Plastic waste awaiting collection in Amstelveen. Photo: DutchNews.nl

The Dutch government is currently working on plans to boost the amount of recycled material used in manufacturing in its 2050 Circularity plan. The plan states that in 30 years time, the use of metals, plastics and other non-organic materials must be cut by 50%. Amsterdam has similar aims.

This approach to reducing waste in general derives from a theory developed by Dutch politician Ad Lansink in 1979. He drew up a hierarchy of waste management – prevention and reuse, recycle, recovery and disposal – which still forms the basis of current EU strategy, although, as Buurman points out, it is widely ignored.

Rising production

Instead of focusing on preventing waste in the first place, and encouraging its reuse, government strategy tends to focus on recycling, which does little to counter the negative effects of rising production and consumption, especially for plastic packaging.

‘In the Netherlands, we continuously monitor litter and it always increases. It is time to start approaching waste differently’, Buurman says.

New legislation bringing in deposits on small plastic bottles and cans, come into effect respectively in July 2021 and January 2023, and will significantly improve the collection and, subsequently, the recycling quality of drinks packaging, he says. The move was furiously contested by the packaging industry, which cited cost concerns.

Victory

‘The deposit discussion is one of the longest-running in the Netherlands. We really achieved a victory here,’ says Buurman. The Netherlands becomes the 16th EU country to introduce deposits on small drinks containers. Some, such as Germany and Estonia, have been doing so since the early 2000s.

imported, fashion industry, reuse old clothes, developed a car, 2050 Circularity plan, has similar aims, bottles, cans, investigation, skyrocket
The struggle to bring in deposits on small plastic bottles – around 100 million are dumped in the Netherlands every year – illustrates the important role the packaging industry has in Dutch recycling strategy.

An investigation by EUobserver in February revealed the role that the packaging industry plays in both processing waste and lobbying against change. Yet national government, recyclers and local authorities are all in some way dependent on the industry.  Local authorities and recyclers need to get paid for the collection and recycling, while the government depends on industry figures for data collection and reporting.

Litter

After the deposits victory, Recycling Netwerk Benelux is now turning to other matters. Buurman has recently given input to the Dutch government about a new communication campaign focusing on litter.  ‘We need more discussion on the relationship between consumer and the product, not just consumer and the bin,’ he says.

Also in the firing line is the online shopping sector. It boomed during the pandemic, causing cardboard waste to skyrocket. The home delivery sector, says Buurman, offers great opportunities for waste prevention and reuse, for example, by standardising boxes and food containers.

Yet, at the moment, there are no incentives – legal or economic – to introduce circular systems. ‘We will not save the world by depending on the voluntary attitude of mindful people,’ Buurman says. ‘An environmental change often starts with a good policy framework.’

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Pro-environment consumers, suppliers patronize 'ugly' fruits and vegetables

Most of the ugly looks of the fruits and vegetables are the outcome of organic, natural farming. Pro-environment consumers and suppliers are patronizing ‘ugly’ agricultural products that do not fit ... Read more »

Teacher at John A. Ferguson Senior High under investigation for inappropriate behavior

A teacher at John A. Ferguson Senior High is under investigation after being accused of inappropriate behavior with a student, the school district said. Miami-Dade County Public Schools on Tuesday ... Read more »

Chipotle cancels in-restaurant Boorito deal for $1 million free burrito giveaway, $5 Halloween meals

Chipotle Mexican Grill is changing its annual Halloween promotion for the second year in a row. Last year amid the coronavirus pandemic, Chipotle moved Boorito to a digital-only offer after ... Read more »

Authors slam Singapore Writers Festival for inviting Wang Lei as speaker

Wang Lei is one of the speakers of a panel discussion about endangered art forms such as getai and Teochew opera. SINGAPORE – Home-grown authors have slammed the Singapore Writers ... Read more »

Flamingos dye their sun-faded feathers to stay pretty in pink

Greater flamingos apparently aren’t fans of a sun-faded look for their neck feathers. Scientists have known that the leggy birds touch up their color by smearing their necks with a ... Read more »

Hot Bods: Training six to seven times a week, sometimes twice a day

Pari Priyadarshini (left) trains six to seven times a week while Lin Diyou cycles for 45 minutes three times a week. SINGAPORE – Meet this week’s hot bods – entrepreneur ... Read more »

Actor Chen Hanwei reunited with mum after two-year Covid separation

SINGAPORE – Actor Chen Hanwei has reunited with his mum, who lives in Johor Baru, after almost two years of not seeing her. The Malaysia-born Mediacorp actor, 52, posted heartfelt ... Read more »

Beyond's Paul Wong shows his love to wife Athena Chu as she turns 50

Musician Paul Wong posted on Weibo a photo of him kissing his wife, actress Athena Chu, on her birthday on Oct 25, 2021. BEIJING – Hong Kong musician Paul Wong ... Read more »

Cutting out even a little salt can have big health benefits

The amount of salt that is safe for people to consume has been embroiled in controversy for a century. NEW YORK (NYTIMES) – Sometimes, seemingly small changes in a health ... Read more »

Singapore children's book Lemonade Sky makes international catalogue

SINGAPORE – Home-grown picture book Lemonade Sky has scored a place in the White Ravens catalogue, an annual selection of the best children’s books from around the world. The book ... Read more »

Neurocognitive disorder is more of an umbrella term than diagnosis

DEAR DOCTORS: My mother passed away several years ago from a form of dementia called organic brain syndrome. Can you tell me what this is? I'd like to know what ... Read more »

Singapore International Film Festival a cinema-only event this year

SINGAPORE – The 32nd edition of the Singapore International Film Festival (SGIFF) will be held in cinemas only, in contrast to last year’s event, which featured physical and online screenings. ... Read more »

Man who gave Alec Baldwin loaded gun previously sacked over weapon safety

LOS ANGELES (AFP) – The assistant director who handed actor Alec Baldwin the loaded weapon that killed a cinematographer had been sacked from a previous production for gun safety violations, ... Read more »

‘Long time coming': Rally calls for federal investigation of Kansas City, Kansas police

Calls for the Kansas City, Kansas Police Department to be the subject of a federal investigation were raised Monday by social justice leaders and families that say they are the ... Read more »

Anti-ageing cream rooted in history

The Neal’s Yard Remedies store in Covent Garden. From humble beginnings in a colourful corner of Covent Garden, Neal's Yard Remedies has expanded its presence to 21 countries. Its roots ... Read more »

Chappelle 'more than willing' to meet LGBTQ groups over special

Dave Chappelle has sparked fury over his latest Netflix special, but insists he is willing to meet transgender activists to talk about their objections. LOS ANGELES: Comedian Dave Chappelle has ... Read more »

Photo contest hopes to 'Rediscover Thailand'

It has been nearly two years that the Thai tourism industry has been negatively affected by the pandemic. A positive side, however, seems to be the revival of nature that ... Read more »

Swatch goes back to the future

A giant Swatch on the headquarters of the Commerzbank in Frankfurt. photos courtesy of Swatch In the 1940s, George Orwell imagined 1984 in his dystopian novel whereas in the early ... Read more »

Showcase highlights award-winning painters

photo courtesy of UOB Thailand A selection of 19 paintings from the 2021 “UOB Painting of the Year” competition are displayed on the first floor of Bangkok Art and Culture ... Read more »

Remember the Raja A tribute to Pornsak Songsaeng who passed away aged 60

Pornsak Songseang. Photo: www.facebook.com/Boat.Sukarom Pornsak Songsaeng, the 'Raja of Molam' from Isan, died of a heart attack in Nong Bua Lam Phu province on Oct 17. He was 60 years ... Read more »

The long road to recovery While far from perfect, the Phuket Sandbox programme and new no-quarantine entry is raising hopes among hard-hit local businesses

Patong beach in Phuket. Photo: Jack TAYLOR / AFP For Chalong Loysamut, the Phuket Sandbox programme — which has reportedly raked in over 2 billion baht from tourists since July ... Read more »

‘Rust' Production Wrapping Set “Until The Investigations Are Complete” In Wake Of Tragedy On Alec Baldwin Movie

The Rust production team released a letter to the crew of the Alec Baldwin feature tonight saying that they’ve “made the decision to wrap the set at least until investigations ... Read more »

Ex-University of St. Thomas football player guilty of raping fellow student in dorm

A onetime University of St. Thomas football player has been convicted of raping a fellow student in a dorm room more than three years ago. Nicholas R. Schnack, 22, of ... Read more »

Jumping spiders' remarkable senses capture a world beyond our perception

Imagine that the world is shades of gray and a little blurry, almost as if your lousy peripheral vision has taken over. This fuzzy field of view extends so far ... Read more »

Singer JJ Lin to hold two concerts next month

SINGAPORE – Fans of JJ Lin may want to take note. The homegrown Mandopop star will be holding two concerts on Nov 27 and Nov 28 this year, he announced ... Read more »

Netflix pushes back against Squid Game-juiced usage fees in South Korea

SK Broadband is suing Netflix to claim fees for using its network. SEOUL (BLOOMBERG) – Netflix is pushing back against a South Korean Internet provider’s demand that it pay to ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin was aiming at camera when gun discharged - affidavit

SANTA FE, NEW MEXICO (REUTERS) – American actor Alec Baldwin was drawing a revolver across his body and pointing it at a camera during rehearsal on the set of Rust ... Read more »

Friends actor James Michael Tyler dies of cancer at 59

LOS ANGELES (AFP) – American actor James Michael Tyler, who played coffee shop manager Gunther on the hit sitcom Friends (1994 to 2004), died on Sunday (Oct 24) at age ... Read more »

Breaking gender stereotypes in toys Outdated expectations still influence what boys and girls are allowed to play with which stifles creative expression

People attend a rally in support of the Netflix transgender employee walkout in Los Angeles, California. Photo: Reuters TOY STORIES Imagine yourself standing in front of a toy shelf in ... Read more »

Expo invites all coffee lovers to join

The expo will feature new coffee technology from around the world. FABB Academy of Coffee Coffee lovers can't miss this. The “FABB Coffee Fair 2021” will kick off this Thursday ... Read more »

Welcoming Chinese EVs

GWM (Great Wall Motor) is the new kid on the block in Thailand's automotive scene. The Ora Good Cat 2022 is GWM's latest 100% electric vehicle (EV), which is being ... Read more »

Hold on to your heart: Oktoberfest returns

The campaign brings Bavarian and German products and food items. Tops Thailand To mark the famous Oktoberfest of Bavaria in Germany, Tops and Central Food Hall are holding “Bavarian Oktoberfest: ... Read more »

A kinder, gentler TT Audi's iconic coupe may have softened its looks, but the roadster still packs a punch at a hefty price

The TT has long represented Audi in the sports roadster segment with both soft- and hardtop variants being offered by the German luxury carmaker. Our ride this week comes from ... Read more »

A plea for tradition

When was the last time we went to a movie theatre? While most cinemas have reopened following months of pandemic-forced closures, I doubt moviegoers are ready to return en masse. ... Read more »

Paying a heavy price Although new tax structures to curb smoking have caused the cost of cigarettes to rise, some experts warn it could have unintended consequences

Smokers are now paying higher prices for their nicotine cravings after retailers and convenience stores made adjustments last week after the introduction of a controversial new excise tax structure earlier ... Read more »

Woman found dead in burning car near Baltimore's Leakin Park on Sunday morning was shot, police say

Woman found dead in burning car near Baltimore’s Leakin Park on Sunday morning was shot, police say Baltimore Police are investigating the killing of a woman whose body was found ... Read more »

Ed Sheeran says he has tested positive for Covid-19

Ed Sheeran would be cancelling public appearances and working at home, in quarantine. LONDON (NYTIMES) – British singer Ed Sheeran announced Sunday (Oct 24) that he had tested positive for ... Read more »

UK defence minister faces call for inquiry into 2012 killing of Kenyan woman

The UK defence secretary, Ben Wallace, is facing calls to launch an investigation into a possible cover-up after no one was held responsible for the alleged killing of a 21-year ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic