Dutch mass case against pharmaceutical company Allergan because of dangerous breast implants

Asia's Tech News Daily

Dutch mass case against pharmaceutical company Allergan because of dangerous breast implants

litigate American style. The Bureau Clara Wichmann foundation is sending pharmaceutical company Allergan this week a notice of liability on behalf of many tens of thousands of Dutch women with breast implants from this company. It will be the first product liability case to make use of the Mass Damages in Collective Action Settlement Act (Wamca), which came into effect last year. This law makes it easier to claim compensation on behalf of a large group of people.

Allergan is held liable for the defective so-called Biocell implants and the health risks that women run as a result. Bureau Clara Wichmann conducts proceedings in which women’s rights are central. It had already announced last summer that it wanted to tackle this matter.

The most far-reaching risk for women with the implants is a rare lymphoma, BIA-ALCL. At least seventy women in the Netherlands have this form of cancer. Two thirds of them have or had Biocell implants from Allergan.

In addition, many women with implants reported other complaints, such as headaches, fatigue and muscle pain. These are associated with breast implants, but scientists disagree.

It is estimated that 60,000 Dutch women have this type of Allergan implants. In recent years, regulators around the world have banned them from the market. They are no longer used in the Netherlands either.

Allergan, part of the American pharmaceutical company AbbVie, has been held liable for marketing a defective product. “As a woman, you are not going to tackle such a billion-dollar company on your own,” says Anniek de Ruijter of Bureau Clara Wichmann. “Certainly not when it comes to product liability, which is legally complex.”

Similar mass cases are underway in Great Britain and the United States. In Spain, the judge awarded a woman 38,000 euros last month because she had contracted lymphoma with Allergan implants.


The special thing about such a liability claim based on the Wamca is that Bureau Clara Wichmann acts on behalf of tens of thousands of women, without them having to do anything themselves. This is only possible with a non-profit organisation, such as a foundation or association, explains Jantina Hiemstra, lawyer of the Bureau. “And it shows that it is a suitable party to represent the victims.”

The call for this new legislation was fueled by a certain jealousy about the class action in the U.S. In the diesel scandal surrounding Volkswagen, for example, Americans were compensated much faster and easier with those cars. But parties such as the Consumers’ Association also wanted to be able to obtain compensation for a large group more easily in smaller cases.

Incidentally, cases have already been brought under the new legislation; against TikTok about violation of privacy, and against Airbnb about unjustly paid service costs. This is the first case involving product liability.

In the US, more than 80 percent of women diagnosed with BIA-ALCL had the Biocell implants last year. Supervisor FDA says the risk of this cancer with this type of Allergan implants is about six times higher than with other comparable breast implants. This is especially distressing for women who have opted for a radical step such as breast reconstruction with implants because they had breast cancer or an increased risk of it.

Still, women should not panic, says Mintsje de Boer, a plastic and reconstructive surgeon in training. She will be awarded a doctorate in December at Maastricht UMC for this lymph node cancer. “A breast implant greatly improves the quality of their lives for many women. That is why it is important that women with these implants know that the risk of this type of cancer is really very small.”

It is not entirely clear why women with breast prostheses can get this disease. “There are indications that women with a hereditary increased risk of breast cancer also have an increased risk of this cancer, but that relatively small study has not yet been confirmed by others,” says De Boer. “Other studies point to certain bacteria around the breast prosthesis. However, no firm conclusions can be drawn from these studies either.”

The Health Care Inspectorate advises women with these breast implants to check carefully whether their breasts are getting bigger or whether a lump develops. With a prompt diagnosis of cancer, the prospects for survival are good.

Insufficient research

For many years, Allergan was one of the largest producers of breast implants. In 2017, it invested 350 million euros in it. A year later, the sales ban came for Europe, in 2019 for the US. The US regulator wrote to Allergan that it had failed to adequately investigate the risks of the implants. In 2020, the company was bought by pharmaceutical giant AbbVie for 55 billion euros.

Allergan offers women with cancer a meager compensation, according to De Ruijter. “For example, we have contact with a woman who could no longer work because of lymphoma. She was offered 6,000 euros. She would also have to pay for the surgery to remove the implants. And she was never allowed to hold Allergan liable again. That is far too little. Yet some women have signed such contracts.”

Bureau Clara Wichmann is now demanding 10,000 euros for women who have not become ill, because of the health risks they run. With that, they can pay for an implant replacement surgery if they want to. For women who have developed lymphoma, the foundation wants at least 60,000 euros in compensation.

Approval of medical devices, which officially includes implants, is different from that of medicines. “Medications are looked at very closely: there are studies with large numbers of patients,” says De Ruijter. “Medical devices are approved by private companies. Once a CE mark has been obtained for a product, it can be marketed anywhere in Europe.”

A well-known example are the PIP breast implants from the French Poly Implant Prothèse. They were filled with industrial rather than medical grade silicone. Thousands of women worldwide were victims of this. The German company that approved the implants was held liable by the French judge and had to pay compensation.

In 2010, the French regulator recalled the implants and PIP was liquidated. Its boss was jailed for four years in 2013.

Dutch mass case against pharmaceutical company Allergan because of dangerous breast implants
Source link Dutch mass case against pharmaceutical company Allergan because of dangerous breast implants

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Co-working firm Awfis plans to double office centres to 200 this year

Homegrown co-working space provider Awfis plans to double to 200 its office centres by adding another 60,000 seats by the end of 2022, founder and CEO Amit Ramani said on ... Read more »

What do rising bond yields to signal to the markets?

A note on the data: Interest rates on personal loans for all listed (BSE) public and private sector banks have been considered for data compilation. Banks for which data is ... Read more »

Burberry forecasts 35 per cent surge in annual profit as luxury fashion brands bounce back from pandemic

Burberry Group predicted a 35 per cent jump in profit for the current financial year, driven by a surge of online sales as luxury brands recovered from the pandemic. The ... Read more »

Budget 2022 expectations: Education sector seeks tax concession, low cost loans and expansion of 80C deductions

“For two years, the education sector is struggling in various ways. While the public institutions are looking for more budget allocations, private sector players in higher education need low-cost loans,” ... Read more »

Refrain from publishing paid news, violating RP Act during elections: PCI to print media

Representative Image Ahead of the upcoming Assembly polls in five states, the Press Council of India (PCI) asked the print media on Wednesday to follow the norms of journalistic conduct ... Read more »

Helsinki Shipyard Oy to build new icebreaker for Norilsk Nickel

The icebreaker will operate in the Yenisei River basin, the Yenisei Bay and the Kara Sea Read more »

India's oil production continues to slip, down 2% in December

Representative image India’s production of crude oil, which is refined to produce petrol and diesel, continued to decline in December 2021, with lower output from state-owned ONGC leading to a ... Read more »

After pressure from investors, ExxonMobil also sets itself climate target for 2050: ‘net zero' emissions

ExxonMobil is also the last of the major international oil companies to set a climate target for 2050. The American oil and gas company announced this on Tuesday. ExxonMobil’s climate ... Read more »

Optum center stage at UnitedHealth in 2021, driving revenue

MINNETONKA, Minn. — UnitedHealth Group posted strong fourth-quarter earnings led by double-digit growth in its Optum division. The largest U.S. health insurer posted fourth quarter net income on Wednesday of ... Read more »

Bulgarian president takes oath of office for second term

The Associated PressBulgaria’s President Rumen Radev arrives for an EU Summit at the European Council building in Brussels, Thursday, Dec. 16, 2021. European Union leaders meet for a one-day summit ... Read more »

BAM allowed to renovate famous building in London's Covent Garden

Photo: ANP Construction company BAM has been commissioned to carry out the redevelopment of the Space House in the London district of Covent Garden. Real estate company Seaforth has a ... Read more »

COVID-19 update | WHO counts 18 million virus cases last week as omicron slows

Representative image The number of new coronavirus cases globally rose by 20% last week to more than 18 million, marking a slowdown in the surge caused by the omicron variant’s ... Read more »

Delaying Nord Stream 2 hurts Europe's economic development, warns Kremlin

The construction of Nord Stream 2 was fully completed on September 10, 2021 Read more »

Taking Stock | Market ends lower for the second day; Sensex dives 656 points, Nifty below 18,000

The market continued to see profit-booking for the second consecutive day, with benchmark Sensex and Nifty falling a percent each on January 19 on weak global cues and high crude ... Read more »

Diginoor.io, offering actor Rajinikanth's movie NFT, raises $1 million from Polygon, Kunal Shah

From left to right: Shaamil Karim, co-founder, Diginoor along with co-founder, Yash Rathod. Image: Diginoor. NFT marketplace, Diginoor launched with non-fungible tokens of south superstar Rajinikanth’s movies today announced $1 ... Read more »

Turkey announces launch of air service with Armenia starting February 2

On January 10, the Armenian Civil Aviation Committee gave its okay to operating the Yerevan-Istanbul-Yerevan route Read more »

IEA: tighter oil market due to limited impact omikron on oil demand

Photo: ANP The tightness in the global oil markets is greater than expected because the rapid advance of the omikron variant has had surprisingly little impact on the demand for ... Read more »

Cabinet sanctions Rs 973 crore to SBI for ex-gratia payment to borrowers

Representative image The government on Wednesday approved sanction of Rs 973.74 crore to State Bank of India (SBI) as reimbursement related to loan moratorium that was implemented in 2020 amid ... Read more »

CIABC urges govt to gradually reduce customs duties on British alcoholic beverages under proposed FTA

Representative image The apex body for liquor firms Confederation of Indian Alcoholic Beverage Companies has urged the government to gradually reduce customs duties on British alcoholic beverages under the proposed ... Read more »

Moldova offers paying January debt to Gazprom in stages, says Deputy PM Spinu

The actual risk of gas supplies being cut off exists, he also noted Read more »

'Wage-inflation spiral' warning

Read more »

Hitachi Energy bags order worth Rs 160 crore to support electrification of rail routes

Representative image Hitachi Energy India on Wednesday said it has bagged orders of over Rs 160 crore to provide key electric components to support the electrification of rail routes in ... Read more »

Luxury fashion and jewelry more popular than before corona

Last Christmas, Richemont even experienced its strongest sales spurt in at least ten years. Shortly after the outbreak of the pandemic, even fewer of his products were sold. Sales of ... Read more »

The Dutch Data Protection Authority does not have to act against Google

Photo: ANP The Dutch Data Protection Authority (AP) does not have to investigate Google itself. This was determined by the judge in a case brought by the Consumers’ Association. He ... Read more »

Tata Steel Q3 PAT seen up 155% YoY to Rs. 9,676 cr: ICICI Direct

Tata Steel now takes a more prudent approach to its capital allocation strategy. ICICI Direct has come out with its third quarter (October-December’ 21) earnings estimates for the Metals & Mining sector. The ... Read more »

Jindal Stainless Hisar Q3 PAT seen up 78% YoY to Rs. 482 cr: ICICI Direct

A JSLL Infra Stainless bench at the tourist information centre in Delhi. ICICI Direct has come out with its third quarter (October-December’ 21) earnings estimates for the Metals & Mining sector. The brokerage ... Read more »

SAIL Q3 PAT seen up 66% YoY to Rs. 2,125 cr: ICICI Direct

(Image: PTI) ICICI Direct has come out with its third quarter (October-December’ 21) earnings estimates for the Metals & Mining sector. The brokerage house expects SAIL to report net profit at Rs.2,125 crore up ... Read more »

Ratnamani Metals and Tube Q3 PAT seen up 64% YoY to Rs. 99 cr: ICICI Direct

ICICI Direct has come out with its third quarter (October-December’ 21) earnings estimates for the Metals & Mining sector. The brokerage house expects Ratnamani Metals and Tube to report net profit at Rs.99 ... Read more »

Graphite India Q3 PAT seen up 668% YoY to Rs. 177 cr: ICICI Direct

Graphite India  | In FY21 so far, the stock has risen 137 percent to Rs 301.05 as on January 25, 2021, from Rs 127.10 as on March 31, 2020. MFs increased their holding in each quarter of the ... Read more »

Moneycontrol Pro Panorama | Red-hot yield: What can calm the markets' nerves?

Dear Reader, The Panorama newsletter is sent to Moneycontrol Pro subscribers on market days. It offers easy access to stories published on Moneycontrol Pro and gives a little extra by ... Read more »

Paytm shares close record low; ends below Rs 1,000 for first time since listing

Paytm operator One 97 Communications Shares of Paytm owner One97 Communications Ltd on January 19 ended at a record low with shares closing below Rs 1,000 a piece for the ... Read more »

Jindal Stainless Q3 PAT seen up 140% YoY to Rs. 408 cr: ICICI Direct

Jindal Stainless (Hisar) | India Ratings assigned A/RWE to company’s credit facilities. ICICI Direct has come out with its third quarter (October-December’ 21) earnings estimates for the Metals & Mining sector. The brokerage ... Read more »

Luxury fashion and Cartier jewelry more popular than before corona

Photo: ANP Clothing and jewelry from luxury brands have become quite popular again in the past year. The Swiss , known for fashion from the Chloé brand and jewelry from ... Read more »

Behind the scenes - Why BharatPe's board decided Ashneer Grover had to take leave of absence and what it really means

Ashneer Grover, co-founder and managing director, BharatPe Ashneer Grover, co-founder and managing director of the $3 billion valued fintech BharatPe said he has taken a voluntary leave of absence till ... Read more »

Premium auto dealership chain Landmark files papers for Rs 762 crore IPO

Representative image Automobile dealership chain Landmark Cars Ltd has filed preliminary prospectus with capital markets regulator Sebi to raise Rs 762 crore through an initial public offering. The public issue ... Read more »

Dileep Sanghani elected as IFFCO chairman

IFFCO. (PC-Shutterstock) Dileep Sanghani has been elected as chairman of the Indian Farmers Fertiliser Cooperative (IFFCO). The election was held on Wednesday, IFFCO said in a statement. These elections were ... Read more »

Wetherspoons says Downing Street 'partygate' staff should have been allowed to go to the pub instead

The pub chain, led by Brexiteer and once -prominent Boris Johnson supporter Tim Martin, confirmed that it will report a half-year loss after Plan B restrictions hit trading over the Christmas period. Read more »

India's third COVID-19 wave likely to peak on January 23, daily cases to stay below 4 lakh: IIT Kanpur scientist

The third wave of the COVID-19 pandemic in India may peak on January 23 with daily cases likely to remain below the four lakh mark, according to a scientist at ... Read more »

NSE largest derivatives exchange for third consecutive year

National Stock Exchange(NSE) is  world’s largest derivatives exchange for 3rd consecutive year in 2021 in terms of number of contracts traded, according to the Futures Industry Association (FIA). In addition, ... Read more »

IndiGo says some flights to and from Delhi cancelled due to Republic Day curbs

Representative image Private carrier IndiGo on January 19 said some of its flights to and from Delhi have been cancelled due to Republic Day-related curbs. The airline has asked passengers ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic