Dunedin man pleads not guilty to rape charges

local police station

A Dunedin 21-year-old allegedly raped two women at the same Orientation Week party, a court has heard.

Samuel Leigh Ebdell is on trial before the High Court at Dunedin after pleading not guilty to three counts of sexual violation by unlawful sexual connection and two of rape.

His defence, counsel Sarah Saunderson-Warner said, was simple: he did not commit the offences with which he had been charged.

The first complainant told the court she was drinking with friends at a Castle St party, in the city’s student sector, on February 17 last year.

In a video interview with police she gave a couple of weeks later, the woman said she bumped into Ebdell, whom she knew through friends, after using the toilet.

The two allegedly kissed before he invited her to join him outside.

“I gave consent at the beginning,” the complainant told police.

However, she said things quickly took a dark turn.

“It began to hurt when he was being a bit too rough with me … I kind of told him I didn’t like it,” she said.

Rather than stop, Ebdell tried to convince her she was enjoying it, the woman said.

“I know you love it. Just let me do it,” he allegedly said.

The woman told police she had been sexually abused when she was younger and the incident sharply triggered memories from her past.

She said she was scared and when she tried to get away, the violation would be become “10 times harder”.

“There was also a little bit of choking, started off soft but then he tightened his grip a little. I would move his hands so I could breathe,” the complainant said.

She told the court she had used the word “no” repeatedly but it had no effect on Ebdell.

“He was different. I had never seen that side of him, personally, so it was scary for me,” the woman said.

The incident ended when another man walked into the area, but she said it was not the only violation she was subjected to that night.

She told police she went to check on Ebdell when he was “throwing up his guts” on the couch.

He allegedly responded by violating her.

The next day, she said, she found bruises on her breast and hips and when she discovered her friend was making disclosures of sexual abuse she told her story.

The defendant allegedly sent her messages on Snapchat apologising for his conduct but they had automatically deleted after 24 hours, she told police.

“I don’t want him to get away with what he’s done,” the complainant said at the end of her interview.

Under cross-examination, the woman said she had had consensual sex with Ebdell in the months leading up to the night in question.

Saunderson-Warner suggested the pair had simply kissed and the sexual allegations were a fabrication, prompting the witness to break down in tears.

“No,” she said.

The woman accepted she had continued dancing and socialising after the alleged violations occurred, and did not inform police or Campus Watch officers who were patrolling the area.

Crown prosecutor Chris Bernhardt said it was alleged Ebdell later went on to rape another woman the same night, witnessed by the first complainant.

She was so intoxicated, he said, that there was no way she could have consented.

Saunderson-Warner urged the jury of six men and six women not to be swayed by hearing evidence of partying which they might find distasteful.

“You’re not here to judge that culture, you’re here to judge the individual charges,” she said.

The trial, before Justice Gerald Nation, is scheduled to conclude before the end of the week.


If it’s an emergency and you feel that you or someone else is at risk, call 111.
If you’ve ever experienced sexual assault or abuse and need to talk to someone contact the Safe to Talk confidential crisis helpline on:
• Text 4334 and they will respond
• Email support@safetotalk.nz
• Visit https://safetotalk.nz/contact-us/ for an online chat
Alternatively contact your local police station – click here for a list.
If you have been abused, remember it’s not your fault.

News Related


Timaru fatal crash: Family, friends remember 'sweet, funny, cool' teens killed

Family and friends of five teenage boys killed in a horrifying crash in Timaru last night are reeling from gravity of the tragedy but are paying tribute to the young ... Read more »

Timaru crash: Five dead, injured driver stable - all local teenage boys

Police have confirmed five young men were killed in a crash near Timaru last night. Aoraki Area Commander Inspector Dave Gaskin spoke to media from Timaru Police Station this morning ... Read more »

Five dead in Timaru crash: All were young local boys

Police have confirmed five young men were killed in a crash near Timaru last night. Aoraki Area Commander Inspector Dave Gaskin spoke to media from Timaru Police Station this morning ... Read more »

Weather: Highways closed as snow falls in South, may lower to sea level

Snow is falling on a number of alpine passes and more is on the way, possibly to as low as sea level in some parts. Metservice is forecasting a rapidly ... Read more »

Weather: Snow could dust South Island cities white this weekend

Snow is set to fall on the South Island this weekend and the freezing weather could even dust Christchurch and Dunedin white, a forecaster says. Snow is expected to settle ... Read more »

Wild weather warning: Rain, 'gusty gales' to sweep the country

Keep your winter woollies and brollies close New Zealand, wet weather and gusty gales are forecast to sweep through the country this weekend. Metservice meteorologist Angus Hines warned people to ... Read more »

Scott Base Hotel: Is Antarctica New Zealand building a luxury polar lodge?

As New Zealand prepares to build its new Scott Base in Antarctica, you’d be forgiven for mistaking it for a high-end polar lodge. The dramatic, wing-like structures to be built ... Read more »

ACC: Auckland records most skiing and snowboarding injuries this year

Auckland has had the highest number of claims for skiing and snowboarding injuries of any region in the country his year. Data from ACC released to the Herald shows $11.9 ... Read more »

Person arrested, two in hospital after serious incident in Ohoka

Two people have been taken to hospital and one person has been arrested after a serious incident in Ohoka, north of Christchurch. Emergency services were called to a property on ... Read more »

Covid 19 coronavirus: Infected mariners in Southland moved to community quarantine

Two crew members from the Mattina container ship who have Covid-19 are quarantining in a monitored facility in the community after being treated at Southland Hospital. Another crew member, the ... Read more »

Covid 19 coronavirus: Infected mariners moved to community quarantine in Southland

Two crew members from the Mattina container ship who have Covid-19 are quarantining in a monitored facility in the community after being treated at Southland Hospital. Another crew member, the ... Read more »

Woman suffers nine cracked ribs after Cardrona chairlift fall

By Tim Brown, RNZ An Auckland woman is facing a months-long recovery after dropping six metres from a chairlift at Cardrona Alpine Resort on Tuesday. Janette Adams said she slipped ... Read more »

Christchurch mosque car bomb threats: Man who denies making threats loses name suppression bid

A man who denies threatening to car bomb two Christchurch mosques on the March 15 terror attack anniversary has today lost his bid for continued name suppression. However, the 27-year-old ... Read more »

US billionaire Peter Thiel's Queenstown house going for just over $6 million

Just over $6 million could buy you one of Queenstown Hill’s most famous houses. The ‘plasma house’, named for its 15-metre wide landscape window, has just been listed with Auckland’s ... Read more »

Three resign from West Coast Conservation Board over Ngai Tahu conflict

In a shock move today, three members of the West Coast Conservation Board have resigned saying they have been called racist for raising what they see as conflicts between the ... Read more »

Icy blast to bring snowfall across New Zealand, thunderstorms, gales lash Auckland north

Thunderstorms are set to rumble across the North Island today before damaging gales blast the top half, and snow falls to low levels across central and southern New Zealand. An ... Read more »

Wheelchair user rides skateboard down central Queenstown street

A wheelchair user has stunned residents in central Queenstown after being seen riding a motorised skateboard through the city. Captured on video, the wheelchair appears to have been strapped sideways ... Read more »

Christchurch murder: Niraj Prasad denies killing Faiz Ali and will stand trial next year

An accountant accused of murdering his ex-wife’s partner in central Christchurch will stand trial next year. Niraj Prasad, 38, is accused of killing Faiz Ali, a manager at Indian grocery ... Read more »

School bus driver charged with assault of Central Otago child

A 78-year-old man is facing charges of assault in relation to a June incident on a Central Otago school bus. A police spokeswoman yesterday said the man had been charged ... Read more »

Fire on boat in central Queenstown, nearby cars damaged

A boat has been severely damaged after a suspicious fire in central Queenstown last night. Emergency services were called to the fire on Gorge Rd at about 7pm on Thursday. ... Read more »

'Ruined my life': Otago woman 'disgusted' rapist granted parole

WARNING: Distressing content A rape victim says she wishes she had never made the complaint after her abuser got parole at his first hearing. William Andrew Laidler, 24, was jailed ... Read more »

Weather: Chances of snowfall in south and north looking pretty good says Metservice

Snow is on the cards for much of the country this weekend, with Metservice saying the chances are “pretty good”. A low-pressure system is on its way from the Tasman ... Read more »

Christchurch stadium row: Decision to reduce capacity to be revisited at council meeting next week

A controversial decision by Christchurch City Council to reduce the number of seats at the city’s new covered stadium will be revisited at a council meeting next week. Christchurch Mayor ... Read more »

Intensive winter grazing improves but not all councils have data on its use

By Susan Murray of RNZ. Intensive winter grazing practices have improved but more effort needs to go into compliance and monitoring activities by regional councils, a new report has found. ... Read more »

Weather: Low-level snow on the cards across the country

Forecasters are predicting a “significant cold break” could bring a fresh dumping of snow across the country with both the South and North Islands in the firing line. MetService says ... Read more »

Covid 19 coronavirus: Canterbury retiree referred by online booking service to vaccination centre in Missouri, USA

A retiree who tried to book his Covid-19 vaccination online was stunned to be informed that the nearest available centre was in the United States, around 13,000km away. Peter Farrant, ... Read more »

Fears remnants of former quarry is seeping into Christchurch water supplies

Fears are escalating water pooling in a signed-off rehabilitated quarry could be leaching into Christchurch’s groundwater. The Christchurch City Council is investigating following allegations water on the former Dunns-Winstone Aggregates ... Read more »

One killed in crash in Dunedin

A person has been killed in a crash on State Highway 88 in Dunedin last night. Police said the crash involved one car which crashed into a barrier barrier on ... Read more »

High-security prisoners protest against move from Christchurch to Otago

High-security prisoners have staged two protests against plans to move them from Christchurch to Otago Corrections Facility. A plan to move about 80 high-security prisoners from Christchurch Men’s Prison to ... Read more »

Ex-wife left to clean Christchurch stroke patient's clothing

A pensioner is mounting up huge laundry bills for an ex-husband in the stroke ward at Christchurch’s Burwood Hospital. Dianne Burke spends $42 double-washing the heavily soiled clothes at a ... Read more »

Fresh dumping: Low-level snow on the cards across the country

Another dumping of snow is on the cards across the country with both the South and North Islands in the firing line. Forecaster WeatherWatch says the warmer weather many have ... Read more »

Tricky moove: Cow craned to safety after bizarre farm accident

Firefighters in Canterbury went to an unusual rescue after a cow got trapped in the centre of a milking platform. Fire crews from Dunsandel and Burnham were called to help ... Read more »

'Science of bull****': National MP Stuart Smith alleges climate change cover-up

National Party MP Stuart Smith has described a Government climate change plan as the “science of bull****” during a talk in Ashburton this week. The Kaikōura MP floated suggestions that ... Read more »

Himalayan Descent Challenge to raise funds for Covid-struck Nepal

Mountaineers and alpinists are known for their uphill struggles, but that is only half the battle. Throughout August some of New Zealand’s top outdoor enthusiasts have signed up to cover ... Read more »

Dog caught killing sheep on camera in Dunedin

Police are investigating after at least three sheep were killed by a border collie. Senior Sergeant Craig Dinnissen said an unknown border collie was caught on camera worrying sheep at ... Read more »

Gloriavale man admits raft of sex offences against children

A man from the Gloriavale Christian community has admitted a raft of charges relating to the alleged sexual abuse of children. The 55-year-old appeared in the Greymouth District Court this ... Read more »

West Coast man admits raft of sex offences against children

A West Coast man has admitted a raft of charges relating to the alleged sexual abuse of children. The 55-year-old appeared in the Greymouth District Court this morning via audio ... Read more »

Christchurch-based New Zealand Health Food Company fined $377,000 over 'reckless' royal jelly labelling

A Christchurch-based health supplements company has been fined $377,000 after “reckless” marketing suggested royal jelly products came from New Zealand, when in fact they were sourced in China. New Zealand ... Read more »

Dunedin Hospital ED staff take legal action demanding urgent improvements

Fears patients could die waiting for treatment in Dunedin Hospital’s beleaguered emergency department have prompted staff to take legal action demanding urgent improvement. Pressure of high patient numbers and low ... Read more »