Dune director claims MCU movies are all the same – and fans aren't happy

Dune director Denis Villeneuve has suggested that Marvel movies are “nothing more than a cut and paste of others”.

Almost two years after Martin Scorcese’s riposte that MCU films “aren’t cinema”, Villeneuve has added his two cents to the debate – and his response has angered sections of the Marvel fanbase.

Speaking to El Mundo (as first seen by The Direct), Villeneuve was asked for his thoughts on Marvel Studios’ multi-billion dollar franchise, and what impact it was having on the moviegoing experience.

  • How to watch the Marvel movies in order
  • These are the 30 best superhero movies of all-time
  • Dune: release date, trailer, cast, plot and more

“Perhaps the problem is that we are in front of too many Marvel movies that are nothing more than a ‘cut and paste’ of others,” Villeneuve replied. “Perhaps these types of movies have turned us into zombies a bit… But big and expensive movies of great value there are many today. I don’t feel capable of being pessimistic at all [about the future of other big movie productions].”

The Arrival and Blade Runner 2049 director’s comments didn’t stop there. In a separate interview with French publication Premiere (as reported by IndieWire), Villeneuve appeared to double down on his earlier quotes.

Responding to another Marvel movie question, Villeneuve said: “If we’re talking about Marvel, the thing is, all these films are made from the same mold. Some filmmakers can add a little color to it, but they’re all cast in the same factory. It doesn’t take anything away from the movies, but they are formatted.”


Analysis: is MCU fan criticism of Villeneuve’s comments over the top?

(Image credit: Chiabella James/Warner Bros.)

Suffice to say, Marvel fans have reacted angrily to Villeneuve’s comments.

Sections of the MCU fanbase have suggested that Villeneuve’s quotes are ironic, with some saying that Dune is another example of the film industry’s current penchant for movie remakes.

Didn’t he direct Dune?In 2021?Wasnt that a movie in…Oh I don’t know…1984.So…Tell me more about cut and paste please.I’m listening. pic.twitter.com/dRO6G2UmE7September 16, 2021

See more

Meanwhile, others claimed that Villeneuve’s decision to criticize the MCU was solely with the intention of generating interest in Dune ahead of its release next month:

“Oh shit, my movie isn’t generating a lot of talk, how can I get more attention… OH I KNOW HOW”September 16, 2021

See more

Marvel fans weren’t the only ones who slammed Villeneuve for his responses, either. Doctor Strange director Scott Derrickson retweeted his response to Scorcese’s 2019 comments about the MCU, before suggesting that anyone criticizing Marvel films “shouldn’t assume they’re all the same”.

time to retweet this https://t.co/oQ0q2Jovn5September 16, 2021

See more

Not everyone was totally against Villeneuve’s quotes, though. Some fans, including those who enjoy MCU movies, argued that it was okay to dislike Marvel films, while others hit out at those interviewing Villeneuve over their attempts to create discourse online.

I’m going to bet the interviewer was trying to get Villeneuve to say something controversial about the MCU to get clicks. Villeneuve’s opinion isn’t something to get angry about, I might disagree mostly with it but I can sort of understand where he’s coming from.September 16, 2021

See more

So, is criticism of Villeneuve (and his comments) valid? In a sense, yes. Fans are passionate about things that they like, so Marvel fanatics are sure to defend the movie series if they feel it’s regularly been attacked by those involved in the filmmaking business.

However, the vilification of Villeneuve is excessive. The Dune director is clearly more reserved than Scorcese in what he says and, at one point, he does note that Marvel Studios’ formula for moviemaking isn’t actually a bad thing; he just doesn’t agree with how Marvel goes about crafting its superhero flicks.

Scorcese and Villeneuve aren’t the only directors to hit out at how superhero movies are made, either. James Gunn, who has helmed both of Marvel’s Guardians of the Galaxy films and Warner Bros’ The Suicide Squad, has claimed that superhero flicks have become “boring” to watch.

Is Gunn deserving of a free pass from Marvel fans, or comic book film fanatics generally, just because he’s been involved in the production of them? Not really. In our view, his criticisms are just as valid as Villeneuve’s, regardless of the fact that Gunn has earned the proverbial t-shirt for his work in this genre.

Whether it’s through new technologies or blending genres together in ways that haven’t been done before, movies need to constantly evolve to prevent the industry from stagnating.

And that, in our opinion, is where Villeneuve is coming from. Marvel movies do tend to stick a basic developmental formula – there’s always a climactic, CGI-laden third act battle, for example – and, while that’s been hugely successful, it’s something that Villeneuve doesn’t necessarily agree with. In that sense, his criticisms are valid, even if diehard Marvel fans won’t agree with them.

  • Marvel’s Eternals: everything we know so far
Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

The Neptunes Get in the Studio With A$AP Rocky, Chloe Bailey, Adam Levine & More: See Photos

Pharrell Williams Known for wearing many hats, Pharrell Williams’ producer cap is the one he started out in. The 48-year-old artist has long been a visible figure in pop culture, ... Read more »

Everything you ever wanted to know to help you get on American Ninja Warrior

Angelou Deign is a familiar face around the set of American Ninja Warrior. She probably knows every single competing Ninja by name, and probably a bunch of other details about ... Read more »

Intel CEO: My job is to win Apple back

Intel CEO Pat Gelsinger says the ball is in the chip giant's court to win back lost business from the Mac making Apple. “My job is to win them [Apple] ... Read more »

Dennis Weening furious: ‘Some bastard hit our sweet cat'

The presenter does not hide his anger. “Some bastard just hit our sweet cat and just drove on,” he writes on Instagram. “She is dead.” Not much later Dennis, who ... Read more »

Facebook whistleblower tells UK lawmakers until 'incentives change,' the company won't

Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen, weeks after testifying before Congress, on Monday delivered to members of the British Parliament a similar message : The social network giant has cultivated a platform ... Read more »

Jeffrey Wright calls Balwin prop gun incident 'a mismanaged set'

Jeffrey Wright, who stars on “Westworld” and will appear in the upcoming “The Batman” film, reacts to Alec Baldwin shooting a prop gun which killed “Rust” director of photography Halyna ... Read more »

Jennifer Aniston, Courteney Cox pay tribute to Friends co-star James Michael Tyler

Jennifer Aniston and Courteney Cox have led tributes to their late Friends co-star James Michael Tyler. The 59-year-old actor, who famously played Gunther in the sitcom classic, died peacefully at ... Read more »

Closing the gap between understanding climate change and fixing it

In an interview with Yahoo Finance’s Rick Newman, Katharine Hayhoe The Nature Conservancy Chief Scientist & Christian Braneon NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies Columbia University Climate School discuss how ... Read more »

AirPods 3 review: Apple ups its sound game with the third-gen earbuds

Take one look at the new design of the third-gen AirPods ($179, £169, AU$279) and the first thing you’ll probably think is: “Those look like the AirPods Pro without ear tips.” ... Read more »

Brendan Fraser books DC Comics blockbuster on comeback trail

Brendan Fraser scored his next role in DC Comics‘ “Batgirl” film. Evan Agostini/Invision/AP Call him the comeback kid. Brendan Fraser has just scored his next major film role. The 52-year-old ... Read more »

Giovanni Pernice denies ‘wrongdoing' after reported split from Maura Higgins

Strictly Come Dancing star Giovanni Pernice has denied that “wrongdoing” led to his recent breakup following his reported split from Maura Higgins. The professional dancer was reported to have split ... Read more »

Scotty McCreery coming to Sioux Falls

SIOUX FALLS, S.D. (Dakota News Now) – Country music artist Scotty McCreery is coming to Sioux Falls next year. © Provided by Sioux Falls(Mitchell) KSFY Scotty McCreery’s ‘Same Truck Tour’ ... Read more »

Bow Wow Confirms He's A Father Of Two, Refutes Past Tweet About Son

© Charley Gallay/Getty Images for Disney Bow Wow confirms that he is the father of a one-year-old named Stone Kamin. The rapper first revealed he had a son last September ... Read more »

Ex-Bangor band director who ‘used trust and admiration to violate' student gets up to two years in prison

A former Bangor Area High School band director who used a student’s trust and admiration to groom and sexually assault her for more than a year was sentenced Monday to ... Read more »

Country stars Jake Owen, Chase Rice, Brothers Osborne to perform in Orlando for K92.3 All Star Jam

Central Florida can soon experience a star-studded lineup of country musicians all under one roof as the 26th annual K92.3 All Star Jam comes to Orlando later this year. Florida ... Read more »

Giselle of aespa Apologizes for Lip-Syncing Racial Slur

Aespa Giselle of the K-pop girl group aespa has issued an apology via Twitter for mouthing a racial slur in a YouTube video featuring the group. On Saturday, the group’s agency, ... Read more »

Shiloh Jolie-Pitt's Yellow Leopard Sneakers Make Headlines - Here's Where They're From

Angelina Jolie may be dropping jaws left and right, wearing beautiful gowns by Atelier Versace, Balmain, and Ralph Lauren on the Eternals red carpets, but her daughters are making sustainable ... Read more »

Judi Love says 'Strictly' fitness is helping her cope with COVID

Judi Love says her Strictly fitness is helping her fight COVID. (BBC/Guy Levy) Judi Love has said she is thankful for having got fit through training for Strictly Come Dancing ... Read more »

J Balvín apologizes for music video depicting Black women as dogs

Colombian pop star J Balvín is apologizing for the controversial music video for his song “Perra” that was labeled “racist” and “misogynistic” toward Black women, USA Today reported. © Getty ... Read more »

Round Hill's Josh Gruss Talks Publishing Boom, Rock's Steadiness & How James Brown Beats Drake

Josh Gruss This week, Round Hill Music co-founder/CEO Josh Gruss will take two weeks off from running one of the more important new competitors in the music publishing business, but not for ... Read more »

Facebook Warns Production Company Behind TV Adaptation of ‘An Ugly Truth' With Firm Legal Letter

© Foy: Maarten De Boer/Variety A buzzy TV series based on the book “An Ugly Truth: Inside Facebook’s Battle for Domination” is currently in the works — but the social ... Read more »

Drake Gifted Rolls-Royce He Used to Rent to 'Keep Up Appearances': 'Manifestation Complete'

As a Grammy-winning artist, world-famous rapper, and all-around musical legend, it’s hard to imagine that there was once a time when Drake couldn’t afford to live in the lap of ... Read more »

What to Eat and Drink at Outside Lands 2021

© Betsy Newman After a year off due to the pandemic, Outside Lands comes roaring back to San Francisco’s Golden Gate Park this Friday, October 29 through Sunday, October 31. ... Read more »

Katy Perry Gets Cozy in Athleisure and ‘Ugly' Sandals for Gap's New Holiday Campaign

© Courtesy of Gap KPerryGap Katy Perry cozied up in comfy footwear for Gap’s new holiday campaign, “All Together Now,” which launched on her birthday today. The musician and UNICEF ambassador ... Read more »

Gwen Stefani Brings Back This Disputed 2000s Trend in a Plaid Skirt & Printed Leggings

© MEGA gwen-stefani-skirt-leggings-vegas Gwen Stefani is back and better than ever. The “Hollaback Girl” singer returned to the stage in Las Vegas this weekend for her new residency, performing in ... Read more »

Hard Rock Casino Cincinnati announces Pete Rose, Tucker Barnhart for grand opening

© Hard Rock – Hard Rock Casino Cincinnati officials announced additional plans for the casino’s official grand opening. Pete Rose, former Cincinnati Reds player and manager, will be placing the ... Read more »

So it turns out the MacBook Pro's M1 Max isn't a gaming chip, does it matter?

The M1 Max was announced, along with the new MacBook Pro computers, about a week ago. I was pretty impressed by it on paper, but now performance information is starting ... Read more »

Cabaret awards for Sara Kroos and Alex Klaasen

Since the VSCD Cabaret Awards were not awarded last year due to the corona crisis, performances that premiered in both the 2019/2020 and 2020-2021 seasons were now eligible. Sara Kroos ... Read more »

S.F. pandemic battle: Restaurants playing music outside, and the neighbors who hate it

Music was central to the experience of eating at the Señor Sisig and Vegan Mob food trucks parked in a vacant lot at Valencia and 18th streets in San Francisco ... Read more »

Shop the Allswell Friends and Family sale for dreamy discounts on luxury mattresses and more

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. While the holidays may be the most wonderful time of the ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin's wife Hilaria breaks silence on shooting tragedy

Hilaria Baldwin, the wife of Alec Baldwin, has broken her silence on her husband’s fatal on-set shooting of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins. Hilaria has been silent on social media as families ... Read more »

Sara Kroos and Alex Klaasen win Poelifinario

Sara Kroos and Alex Klaasen each won a Poelifinario on Monday evening. The winners of the most important Dutch cabaret prize were announced in Diligentia in The Hague. Kroos won ... Read more »

The best city building games to rule the urban jungle

The best city building games give you power. Like, a lot of power. All the power, sometimes. And, depending on your own sensibilities, sometimes too much power. Which is to ... Read more »

Oakley vs. 3M: How does a $100+ and a $10 pair of safety glasses compare?

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. A good pair of safety glasses is one of the most ... Read more »

The Weeknd cancels 2022 tour including Cleveland date, promises ‘something bigger'

CLEVELAND, Ohio — The Weeknd has scrapped his 2022 tour plans, instead promising a stadium tour announcement. The canceled tour includes a date at Cleveland’s Rocket Mortgage FieldHouse that was ... Read more »

The ghosts of the Suntan Art Center in St. Pete Beach

The Suntan Art Center in St. Pete Beach is full of creative energy, with classes and exhibits featuring works by local artists. But a paranormal energy also exists at its ... Read more »

Brandi Carlile shares dates for ‘Beyond These Silent Days' 2022 tour

A new album, an appearance on Saturday Night Live, and a full-fledged tour. October hasn’t been a bad month for Brandi Carlile. © Provided by Audacy BRandi Carlile Carlile has ... Read more »

10 things to do with kids in November in the Tampa Bay area

As the weather cools, there are lots of family-friendly options for outings with the kids in November. © Luis Santana/Tampa Bay Times/Times Professor Charles McGraw Grow speaks about his new ... Read more »

Troye Sivan talks 'Angel Baby' and his proudest accomplishment as an artist

Troye Sivan’s latest single, “Angel Baby,” is a song dedicated to celebrating queerness and fantasy, but the prideful song isn’t the only “Angel Baby” in Troye’s life. The Australian-born singer ... Read more »

A$AP Rocky's Debut Mixtape ‘Live. Love. A$AP' Is Finally Heading to Streaming

© FilmMagic for Life is Beautiful Music & Art Festival A$AP Rocky’s debut mixtape Live. Love. A$AP is heading to streaming services for the first time on October 29th to ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic