Driver, not Honolulu police, is at fault for teen's injuries, city alleges

Asia's Tech News Daily

Oct. 16—Court documents filed by city attorneys Friday argue that Honolulu police are not responsible for an alleged high-speed pursuit on the Leeward Coast that left a 14-year-old boy paralyzed, countering that the driver of the car that crashed is to blame for the tragedy.

The city's response to the filed by the teen's parents does not contain any details or mention of the incident, nor does it name the Honolulu Police Department or the officers involved.

Dennis and Ualani Gouveia are suing HPD and the city in connection with the Sept. 12 crash that left their son paralyzed from the waist down.

“The Plaintiffs or minor's injuries or damages are the result of the wrongful or negligent conduct of other individuals including but not limited to, the co-defendants Johnathon Sinapati and Brittany Miyake, ” wrote city Corporation Counsel Dana Viola and Deputy Corporation Counsel Derek Mayeshiro.

Sinapati, who remains hospitalized, is the alleged driver, and Miyake is the registered owner of the car.

The Gouveias' attorney, Eric Seitz, claims that 15-year HPD veteran Joshua Nahulu, a patrol officer, had an ongoing feud with Sinapati. According to Seitz, Nahulu led two other patrol officers in a pursuit of the car Sinapati was driving after the three officers found him at an early morning party at Maili Beach Park.

After Nahulu, who was driving an HPD-subsidized SUV, and the two other officers, each with three years of service, saw Sinapati crash, they fled the scene without helping the victims, Seitz said. The trio reportedly pretended they didn't know what happened when a 911 dispatcher sent them to the scene of the crash, a ruse witnesses at the scene quickly dismissed, he said.

“The Complaint fails to state a claim against City upon which relief can be granted, ” wrote city attorneys.

The Gouveias' claims are “barred because the alleged injuries or damages, if any, were not the result of any act or omission by the City or its employees, but were due to the acts or omissions of others, and /or third parties over whom the City and its employees had no control, or by other superseding interventions outside of the City and its employees' control.”

Acting Honolulu Police Chief Rade Vanic did not respond to questions about the allegations against the officers or the response filed by city attorneys on behalf of HPD.

“The City gives notice that it may rely on the defense that employees (were ) acting outside the course and scope of employment, ” wrote Viola and Mayeshiro.

Seitz has said the 14-year-old boy randomly jumped into the vehicle with Sinapati after police arrived to break up the gathering and the people he went to the beach park with had left.

“I don't have any indication they (HPD ) are going to give us anything, ” Seitz said. “The kid is paralyzed in the hospital, and we need money to get him what he needs … and they don't care. I have no indication they have any concerns about the welfare of my client or his family.”

Surveillance video from three Leeward Coast businesses that was reviewed by the Honolulu Star-Advertiser appears to show the police vehicles chasing the car full of revelers shortly before it crashed. In the footage, the police vehicles do not have their blue lights on or flashing and are seen driving back in the opposite direction shortly after Sinapati's car crashed.

None of the footage acquired by Seitz so far shows the moment Sinapati's car left the roadway.

The official police description of the incident that was posted on HPD's website describes it as a “single-vehicle crash ” at about 3 :51 a.m. Sept. 12 and does not mention a high-speed chase of suspects who were allegedly violating park closure rules and other laws.

According to Honolulu Emergency Medical Serv ­ices, paramedics responded at 3 :47 a.m. to a report of a motor vehicle crash with six patients at 84-1092 Farring ­ton Highway.

EMS said the westbound vehicle was driving at an “unknown rate of speed … veered to the right and somehow lost control, causing (the ) car to roll over and land on its side ” in the yard of a home.

Although six people were injured, one of them had left the scene before ambulances arrived, the EMS report said. Four people were ejected from the vehicle.

Five of the injured were males ranging in age from 14 to 18, and the other was in his 30s.

“The three officers had their police powers removed following the incident, and the criminal and administrative investigations are ongoing, ” said Michelle Yu, HPD spokeswoman, in a statement to the Star-Advertiser.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Steve Cohen trying to replicate Dodgers' roster, reputation with Mets: Sherman

The old owner squeezed nickels despite running a huge-market franchise. The new owner told baseball operations to spend what is necessary to change not just the talent level, but perceptions ... Read more »

Three Omicron cases in UK & 225 more ‘likely' but new rules ‘won't ruin Christmas'

HEALTH chiefs last night confirmed a third case of the new Omicron Covid strain in the UK — amid fears there are already hundreds of others. More than 75 “probable” ... Read more »

More than 17 million have used buy now, pay later

© Getty Images More than 17 million UK customers have now used a buy now pay later (BNPL) company to make an online purchase, company data shows. The payment method ... Read more »

Letters: New restrictions show that Britain still hasn't learnt to live with Covid

People wearing face masks cross Westminster Bridge, with St Thomas’s hospital in the background – Getty SIR – The Prime Minister’s suggestion that travel restrictions are needed to “buy more ... Read more »

R20bn life extension of Koeberg power station poses significant risks for South Africa

Preparations are under way for the replacement of the six steam generators at Eskom’s 1,840MW Koeberg nuclear power station, in what South Africa’s national electricity utility says is the most ... Read more »

Celtic 2-1 Barcelona hailed as club's standout score of all time - but do you agree?'

Celtic 2 Barcelona 1, November 7, 2012 “This was one of the greatest nights in the club’s recent history. It is up there with anything I have done in my ... Read more »

Britain and Israel to sign trade and defence deal

Britain and Israel will sign a 10-year trade and defence pact in London on Monday, promising cooperation on issues such as cybersecurity and a joint commitment to prevent Iran from ... Read more »

BA suspends Hong Kong flights as crew reportedly taken to quarantine camp

© Getty Images BA said a member of staff tested positive on arrival in the region after testing negative before departure – Getty Images British Airways has suspended flights to ... Read more »

Coronavirus set to hammer foreign tourists' Christmas visits, warns industry

The number of overseas tourists to Britain in the run-up to Christmas is expected to plunge by three quarters compared with 2019, research reveals today. International visitor numbers are expected ... Read more »

Boris Johnson's 'disrespectful' Peppa Pig speech 'jeopardised foreign investment'

Boris Johnson’s “totally disrespectful” Peppa Pig speech to business chiefs may have jeopardised foreign investment in Britain, Labour has warned. Shadow Chancellor Rachel Reeves said “f*** business” – as the ... Read more »

Watch: Roy Keane and Jamie Carragher have heated Cristiano Ronaldo debate

© Alamy Stock Photo ROY KEANE and Jamie Carragher got into a heated debate during Sky Sports’ coverage of Chelsea-Man United today. The Corkonian was critical of the decision to ... Read more »

Omicron response should focus on global vaccine equity, not travel bans: scientists

As Canada confirms its first cases of the Omicron COVID-19 variant, scientists say banning travellers from southern African countries in an effort to curb its importation is wishful thinking that ... Read more »

Sadis, kanak-kanak 10 tahun dirogol, dibunuh, disumbat ke dalam guni selepas pulang mengaji. Kisah ini buat ramai sebak

Amaran: Kandungan artikel ini mungkin menganggu perasaan pembaca. KETAGIHAN pornografi atau menonton video lucah mampu mendorong seseorang melakukan sesuatu di luar batasan sehingga sanggup membunuh! Insan yang tidak berdosa termasuk ... Read more »

As Barbados heads toward a republic, some wonder why it matters

© Reuters/POOL COP26 in Glasgow By Julio-Cesar Chavez BRIDGETOWN (Reuters) – As Barbados prepares to form a republic and remove the British queen as its sovereign, some residents in the ... Read more »

Passenger from S Africa lands in Mumbai via Delhi, tests positive

© Provided by The Indian Express A 32-year-old resident of Dombivili in Mumbai, who arrived from South Africa via Delhi on November 24, tested positive upon arrival in the national ... Read more »

Prince of Wales to reaffirm ‘affection' for Barbados at republic ceremony

Charles and Camilla at Sandringham – Geoff Robinson The Prince of Wales is to “reaffirm” the “admiration and affection” between Barbados and Britain as he visits the Caribbean island to ... Read more »

Black Friday Isn't Over Yet — Almost Everything is Still 50% Off at Kate Spade's Blowout Black Friday Sale

© Ringo Chiu via AP. If there’s one designer brand that constantly takes our breath away with their uniquely adorable designs, it’s Kate Spade. We regularly find ourselves fighting the ... Read more »

The best things you can buy at the Lululemon Cyber Monday sale

© Reviewed / Lululemon The best things you can buy at the Lululemon Cyber Monday sale — Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links ... Read more »

Amazon Cyber Monday Deals: Shop 1 Carat Diamond Earrings Under $600

© Amazon Each product has been independently selected by our editorial team. We may receive commissions from some links to products on this page. Promotions are subject to availability and ... Read more »

Kim Kardashian & Pete Davidson Take Selfies With Dutch Tourist During Beverly Hills Outing

© etonline A trip to truly remember. During a visit to Beverly Hills, one Dutch tourist got a real thrill when he ran into Pete Davidson and Kim Kardashian. Paul ... Read more »

Stocks, oil regain some composure after Omicron battering

© Reuters/KIM KYUNG-HOON A man wearing a protective face mask amid the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) outbreak, looks at an electronic board displaying Japan’s Nikkei Index outside a brokerage in Tokyo ... Read more »

Later life UK mortgages decrease as stamp duty holiday ends

Lending to older borrowers, those aged over 70, was stable across the period due to them accessing the market primarily through products that are not related to house purchase. Photo: ... Read more »

Vaccine experts expected to give advice on expanding boosters to all adults

Millions more people could be offered booster jabs as advisers consider extending them to all adults under emergency measures to limit the spread of the Omicron variant. A decision from ... Read more »

Police: Officer in Maryland fatally shoots man with knife

GLEN BURNIE, Md. (AP) — A police officer in Maryland fatally shot a knife-wielding man and later found a woman dead inside the same home, authorities in Anne Arundel County ... Read more »

Charles to highlight UK bonds as Barbados becomes a republic

The Prince of Wales will highlight the shared goals and enduring bonds between Barbados and the UK during a ceremony marking the Caribbean country’s transition to a republic. Charles will ... Read more »

Woman attacks Spirit Airlines flight attendants, restrained by passenger with zip ties

A woman attacked two flight attendants on a Spirit Airlines flight to Nashville on Saturday night, was restrained by a fellow passenger, and then yelled at police officers to “shoot ... Read more »

JDT masih pilihan juara

KEINGINAN setiap pemain untuk muncul juara menjadi formula terbaik memacu Johor Darul Ta’zim (JDT) ketika berdepan Kuala Lumpur (KL) City FC pada aksi final Piala Malaysia di Stadium Nasional, Bukit ... Read more »

Manchester United, Chelsea sama gagah di London

© Provided by Sinar Harian MANCHESTER United mengetepikan prestasi tidak menentu saingan liga apabila mengecewakan pendahulu Liga Perdana Inggeris (EPL), Chelsea dengan keputusan seri 1-1 di Stamford Bridge pada Ahad ... Read more »

Venezuela President Maduro brands EU electoral observers 'spies'

© Reuters/LEONARDO FERNANDEZ VILORIA FILE PHOTO: Venezuela’s President Maduro speaks in Caracas By Mayela Armas CARACAS (Reuters) – Venezuela’s President Nicolas Maduro on Sunday denounced members of the European Union’s ... Read more »

OCTA: Philippine active COVID-19 cases to be halved if previous reports resolved

Some quarantine facilities in Pasig closing down with fewer COVID-19 cases The number of active COVID-19 cases in the Philippines is expected to be nearly halved once the classification of ... Read more »

Virgil Abloh passes away at 41; Priyanka Chopra, Karan Johar, Sonam Kapoor & others offer condolences

© Provided by Pinkvilla Sunday was a dark day in the fashion world as it was announced that Off White’s chief executive officer and founder Virgil Abloh passed away at ... Read more »

Clearlake Capital to buy Quest Software from Francisco Partners - WSJ

(Reuters) – Private equity firm Clearlake Capital has struck a deal to buy Quest Software Inc from Francisco Partners, valuing it at $5.4 billion including debt, the Wall Street Journal ... Read more »

Man arrested, charged with threatening Funky Murphy's staff with gun

WORCESTER — A Marlborough man was arrested early morning Sunday, after he allegedly threatened staff at a city bar with a gun when they refused him entry. Daniel Mercado, 23, ... Read more »

3 arrested, 1 sought in Ventura smoke shop holdup

Police arrested three and sought a fourth person after an apparent holdup and robbery of a Ventura smoke shop Saturday night, authorities said. The Ventura Police Department said two people ... Read more »

Black magic? Creepy display of mini-coffin stuck between two paper figures outside HDB, woman asks if it's a curse

© The Independent Singapore © The Independent Singapore Singapore — A Housing and Development Board (HDB) resident in Ang Mo Kio took to social media to question if her neighbour ... Read more »

Omicron: WHO skip a letter in the Greek alphabet in naming the new variant?

© The Independent Singapore © The Independent Singapore The long-awaited land travel reopening of Singapore starts tomorrow (Nov 29) at the Causeway with 1,440 bus passengers each way. At the ... Read more »

Kia EV6 Ramps-Up: Over 5,000 Were Delivered In October 2021

© InsideEVs Kia EV6 in UK The wholesale sales already reach a level of 7,000. Kia reports global car sales of 217,872 (down 18.9% year-over-year) in October. The decrease is ... Read more »

Man arrested in Cambridgeshire after man and woman stabbed to death in north London

A man has been arrested in Cambridgeshire hours after two people were been stabbed to death in north London. © Metropolitan Police Met Police found the man and woman dead ... Read more »

Ava White: Boy, 14, charged with murder of 12-year-old girl in Liverpool city centre

A teenager has been charged with the murder of a 12-year-old girl in Liverpool city centre, police have said. © PA POLICE20Liverpool202013503311.jpg Ava White had been in the city with ... Read more »

How to stream Xbox Game Pass games on iPhone and iPad

© Provided by GamePur Xbox Game Pass Ultimate members have the ability to stream games from the service onto supported devices. iPhones from the XS onward and all modern iPads ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic