Draconian border security doesn't work and costs lives. Why is Britain pushing it?

Asia's Tech News Daily

In the Calais museum to the second world war, housed in a former Nazi bunker in one of the town’s parks, there is a room dedicated to people smugglers. A giant map shows the routes by which members of the French resistance spirited Jews, stranded British soldiers and others out of German-controlled territory. The paths stretch from France into southern Europe and out over the Mediterranean – an echo of the dangerous journeys taken by many who seek to reach the UK without permission today.

Draconian border security doesn’t work and costs lives. Why is Britain pushing it?
© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Rafael Yaghobzadeh/AP

Smuggling people across borders is neither inherently good nor inherently evil. Those who do it can show a callous disregard for human life. Or they can be motivated by a desire to protect and nurture, like when Rob Lawrie, an army veteran who volunteered in the Calais refugee camp in 2015, hid a four-year-old Afghan girl in his van and tried to board a ferry to the UK. (Lawrie narrowly escaped a prison sentence but was found guilty in France of the lesser offence of endangering a child.) Very often, the “smugglers” are the people on the move themselves, helping one another out as they travel.

What such efforts have in common – from wartime heroics, to profit-making gangs, to acts of charity – is that they are responses to needs. When people feel compelled to move, they will look for ways to do so. If obstacles are placed in their way, the chances that they will turn to the services of smugglers, or attempt dangerous journeys under their own volition, will increase.

After last week’s disaster – the deadliest at the UK’s border with mainland Europe since 39 people were found dead in a lorry in Essex in October 2019 – the British government is under pressure to put an end to the Channel crossings. Its instinct is to reach for yet more border security: on 26 November, Boris Johnson proposed more patrols at sea, more electronic surveillance, more spying and harsher treatment of migrants who reach the UK. But the situation in the Channel is the clearest evidence we have of where an unrelenting focus on security leads us.

For more than two decades, successive governments have sought to discourage unwanted migrants, mostly people seeking asylum, from crossing the Channel. During the 1990s and early 2000s, Britain and France set up “juxtaposed” border controls, placing officials at transport hubs in each other’s countries, to stop people taking ferries and trains. When people stowed away on vehicles instead, Britain prevailed on France and its neighbours to increase security at ports and entry points. In 2014, for instance, the UK pledged £12m to help France build fences around the port of Calais to stop people breaking in. As these journeys became more difficult, the use of small boats became increasingly common from 2018, accelerating in 2020 as the pandemic shut down other travel options.

Draconian border security doesn’t work and costs lives. Why is Britain pushing it?
© Photograph: Rafael Yaghobzadeh/AP A camp in Calais, where migrants were waiting on 27 November for the chance to cross the Channel despite the death of 27 people in the same week.

We have known for years that border security has deadly consequences. Between 1999 and 2020, according to a report published by the Institute for Race Relations, just under 300 people lost their lives trying to cross to the UK. People have been hit by cars on the motorways of northern France, they have suffocated inside lorries or been electrocuted in the Channel tunnel, and they have drowned. But the shift to small boats is potentially far more dangerous: while market dynamics create an incentive for smugglers to cram people into unsafe boats, many more migrants are simply clubbing together to buy their own, as the UK’s National Crime Agency admits.

From the British government, you couldn’t find a response more likely to make the situation worse. Not only does it follow the security-focused trajectory of its predecessors, but this now comes wrapped up in Johnson’s toxic post-Brexit mode of engagement. Its diplomatic posturing has soured relations with France, which makes international cooperation more difficult. Some have noted the irony that Brexit actually seems to have given the UK less control of its borders – by leaving the EU’s common agreement on asylum at the end of 2020, for instance, the UK has lost the ability to return asylum seekers to other European countries they may have passed through. But by far the greater problem is the nationality and borders bill currently making its way through parliament.

The bill is an attempt to reshape policy around the Faragist lie that the country is at “breaking point” from unwanted immigration, by introducing a system that punishes asylum seekers who arrive in the UK of their own accord. This, Priti Patel has said, will encourage refugees to use official routes, ensuring that asylum is “based on need, not the ability to pay people smugglers”. Yet the government’s own assessment of the legislation accepts there is “a risk that increased security and deterrence could encourage [asylum seekers] to attempt riskier means of entering the UK” and that “evidence supporting the effectiveness of this approach is limited”.

Opponents of the bill argue – correctly – that the UK should instead expand safe routes to asylum, through official refugee resettlement schemes. Even where the government claims to want this, its efforts are sorely lacking: the much-vaunted Afghan citizens resettlement scheme has still not opened, more than three months after the Taliban seized Kabul. (On Thursday, just a day after the disaster in the Channel, a former Afghan soldier was among the passengers of a boat that arrived at Dungeness beach in Kent.) A concerted effort to encourage people to claim asylum by other means could undermine demand for smuggling routes. Safe facilities in northern France where people could stay and claim asylum in either country – or humanitarian visas that allow people to travel to the UK to make their claims – would reduce the need for people to attempt crossings.

Yet whether the response is authoritarian or liberal, a common mistake would be to think that there will be a “solution” to Channel crossings in the sense that one or other approach will make this issue disappear entirely. For as long as the UK wishes to maintain border controls there will be people who want to evade them. We can choose to mitigate the damage these controls cause or to ignore it. To go further than that, however, would require a more profound rethinking of our attitudes towards migration, and the way that the UK relates to the rest of the world.

Precious little is known so far about the 27 people who died on Wednesday. Yet what we do know already suggests they were not complete strangers to Britain. Maryam Nuri Mohamed Amin, a 24-year-old Kurdish student from northern Iraq, was trying to join her fiance here. Harem Pirot, 25 and from the same part of the world as Maryam, was trying to join his brother in Cambridge. Why did both see a deadly boat journey as their only option to follow these everyday family relationships? And what would it take for our society to see such international connections as these as a strength, rather than a threat?

After tragedies like the one last week, our political leaders say they want to stop smuggling. What they really mean is that they want to stop migrants. Those two things are not the same – and the gap between them is a matter of life and death.

  • Daniel Trilling is the author of Lights in the Distance: Exile and Refuge at the Borders of Europe and Bloody Nasty People: the Rise of Britain’s Far Right

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Britain's top five pies have been revealed — where does your favourite rank?

STEAK and kidney has been voted the UK’s favourite pie. It earned its crust as the nation’s top savoury filling, ahead of classic chicken and mushroom and beef and onion. ... Read more »

Arsenal fans can camouflage themselves on the Tube in new shirt inspired by seats

ARSENAL fans can now camouflage themselves on the train — in a new shirt inspired by seats. It features the bold pattern seen on the London Underground line that runs ... Read more »

Boris Johnson's aides accused of blackmail as targeted MPs urged to call cops

BORIS Johnson was last night rocked by sensational claims his aides “blackmailed” rebel MPs – as a top Tory urged those targeted to call the cops. In a bombshell intervention, ... Read more »

Parasite Director and Robert Pattinson Team Up for New Sci-Fi Thriller About Clones

© Provided by People getty (2) Robert Pattinson is teaming up with Parasite’s Oscar-winning director. Pattinson will star in the upcoming movie Mickey7, which will be written and directed by ... Read more »

Jurgen Klopp goes out of his way to double down on Gabriel Martinelli praise

Jurgen Klopp has doubled down on his praise of Arsenal’s Gabriel Martinelli. The Arsenal youngster is into his third season in England but has showcased his star quality on a ... Read more »

The best new motor for 2022 is electric: Kia's £41,000 EV6 trumps all petrol and diesel rivals to take What Car?'s Car of the Year award

Kia's EV6 is only the second electric vehicle to win the motoring awardWhat Car?s COTY gong has been handed out annually since 1978It is the first major automotive award ceremony of the year with 27 categoriesFind out which other models have been recommended by the judging panel  Read more »

Legendary music promoter's South Melbourne home that once hosted The Beatles in the '60s sells for an undisclosed sum

A South Melbourne terrace that once housed music icons The Beatles has sold just before Christmas. The 262 Albert Road home was previously owned by music promoter Kenn ‘Mr Showbiz’ ... Read more »

Austrian lawmakers back mandatory vaccination bill

© Getty Images Health Minister Wolfgang Mueckstein said the mandate was how the country would “escape the cycle of opening and closing, of lockdowns” Austria has moved closer to introducing ... Read more »

Ian Poulter credits playing son Luke for sharp start to Championship

Ian Poulter has found the perfect sparring partner as he bids to keep up with the young guns on the DP World Tour — his 17-year-old son Luke. An intense ... Read more »

Claudio Ranieri warns Norwich ‘cup final’ will not decide Watford’s season

© PA Wire Watford manager Claudio Ranieri says Friday’s match with Norwich is a ‘cup final’ (Owen Humphreys/PA) – PA Wire Watford manager Claudio Ranieri has described Friday’s meeting with ... Read more »

Dani Alves produced crazy bicycle kick to assist Pedri's 93rd minute equaliser vs Athletic Bilbao

© GiveMeSport Dani Alves produced a crazy bicycle kick to assist Pedri Barcelona travelled to Athletic Bilbao for their Copa del Rey last-16 tie on Thursday evening. Barca got off ... Read more »

Chris Mueller watch: How new boy fared on Hibs debut

© Chris Mueller impressed on his Hibs debut Starting in a new-look forward line with Christian Doidge and fellow debutant Ewan Henderson, the 25-year-old looked likely in the early exchanges, ... Read more »

Francis Ngannou would rather fight Tyson Fury than Jon Jones after UFC 270

Francis Ngannou admits he would rather box heavyweight champion Tyson Fury next and not face UFC star Jon Jones. Ngannou makes the first defence of his UFC heavyweight title this ... Read more »

Soccer-Algeria out as group phase ends with more shocks

© Reuters/THAIER AL-SUDANI Africa Cup of Nations – Group E – Ivory Coast v Algeria By Mark Gleeson (Reuters) – The Ivory Coast dumped defending champions Algeria out of the ... Read more »

'Nothing beats it' Martin Lewis urges Britons to try and get the 'best form of savings'

On tonight’s episode of the Martin Lewis Money Show, Nigel called in asking the money saving expert if people have to be on Universal Credit for the duration of the ... Read more »

Video: 'Why did they make her get up at 4.30 just to announce her exit?' Devastated Apprentice fans react to Shama Amin leaving due to ill health - as Navid is fired following chaotic drinks task

Read more »

'I'm so sorry but my show ain't ready': Adele sobs as she POSTPONES Las Vegas residency because COVID cases among crew members have caused preparation chaos 

Adele shocked her fans on Thursday when she revealed in a tearful video that she had been forced to postpone her massively popular upcoming Las Vegas residency. In a video ... Read more »

Sotomayor Calls Texas Anti-Abortion Case ‘A Disaster for the Rule of Law,’ Accuses Fifth Circuit of ‘Egregious Distortion’ of Recent Supreme Court Decision

© Provided by Law & Crime Justice Sonia Sotomayor appears in a file photo. The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday refused to issue a writ of mandamus — a legal ... Read more »

Video: 'I'm so sorry but my show ain't ready': Adele sobs as she POSTPONES Las Vegas residency because COVID cases among crew members have caused preparation chaos 

Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: Cops who found Charlise Mutten's body inside a barrel 'weighed down with sand so it would sink in a river' are too traumatised to return to work

Body of nine-year-old Charlise was found near Colo River in the Blue MountainsHer remains had been placed in a barrel with sand and left near the river bankPolice who attended the scene on Tuesday afternoon described it as horrific  Justin Stein, 31, has been charged with Charlise's murder and remains in custodyStein's barrister asked he be separated from other prisoners while on remand  Read more »

Prince William comforts grieving boy who lost his mother

The Duke of Cambridge has sympathised with a grieving schoolboy during a visit to a centre helping vulnerable people, telling him things will get ‘easier’. Prince William, 39, who lost ... Read more »

Robin Goodfellow's Racing Tips: Best bets for Friday, January 21

Sportsmail’s racing expert Robin Goodfellow dishes out his tips for Friday’s meetings at Lingfield, Market Rasen, Southwell and Newcastle.    Sportsmail’s racing expert Robin Goodfellow dishes out his tips for Friday’s meetings ... Read more »

Video: Cardi B is called an 'angel' by family member of tragic Bronx apartment fire victims after announcing she'll cover funeral costs: 'My family cannot thank you enough for what you've done'

Read more »

Last-gasp Leicester win worth so much more than three points to Spurs, says Pierre-Emile Hojbjerg

Tottenham midfielder Pierre-Emile Hojbjerg believes Wednesday’s last-gasp win at Leicester will give his side more than just three points. © PA Wire Tottenham won their match at Leicester in dramatic ... Read more »

3G Networks Ruin Your Car’s Tech

Yay for progress or something… Automakers really love technology and they claim consumers do as well. That might be true, but with the switching off of 3G networks in preparation ... Read more »

Diogo Jota earns new song as deadly Liverpool partnership emerges at Arsenal

Diogo Jota must wish he can play Arsenal every week. Having netted in all three Premier League meetings against the Gunners since arriving at Liverpool in September 2020, the Portuguese ... Read more »

Golden State Warriors vs. Indiana Pacers NBA betting odds, lines, trends

The Golden State Warriors (32-12) are heavily favored (by 11.5 points) to extend a three-game home win streak when they host the Indiana Pacers (16-29) on Thursday, January 20, 2022 ... Read more »

Biden's decline may have severe consequences for US, world: GERAGHTY

On Thursday, President Joe Biden and his administration frantically walked back an incredibly dangerous blunder that he made less than 24 hours ago. Sitting behind a desk and reading from ... Read more »

Police ask for help to find missing mum and baby son last seen at Trafalgar Square

A mother and her baby son missing from Hertfordshire were last seen together in Central London this afternoon. Laura, from Waltham Cross, was last seen at 2.30pm today (Thursday January ... Read more »

Jurgen Klopp labels Gabriel Martinelli as ‘outstanding' as Liverpool punish Arsenal

© Arsenal FC via Getty Images GabrielMartinelli2001B Liverpool boss Jurgen Klopp picked out Arsenal forward Gabriel Martinelli for praise despite the Gunners’ defeat in Thursday’s Carabao Cup semi-final, calling the ... Read more »

Michelle Dockery to marry Fleabag star Phoebe Waller-Bridge's brother

It’s been six years since the death of her fiance. Now Downton Abbey star, Michelle Dockery appears to have healed her broken heart – and revealed her engagement to Phoebe ... Read more »

Mikel Arteta's response to Thomas Partey red card just hours after flying back from AFCON

Thomas Partey endured a miserable Arsenal comeback after jetting back from Cameroon just 48 hours after Ghana were dumped out of the Africa Cup of Nations. The midfielder was not ... Read more »

Celebs Go Dating's Abz Love gobsmacked over 90s throwback snap with Anna Williamson

Abz Love was left gobsmacked on Thursday’s Celebs Go Dating as Anna Williamson surprised him with a 90s throwback snap of them pictured together. During the latest instalment, Anna, 40, ... Read more »

Jake Tapper Grills Jen Psaki Harder Than Fox News Did

© Provided by The Daily Beast CNN CNN anchor Jake Tapper on Thursday repeatedly confronted White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki over President Joe Biden’s voting-rights comments during the day ... Read more »

Bowman arrested during voting rights protest at Capitol

© Greg Nash Rep. Jamaal Bowman (D-N.Y.) addresses reporters during a press conference on Wednesday, December 8, 2021 about a resolution condemning Rep. Lauren Boebert’s (R-Colo.) use of Islamaphobic rhetoric and ... Read more »

Tottenham captain Hugo Lloris agrees a new two-year contract with the club

© PA Hugo Lloris. SPURS CAPTAIN HUGO Lloris has agreed a new contract at the club. The France goalkeeper’s existing deal was due to expire in the summer, but he ... Read more »

Manchester United players told how they should 'shut up' and follow Cristiano Ronaldo

Louis Saha has questioned the attitudes of the Manchester United players and their desire to be a “winner” like Cristiano Ronaldo. United’s returned to winning ways against Brentford after being ... Read more »

Twitter is rolling out verified NFT profile pictures

© Adobe Stock Twitter on Thursday began rolling out a feature that will let some users set NFTs that they own as their profile picture to signal their investment in ... Read more »

US Fed kicks off debate on issuing its own digital currency with new white paper

© DANIEL SLIM The US Federal Reserve seen in Washington DC. AFP Creating an official digital version of the US dollar could give Americans more, and speedier, payment options, but ... Read more »

Bulls star Lonzo Ball out at least 6 weeks due to knee surgery

The Chicago Bulls will be without Lonzo Ball for the foreseeable future. Ball opted to have arthroscopic surgery on his left knee, and will miss up to eight weeks recovering, ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic