DR MAX PEMBERTON: Sorry, but vouchers that bribe people to lose weight won't work

Asia's Tech News Daily

Obesity epidemic costs every person in the UK an extra £409 in taxes annuallyA new scheme is being trialed in Wolverhampton for making healthy choices Dr Max says people must recognise long-term health benefits for lasting change 

As a nation, we really are nowhere near as healthy as we could be. The UK is the second fattest country in Europe, after Malta. And one study estimated that the obesity epidemic costs every person in the UK an extra £409 in taxes annually. That’s unacceptable — something simply has to be done.

But what? Despite millions of pounds being spent on public health campaigns, we still seem to be stuck on the couch, shovelling fast food into our mouths without an apparent care in the world.

We clearly need a different approach. Enter a new scheme being trialled in Wolverhampton whereby residents are given incentives, such as free cinema tickets, shopping vouchers and theme park entry, for making healthy living choices.

The coupons — which some have termed ‘sloucher vouchers’ — will be given out to lazy locals who boost their exercise levels and improve their diet.

A new scheme being trialled in Wolverhampton involves residents being given incentives, such as free cinema tickets, shopping vouchers and theme park entry for making healthy living choices (file image)

A new scheme being trialled in Wolverhampton involves residents being given incentives, such as free cinema tickets, shopping vouchers and theme park entry for making healthy living choices (file image)

They’ll be given a fitness tracker linked to an app that will monitor things like step count and the amount of fruit and vegetables they consume.

The £3 million trial is part of a £100 million package of government measures to tackle obesity which, with related diseases, is estimated to cost the NHS an enormous £6 billion a year.

It’s going to run for six months and then may be rolled out across the country.

I’m going to admit to feeling rather conflicted by this. On the one hand I understand that the ‘nudge’ approach of gently encouraging people to make lifestyle changes by offering incentives often, in the long run, saves money.

The improvements made can mean money is saved on costly treatments linked to an unhealthy way of living — prevention being better (and cheaper) than cure.

The idea of incentivising people in this way isn’t actually new. I remember once, when working in a drug rehabilitation clinic, being involved in a study looking at infections in drug users.

It was an uphill struggle because no one volunteered.

After several months of trying and failing to recruit patients to assist, the study suddenly became a success. This was down to one simple thing: money.

Given the importance of the research, it had finally been decided that a financial incentive of a few pounds should be offered to encourage people to participate. Once this had been introduced, the uptake of testing shot up from only a handful of volunteers to nearly every patient I saw.

Dr Max Pemberton (pictured) says for lasting change people must themselves recognise the long-term benefits to their health, rather than be doing it for a night at the cinema courtesy of the taxpayer

Dr Max Pemberton (pictured) says for lasting change people must themselves recognise the long-term benefits to their health, rather than be doing it for a night at the cinema courtesy of the taxpayer

At first I felt uneasy about this as it seemed like bribery. But I came to appreciate that it was a case of weighing up the ethics of financial coercion with the benefits to the greater good the research produced.

Ethically it was complex, but in practical terms the strategy worked, and for the initial investment of a few pounds per recruit, it provided a better understanding of where to direct resources and thus reduce waste.

But offering a benefit like cash to participate in a study is different to bribing people to live healthier lives.

For one, there’s evidence that suggests that, while people are initially keen, in the long term they soon get bored. In particular, those most at risk due to obesity or poor lifestyles are the ones most likely to resort back to their old ways.

Older drivers could avoid prosecution for careless driving under a scheme being considered across the UK. Over-70s who had been tested would avoid a fine and penalty points for offences like driving too slowly or jumping a light. This is a great idea. Older drivers tend to be incredibly safe. From working in A&E, the people I worry about getting behind the wheel are young men. 

The bribes seem less exciting, lose their novelty and appeal, and the effort that is required to get them soon tips the scales the other way.

For lasting change, people have to really want to change. They themselves must recognise the long-term benefits to their health, rather than be doing it for a night at the cinema courtesy of the taxpayer.

And this is another issue I have with schemes like this.

As a taxpayer, I rather resent my money being spent on things like shopping vouchers for other people to get them to do the things — like going to the gym or eating healthily — that I do anyway. It just seems inherently unfair.

Yes, I understand that in a socialised medical model like the NHS we all have to carry the burden of other people’s choices and therefore it’s in all our benefits to do what we can to get them to improve things.

But still, while it’s probably the right thing to at least try, the scheme rather sticks in the craw doesn’t it?

 

Therapy beats a boob job, Shirley

Dr Max said rarely do cosmetic procedures improve body confidence in the long term and certainly don’t fix the underlying problems in any relationship. Pictured: Shirley Ballas who had breast augmentation and liposuction in a bid to improve her self-esteem
Pictured: Shirley on the cover of Prima magazine

Dr Max said rarely do cosmetic procedures improve body confidence in the long term and certainly don’t fix the underlying problems in any relationship. Pictured: Shirley Ballas who had breast augmentation and liposuction in a bid to improve her self-esteem 

Strictly Come Dancing head judge Shirley Ballas has spoken candidly about the lengths she went to to save her marriage before realising she was ‘doing it for the wrong reasons’. As well as breast augmentation, she had liposuction to her arms and legs in a bid to improve her self-esteem. I feel for Shirley — I’ve seen so many women who have undergone similar invasive procedures under the misguided belief that it will help their relationship. The truth is these procedures rarely improve body confidence in the long term and certainly don’t fix the underlying problems in any relationship. When people ask my advice about cosmetic procedures, I always say the same thing: have psychotherapy for two years (which will cost far less) and work on your self-esteem. If after this you still want it done, do it with my blessing. So far, not a single person who has gone through the therapy has had surgery, but they have all felt much better about themselves — and their bodies.

 

Dr Max admits that he doesn't buy that a third of us are walking around with a mental illness once the dark nights set in. Pictured: Mick Jagger wearing 'sad  glasses'

Dr Max admits that he doesn’t buy that a third of us are walking around with a mental illness once the dark nights set in. Pictured: Mick Jagger wearing ‘sad  glasses’ 

  • Mick Jagger has been photographed wearing ‘sad glasses’. No, not glasses that are uncool — these are the latest fad for treating seasonal affective disorder (SAD), where the symptoms of depression are triggered by the onset of winter. While I’ve seen a few patients over the years who seem to have a seasonal variation to their depression, studies suggest one in three people suffer. Really? A third of us are walking around with a mental illness once the dark nights set in? I just don’t buy it. Feeling a bit down or miserable because it’s cold outside is not the same as being clinically depressed.
 

Dr Max prescribes…

Qigong for endometriosis

Often referred to as Chinese yoga, Qigong aims to help sleep, stress and energy levels. Research has shown that it can also relieve chronic pain from conditions including endometriosis — a common and painful condition where the lining of the womb grows outside the uterus. If you’re unfortunate enough to suffer from this, there’s an online two-hour Qigong session on wellbeing website kaylolife.com — part of the site’s ‘endo week’.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Aston Villa could beat Liverpool and Manchester United to surprise Man City transfer

Aston Villa have made an impressive start to the January transfer window and reports claims that their business is far from complete this month. Villa have managed to land Philippe ... Read more »

Free lateral flow Covid tests to be scrapped by JULY

Free Covid lateral flow tests will be scrapped from July under the Government’s virus ‘exit strategy’, according to documents sent between the UK’s health agencies.   Ministers have urged Britons to ... Read more »

Market Faces Key Test As ‘FAAMG' Earnings Loom Amid Tech Selloff

Wall Street’s fourth-quarter earnings season kicks into high gear this week, with investors bracing for a rocky reporting period amid worries over the Federal Reserve’s tightening plans. With the NASDAQ ... Read more »

US and UK agree to begin talks on removing steel tariffs

The United States has agreed to begin talks seeking to remove the tariffs on British steel and aluminium imposed by former president Donald Trump International Trade Secretary Anne-Marie Trevelyan said ... Read more »

The part the Evening News played in catching the Princes Street Gardens bomber

© Nikolaos Karvounakis was convicted of a terrorist offence at the High Court in Edinburgh on Wednesda… Sometimes, like the dawn phone call on the morning former Royal Bank of ... Read more »

UK 'needs to change immigration policies' to tackle Channel crossings, says Macron

Emmanuel Macron has called on the UK government to tackle migrant crossings in the Channel by creating “legal, safe routes” to Britain. © Associated Press Emmanuel Macron addressed the European ... Read more »

Tori Spelling and Dean McDermott are 'still attempting' to work on their marriage

© Bang Showbiz Tori Spelling and Dean McDermott are still trying to make their marriage work Tori Spelling and Dean McDermott are “still attempting” to work on their marriage, a ... Read more »

Radar clue in hunt for body of mother kidnapped in 1969

The family of a woman who died in a bungled kidnapping after being mistaken for Rupert Murdoch’s wife has used ground-penetrating radar to search for her body.  Muriel McKay’s killer, ... Read more »

Shortages of homes for sale are driving up prices, say surveyors

© PA Archive The report highlighted a lack of homes available to buy (Peter Byrne/PA) – PA Archive Shortages of homes available to buy are holding back sales and pushing ... Read more »

New-look Diamonds show fight in Quad Series and potential for sparkling future

Ahead of this week’s Quad Series in London, the onus on a new-look Diamonds team, who had played just a handful of Tests together, was to at least show some ... Read more »

England batter Phil Salt out to make more memories at Barbados’ Kensington Oval

© PA Archive Phil Salt spent much of his youth in Barbados (Nigel French/PA) – PA Archive Phil Salt admitted it would be “very special” to make his Twenty20 debut ... Read more »

Corrections and clarifications

• An article said that the artists Keith Piper and Eddie Chambers met in 1979 “while studying at what is now Wolverhampton School of Art”. The pair met at Lanchester ... Read more »

What is the BEST Shapes flavour? Aussies settle the debate once and for all - as Arnott's launches a tasty new contender

Arnott's have just launched a new flavour of Shapes in supermarkets across AusThe new Mini Bites Shapes in cheese and smoky bacon are packed full of flavour The all new Shapes flavour will be available to buy this month for just $3.20 eachThe new box will join the almighty Shapes flavour debate that's gone for years Read more »

Leading doctors' publication The BMJ slams Facebook for censoring

The editor of the British Medical Journal has slammed Facebook for ‘censoring’ its report into allegations of malpractice during Pfizer’s Covid vaccine trials.    Dr Kamran Abbasi accused the social media giant ... Read more »

‘In recent hours' - Newcastle now moving to sign 'tenacious' Carlos alternative; offer made

Newcastle United are reportedly now in talks to sign Benoit Badiashile in the January transfer window. © Provided by Transfer Tavern Wolves, Molineux, Premier League, Benoit Badiashile The Lowdown: Carlos ... Read more »

Sky reveal new "heavyweight" manager "under consideration" at EFC, fans surely livid - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Jose Mourinho Everton owner Farhad Moshiri is interested in a deal to appoint Jose Mourinho as the Toffees’ next manager. What’s the talk? That’s according ... Read more »

Republicans block voting rights protections from advancing – live

LIVE – Updated at 03:01 Read more »

Manchester United should not turn up nose at potential Pochettino and Ten Hag alternative

The pool is shallow but Manchester United still need to dive in headfirst. United are now on the hunt for their next permanent manager but it’s slim pickings at the ... Read more »

Patrick Roberts set for one last loan as a Man City player

Patrick Roberts is set for one last throw of the dice before leaving Manchester City in the summer. The winger, who is being strongly linked with one last loan move ... Read more »

"Would be a marquee signing": Journalist drops claim on 29 y/o amid key Newcastle update today

Journalist Liam Kennedy reckons that Jesse Lingard would be a marquee signing for Newcastle and represent “real progress” for the club. The Magpies have already added a high-profile signing to their ... Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: How a conwoman threatened to DESTROY the life of Vince Colosimo unless the Underbelly star handed over $50,000 - as he prepares to appear on Celebrity Apprentice Australia

Australian actor Vince Colosimo has become the victim of an opportunistic conwoman who threatened to ruin his career if he didn’t hand over $50,000.  Colosimo, who is best known for ... Read more »

Southampton enter pole position to sign ‘very exciting' player as reporter shares promising news

Speaking to Give Me Sport, journalist and ‘transfer insider’ Dean Jones of Eurosport has dropped an exciting update as Southampton eye Fulham attacker Fabio Carvalho. © Provided by Transfer Tavern ... Read more »

Don Goodman sends West Brom play-off warning as Daryl Dike arrives to aid attack

© Provided by Football League World Dike n Speaking to OLBG, Don Goodman has said that he feels West Bromwich Albion need to be looking over their shoulder in the ... Read more »

Lifting of all COVID rules in England announced - with self-isolation set to go in March

Work from home guidance, COVID passports and mandatory wearing of face masks are being scrapped in England, as Boris Johnson announced the lifting of Plan B measures. © Reuters Plan ... Read more »

Bengals' Trey Brown to get general manager interview with Raiders

While the Cincinnati Bengals are busy prepping for their showdown with the Tennessee Titans in the divisional round of the NFL playoffs, eliminated teams have an interest in poaching some ... Read more »

Cristiano Ronaldo 'holds showdown talks' with new Man Utd chief Richard Arnold

Manchester United’s incoming Chief Executive Richard Arnold has been handed a baptism of fire, with Cristiano Ronaldo reportedly demanding showdown talks. Ronaldo sent shockwaves through Old Trafford following an explosive ... Read more »

Chargers Scouting Report: Clemson CB Mario Goodrich

With the Senior Bowl less than a week away, we have begun our scouting process on identifying good fits for the Chargers from the upcoming class of NFL Draft prospects. ... Read more »

Chargers interview Giants special teams coordinator Thomas McGaughey

© Provided by Giants Wire MORE: Giants kick off in-person GM interviews with Joe Schoen Giants add to trenches in latest PFF mock draft Giants rolling over league’s least amount ... Read more »

Romelu Lukaku and Hakim Ziyech must now prove Thomas Tuchel right amid animated Chelsea incident

Things are far from perfect at Chelsea at the moment. The Blues’ draw with Brighton on Tuesday night means that they are still without a Premier League win since Boxing ... Read more »

Brian Daboll, Leslie Frazier focused on Bills postseason over interviews

Buffalo Bills coaches Brian Daboll and Leslie Frazier are hot commodities right now. With eight head coaching positions in the NFL open, both have already been linked to more than ... Read more »

NFL World Reacts To Wednesday’s Jimmy Garoppolo News

© Provided by The Spun Jimmy Garoppolo meets with the media at the Super Bowl. San Francisco 49ers quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo reportedly suffered a shoulder injury in the Wild Card ... Read more »

Eddie Hearn insists Tyson Fury vs Anthony Joshua will happen in late 2022 or early next year

Anthony Joshua and Tyson Fury will fight each other before the end of next year, according to Eddie Hearn. Joshua and Fury were locked in for an all-British showdown for ... Read more »

Kate Middleton wears £7 high street earrings for first appearance of 2022 with Prince William

The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge stepped out for their first joint appearance of 2022 on Wednesday (19 January) morning, as they paid a visit to the Foundling Museum in ... Read more »

Ex-Texans DE takes shot at 'circus' in Houston

© Troy Taormina-USA TODAY Sports One former Houston Texans player is letting us know how he really feels about his old team. San Francisco 49ers defensive end Charles Omenihu, who ... Read more »

Stetson Bennett announces he's returning to Georgia for sixth season

© Brett Davis-USA TODAY Sports Stetson Bennett heard the cries for one more year, and couldn’t help but say yes. Georgia’s championship-winning quarterback announced Wednesday he will return to school ... Read more »

Report: NHL to stop testing asymptomatic players after All-Star break

© Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports A view of a puck and the NHL logo. Similar to discussions had within the NFL and NBA, the NHL and NHL Players’ Association have ... Read more »

'They'll go after my children but not Hunter': Trump slams Democrats as January 6 committee and New York investigation close in on Eric, Don Jr and Ivanka

Trump responded to the latest developments in two probes on Wednesday He complained to reporters that investigators would not go after Biden's troubled Hunter but were intent on chasing down his ownA day earlier it emerged that House investigators had obtained phone records of Eric Trump and Kimberly Guilfoyle, Don Jr.'s fiancée And the New York attorney general is seeking to force Don Jr. and Ivanka to answer questions about the family business Read more »

Mystery as FBI agents descend on Rep. Henry Cuellar's mansion in an 'ongoing investigation': Texas Democrat who slammed Biden and Harris over border chaos says he will fully cooperate

FBI agents were seen photographing vehicles at Cuellar's home in LaredoBureau would only confirm it is conducting an 'ongoing investigation'Cuellar said in a statement that he will 'fully cooperate in any investigation'The nature of the investigation remains a mystery closely guarded by the FBICuellar is a Democrat who has harshly criticized Biden's border policiesHe has also called VP Kamala Harris ineffective in her role as 'border czar'  Read more »

Eleven-month-old baby sitting in a car is left in critical condition after being shot in the FACE by a stray bullet in the Bronx: New Mayor Eric Adams battles to deal with soaring violent crime in the Big Apple

The little girl, who will turn one on Friday, was sitting in a car with her 32-year-old mother in the Fordham Manor district of the BronxA male suspect further up the block started firing at another man around 6:45pm, and the baby was hit in the cheek - her mother was uninjuredThe baby was taken to St. Barnabas Hospital in critical but stable condition before being transferred to another area hospitalThe 52nd Precinct tweeted: 'Due to Police activity, please avoid the vicinity of East 198 Street between Bainbridge and Grand Concourse'Eric Adams, the mayor of New York, was elected on a campaign promise to reduce crime but it has risen in the first two weeks of his ruleIn the first two weeks of January there were 52 shootings, and 57 people injured - a 15.6 per cent rise on the 2021 statisticsPolice recorded counted 1,562 shootings across the five boroughs last year, 30 more than in 2020, with the Bronx accounting for 32 percent of shootings Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic