Dr Jacqueline Rowarth: Code Red and green solutions

International Panel for Climate Change (IPCC)

Opinion: When it comes to feeding the world in the face of climate change – solutions are offered, but what are the implications of those solutions, Dr Jacqueline Rowarth asks.

“Code Red for humanity” is an attention-grabbing headline. The official title from the International Panel for Climate Change (IPCC) is “AR6 Climate Change 2021: The Physical Science Basis”. It simply doesn’t have the same impact. But whatever the heading, the fundamental message is the same: action is required.

In response, the message from Greenpeace New Zealand was the same as every time there is a global or national report on climate or environment – ban synthetic nitrogen, reduce the number of cows and move to organic regenerative agriculture.

Greenpeace issued its statement in response to the IPCC report at 8.22pm on August 9.

The United Nations commented at 8.29pm, and RNZ was broadcasting headlines from 9pm.

Greenpeace was clearly poised to respond, and though the general direction was predictable, other organisations took more time to digest the content. And think about the implications.

It is important to acknowledge that Greenpeace’s three-pronged suggestion would work to decrease emissions if enacted globally. The decrease would not, however, be for the reasons believed.

1. Banning synthetic nitrogen would result in a marked reduction in food availability. Synthetic nitrogen has been estimated by Massachusetts Institute of Technology researchers to feed half the current global population.

2. Reducing cow numbers would reduce diet quality. Animal protein contains essential amino acids that are not provided by vegetable protein in the quantity required without consumption of excess calories and excretion of excess nitrogen (with its own GHG impact).

3. Regenerative organic agriculture cannot produce enough food for the global population, now or predicted – because it doesn’t use synthetic nitrogen. See point one.

In making the statements, Greenpeace NZ is focusing on New Zealand without apparently recognising that in a world of food shortage, we would not be isolated from the needs of other countries.

War is generally about scarce resources (and religion). Climate change, brought about by release of fossil fuel and the greenhouse gases (GHG) associated with modern living, is a global problem.

Most people recognise that it is population growth and lifestyle choices that are driving climate change. We want to be warm, eat good food, get about easily and have things.

Reducing animals, most of which graze on land unsuitable for anything but pasture or are fed waste from biofuel and alcohol distilleries, would increase the price of animal-based food globally, putting it beyond the reach of the people who need it for bones and muscle development.

International Panel for Climate Change (IPCC)

Dr Jacqueline Rowarth. Photo / Supplied

Dairy cows in New Zealand are particularly efficient, producing less than 0.04 per cent of the world’s GHG and provide the essential amino acids of approximately 1 per cent of the global population. They are fed high-quality pasture and managed for health and welfare.

A change to organic regenerative agriculture in New Zealand would increase the GHG footprint per kg of product.

This is because pasture quality cannot be maintained under long-grazing of a mixed herbal pasture – the research has been done.

The United Nations methane report suggested that improving feed quality to animals and improving the genetics of the animals themselves (their ability to turn forage into meat and milk) and increasing their longevity, would reduce their impact. New Zealand has been doing what is recommended for decades.

The big impact of a switch to regenerative organic agriculture is, however, the reduction in yield.

Globally yields from organic farms, whether regenerative or not, are less than 60 per cent of a conventional farm over a decade.

Listen to Jamie Mackay interview Dr Jacqueline Rowarth on The Country below:

The reduction isn’t apparent initially because nutrients are mineralised from the organic matter (OM) by micro-organisms. Carbon dioxide is released to the atmosphere from the OM and the OM content decreases unless manure (containing organic matter) is imported.

Not acknowledged is that the manure doesn’t always come from organic sources – it has involved synthetic nitrogen. This is termed green-laundering.

Plant-based protein has been offered as an alternative to animal protein, but leguminous crops such as soybeans require land.

They also require irrigation and agrichemicals including nitrogen fertiliser if the goal is high yields (minimising the amount of land needed for a certain quantity of food).

For those who think that cultured animal protein can fill the void, ponder this: The Good Food Institute (a group promoting cultured food) has calculated that to fill only 10 per cent of the world’s current meat market would require 4000 facilities each housing 130 bioreactor lines and vats (for fermentation) of a size that has not yet been developed.

The estimate of cost has reached US$1.8 trillion…

And overlooked appears to be the fact that the bioreactors are fuelled with sugar which comes from crops requiring land and agrichemicals including nitrogen.

Further, the GHG associated with cultured meat will last for very much longer in the atmosphere than the methane associated with animals.

Research by University of Oxford physicists has calculated that the effect of cultured meat is greater than that of efficiently managed animals.

There are no easy answers. Greenpeace’s solution for New Zealand would have unintended consequences for the world, just like the use of fossil fuel.

Dr Jacqueline Rowarth, Adjunct Professor Lincoln University, is a farmer-elected director of DairyNZ and Ravensdown. The analysis and conclusions above are her own. jsrowarth@gmail.com

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Focus: NZ Delta Outbreak | Wednesday 20th Oct Wrap

There were 60 new cases of COVID-19 in the community on Wednesday. Video / Alex Burton / Jed Bradley / Mark Mitchell / Dean Purcell Read more »

Covid 19 coronavirus: A Very Welly Christmas cancelled in 2021

The capital’s Christmas festival has been reined in for 2021 due to uncertainty around Covid-19. Wellington City Council announced on Wednesday this year’s A Very Welly Christmas festival would not ... Read more »

Matahui School, near Katikati, finds finance to stay open

Matahui School, south of Katikati has secured funding to continue to operate so students, staff and whānau can now look forward to a brighter future. In July the school announced ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: South Otago A and P Show to go ahead without public

Next month’s South Otago A&P Show will be conducted behind closed doors. South Otago A&P Society president Bridget Lowry said the show committee unanimously decided at a planning meeting last ... Read more »

Rugby star Sean Wainui car crash death: Givealittle page exceeds $82,000 after tragic death

More than $82,000 has been raised for rugby star Sean Wainui’s family after he died tragically in a car crash. Wainui, 25, was killed in a single-vehicle crash about 7.50am ... Read more »

The Country - Rural Sports Awards edition

Today on The Country, Jamie Mackay caught up with the Founder of the Norwood NZ Rural Sports Awards, Steve Hollander, to find out all about the big event for 2022. ... Read more »

Rugby star Sean Wainui car crash death: Givealittle page exceeds $70,000 after tragic death

More than $70,000 has been raised for rugby legend Sean Wainui’s family after he died tragically in a car crash. Wainui, 25, was killed in a single-vehicle crash about 7.50am ... Read more »

Heavy rain likely for Northland on Thursday

Northlanders should be prepared to batten down the hatches tomorrow with the MetService issuing a heavy rain watch for the region, with the Far North particularly likely to be hit. ... Read more »

Natalie Cooper: Don't be an unvaccinated, walking bio-weapon of a host

I clearly remember being at a London pub in February last year. We were jokingly passing around hand sanitiser thinking “pffft, another virus, doubt it will affect us as usual”. ... Read more »

Taco Bell will open new store on Wellington's Cuba St

Wellington will be the next New Zealand city to get its own Taco Bell, the Herald can confirm. A spokesperson for Restaurant Brands, which manages Pizza Hut, KFC, Carls Jnr ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: Southern mayors inspire farm gate vaccination drive

Planning is well underway with Gore Mayor Tracy Hicks and Southland Mayor Gary Tong for a “farm gate tour” of the deep South in early November to visit up to ... Read more »

Cemetery theft: Family at wits' end after offenders target them again

Thieves have struck again at Havelock North Cemetery, leaving a grieving family at their wits’ end. Headstones have been raided at the cemetery on at least four occasions in recent ... Read more »

Hawke's Bay Arts Festival now on at level 2

The 2021 Hawke’s Bay Arts Festival has officially begun and bucked the trend of major events being cancelled due to the Covid pandemic. Instead of the usual grand opening, a ... Read more »

Squash: Changing of the guard as Chris van der Salm wins Whanganui men's open title

The annual Whanganui Squash Club champs for 2021 finally ended last weekend, having started way back on August 17, the night before lockdown occurred. During the past two weeks, club ... Read more »

Police lose bid to seize Northland fraudster's KiwiSaver cash

An attempt by police to seize some of convicted Northland fraudster Joanne Harrison’s KiwiSaver funds has failed in the Court of Appeal. Harrison, who was jailed for defrauding the Ministry ... Read more »

Palmerston North High Flyers fire treated as suspicious

By Jimmy Ellingham of RNZ Emergency services are today continuing to investigate a fire in a landmark inner-city Palmerston North building. Emergency services rushed to the High Flyers building on ... Read more »

First We Eat: Line-up revealed for Bay of Plenty summer food festival

The line-up of “culinary stars” who will be cooking up a storm at a Bay of Plenty food festival this summer has been revealed. Held at the Tauranga and Wharepai ... Read more »

Little berries a big passion for South Canterbury organic black currant growers

A South Canterbury husband-and-wife team are squeezing every return they can out of an organic crop, writes the Otago Daily Times’ Tim Cronshaw. Trusting their instincts has paid off for ... Read more »

Changes to dairy product names likely needed for EU trade deal - Damien O'Connor

By Sally Murphy of RNZ. Trade Minister Damien O’Connor is back from a two-week trip to the US and EU and says good progress has been made on trade talks. ... Read more »

The Country - Bus edition

Today on The Country, Jamie Mackay found out why Jane Smith thought James Shaw had thrown Damien O’Connor under the climate change bus. On with the show: Jane Smith: The ... Read more »

Public health warning for Lake Rotorua after wastewater overflow

A public health warning is in place for Lake Rotorua following a wastewater overflow. Rotorua Lakes Council said in a social media statement the warning was in place near Arnold ... Read more »

Wellington City Council's sneak peek inside empty central library labelled 'depressing' and 'heart-breaking'

Wellington City Council’s “tour” inside its closed central library has saddened some of the community, who say they just want the building back. The library has been closed for more ... Read more »

Effluent discharge penalty part cancelled for Southland farmer

A Southland farmer has had part of his penalty cancelled after a dirty dairying incident five years ago. Klaas Waslander was found guilty of charges in relation to discharging dairy ... Read more »

Wellington lobby group taking airport to court over 'aggressive and unsustainable' planned expansion

A Wellington lobby group is taking the city’s airport to environment court for what it says is an “aggressive and unsustainable” expansion plan. The group, known as Guardian of the ... Read more »

On-site Covid-19 vaccine clinic for Rotorua Boys' High School community

A Covid-19 vaccination clinic will be held at Rotorua Boys’ High School this week in an effort to boost jab rates among students, staff and whānau in the community. School ... Read more »

Fine Art: Top Whanganui team recognised for Thank Your Cleaner Day

They are the good elves and fairies who often come in the night to leave workplaces and education centres sparkling clean. This week, commercial cleaning company OCS New Zealand will ... Read more »

NZ primary sector No 1 in KPMG's Net Zero Readiness Index

New Zealand’s agriculture, land use and forestry sector has been ranked No 1 for tackling climate change issues in a recently released global report. In its Net Zero Readiness Index ... Read more »

Traffic delays in Whanganui as Anzac Parade slip repair work begins

Whanganui drivers are asked to plan ahead for delays on Anzac Parade over the next four weeks. Waka Kotahi New Zealand Transport Agency has announced that contractors will be completing ... Read more »

Welcoming warmth after 'rough spring' at Munro Valley Farms

In an occasional series, Shawn McAvinue of the Otago Daily Times travels highways in Otago and Southland and when something catches his eye, he stops for a chat with the ... Read more »

Cricket: Wanganui Marist unbeaten on opening day of Coastal Challenge Cup Twenty20

The 2021-22 cricket season got under way on Saturday, with the first two rounds of the Coastal Challenge Twenty20 tournament. The Whanganui matches were played at Springvale Park and Whanganui ... Read more »

Mount Maunganui's Mauao base track to close on Wednesday

The Mauao base track will be closed from 7.30am to 12pm on October 20. The closure is to ensure public safety while Tauranga City Council prunes a damaged Pohutukawa tree ... Read more »

Rugby: Tributes flow for Chiefs and Māori All Blacks star Sean Wainui after tragic death

The rugby community is mourning the death of Sean Wainui after the 25-year-old died in a tragic car crash on Monday. The Chiefs, Bay of Plenty and Māori All Blacks ... Read more »

The 90% Project: Northland cracks 5000 doses in Super Saturday's final tally

The final number of vaccinations delivered in Northland on Super Saturday was a whopping 5115 – making it easily the region’s biggest vaccination day to date. Of those 2342 came ... Read more »

Pink sea: Algal blooms in Napier turn the water pink

Head to West Quay in Napier and you might see the water light up a shade of pink. On Monday, the water around West Quay was a shade of bright ... Read more »

T&G Global lowers full year profit expectations

Persistent labour shortages and rising shipping costs has forced produce grower and exporter T&G Global to lower its full-year profit expectations. The company is now forecasting earnings of between $4 ... Read more »

Southland farmer spends birthday docking lambs

Farmer Wilson Ronald celebrated his birthday docking sheep with his family in Western Southland earlier this month. The family docked some of the 1750 Texel Coopworth lambs on their 84ha ... Read more »

'Good for the soul' gardens on show in Dannevirke

For Lynne Mitchell gardening is a passion. Which is probably a good thing considering how much garden she has at her Umutaoroa Rd property. Known as Te Kiteroa Gardens, the ... Read more »

Plant proteins to 'meat' changing consumer demands

For many people, nothing beats the taste and texture of a big juicy burger, but how do you recreate that eating experience with sustainable plant-based protein? That is the culinary ... Read more »

The Country - Avocado edition

Today on The Country, Jamie Mackay caught up with NZ Avocado chief executive Jen Scoular to find out why the industry was going through one of its toughest seasons in ... Read more »

Warm and cloudy days in Whanganui region in lead-up to Labour Weekend

Strong winds have given way to warm and cloudy weather in the Whanganui region this week. Metservice meteorologist Peter Little said strong northerly wind gusts of 70km/h were recorded at ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic