Don't blame Rupert Murdoch or Nigel Farage – Ofcom is responsible for the demise of impartial news

© REUTERS FILE PHOTO: Murdoch takes part as a judge during a global start up showcase during the WSJDLive conference in Laguna Beach

He may be 90, god bless him, but Rupert Murdoch can still smell blood in the water. GB News, it is fair to say, is a bit of a wounded beast in the shark-infested waters of the British media, not waving to its few remaining viewers, but drowning. Having previously swam away from the territory, Murdoch now spies an opportunity.

He’s watched GB News make its mistakes, waited until its only serious asset, Andrew Neil, left and now he’s circling and is going to launch his own channel, talkTV, next Spring. He’s going to put it out on every available medium, including Freeview and the web, he’s going to back it with the full resources and advertising heft of his media empire, and he’s signed up Piers Morgan, the big fish that got away from GB News. Nigel Farage will be left croaking on his precarious raft, like one of the migrant dinghies in the English Channel he so loves to hate.

But the thing about talkTV is that it might actually work. It is being launched by a proper journalist; it will have proper journalists, including Morgan, as stars; it will feature proper news broadcasts and sport, entertainment and current affairs; and it will be much more like normal, responsible television than the grotesque paranoid mess that is GB News. That, though, might also be its weakness when it goes up against GB News, since GB News viewers aren’t much interested in that sort of stuff and seem to just want a constant diet of migrant hate, Covid conspiracy theories and anti-EU propaganda. There aren’t many of them, but they know what they like.

The rumours are that GB News is just going to keep doubling down on its extreme content. It’s already dominated by the personality of Nigel Farage, and it is being gradually packed by refugees from Ukip, The Brexit Party and Reform UK. Even now the GB News presenting mix is disproportionately full of old Farageist lags, such as Alex Phillips (former Brexit Party MEP), Michelle Dewberry (former Ukip and Brexit Party candidate for Westminster) and Liam Halligan (prominent Leave supporter). There are apparently plans to recruit Gawain Towler (former head of press to, erm, Nigel Farage), Martin Daubney (former Brexit party MEP) and, jewel in the crown, Ann Widdecombe, last seen mooning at the youth orchestra playing the European anthem when she was, yes, a Brexit Party MEP. And they said GB News wouldn’t be an echo chamber…

As Neil now seems to imply, GB News is indeed going the way of Fox News which, in his words, “deals in untruths, it deals in conspiracy theories, and it deals in fake news”. To his credit, Neil says: “That is not my kind of journalism and I would never have set out to do that.”

Now, of course it’s possible that talkTV will be just as biased, but this time broadly in favour of Boris Johnson rather than as an apparent front for Reform UK. But none of that is alright. The various biases do not cancel themselves; they merely turn over British broadcasting to special interest groups with their own agendas, broadcasting various strains of propaganda.

Imagine, for a moment, a not too remote world where Len McCluskey persuaded Unite to fund a new TV channel fronted by Jeremy Corbyn, with Diane Abbott, John McDonnell, and Laura Pidcock all “interviewing” one another and agreeing how dreadful Keir Starmer is. And Ofcom said it was all OK, because there’s another parody of journalism called GB News, and another called talkTV and viewers can take their pick, like they do with websites and newspapers. The point of British TV regulation is to protect a uniquely powerful medium; it requires across all channels due balance and accuracy. Not pushing Ivermectin as a treatment for Covid or distorting the truth about Afghan refugees.

So I don’t blame Murdoch or Farage or Legatum (the consortium behind GB News) for the decline in the standard of news broadcasting to sub Fox News levels, but Ofcom, which cheerfully allows this bastardisation (in all senses) of journalism to fester and ferment. Maybe the new culture secretary and likely incoming boss of Ofcom can be relied upon to redress the balance and restore standards. Yes, that’s right, we’re going to have to rely on Nadine Dorries and Paul Dacre to save British television journalism.

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


BJP MLA Nitin Agarwal files nomination for UP Assembly Deputy Speaker election

BJP MLA Nitin Agarwal filed his nomination on Sunday for the Uttar Pradesh Assembly Deputy Speaker election in presence of Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath in Lucknow. Several BJP ministers also ... Read more »

'Last Chance for Redemption': Back in Saddle, Sidhu Writes to Sonia Gandhi on 13-Point Agenda for Punjab

© Provided by News18 ‘Last Chance for Redemption’: Back in Saddle, Sidhu Writes to Sonia Gandhi on 13-Point Agenda for Punjab Navjot Singh Sidhu, who made a comeback as president ... Read more »

17 US missionaries kidnapped by gang members in Haiti

© Provided by The Statesman 17 US missionaries kidnapped by gang members in Haiti A group of 17 U.S. missionaries including children was kidnapped by a gang in Haiti on ... Read more »

Joyce expects colleagues to reject deeper cuts to greenhouse gas emissions by 2030

Nationals leader Barnaby Joyce expects his colleagues to reject the idea of making deeper cuts to greenhouse gas emissions by 2030 despite support within the government for stronger action on ... Read more »

Galliker: Liefersituation in Schweiz deutlich besser als in Europa

© KEYSTONE/ENNIO LEANZA In der Schweiz bestehen nach Ansicht des Transporkonzerns Galliker keine Anzeichen für eine Versorgungskrise wegen fehlender LKW-Fahrern. “Die Situation in der Schweiz ist deutlich besser als im ... Read more »

The sky's the limit

© Provided by The Edge KUALA LUMPUR (Oct 17): Winemaking is a path that is, more often than not, paved with and by passion. This seems to be the case ... Read more »

'Jumpa semula gelang emas jatuh dalam sungai'

© Provided by Sinar Harian KUALA TERENGGANU – Ketua Komunikasi Korporat di salah sebuah syarikat berkaitan kerajaan (GLC) Terengganu, Norfarizan Hashim, 42, tidak menyangka aduan mengenai kehilangan gelang anaknya di ... Read more »

Wajib minta kebenaran MOTAC iklan pakej umrah

© Provided by Sinar Harian SHAH ALAM – Kerajaan mewajibkan syarikat terlibat pengendalian umrah memohon kebenaran daripada Kementerian Pelancongan, Seni dan Budaya Malaysia (MOTAC) terlebih dahulu sebelum membuat iklan atau ... Read more »

Kerajaan kaji keperluan lengkap vaksin untuk pemohon baharu

© Provided by Sinar Harian BERA – Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri Yaakob memberitahu kerajaan akan melihat keperluan pemohon baharu perkhidmatan awam untuk lengkap vaksin sebelum memasuki sektor berkenaan. Bagaimanapun, menurut ... Read more »

The US families missing out on Biden's child benefits

© Getty Images When Joe Biden expanded the US Child Tax Credit (CTC) this summer, it immediately slashed America’s high child poverty rate by a third. Yet while about 67 ... Read more »

Air hostess copies viral IndiGo girl's Manike Mage Hithe dance on empty flight. Watch

(L) Bhavna Khanna, the IndiGo air hostess who danced to Manike Mage Hithe. (R) Aayat, whose Manike Mage Hithe dance video went crazy viral on social media. Remember Aayat, the ... Read more »

PHOTOS: Kriti Sanon & Rajkummar Rao look stunning in white while promoting film ‘Hum Do Hamare Do'

This Diwali will be super fun as Kriti Sanon and Rajkummar Rao starrer Hum Do Hamare Do will be releasing. The film is backed by Dinesh Vijan and directed by ... Read more »

Prabhas spotted as he makes stylish arrival on the sets in Mumbai

Prabhas is the pan Indian actor, who is foraying into the world of Bollywood. The actor is the latest happening celebrity for paparazzi to capture as he has fandom all ... Read more »

Shane Warne vows to make Melbourne 'great again'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Australian cricketing icon Shane Warne has vowed to make Melbourne ‘great again’ after months of harsh lockdowns. Taking to Twitter on Saturday, the ... Read more »

Police or private guards will protect MPs at weekly surgeries

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo MPs will be offered face-to-face police protection or private security guards while they hold their constituency surgeries in the wake of the murder ... Read more »

Navotas lifts liquor ban under Alert Level 3 in NCR

METRO MANILA CITIES- Navotas map The city government of Navotas lifted the liquor ban effective Friday, October 15, as the National Capital Region quarantine status was downgraded to Alert Level ... Read more »

Average number of COVID-19 health rule violators decreased during Alert Level 4 –PNP

© REUTERS/Lisa Marie David People huddle and share a meal while visiting an amusement park in Pasay City on October 16, 2021 as the National Capital Region loosens COVID-19 restrictions ... Read more »

Elizabeth Strout: ‘I've thought about death every day since I was 10'

Three years ago, Elizabeth Strout was in New York sitting in on rehearsals for the stage version of her novel My Name Is Lucy Barton (a show that came to ... Read more »

Takeaways: What should Tennessee's punishment be for ugly scene in Knoxville?

As the dozens and dozens of items flew down onto the field — everything from water bottles to a mustard bottle to a yellow golf ball — Tennessee’s reputation as ... Read more »

Ryan Tannehill Player Prop Bets for NFL Week 6 - Tennessee vs. Buffalo

Discover player props odds, plays, and insights for Ryan Tannehill in his Week 6 contest with the Tennessee Titans against the Buffalo Bills. © Provided by Sports Illustrated Oct 10, ... Read more »

NFL Week 6 predictions: Browns will beat undefeated Cardinals

Home teams in CAPS BROWNS (-3) over Cardinals Cleveland became the first chalk in modern league history to score at least 40 points, rack up more than 400 yards avoid ... Read more »

Dance Umbrella: Extra Time; Nowhere review – a game of two halves

Never let it be said that dance doesn’t broaden your horizons. Last week it took me to Hounslow in west London, where I sat outside a pleasant pub called the ... Read more »

Navjot Singh Sidhu writes to Sonia Gandhi, cites 'priority areas that Punjab govt must deliver upon'

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Punjab Congress chief Navjot Singh Sidhu on Sunday (October 17, 2021) publicly shared a letter he wrote to the party’s ‘full-time and hands-on ... Read more »

Nasa launches Lucy mission to study ‘solar system's evolution'; to fly by 8 ancient asteroids

Nasa’s Lucy, the agency’s first mission that will fly by a total of eight ancient asteroids to study about “solar system’s evolution”, was launched on Saturday. Lucy is Nasa’s “first ... Read more »

IAEA chief vows close consultations with Seoul over Fukushima water release plan

© Provided by The Statesman IAEA chief vows close consultations with Seoul over Fukushima water release plan The chief of the United Nations nuclear watchdog has vowed to continue close consultations ... Read more »

SP Smells 'Political Vendetta' as Police Book Akhilesh Yadav for Staging 'Dharna' over Lakhimpur Violence

© Provided by News18 SP Smells ‘Political Vendetta’ as Police Book Akhilesh Yadav for Staging ‘Dharna’ over Lakhimpur Violence An FIR has been registered against Samajwadi Party chief Akhilesh Yadav ... Read more »

Murder of UK lawmaker declared terrorist incident

© Provided by The Statesman Murder of UK lawmaker declared terrorist incident The murder of British lawmaker David Amess was declared a terrorist incident by London’s metropolitan police with an ... Read more »

Mohamed Salah meets up with agent in London as Liverpool contract negotiations continue

Mohamed Salah’s agent Ramy Abbas Issa has flown into London, leading to speculation over the Liverpool forward’s contract negotiations. Having been reported by the Mirror yesterday evening that Salah ’s ... Read more »

Boli Bolingoli in Celtic penalty 'admission' as Motherwell striker fumes at linesman verdict

Motherwell striker Kevin Van Veen has claimed Boli Bolingoli a penalty should have been awarded against Celtic on Saturday. With Well trailing 2-0 thanks to goals from Jota and their ... Read more »

Sunday Read: Pandemic leaves islanders on isolated Mauritius ‘fighting to work'

© Provided by City AM Tourism industry workers in Mauritius have urged UK holidaymakers to return to the island after being left “fighting” for jobs due to the worldwide pandemic. ... Read more »

‘Unacceptable', ‘Disgraceful' – Many Ipswich Town fans react to recent events

© Provided by Football League World League One – AFC Wimbledon v Ipswich Town Many Ipswich Town fans have taken to Twitter to react after seeing their side give away ... Read more »

"Another string to their bow" - Ashley Preece hails AVFC as "trailblazers" after ingenious move

Birmingham Live journalist Ashley Preece has claimed that Aston Villa have added another dimension to their game by bringing in a set-piece specialist coach this season. © GiveMeSport Kortney Hause ... Read more »

Raab sets out plans to end European judges ‘dictating' UK on human rights

© Provided by City AM The new Justice Secretary, Dominic Raab, has revealed new details about how he plans to prevent interference from Strasbourg in British matters as part of ... Read more »

9 quotes you should read if you are an introvert

Are you the one who makes all the plans, and then ends up looking for reasons to cancel them when the time comes? Or do you prefer being all by ... Read more »

Ranveer Singh, Ayushmann Khurrana to Sidharth Malhotra: Who was your BEST DRESSED man from the week?

And, just like that Sunday is here. The day that calls for a revisit of suave looks sported by Bollywood men throughout the week that went by crowded with festive ... Read more »

How To Handle A Bad Day

A bad day is something that all of us go through more often than we think. Sometimes, a day usually starts out as bad, or by the time the clock ... Read more »

Australia to allows flights from New Zealand's South Island

Quarantine-free flights between Australia and New Zealand‘s South Island are set to resume from Tuesday. Meanwhile, Australians remain unable to freely travel to and from New Zealand‘s North Island. Australia’s ... Read more »

Super Tekla forgives store clerk who accused him of shoplifting in a convenience store

© Provided by Nabiktima ng mistaken identity ang Kapuso comedian na si Super Tekla. Kahapon, October 16, ikinuwento ng The Boobay and Tekla Show (TBATS) host, sa pamamagitan ng ... Read more »

2 things Lee Bowyer needs to weigh up following Birmingham City's 1-0 loss against West Brom

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Birmingham City v Fulham Karlan Grant’s 75th-minute strike proved to be the difference in the West Midlands derby as West Bromwich Albion ... Read more »

Ronit Roy talks about pay cuts during the pandemic says A listers have doubled their salaries: 'Gareebon ka paisa kaat rahe hain'

© Provided by Desimartini Where in a post pandemic world pay cuts are being normalized in the entertainment industry, actor Ronit Roy claims that this is only half the truth. ... Read more »