Donald Trump Has a Fresh Legal Headache and It May Be His Worst Yet

donald trump has a fresh legal headache and it may be his worst yet

White House chief of staff Mark Meadows listens as Donald Trump speaks to the press outside the White House on Oct. 30, 2020. Sarah Silbiger/Getty Images

Former President Donald Trump once promised that under him, his supporters would “get tired of winning.” He must not have been talking about in the courtroom. On Friday it was reported that Trump has suffered yet another devastating judicial defeat in his campaign to thwart the various criminal investigations targeting him. D.C. District Court Judge Beryl Howell rejected his claim of executive privilege to stop his former chief of staff Mark Meadows and other top aides from testifying in Special Counsel Jack Smith’s Jan. 6 probe.

Indeed, it may be the costliest moment yet in Trump’s long losing streak against Smith, greatly increasing the odds of federal charges against the former president.

Meadows’ testimony matters enormously. He was one of the few staffers in continuous contact with Trump on Jan. 6 as the siege occurred. And in the weeks leading up to Jan. 6, according to NPR, Meadows was also “at the very center of Trump’s plans to overturn his presidential election” loss.

For example, Meadows traveled to Georgia seemingly on Trump’s behalf on December 22, 2020, and was apparently involved in setting up Trump’s call the following day to the state’s chief elections investigator, Francis Watson. That call was tape recorded, as was Trump’s infamous January 2, 2021 phone call to Brad Raffensperger, Georgia’s secretary of state, in which Meadows participated. (Fulton County, Georgia, District Attorney Fani Willis is also investigating those events.)

Meadows also has vital testimony about Jan. 6 itself. Evidence the House Jan. 6 committee gathered showed that he had advance intelligence about the coming violence. If so, Smith will want to know about any discussion with Trump about those early warnings.

Likewise, Smith will surely seek Meadows’ testimony about a damning conversation to which Cassidy Hutchinson, Meadows’ aide, testified in Congress. She said Meadows told her that Trump, upon hearing that the insurrectionists were screaming “Hang Mike Pence!,” replied that Pence “deserved it.”

In addition, Meadows withheld about 1,000 text messages subpoenaed by the Jan. 6 committee, after providing more than 2,300 others. The committee has shared the documents it received with the special counsel, and he will certainly want those additional withheld messages, along with Meadows’s testimony about them. (Meadows refused to testify before the Jan. 6 committee, making an executive privilege claim similar to the one that has now been rejected in court.)

As for Judge Howell’s ruling that Meadows and the others must testify, we don’t know her exact reasoning because her ruling is under seal. But we do know its foundations.

In a 1977 case involving former President Richard Nixon after he’d left the White House, the Supreme Court said the incumbent president who succeeded him was “in the best position to assess the present and future needs of the Executive Branch” in deciding whether the privilege applies. Trump’s successor, President Joe Biden, has consistently declined to support Trump’s privilege claims around Jan. 6.

In January 2022, the Supreme Court rejected those claims when Trump unsuccessfully sought to block release of White House documents to the Jan. 6 committee.

In another Supreme Court decision involving Nixon, 1974’s celebrated “White House tapes” case, the court held that “the President’s generalized assertion of privilege must yield to the demonstrated, specific need for evidence in a pending criminal trial.”

Although this criminal trial isn’t yet “pending,” we have that specific need here in spades. Indeed, another federal judge found Trump “more likely than not” conspired to defraud the United States in connection with the effort to persuade then-Vice President Mike Pence to reject certain states’ electoral votes, and also conspired to obstruct Congress on Jan. 6. Then there are the crimes for which the Jan. 6 committee issued criminal referrals to the Justice Department, such as inciting, assisting, and giving aid or comfort to insurrectionists.

Trump is expected to appeal, as usual. Though his prospects are dismal given the precedents, appeals can take time.

Then again, it took less than a day for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit this month to reject another Trump appeal to keep his lawyer, Evan Corcoran, from providing evidence about Smith’s Mar-a-Lago documents investigation. It seems clear that judges are losing patience with the former president’s dilatory litigation tactics.

At any rate, Smith’s focus on Meadows suggests the special counsel is preparing his endgame. In conspiracy cases, prosecutors proceed first to gather evidence from the least culpable witnesses and last to gather evidence from those who are most culpable and closest to the investigation’s target.

As for Meadows’s endgame, with executive privilege off the table, his most likely recourse to block questioning will be the Fifth Amendment. Based on what we know from the Jan. 6 committee’s extensive public record, Meadows has serious criminal exposure of his own.

If Meadows invokes his right to remain silent, the Justice Department will decide whether to compel his testimony by granting him immunity. Such grants eliminate a witness’s criminal exposure and therefore his right to remain silent.

Whatever Smith decides, he now has the upper hand. He has shown that he picks his battles smartly, starting only the fights in which he is confident he can prevail. The special counsel has apparently not gotten tired of winning in his relentless investigations of Donald J. Trump.

News Related


Louise McSharry: How to master DIY pre-holiday primping for dashing lashes, brows and nails in the sun

Sun cream’s on special in Tesco, the bikinis are spawning in Penneys, and the airport is chock-full of excited faces. That’s right, it’s holidays season and, let’s be honest, there’s ... Read more »

Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch loses bid to have his legal costs in murder trial paid for by the State

The State refused the application from Hutch’s lawyers in the Special Criminal Court today. CRIME FIGURE “The Monk” Hutch has failed in a bid to recoup his legal costs from ... Read more »

King Charles's 'bizarre' Coronation afterparty detailed by concert performer

Alexis Ffrench wowed the nation when he took to the stage at King Charles’s Coronation Concert to perform a magical rendition of Simple Minds’ Don’t You (Forget About Me). With ... Read more »

One in 20 children with food allergy suffers accidental allergic reaction while in school or pre-school setting each year – study

The most common food allergen was peanuts which affected two-thirds of children examined in the study followed by other nuts, eggs, milk and fish. Stock picture One in every 20 ... Read more »

Louth TY student Lucy graduates as mental health ambassador

Lucy Maher of Ardee Community School, Ardee, joined 122 Transition Year students across Ireland to graduate as a Walk in My Shoes mental health ambassador during a special online ceremony ... Read more »

War Pony review: Subtle drama set in a corner of Native American society

Two young men on a South Dakota reservation represent different stages of reality for today’s Native Americans. For 12-year-old Matho (LaDainian Crazy Thunder), life is all about vaulting towards adulthood ... Read more »

Trina Cleary funeral: ‘Celebration of life’ to take place today for cancer campaigner (38)

The funeral of cancer awareness campaigner Trina Cleary, who has died at the age of 38, will take place in Co Wexford this afternoon. Ms Cleary be reposing in Ryan’s ... Read more »

Bryan Cranston on going to therapy with wife: We want to go the distance

Bryan Cranston has opened up about his marriage to wife Robin Dearden, revealing that they started therapy before getting married. The Breaking Bad actor, 67, discussed his work and home ... Read more »

Circus stunts, the science of flight, and wild ideas as Wexford prepares for Cruinniú na nÓg ‘23

Ireland’s national day of creativity for young people takes place this Saturday, June 10 and, as a county renowned for its artistic streak, Wexford will host a variety of fun ... Read more »

Liverpool sign World Cup-winning Argentina international Alexis Mac Allister

Alexis Mac Allister. LIVERPOOL HAVE BEGUN the rebuild of their midfield with the signing of Brighton’s World Cup-winning Argentina international Alexis Mac Allister. A fee has not been disclosed but ... Read more »

Medusa Deluxe review: Whodunnit set in the world of competitive hairdressing is a cut above

Between its single-take cinematography (courtesy of Dublin maestro Robbie Ryan), supremely bitchy dialogue, and proximity to sharp implements, there is an uncommon kinetic energy that wafts through this murder mystery ... Read more »

How Le Mans is using grape residues and hydrogen to drive a sustainable future

Motorsport – and Le Mans in particular – has long been a pioneering proving ground for new technologies. However, as the world zeroes in on net zero goals, reducing carbon ... Read more »

20,000 people to attend UCD Festival this weekend with Morgan Freeman appearance

More than 20,000 people are expected to attend University College Dublin’s annual UCD Festival which will see Morgan Freeman serve as the honorary master of ceremonies. On Sunday, June 11, ... Read more »

Manchester United set to play in Dublin ahead of new season

Manchester United are set to come to Dublin for a prestige pre-season friendly in August, with plans to confirm the fixture believed to be at an advanced stage. The Manchester ... Read more »

Space Jaru restaurant review: ‘The pricing at this cool Korean spot is refreshing — a big KFC burger will set you back just €13’

Space Jaru feels like a breath of fresh air. We’ve become so used to booking via an online widget, inputting our card details and worrying whether we’ll be penalised if ... Read more »

Sea of red greets Munster captain Peter O'Mahony as he brings URC Cup to daughter Indie’s (7) school

MUNSTER rugby captain Peter O’Mahony fulfilled a promise to his biggest fan, his daughter Indie (7), by bringing the URC Cup to her Cork primary school to celebrate the province’s ... Read more »

Council probes traveller status of applicants in Martin Clunes planning row

A council considering plans submitted for a permanent travellers’ site next to the home of actor Martin Clunes have delayed the decision again as it investigates whether the applicants can ... Read more »

Lottie and Arthur urge contestants to dress 'playful' for Dubai Duty Free Most Stylish

And we’re off! The chase to find the Dubai Duty Free Irish Derby’s Most Stylish attendees for 2023 is officially on. The annual best dressed competition has long been a ... Read more »

Trump's Former National Security Chief Says Ex-President Did 'Enormous Damage' To US, Republican Party

Trump’s Former National Security Chief Says Ex-President Did ‘Enormous Damage’ To US, Republican Party Donald Trump’s National Security Adviser, John Bolton, said the former president did ‘enormous damage’ to the country ... Read more »

Man pushes partner's head down toilet after downing three litres of wine together

A balding man with a cigarette and a striped jumper An angry boyfriend pushed his partner’s head into the toilet after she threw a dirty loo brush at him during ... Read more »

'Their relationship fizzled out' Friends of Taylor Swift and Matty Healy are not surprised it's over

It was a match that no one saw coming and a split that certainly has taken us by surprise as it is to be believed that Taylor Swift and Matty ... Read more »

Rory McIIroy reacts to Phil Mickleson’s lastest LIV comments

Rory McIlroy LIV The war between Rory Mcllroy and Phil Mickelson continues as Mickelson commented again about playing for the LIV Tour, which Mcllroy didn’t let go. Mickelson bragged that ... Read more »

Britain's Got Talent voting figures revealed as winner Viggo Venn booed at final show

Britain’s Got Talent voting figures have been revealed, which shows winner Viggo Venn bagged the title with a clear advantage despite being booed. The popular ITV show came to an ... Read more »

Shamrock Rovers cruise to victory at Sligo

Rovers stay top. Shamrock Rovers 3 Jessica Farry reports from The Showgrounds SHAMROCK ROVERS CONTINUE to lead the way at the table after a comprehensive 3-0 win over Sligo Rovers ... Read more »

Prince Andrew laughs as he gets stuck behind an 'oblivious' dog walker

andrew Prince Andrew was on a drive around when he appeared to get stuck behind a dog walker, who was clearly “oblivious” that she was blocking the Duke of York ... Read more »

Humans may only have two years before AI systems become too powerful to control, Sunak’s tech chief warns

The human race may only have two years left to tame advanced artificial intelligence systems before they become too powerful to control, Rishi Sunak’s chief adviser on the technology has ... Read more »

Apple announces iOS 17

iOS 17 is official. Apple’s iOS 17 is official, making its debut on WWDC 2023’s keynote stage. Highlights include redesigned contact cards and live voicemail. Your contact book is getting ... Read more »

Nearly 16,000 Ukrainian pupils signed up in Irish schools as Ireland has one of highest rates of enrolment

The number of Ukrainian pupils in Irish schools continues to rise, with 15,589 enrolled last month. In Europe, Ireland has one of the highest rates of enrolment for students who ... Read more »

Dannii Minogue to ‘play Cupid again’ on new BBC Three show I Kissed A Girl

Dannii Minogue will be “playing Cupid again” as host of new BBC Three dating show I Kissed A Girl. The Australian singer, sister of Kylie, announced the opening of applications ... Read more »

An internal Twitter document reportedly shows ad revenue down 59%, casting doubt on Elon Musk's statement that 'almost all advertisers have come back'

Advertising revenue is down at Twitter, according to internal documents obtained by The New York Times. Susan Walsh/AP Internal Twitter documents show the platform’s ad revenue down 59% year-over-year, The ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự