'Does the Liberal government have a money tree?': Report reveals focus group's thoughts on last federal budget

Asia's Tech News Daily

'Does the Liberal government have a money tree?': Report reveals focus group's thoughts on last federal budget
© Provided by National Post Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland responds to questions from MPs after she delivered the federal budget in the House of Commons on April 19, 2021.

OTTAWA — Does the Liberal government have a money tree hidden some place? That’s what some focus group participants wondered aloud in reaction to the last federal budget, according to research commissioned by Finance Canada.

Last April, as Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland delivered the first budget speech in two years in which she announced $101 billion in massive new spending measures, 32 Canadians sat watching with a dial in their hand, rating every new promise and expense.

They were part of a focus group assembled by polling firm Leger at the behest of Finance Canada as part of a $53,445 contract for public opinion research.

The goal of the research was to provide Freeland’s department with insight into people’s opinions on the budget and offer direction to the government.

And the opinions expressed by participants indeed went in every direction, although everyone generally ended up expressing a positive opinion of a spending blueprint designed to be liked.

“In the words of many participants, it would be difficult to be negative about this budget that included elements to ‘satisfy everyone in Canada’, was in continuity with the efforts to limit the negative impacts of the pandemic on Canadians, as well as a ‘recovery-oriented budget,’ ” Leger notes in the report obtained by the National Post.

But the initial positive impression quickly gave way to cynicism and skepticism amongst many participants, with some describing it as an “electoral budget” and many concerned that certain measures would never be implemented or that the Liberals would not be able to deliver on their promises.

The focus groups were divided into four categories: parents of children aged 0 to 6 years old, seniors (over 65 years old), people who received the Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) and Quebecers.

Among the four groups surveyed, seniors were the most critical of the budget (though it was still “well received”), expressing skepticism about how all the promises would be implemented and then how everything would be paid for.

“I just feel that the government must have a money tree some place; I don’t know how they’re going to be able to pluck it all off the tree to do what they say they’re gonna do,” one told Leger.

Among the worst-rated moments of Freeland’s speech for seniors: any references to the “sacrifices youth and young adults made as a result of the pandemic.”

“You could detect a generation gap when it comes to COVID impacts,” Leger concludes.

The parents surveyed gave high marks to a wide swath of the budget, including all promises of more money for early childhood education and care, increasing minimum wage, more assistance for family businesses and job creation, and any support to the younger generation of Canadians.

But many were concerned that it was an “election budget” and that the Liberals’ proposed luxury tax on boats (worth over $250,000) and cars (worth over $100,000) was neither inclusive nor bold enough.

Parents were also skeptical of the government’s promises to Indigenous people, with one noting that, “I know they do their best for Indigenous people, but until you can just give them drinking water, I feel like you’ve just failed.”

While parents were skeptical of the effectiveness of the proposed luxury tax, the Quebec focus group viewed it extremely positively.

In fact, Quebecers gave the budget speech the highest average rating, with top marks for promises to help low-wage workers and business during the pandemic, and for measures aimed at young Canadians and investments in various leading sectors such as biopharmaceutical.

“The government is casting a wide net and they want to please everyone,” one Quebec participant noted, according to Leger.

But Quebecers were much less happy about the Liberals’ timelines for certain environmental measures, such as 2050 to achieve carbon neutrality and the seven-year target to implement a net zero accelerator.

The final category of participants, Canadians who received CERB during the pandemic, unsurprisingly supported measures related to extending COVID-19 benefits, as well as child-care initiatives and aid to students.

“There have been a lot of great announcements, but now we have to see IF they will implement them,” reads one comment quoted in the report.

On the flip side, they were “generally skeptical” of the government’s ability to fulfil its promise of pushing for office towers to be repurposed into affordable housing. They also gave a below-average rating to passages of the budget speech that mentioned women and feminism.

“Talk is cheap. We’ve heard them talk a lot, and this budget was very positive, but something doesn’t sit right. Like it’s too good to be true,” one respondent said.

• Email: cnardi@postmedia.com | Twitter: ChrisGNardi

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Michelle Dockery to marry Fleabag star Phoebe Waller-Bridge's brother

It’s been six years since the death of her fiance. Now Downton Abbey star, Michelle Dockery appears to have healed her broken heart – and revealed her engagement to Phoebe ... Read more »

Mikel Arteta's response to Thomas Partey red card just hours after flying back from AFCON

Thomas Partey endured a miserable Arsenal comeback after jetting back from Cameroon just 48 hours after Ghana were dumped out of the Africa Cup of Nations. The midfielder was not ... Read more »

Celebs Go Dating's Abz Love gobsmacked over 90s throwback snap with Anna Williamson

Abz Love was left gobsmacked on Thursday’s Celebs Go Dating as Anna Williamson surprised him with a 90s throwback snap of them pictured together. During the latest instalment, Anna, 40, ... Read more »

Jake Tapper Grills Jen Psaki Harder Than Fox News Did

© Provided by The Daily Beast CNN CNN anchor Jake Tapper on Thursday repeatedly confronted White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki over President Joe Biden’s voting-rights comments during the day ... Read more »

Bowman arrested during voting rights protest at Capitol

© Greg Nash Rep. Jamaal Bowman (D-N.Y.) addresses reporters during a press conference on Wednesday, December 8, 2021 about a resolution condemning Rep. Lauren Boebert’s (R-Colo.) use of Islamaphobic rhetoric and ... Read more »

Tottenham captain Hugo Lloris agrees a new two-year contract with the club

© PA Hugo Lloris. SPURS CAPTAIN HUGO Lloris has agreed a new contract at the club. The France goalkeeper’s existing deal was due to expire in the summer, but he ... Read more »

Twitter is rolling out verified NFT profile pictures

© Adobe Stock Twitter on Thursday began rolling out a feature that will let some users set NFTs that they own as their profile picture to signal their investment in ... Read more »

US Fed kicks off debate on issuing its own digital currency with new white paper

© DANIEL SLIM The US Federal Reserve seen in Washington DC. AFP Creating an official digital version of the US dollar could give Americans more, and speedier, payment options, but ... Read more »

Bulls star Lonzo Ball out at least 6 weeks due to knee surgery

The Chicago Bulls will be without Lonzo Ball for the foreseeable future. Ball opted to have arthroscopic surgery on his left knee, and will miss up to eight weeks recovering, ... Read more »

Jury selected for federal trial over George Floyd's killing

ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) — A jury was picked Thursday for the federal trial of three Minneapolis police officers charged in George Floyd’s killing, with the judge stressing repeatedly that ... Read more »

Cadillac Escalade-V Teaser Promises 'Something Exciting' On Jan 21

It’s certainly been a long time coming. We give Cadillac credit where it’s due. The high-performance Escalade-V has been a well-kept secret, all things considered. We’ve only had three prototype ... Read more »

USC to require security guards block access to bedrooms during frat parties

Fraternities at the University of Southern California could soon begin hosting social gatherings again following allegations of sexual assault, so long as the groups follow a new set of guidelines. ... Read more »

Eric Adams is turning his first NYC mayor paycheck into bitcoin

© Independent NYC Mayor-Elect Eric Adams Wants Bitcoin for First Three Paychecks New York City mayor Eric Adams said that he would be turning his initial income from his role ... Read more »

Royal maid says Prince Andrew LAUGHED when his dog bit her leg

ROYAL maid Charlotte Briggs says Andrew laughed when his dog bit her on the leg. Charlotte, then 22, was ­attacked by nine-year-old Norfolk terrier Bendicks, named after Fergie’s favourite chocolates. ... Read more »

Trump campaign officials, including Giuliani, oversaw 2020 fake electors' plan -CNN

© Reuters/Mike Segar FILE PHOTO: U.S. President-elect Donald Trump stands with former New York City Mayor Rudolph Giuliani before their meeting at Trump National Golf Club in Bedminster LOS ANGELES ... Read more »

The Staff & Graph Podcast: iDesk Guy

© Provided by The Hockey News Rachel Doerrie and Mike Stephens make a major announcement and discuss the changes to the Staff & Graph Podcast going forward. Then, the two ... Read more »

Arsenal's need for midfield reinforcements laid bare in Liverpool defeat

If Mikel Arteta wasn’t already desperate for midfield reinforcements for his paper-thin Arsenal squad, he certainly will be now. © Provided by 90min Partey was dismissed on his return | ... Read more »

'Incredible!' - Manchester United youngster Di'Shon Bernard earns rave reviews on loan at Hull

Manchester United loanee Di’Shon Bernard has had fans talking after his man of the match performance for Hull City against Blackburn Rovers. It proved to be a scalp for Grant ... Read more »

Sen. Chuck Schumer defends failed push for voting rights: ‘Imagine telling Dr. King not to march’

Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) gave an impassioned defense of the Democratic push to enact voting rights reforms, which collapsed when two moderates joined Republicans to block a needed change in ... Read more »

Year 2: Biden plans more public outreach, less legislating

© Provided by Associated Press President Joe Biden speaks during a meeting with the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology at the Eisenhower Executive Office Building on the ... Read more »

US charges Belarus officials with air piracy over Ryanair flight diversion

© PETRAS MALUKAS The United States has charged four Belarus officials with air piracy over the diversion of a Ryanair flight in May 2021 in order to arrest a dissident. ... Read more »

Infantino focuses on tackling workload in player talks

LONDON (AP) — FIFA President Gianni Infantino assured players during talks Thursday that a reshaped international calendar will tackle their workload and fixture congestion concerns, while backing away from heavily ... Read more »

'My partner loves to humiliate me in front of other people, and I hate it'

When my partner Max* is in a great mood, he usually pranks me or does something silly to embarrass me in public. He gets great enjoyment in watching me squirm ... Read more »

Brooke Blurton’s makeover round two!

Just days after debuting a dramatic new look, Brooke Blurton has headed into the salon again to makeover her hair for a second time. The 2021 Bachelorette revealed her latest ... Read more »

I'm a teacher and my pupils have no idea about the ‘special filing system' I use for homework… we all have one

IF YOU are wondering where teachers store their huge piles of students’ homework, then listen up. A teacher has taken to TikTok to share how she claims she stores the ... Read more »

Elton John told Charlie Puth that his old music was 'not good'

© Provided by INSIDER Elton John and Charlie Puth. Erika Goldring/Steve Jennings/Getty Images Charlie Puth discussed his friendship with Elton John in a new interview with Audacy. He said the ... Read more »

Help stop car condensation with this clever dehumidifier

Help stop car condensation with this clever dehumidifier. (Getty Images) Yahoo Life's editors are committed to independently selecting wonderful products at great prices for you. We may receive a share ... Read more »

Green light given for Irish Government to lift majority of Covid restrictions

The Irish Government has been given the green light to lift the majority of the state’s Covid restrictions. It is understood that the National Public Health Emergency Team (Nphet) has ... Read more »

Shock! Barcelona’s new bosses don’t like Bayern Munich poaching their stars

© Photo credit should read FABRICE COFFRINI/AFP via Getty Images According to a report by Sport1, the new bosses at FC Barcelona are not on good terms with Bayern Munich ... Read more »

Nightmare Alley, review: not even Bradley Cooper can save Guillermo del Toro's stiff, synthetic thriller

Early on in Nightmare Alley, when Bradley Cooper’s aspiring con artist is being schooled in the mind-reader’s devious art, his tutor (David Strathairn) gives him an indispensable piece of advice. ... Read more »

Trump news - live: Ivanka asked to testify about Jan 6 as ex-president reacts to Georgia grand jury move

LIVE – Updated at 22:01 Former President Donald Trump has defended his “perfect” phone call with Georgia officials regarding election fraud in the state. Earlier on Thursday, the Fulton County ... Read more »

Austria approves Europe's first vaccine mandate for all adults

© Getty Images Austria approves Europe’s first vaccine mandate for all adults Austria approved Europe’s first coronavirus vaccine mandate for all adults on Thursday as massive protests were held against ... Read more »

US charges 2nd key suspect in killing of Haiti's president

© Provided by Associated Press FILE – A person holds a photo of the late Haitian President Jovenel Moise during his memorial ceremony at the National Pantheon Museum in Port-au-Prince, ... Read more »

Revelations in New York court underscore Trump's legal peril on multiple fronts

Trump Organization accused by New York attorney general's office of fraud See more videos What to watch next WH clarifies position on elections, voting rights Less than a day after ... Read more »

Unions are at war with Boris Johnson over returning to the office

Boris Johnson faces a fierce battle with union leaders after they frustrated his drive to get Britain back to work. In a bid to return the country to ‘complete normality’, the ... Read more »

Ax-Wielding Tennessee Woman Arrested for Allegedly Violating Protection Order, Attacking Family Members

© Provided by People oconee county sheriff’s office A Tennessee woman faces multiple charges after authorities say that she broke into a relative’s home and attacked two family members with ... Read more »

Jamie Lynn Spears responds to Britney Spears' cease and desist letter

© Provided by Cover Media Jamie Lynn Spears Jamie Lynn Spears has issued a response to her sister Britney Spears’ cease and desist letter. On Monday, Britney’s lawyer Mathew Rosengart ... Read more »

Netflix growth in recent quarter slightly misses mark

© Olivier DOULIERY Netflix sees slowing subscriber growth Netflix on Thursday reported falling short of estimates on new subscribers, and predicted slower growth in 2022 as fierce competition and the ... Read more »

Kimberley business chamber slams proposed ban on almost all takeaway alcohol

© Provided by ABC Business The chamber wants bottle shops to be allowed to continue selling heavy and mid-strength alcohol. (ABC News: Ted O’Connor) The East Kimberley chamber of commerce ... Read more »

Canucks Hire Rachel Doerrie in Analytics Role

The Vancouver Canucks have hired The Hockey News’ own Rachel Doerrie to join their front office in a research role. © Provided by The Hockey News Steven Ellis/The Hockey News ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic