Do the northern lights make sounds that you can hear?

Fiona Amery, University of Cambridge, puzzled observers for centuries, near Earth’s poles, Finnish study, A recording, My recent resear, personal testimonies, Second International Polar Year of 1932-3, commented that, conjure a whooshing sound, optical illusion, published accounts, Clarence Chant, metallic odor, two auroral physicists, still debate, 5% of violent auroral displays, Ēriks Ešenvalds, Northern Lights, BBC 3 radio pro, The Conversation, original article

The author of this article is Fiona Amery, PhD Candidate in History and Philosophy of Science at the University of Cambridge.

It’s a question that has puzzled observers for centuries: do the fantastic green and crimson light displays of the aurora borealis produce any discernible sound?

Conjured by the interaction of solar particles with gas molecules in Earth’s atmosphere, the aurora generally occurs near Earth’s poles, where the magnetic field is strongest. Reports of the aurora making a noise, however, are rare – and were historically dismissed by scientists.

But a Finnish study in 2016 claimed to have finally confirmed that the northern lights really do produce sound audible to the human ear. A recording made by one of the researchers involved in the study even claimed to have captured the sound made by the captivating lights 70 meters above ground level.

Still, the mechanism behind the sound remains somewhat mysterious, as are the conditions that must be met for the sound to be heard. My recent research takes a look over historic reports of auroral sound to understand the methods of investigating this elusive phenomenon and the process of establishing whether reported sounds were objective, illusory or imaginary.

Historic claims

Auroral noise was the subject of particularly lively debate in the first decades of the 20th century, when accounts from settlements across northern latitudes reported that sound sometimes accompanied the mesmerizing light displays in their skies.

Witnesses told of a quiet, almost imperceptible crackling, whooshing or whizzing noise during particularly violent northern lights displays. In the early 1930s, for instance, personal testimonies started flooding into The Shetland News, the weekly newspaper of the subarctic Shetland Islands, likening the sound of the northern lights to “rustling silk” or “two planks meeting flat ways”.

These tales were corroborated by similar testimony from northern Canada and Norway. Yet the scientific community was less than convinced, especially considering very few western explorers claimed to have heard the elusive noises themselves.

The credibility of auroral noise reports from this time was intimately tied to altitude measurements of the northern lights. It was considered that only those displays that descended low into the Earth’s atmosphere would be able to transmit sound which could be heard by the human ear.

The problem here was that results recorded during the Second International Polar Year of 1932-3 found aurorae most commonly took place 100km above Earth, and very rarely below 80km. This suggested it would be impossible for discernible sound from the lights to be transmitted to the Earth’s surface.

Auditory illusions?

Given these findings, eminent physicists and meteorologists remained skeptical, dismissing accounts of auroral sound and very low aurorae as folkloric stories or auditory illusions.

Sir Oliver Lodge, the British physicist involved in the development of radio technology, commented that auroral sound might be a psychological phenomenon due to the vividness of the aurora’s appearance – just as meteors sometimes conjure a whooshing sound in the brain. Similarly, the meteorologist George Clark Simpson argued that the appearance of low aurorae was likely an optical illusion caused by the interference of low clouds.

Nevertheless, the leading auroral scientist of the 20th century, Carl Størmer, published accounts written by two of his assistants who claimed to have heard the aurora, adding some legitimacy to the large volume of personal reports.

Størmer’s assistant Hans Jelstrup said he had heard a “very curious faint whistling sound, distinctly undulatory, which seemed to follow exactly the vibrations of the aurora”, while Mr. Tjönn experienced a sound like “burning grass or spray”. As convincing as these two last testimonies may have been, they still didn’t propose a mechanism by which auroral sound could operate.

Sound and light

The answer to this enduring mystery which has subsequently garnered the most support was first tentatively suggested in 1923 by Clarence Chant, a well-known Canadian astronomer. He argued that the motion of the northern lights alters Earth’s magnetic field, inducing changes in the electrification of the atmosphere, even at a significant distance.

This electrification produces a crackling sound much closer to Earth’s surface when it meets objects on the ground, much like the sound of static. This could take place on the observer’s clothes or spectacles, or possibly in surrounding objects including fir trees or the cladding of buildings.

Chant’s theory correlates well with many accounts of auroral sound, and is also supported by occasional reports of the smell of ozone – which reportedly carries a metallic odor similar to an electrical spark – during northern lights displays.

Yet Chant’s paper went largely unnoticed in the 1920s, only receiving recognition in the 1970s when two auroral physicists revisited the historical evidence. Chant’s theory is largely accepted by scientists today, although there’s still debate as to how exactly the mechanism for producing the sound operates.

What is clear is that the aurora does, on rare occasions, make sounds audible to the human ear. The eerie reports of crackling, whizzing and buzzing noises accompanying the lights describe an objective audible experience – not something illusory or imagined.

Sampling the sound

If you want to hear the northern lights for yourself, you may have to spend a considerable amount of time in the Polar regions, considering the aural phenomenon only presents itself in 5% of violent auroral displays. It’s also most commonly heard on the top of mountains, surrounded by only a few buildings – so it’s not an especially accessible experience.

In recent years, the sound of the aurora has nonetheless been explored for its aesthetic value, inspiring musical compositions and laying the foundation for novel ways of interacting with its electromagnetic signals.

The Latvian composer Ēriks Ešenvalds has used journal extracts from the American explorer Charles Hall and the Norwegian statesman Fridjtof Nansen, both of whom claimed to have heard the northern lights, in his music. His composition, Northern Lights, interweaves these reports with the only known Latvian folksong recounting the auroral sound phenomenon, sung by a tenor solo.

Or you can also listen to the radio signals of the northern lights at home. In 2020, a BBC 3 radio program remapped very low-frequency radio recordings of the aurora onto the audible spectrum. Although not the same as perceiving audible noises produced by the northern lights in person on a snowy mountaintop, these radio frequencies give an awesome sense of the aurora’s transitory, fleeting and dynamic nature.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Source: The Conversation / #NorwayTodayTravel

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Future Playoff Watch: What a 12-Team Bracket Would Look Like After Week 8

Decisions are getting tough in SI’s latest update on a hypothetical expanded college football postseason in 2021. View the original article to see embedded media. This is a weekly Sports ... Read more »

COP26: How rich nations can keep promises to curb emissions and fund climate adaptation

The time has come for Canada and other rich nations to pony-up and pay for the devastation they have caused countries in the Global South. That means, for a start, ... Read more »

'The pandemic isn't over': CDC extends Conditional Sailing Order for cruises into January amid COVID

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention temporarily extended the agency’s Framework for Conditional Sailing. The Framework for Conditional Sailing Order was published initially Oct. 30, 2020. The CSO includes ... Read more »

Moderna reports good vaccine response among 6-11-year-olds

The vaccine manufacturer Moderna says test results for the corona vaccine in children aged 6 to 11 years are good. Moderna reports a “robust response” when it comes to “antibody ... Read more »

Report: Browns RB Nick Chubb Expected to Return vs. Steelers

© Provided by Sports Illustrated Browns running back Nick Chubb is reportedly expected to return Sunday against the Steelers as long as he does not have any setbacks in practice. ... Read more »

Tromsø: 46 new corona cases registered in the last 24 hours

A total of 46 new corona infection cases have been registered in Tromsø in the last 24 hours. According to Tromsø Municipality, 318 corona tests were carried out on Sunday. ... Read more »

Inside Melbourne's Park hotel, refugees sit and wait for Covid to find them

Photograph: Daniel Pockett/AAP Inside the closed door of his room in the Park hotel in Melbourne – his “cage” for the past 10 days after eight years in detention – ... Read more »

How to know if a country is serious about net zero: look at its plans for extracting fossil fuels

Fresh emissions targets from Saudi Arabia and Australia – two of the world’s largest fossil-fuel producers – are due to arrive just in time for global climate talks in Glasgow. ... Read more »

Geoffrey Chater obituary

The distinctive character actor Geoffrey Chater, who has died aged 100, was a familiar face on countless television drama series, from Dixon of Dock Green to Callan, The Cleopatras and ... Read more »

Stopping oil drilling would mean the end of the green shift, Støre tells Financial Times

Norway’s Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Støre told the Financial Times that an abrupt stop of Norwegian oil activities would destroy the transition to environmentally friendly energy. In an interview with ... Read more »

9 Amazing Airbnb Rentals for Your Next Florida Vacation

Kick back and enjoy the awesome views of Siesta Key for your next Sunshine State getaway. (Airbnb/) Now more than ever, Florida is on the top of most American’s travel ... Read more »

Tom Brady Shares Special Moment With Fan at End of Bucs Win

© Provided by Sports Illustrated Tom Brady broke the 600 passing touchdown plateau on Sunday, but he also did much more than that. View the original article to see embedded ... Read more »

SAS boss says the company is “fighting to survive”

SAS’s share fell over 9% on the stock exchanges in Oslo and Stockholm on Monday. According to SAS CEO Anko Van der Werff, the airline is fighting to survive. “SAS ... Read more »

Tiny swimming creatures can create big currents in lake water – new research

Lake Windermere, in England’s Lake District, experiences different mixing processes in its water column. BarnyZ/Flickr Lakes are usually pictured as tranquil environments, largely uninfluenced by the enormous tidal power which ... Read more »

¿Por qué hay desabastecimiento de chips a nivel mundial?

© Richard Newstead Foto de referencia sobre chips – Getty Images Vivimos en un mundo hiperconectado en el que cada vez más objetos están dotados de la tecnología necesaria para ... Read more »

Brace yourself: It may be a rough holiday travel season — but not for the reason you think

© Provided by The Points Guy MSN has partnered with The Points Guy for our coverage of credit card products. MSN and The Points Guy may receive a commission from ... Read more »

The 10 best holidays to book for a Christmas getaway

stuttgart christmas market – Getty The countdown is on. There are just two months until we tuck into elaborate roasts, exchange presents and – let’s hope – gather with friends ... Read more »

Great place to chill: Former refrigerated truck trailers transformed into twin-bedroom holiday rentals with kitchens (and next year guests can VOTE for where they'll be set up)

Polish mobile hotel chain Good Spot operates four such rentals, created by Polish design firm Znamy Sie In the centre of each trailer is a bathroom, where the icy blue colour reflects the vehicle's cold-storage history There is a kitchen, and two bedrooms at either end, plus a small porch running down one side  Read more »

Police: Clothes found by the waterfall in Kvam – the search for three missing people continues

The police state that they have found clothes in the same area by the waterfall at Tokagjelet in Hardanger where the boat of the three missing people was found earlier ... Read more »

What to know about COP26 ahead of global climate summit

© Qilai Shen/Bloomberg/Getty coal-1278938-640×360.jpg Shelley Inglis is executive director of the University of Dayton Human Rights Center. Over two weeks in November, world leaders and national negotiators will meet in Scotland ... Read more »

Norwegian film “The Worst Person in the World” chosen as Norway's Oscars candidate

Directed by Joachim Trier, “The Worst Person in the World” has been selected to represent Norway at the Oscars in Hollywood next year. The massive film event, also known as ... Read more »

Week 8 IDP Waiver Wire Report

Digging deep for some defensive fantasy help Welcome back to the IDP waiver wire report. I was told to dig a little deeper ahead of this Week 8 edition. I ... Read more »

Report: Dolphins Owner Not Currently Pushing for Watson Trade

© Provided by Sports Illustrated Dolphins owner Stephen Ross is reportedly not currently pushing the franchise’s football personnel to trade for quarterback Deshaun Watson. View the original article to see ... Read more »

Por qué el Barça no está arruinado

© Proporcionado por RPP FC Barcelona Joan Massons Rabassa, Universitat de Vic – Universitat Central de Catalunya Una cosa es poder demostrar con cifras en la mano la debilidad no ... Read more »

The climate crisis affects everyone – here's how to make sure discussions aren't dominated by white men

City-level climate talks are often dominated by those who carry social privilege. UNFCCC/Flickr Governments across the world are facing increasing pressure to keep rising global temperatures below 1.5C above pre-industrial ... Read more »

Norway's new Foreign Minister Anniken Huitfeldt to meet Russian counterpart Lavrov

Anniken Huitfeldt’s (AP) first major task as a foreign minister will be to meet her Russian counterpart, Sergei Lavrov. Espionage and security policy will be the backdrop to Monday’s meeting ... Read more »

10 best haunted attractions across the country, according to readers

Halloween is all about wild and wacky costumes, scary movies, haunted houses and celebrating all things spooky. So, 10Best went on the hunt for the best haunted attractions across the ... Read more »

Kyle Shanahan on Whether Garoppolo Will Remain 49ers' Starter: 'I Would Guess So'

© Provided by Sports Illustrated San Francisco’s loss to Indianapolis on Sunday Night Football marked the 49ers’ fourth consecutive defeat. View the original article to see embedded media. 49ers coach ... Read more »

San Diego State vs. Fresno State College Football Odds, Plays and Insights

Check out odds, insights and more in our betting preview for the San Diego State Aztecs vs. Fresno State Bulldogs college football matchup on October 30, 2021. © Provided by ... Read more »

Oslo: 120 new corona cases registered in the last 24 hours

A total of 120 new corona-infected people have been registered in Oslo in the last 24 hours. That is 63 more than the same day last week and eleven more ... Read more »

COVID: how worried should we be about the new AY.4.2 lineage of the coronavirus?

SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, with its spike proteins shown in blue. Design_Cells/Shutterstock No sooner than you thought all the talk of new COVID variants was over, there’s news ... Read more »

Exclusive for Mail on Sunday readers: See the Northern Lights with Sir Ranulph Fiennes

With their dramatic mountains, towering cliffs and majestic waterfalls, the Norwegian fjords are among the most beautiful and unspoilt places on Earth. A winter cruise is the best way to ... Read more »

How a new Dante-themed hotel in Florence is bringing the author to a new audience

25hours Hotel Piazza San Paolino, Florence The first thing I noticed about my room in Florence was “Welcome to Hell” scrawled across the shower door. The second was a mobile, ... Read more »

Anya Taylor-Joy announced as Dior's latest brand ambassador

Photo credit: Rich Fury – Getty Images Anya Taylor-Joy has been announced as Dior's latest global brand ambassador. The actress – who has been a fan of the house for ... Read more »

Edita Gruberova, coloratura soprano known as the ‘Slovakian Nightingale' – obituary

Edita Gruberova in 2000 – ullstein bild via Getty Images Edita Gruberova, who has died aged 74, was a soprano known as the Slovakian Nightingale; she appeared in opera houses ... Read more »

Six jailed in Spain for selling fakes of Goya and other artists online

Six people have been jailed in the eastern Spanish region of Valencia after police broke up a criminal gang that was using the internet to sell crudely forged paintings attributed ... Read more »

Huseierne: Norwegian homeowners need to prepare for rising housing-related costs

More expensive electricity is only the beginning of rising housing costs in the future, according to the organization Huseierne. The organization is now asking homeowners to prepare for tighter economic ... Read more »

Back to the bush: Safaris are open again - and the elephants in Kenya are among the biggest on earth. Best of all, this lodge doesn't need a jumbo wallet

Covid all but obliterated international safari tourism more than 18 months ago Kenya lost almost a billion dollars in lost tourist revenue in 2020 But the lodges stayed open and were run on skeleton staffGraham Boynton checked into the Satao Camp in Tsavo East National Park Read more »

WA border restrictions: Quarantine travel with Queensland from Wednesday

People travelling from Queensland to WA will not be required to quarantine from Wednesday. The government originally planned to classify the Sunshine State as “very low risk” from last Friday ... Read more »

More than 50 rescue crews are participating in the search operation in Kvam

More than 50 crews are searching for the three people who are missing after a boat was taken away by the current on a river at Tokagjelet in Kvam in ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic