Disinformation in a time of Covid-19: A historic partnership ahead of the municipal elections

Asia's Tech News Daily

The Independent Electoral Commission and Media Monitoring Africa have joined hands with major social media platforms to fight the spread of disinformation in the 1 November municipal elections.

Disinformation in a time of Covid-19: A historic partnership ahead of the municipal elections
© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved

Week 35: The significance of partnerships

Last week the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) released a press statement that focused on the announcement of a historic coming together of the IEC, civil society and the major social media platforms. What makes it so important and why should you care? This week we unpack a South African and African first.

With a tendency for fighting and conflict to be the subject of most headlines, it’s easy to forget the value of celebrating entities working together.

“The Electoral Commission and Media Monitoring Africa (MMA) have joined hands with major social media platforms to fight the spread of disinformation, in the run-up to, during and beyond the November 1, 2021 municipal elections.

“The Commission and MMA, who in 2019 launched a joint action to deal with disinformation, have today — 19 October 2021 — reached an agreement with Google, Facebook, Twitter and TikTok to work in support of our efforts to end the scourge of disinformation.”

You may wonder what the big deal is. There are a number of aspects that make this important. First, the IEC, like several other electoral management bodies globally, understands the threat posed to elections by disinformation. The IEC delivered a world first in 2019 when we worked with them to introduce the Real411 platform. Now, in 2021, the step of bringing the big social media platforms together for a coordinated response takes the fight to the next level.

Suggesting that the social media platforms, the IEC and civil society all work together is perfectly logical, but it is easier said than done, which leads to the second reason the announcement is significant. 

Google (market cap: $1.84-trillion), Facebook (market cap: $915-billion), TikTok (market cap: $250-billion), and Twitter (market cap: $49-billion) are all multibillion-dollar entities; they are global, increasingly pervasive and have great power. 

As we saw in the US elections in 2016 and in 2020, and elsewhere, these platforms are able to affect election outcomes and are frequently abused to spread hatred, incite violence and spread misinformation and disinformation. There is extensive work being done around the world on whether each of them is doing enough to combat digital harms like disinformation.  

Facebook is currently in the news because of whistle-blowers, suggesting it hasn’t been doing nearly enough. The pressure on each of these social media platforms to do more will continue, and Media Monitoring Africa will be among those working to ensure more effective and appropriate steps are taken. We must, however, also accept that like any major source of power, changing these platforms is difficult.

As major power brokers in society, each of the platforms is subjected to mountains of complaints, queries, demands, lobbying, threats and enticements. The bigger the market and power of the entity the more likely it is to listen. Many, for example, have appeared before special tribunals and congressional hearings in the US and before the EU. 

In our context, when the platforms were invited to appear before the Parliamentary Committee on Communication and Digital Technologies in May, only Google appeared. All had been, and we understand continue to be, willing to engage with the government. South Africa’s internet access is increasing and estimates place access at 64% of our population, or about 38 million people. The most popular platform is Facebook with about 27 million users in South Africa. It sounds like a lot until you consider that Facebook has about 2.85 billion monthly users worldwide. So we account for less than 1% of users, against 221.6 million users in the US (7.8%).  

There is no doubt that all the social media platforms are aware of the huge growth coming from Africa and are paying increasingly more attention to our issues, but it is also clear that South Africa is punching above its weight in terms of engagement with social media platforms.

In addition, we need to consider that while most of the social media platforms have local staff, many of whom have worked in government, civil society or other related sectors, the platforms themselves are headquartered in different parts of the world. This means getting messages and information up through the chain to the key decision-makers requires enormous effort and determination from in-country people.

It is in this context then that the IEC and Real411 have brought four of the biggest social media platforms together to commit to combating disinformation over the election period. It demonstrates huge commitments from the local platform representatives.

The third reason the announcement is so important relates to the platforms themselves. As we have reflected several pieces previously, one of the biggest challenges we face is that the platforms all have different views and understandings of what they consider to be misinformation and disinformation. This is one of the key reasons Real411 was developed to begin with, as not only are these views all different, but they don’t speak to South African laws, our Constitution and our democracy.

Getting them to agree with hearing what the IEC and Real411 are saying and agreeing to act expeditiously is no small achievement. While the platforms are not assessing misdemeanours on the same basis as we are, their support of the process and recognition of the importance of the IEC is a huge step for recognition of the importance not just of South Africa’s elections, but for electoral bodies more broadly.

What are the key elements of the Framework of Cooperation that the platforms have all agreed to support?

“1.1. The purpose of the Framework of Cooperation is to identify the measures that the Participants may put in place to address the challenges related to disinformation during the election period; to promote conditions that are conducive to free, fair and credible elections; and to assist the IEC in its mandate to address intentionally false statements as set out in section 89(2) of the Electoral Act and section 69(2) of the Local Government: Municipal Electoral Act.” (LGE Framework of Cooperation)

In addition to identifying measures and seeking to promote conditions conducive to free, fair and credible elections, and to assist the IEC in combating disinformation, the framework sees the participants committing to take steps towards the following:

“2.1.1. Deploy appropriate policies, processes, and safeguards to facilitate access to accurate information regarding electoral matters.

2.1.2. Implement and promote appropriate policies, processes, and safeguards to address disinformation.

2.1.3. Voluntarily undertake information, education, and communication campaigns to build awareness around the 2021 Local Government Elections in South Africa.

2.1.4. Voluntarily undertake information, education, and communication campaigns to build awareness around the harms, risks, and consequences of the dissemination of disinformation in the context of elections.

2.1.5. Endeavour to collaborate and impart training on various products, services, mechanisms, and processes for responding to concerns of disinformation.” (LGE Framework of Cooperation) 

The framework then sees the participants committing to support and work with the IEC and Real411. In addition to Real411, the social media platforms have appointed persons or teams during the election period to prioritise referrals from the commission. Actions taken by the platforms are in terms of their policies and may include the removal of the content, the publication of an advisory warning and/or the delisting of the post.

Finally: “With regard to advertising content by contestants, PADRE [software] will enable all stakeholders to make use of this transparent repository of political advertisements. All political advertisements, including those targeted at individuals or specific groups using online media, should also be available through the repository. The purpose of the repository is to increase transparency and to enable the verification of the authenticity of any political advertisement.”

The framework has gaps, and there is no enforcement mechanism or punishment if the platforms don’t adhere to it, but it is a framework of cooperation, not a binding code. There are also other areas it might address and we will welcome greater commitment, but as a first version, the framework represents a significant shift towards recognising the importance of human rights and free, fair and credible elections and democracy in an African context. It also represents the beginning of building deep and meaningful commitment to combating disinformation by all the participants.

With all the challenges we face, the framework is a really important good news achievement. Now it’s up to the public to do its bit. We know that we cannot remove every piece of disinformation, but the more we expose it, the more platforms act and take down content that is in breach of their own community guidelines, the greater the awareness and the more difficult it is for those who seek to spread disinformation.

We need people to keep on standing up and reporting those who seek to exploit fears. It won’t stop disinformation, but it may reduce its spread and cause less harm. It is critical that we all play our part in combating and mitigating digital offences.

If you suspect that content could be disinformation, hate speech, harassment of journalists or incitement to violence, there is something you can do about it.

To make it even more simple, download the Real411 mobile app. Again, we take this chance to remind you: We are in that magical period where political parties need to show us that they care, so in addition to asking about what they will do in your area, ask them to issue one public statement that highlights and condemns any attacks on our journalists and then to demonstrate what action they took to help combat that. If they are edgy or push some other hogwash agenda, don’t easily vote for them because they don’t believe in democracy. DM

William Bird is director of Media Monitoring Africa (MMA) and Nomshado Lubisi is communications manager at MMA, a partner in the 411 platform to counter disinformation.

Disinformation in a time of Covid-19: A historic partnership ahead of the municipal elections
© Provided by Daily Maverick            

Download the Real411 App on Google Play Store or Apple App Store.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


India making efforts to get Hindi recognised as official UN language, says V Muraleedharan

The Indian government on Thursday said in Parliament that “sustained” efforts were being made to have ‘Hindi’ recognised as an official language of the United Nations and to “popularise” it ... Read more »

Bharat Dynamics climbs 4% after inking Rs 471 crore deal with Indian Army

NEW DELHI: Shares of Bharat Dynamics extended gains and jumped close to 4 per cent in early trade on Friday after the defence sector player and the Indian Army inked ... Read more »

Asian Squash Championship: India teams in semis

The Indian men’s and women’s teams sailed into the semi-finals at the Asian Team Squash Championship here on Thursday.  While the men’s team got the better of Indonesia 3-0, the ... Read more »

Searching for alpha? This debutant auto-parts maker can jump upto 50%

NEW DELHI: Sansera Engineering, a manufacturer of critical precision forged and machined components, is likely to provide the much needed alpha to your portfolio amid a range-bound market and high ... Read more »

Anupamaa, Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai, Udaariyaan - Interesting spoilers of the upcoming episodes of your fave top 5 shows

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com Anupamaa We will see that Baa and Bapuji’s functions happen. Kavya (Madalsa Sharma) will remind Anupamaa (Rupali Ganguly) that how she was an outsider when the ... Read more »

Cyclone Jawad Updates: Odisha, Bengal Brace for Heavy Rains as Storm to Hit Coast Tomorrow Morning, Says IMD; Trains Cancelled, Fishermen Warned

Read more »

Pep Guardiola issues Aston Villa verdict as Rangers ace responds to transfer talk

Welcome to our Aston Villa coverage on Friday, December 3. Here’s are your morning headlines from BirminghamLive as Villa prepare for Sunday’s Premier League clash against Leicester City. Guardiola agrees ... Read more »

Samantha Ruth Prabhu FINALLY reveals what's making her go on post divorce with Naga Chaitanya

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com Ever since their divorce announcement, Samantha Ruth Prabhu and Naga Chaitanya have been grabbing headlines a lot more. There have been various speculations about the divorce ... Read more »

After rap from SC, Centre sets up 'enforcement task force' to curb pollution in Delhi-NCR

After the Supreme Court’s strong worded directions on taking measures to control pollution in Delhi, the Centre on Friday said it has set up a five-member ‘enforcement task force’ to ... Read more »

Lee Bowyer gives bleak Riley McGree update as Birmingham City get fitness boost

Welcome to BirminghamLive’s coverage of all things Birmingham City. Strife of Riley Lee Bowyer insists Birmingham City are doing everything they can to work out any kind of deal that ... Read more »

Flight attendant shares trick that 'might help' for upgrade - crew members to 'go for'

Although it’s difficult, being moved to the premium cabin onboard a flight is not impossible. How can you get it? Flight attendant Helena Afroughi explained why choosing the right cabin ... Read more »

Devils' poor play continues in ugly loss to Wild

The New Jersey Devils were overmatched in this one. Kirill Kaprizov collected two goals and an assist, Ryan Hartman added a goal and two assists and the Minnesota Wild extended ... Read more »

NPA's Investigating Directorate boss no more: Hermione Cronje quits after frustrating 30 months

Hermione Cronje has submitted a request to be relieved of her duties for personal reasons. © Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved Hermione Cronje has resigned as head ... Read more »

Covid-19 ‘fake news' man walks free as magistrate slams prosecution

© Provided by Times Live The Cape Town magistrate’s court struck the case from the roll after the state asked for a postponement as Stephen Birch was set to plead ... Read more »

Zolani Matthews sacked by Prasa

© Provided by Times Live TimesLIVE has established from sources in Prasa that Matthews was informed of the decision to terminate his contract on Wednesday, just a few days before ... Read more »

Sagittarius: Your finance horoscope - December 03

© Astrofame Sagittarius On the whole, the outlook for the day is fairly good, but don’t plan to engage in any activity that is a challenge to you. You’ll be ... Read more »

More rainfall expected into the weekend

© Provided by SowetanLive The rainfall is expected over the central and western parts of SA. “The weather system will move east-west, towards the central parts of the country by ... Read more »

Siviwe Gwarube elected new deputy chief whip of DA

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Cape Town – DA MP Siviwe Gwarube has been elected deputy chief whip of the party in Parliament following a caucus meeting on Thursday. ... Read more »

Court told body parts of slain Nosicelo Mtebeni were immersed in bleach

© Twitter. Nosicelo Mtebeni. CAPE TOWN – A murdered Fort Hare University student was dismembered to conceal her identity. That’s been heard in the East London High Court, where Alutha ... Read more »

WATCH | Cristiano Ronaldo scores record 800th goal – does a SIUUU!

© Provided by The South African Michael Carrick exited Manchester United with a win as Cristiano Ronaldo surpassed 800 goals for club and country with a double to see off ... Read more »

Paolo Duterte throws support behind Bongbong's prexy bid

Davao City Representative Paolo Duterte, son of President Rodrigo Duterte, has thrown his support to the presidential bid of former Senator Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr. in the 2022 elections. “From ... Read more »

8 million vaccinated during Nov. 29 to Dec. 1 vax drive —NVOC

© Danny Pata Over 500K vaccinated on first day of national vax drive Around 8 million individuals were inoculated against COVID-19 during the November 29 to December 1 vaccination days, ... Read more »

Duterte says he respects Go's decision to withdraw from 2022 presidential race

© Senator Bong Go’s office President Duterte and Senator Bong Go President Rodrigo Duterte on Thursday said he respects the decision of his longtime aide, Senator Christopher Lawrence “Bong” Go ... Read more »

BLM urges boycott of white companies for 'Black Xmas'

LONDON, ENGLAND – OCTOBER 12: Santa Claus during the Selfridges 2020 Christmas Shop “Once upon a Christmas” photocall at Selfridges, Oxford Street on October 12, 2020 in London, England. (Photo ... Read more »

U.S. VP Harris' office shakeup to bring 'new voices' into White House, Psaki says

U.S. Vice President Harris visits El Paso, Texas By Nandita Bose (Reuters) -U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris' senior adviser and chief spokesperson Symone Sanders is leaving by the end of ... Read more »

COVID-19: At least 50 people infected with Omicron variant at Christmas party in Norway

The news comes as Norway joins a number of other countries trying to control the spread of the variant with tougher rules. Read more »

The Tory win in Old Bexley and Sidcup is one Johnson cannot take for granted

Photograph: Gareth Fuller/PA Analysis: poor turnout suggests Conservatives had trouble mobilising their voters as disaffected supporters criticised PM’s leadership skills Boris Johnson is still invincible. Or so some Tories think. ... Read more »

Sturgeon is being forced to play the long game on a second referendum

Here are four truths about Scottish politics. The nationalist SNP commands the stage, reinforced by its latest Holyrood election mandate in May. Its leader, Nicola Sturgeon, is Scotland’s most admired ... Read more »

Potensic Dreamer Pro review: A DJI alternative at a DJI price

© Provided by T3 Potensic Dreamer Pro drone review Once you’re ready to spend a few hundred dollars on a drone, you’ve likely already turned your eyes toward DJI. That ... Read more »

Covid: Javid says snog who you like under mistletoe, contradicting Coffey

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: James Veysey/Rex/Shutterstock Ministers have clashed repeatedly over advice on festivities and mistletoe, with Home Office staff being urged to limit numbers attending Christmas parties ... Read more »

Semua pasar ada harga kartel sayur sendiri ikut kawasan

© Provided by Sinar Harian SHAH ALAM – Semua pasar di seluruh negara mempunyai harga kartel sendiri yang telah ditetapkan mengikut kawasan tersebut. Pengerusi Persatuan Pekebun Melayu Cameron Highlands, Datuk ... Read more »

Novavax mula pembuatan vaksin khas lawan Omicron Januari ini

© Provided by Sinar Harian NOVAVAX akan memulakan pembuatan komersial vaksin Covid-19 yang dikhaskan buat varian Omicron bermula Januari depan. Pada sama masa ia turut menguji sama ada vaksin semasa ... Read more »

Phase four takeaway: Freshly-made stuffed 'chee cheong fun' at Puchong Jaya's Restoran Anson Chee Cheong Fun & Dessert

© Provided by Malay Mail Visit this Puchong Jaya eatery to get freshly-made Anson-style ‘chee cheong fun’ to be eaten with pickled green chillies. — Pictures by Lee Khang Yi ... Read more »

S.Korea makes vaccine pass mandatory for many more venues as Omicron fears rise

© Reuters/KIM HONG-JI Women wearing masks to prevent contracting the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) walk under a Christmas illumination at a shopping district in central Seoul By Sangmi Cha SEOUL (Reuters) ... Read more »

Oppo Reno6 Z 5G edisi terhad beri produk Shiseido bernilai RM450 percuma

Oppo Malaysia mengumumkan penjualan Reno6 Z 5G edisi terhad. Mereka telah bekerja sama dengan jenama kosmetik terkenal, Shiseido untuk hadir dengan produk itu. Lebih menarik, harga seunit edisi terhad ini ... Read more »

19 sekeluarga terkandas selepas rumah dimasuki air banjir di Kuala Nerus

© Provided by Sinar Harian KUALA NERUS – Seramai 19 sekeluarga terpaksa tidur dalam keadaan digenangi air apabila kediaman mereka dilanda banjir sejak dua hari lepas. Menurut Mansor Harun, 70, ... Read more »

Murid Berkeperluan Khas berpotensi dalam sukan ragbi. Wargamaya luah rasa bangga!

“Murid Berkeperluan Khas (MBK) juga berbakat dalam bidang sukan dan permainan di sekolah. “Mereka perlu dilatih dengan konsisten sekiranya mahu melahirkan atlet yang terdiri daripada MBK ini,” kata Cikgu Mohd ... Read more »

Bidens help light National Christmas Tree

The Christmas season has begun in Washington, with bright lights, festive trees and a touch of bipartisanship in the spirt of the holiday. President Joe Biden, joined by first lady ... Read more »

Vodafone Idea under F&O ban on December 3

© Ruchira Kondepudi Vodafone Idea under F&O ban on December 3 Beleaguered telecom operator Vodafone Idea Limited (VIL) and Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited have been put under ban for trade ... Read more »

Stuck in limbo, Syrians in Denmark suffer unbearable wait

Bilal Alkale’s family is among the hundred or so Syrian refugees in Denmark whose lives are on hold amid an insufferable legal limbo — their temporary residency permits have been ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic